Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have I massively overreacted?

234 replies

HoneyGate · 25/08/2022 21:06

DP and I often commute home together, I’m more than happy to commute alone however today I had my bag, a full size umbrella and a large bouquet of flowers from my team at work. As I have to get a train and a bus, and I’m 7 months pregnant, I text DP asking if we were getting the train together as I could do with a hand, he said yes. An hour later, he texts me to say actually he’s in the pub and won’t be leaving at the same time as me. Obviously this pissed me off but I managed to make the journey home, I text my partner explaining I was annoyed and got the following responses which infuriated me:

‘I didn’t realise the night was going to be like this’ - are you not in control of when you leave then?

‘I’m allowed a life’ - I didn’t say you weren’t, I just asked for help
‘I’ve done nothing wrong’ - hmm I beg to differ
‘I’m standing up for myself’ - this really upset me like I’m some sort of bully

I got myself so worked up and angry and upset that I couldn’t bear to sit at home and wait for him to roll in at midnight so I decided to drive to my parents house who live 45 minutes away. Normally this would be fine, however tomorrow DP and I, along with my parents, siblings and their DPs and DCs are all due to go away for the weekend, but DP now has no way of joining us as we share a car.

One minute I calm down and think I’ve massively overreacted (blaming the pregnancy hormones if so), the next I go over everything again and get angry and upset and stand by my decision.

YABU - you’ve overreacted

YANBU - you haven’t overreacted

OP posts:
fannyfan · 27/08/2022 01:22

mountainsunsets · 26/08/2022 11:06

Gosh shocked at some of the patronising and unkind responses here! What happened to women supporting women?!

We don't have to agree with someone just because they're female.

Quite.

However if you disagree the majority apparently think you're either

A) a man
b) more suited to an MRA forum(!) despite being a gay woman with a wife and 2 children
C) anti feminist

Not just confused why you can't the train whilst pregnant.

This forum has changed

gonutkin · 26/08/2022 21:04

InsomniacVampire · 26/08/2022 19:42

@gonutkin Surely it's fine to express my opinion on someone else's (rudely put) opinion? "Running to mummys's house", how patronising was that. I find it funny how people defend a dude in a pub (it's not like he would have missed out on a one of a lifetime occasion) but try to belittle his partner with petty comments like that.
The partner went to a pub- something that he could have done on any other day. No obstacles. On this particular day he said he would help out with something YOU don't find a big deal, maybe OP did, she's pregnant, and she knows her circumstances. The DP was being a dick about it like if she was limiting his personal freedom on ONE DAY, all was asked of him was to keep his word.

"Or are you one of those people whom no one ever helps"

I think you were miles ruder. If you think someone else was being rude then by all means point it out. Your no better for your reply, I totally get what your saying about it being unreasonable of her partner.

InsomniacVampire · 26/08/2022 19:42

@gonutkin Surely it's fine to express my opinion on someone else's (rudely put) opinion? "Running to mummys's house", how patronising was that. I find it funny how people defend a dude in a pub (it's not like he would have missed out on a one of a lifetime occasion) but try to belittle his partner with petty comments like that.
The partner went to a pub- something that he could have done on any other day. No obstacles. On this particular day he said he would help out with something YOU don't find a big deal, maybe OP did, she's pregnant, and she knows her circumstances. The DP was being a dick about it like if she was limiting his personal freedom on ONE DAY, all was asked of him was to keep his word.

LookItsMeAgain · 26/08/2022 18:37

I hope you've been able to start your break on a good footing @HoneyGate .

bellac11 · 26/08/2022 18:21

I forgot to say that you are utterly unreasonable for having one of those massive brollies anyway. Dangerous in the wind, they'll have someones eye out.

gonutkin · 26/08/2022 16:19

InsomniacVampire · 26/08/2022 15:44

@luxxlisbon Have you read the post? He promised he would help and then f* off to the pub. A rgrown man surely is capable of going out another night if they want to and discuss it in a mature way insted of throwing a hissy fit and be stroppy nd reuse to help. You clearly are having a bad day, or you are one of those people whom no one ever helps so you think it's normal not to get help/help others.

That's not fair at all just because someone else stated their opinion and it was different to yours. We don't really know the whole context of the situation as we don't know the relationship of the people this post is about.

Personally, if my partner "agreed" to help me with something I was capable of doing on my own, and then changed his plans to see friends instead, I'd be a bit miffed but it's not a big deal. Life is too short for this shit.

InsomniacVampire · 26/08/2022 15:44

@luxxlisbon Have you read the post? He promised he would help and then f* off to the pub. A rgrown man surely is capable of going out another night if they want to and discuss it in a mature way insted of throwing a hissy fit and be stroppy nd reuse to help. You clearly are having a bad day, or you are one of those people whom no one ever helps so you think it's normal not to get help/help others.

OhPissOffPlease · 26/08/2022 14:44

This will be long I'm sorry. My own dh, has on occasions in the early days been the type who goes to the pub "for a couple of pints" to watch football at 3pm and will say he'll be home by 8pm and that he wants dinner together and would make plans with me to watch a movie or whatever and then it gets to 1am and he still not home and as he's been known to fall asleep on park benches, or get into some right states sometimes, it was only a handful times a year and he sort of grew out when I was late home (by an hour and a half) and he was worried I'd fallen over drunk or whatever and he sort of realised then how I must have felt when he's five hours later than he said he would be. It's easy to get caught up in having fun and lose track of time but i totally get the annoyance at being ditched and having plans changed.

I do think you overreacted by driving off to parent but I think he's been a bit of twat too. Not because he's had a couple of pints, that's not the issue. Dh would never go out on a bender if he had something important the next day, like a weekend away because he'd be helping make sure we hadn't forgot to pack anything and all that shit and he wouldn't want to risk still being over the limit the following morning and not being able to do his share of the driving if I wasn't feeling well (which I often didn't in the last few months of pregnancy) but also, as my maternity leave got closer we both started having a bit of nerves and anxiety and I do understand those saying he's trying to make up for what he feels is him not being able to go out much after baby is here but that applies to women too.

It's not just the men who feel like this, women also face big changes to their lives and bodies and have their "oh fuck it's really happening I'm scared" moments too and for me personally, maternity leave was one step closer to my life and body changing and it was just as scary for me as him. My last day of work before maternity, dh actually had secretly arranged to finish his own job early, he drove to my work and surprised me because he suspected I'd have a lot to carry on the bus, as I worked with families who'd also been very kind and bought me baby things as well as my colleagues and he said he thought I might like a hug if I'm emotional when leaving too. We went for a nice little meal and walk and talked through how scared we both were and becoming parents I talked about worried was about pushing a baby out of fanny and it never being the same again.

So while I agree you were unreasonable driving off to your parents, I think sometimes it's easy to forget, it's not just men who struggle becoming a parent and it sounds like it's less about carrying a brolly and a some flowers, and more like him not being there for you when he said he would be, at a time that's just as daunting for you and I hope he acknowledges that instead of just telling you he "still loves" you and you being the only that apologises, he acknowledges it wasn't great in his part either, because for you, the big changes have already started, that was your last commute home together for a while, possibly forever depending on what your plans are after maternity leave, his day to day routine remains unchanged for a while yet, yours is changed now, and you'd asked him to be there for you and he wasn't and it's not crazy pregnant hormones to be a bit hurt and annoyed. It's a very valid way to feel. I hope you have a lovely weekend. Flowers

gonutkin · 26/08/2022 14:12

luxxlisbon · 26/08/2022 11:46

I dunno, he’s getting a lot of flack here for the “standing up for himself” comment but if you frequently put these kind of requests on him I can understand him finally wanting to say no.
Expecting him to go home with you so he can hold your umbrella is v v unreasonable. You need to learn to be self sufficient, and the fact that you ran right off to mummy’s house is further proof of that.

This

jewishmum · 26/08/2022 13:03

My husband didn't even see me lift a shopping bag out the car when I was pregnant. He was very protective of the unborn baby.

luxxlisbon · 26/08/2022 11:46

I dunno, he’s getting a lot of flack here for the “standing up for himself” comment but if you frequently put these kind of requests on him I can understand him finally wanting to say no.
Expecting him to go home with you so he can hold your umbrella is v v unreasonable. You need to learn to be self sufficient, and the fact that you ran right off to mummy’s house is further proof of that.

Meraas · 26/08/2022 11:39

Vikinga · 26/08/2022 11:37

I don't often see threads on here where I don't side with women but I'm not going to agree with something just because it's a woman. Carrying a bag, flowers and a brolly and being pregnant isn't a big deal and her husband went for a few drinks instead of helping her. But she didn't really need the help.

However, he should have asked her as he had already agreed.

But she didn't really need the help.

Well, the OP says she’s 7 months pregnant and unsteady on her feet but what does she know about her own body, right?

Let’s just believe @Vikinga Hmm

Vikinga · 26/08/2022 11:37

mountainsunsets · 26/08/2022 11:06

Gosh shocked at some of the patronising and unkind responses here! What happened to women supporting women?!

We don't have to agree with someone just because they're female.

I don't often see threads on here where I don't side with women but I'm not going to agree with something just because it's a woman. Carrying a bag, flowers and a brolly and being pregnant isn't a big deal and her husband went for a few drinks instead of helping her. But she didn't really need the help.

However, he should have asked her as he had already agreed.

mountainsunsets · 26/08/2022 11:06

Gosh shocked at some of the patronising and unkind responses here! What happened to women supporting women?!

We don't have to agree with someone just because they're female.

trytopullyoursocksup · 26/08/2022 10:55

It isn't about whether it is possible to carry an umbrella on a train while pregnant (or course it is, usually. Even a full size one). It's about that her husband agreed to do something and then said "no fuck that, booze" - at the last minute - and then positioned it as "standing up for himself".
You need to watch that one. Seriously.

Mammyloveswine · 26/08/2022 10:40

Gosh shocked at some of the patronising and unkind responses here! What happened to women supporting women?!

Op you were not unreasonable to be annoyed at DP changing his mind and going to the pub...he could have helped you on to the train and then taken the brolly to the pub at least freeing up another hand. Or given you notice so you could've left the brolly at work.

I also don't think you're unreasonable to have gone to your parents, you are heavily pregnant and your partner has left you feeling a bit vulnerable to go out ti the pub last minute.

He needs to apologise for being an inconsiderate prick.

Hopefully you are now on your way to a weekend away (and I assume your dad will pick up your DP and have a little chat with him about how he needs to make sure he is putting YOU first as you are pregnant with his child).

saleorbouy · 26/08/2022 09:26

Yes you have over reacted, put the bag strap over your shoulder, and carry the umbrella in one hand and the flowers in the other.
If this is too difficult leave the brolly in work and collect it next week!
It's not that difficult, presumably you managed to carry the bag and the brolly to work on your own?
I think you have blown this out of all proportion, obviously pregnancy and hormones don't help but I feel for your hubby who must be a bit bemused by this reaction.

Sparkletastic · 26/08/2022 09:23

It was selfish and thoughtless of him. Don't blame you for feeling pissed off. Hope he shapes up when the baby arrives.

TeaTurtle · 26/08/2022 09:22

I’m obviously late to this but I can understand why you were upset. Especially as you say you don’t ask for help often.

He has let you down when you asked for help. He needs to prove he is reliable and takes you seriously. That really matters.

I hope you have a good weekend but I do not think you have been ridiculous at all.

coffeerevelsrule · 26/08/2022 09:14

I regret my post about men posting here. Because I know from experience both in rl and on here, women are often incredibly hard on each other in this type of situation. It's both depressing and infuriating.

So many people are continuing to bang on about whether or not it's possible to carry umbrellas and flowers and are bleating that pregnancy isn't an illness. I don't understand why the OP is ridiculed for wanting help yet it's an outrage that he will have to transport himself 45 minutes under his own steam this morning! What if the OP hadn't termed going to her parents' house as flouncing but had asked whether she was UR to go there last night as she was feeling a bit lonely and didn't want to sit alone all night waiting for H to get in pissed at midnight. Surely most posters would have said she should go and he would need to sort himself out in the morning.

People have missed the point that it's not about brollies and flowers, but about a wife asking for support from her husband, being let down at the last minute and then subjected to some defensive and gaslighty texts, culminating in being 'forgiven' for being ridiculous. It's really not great and does raise concerns about how he will operate as a father.

lottiegarbanzo · 26/08/2022 09:12

He's 'standing up for himself' against the needs of an unborn baby.*

What a hero.

Take care of yourself OP.

Be clear and honest with your parents. They need to know what's really going on and your real feelings. They will (if good people, as they sound) act as a force for calm and cohesion.

But beware, parents, like everyone, will tread very carefully around your relationship - its yours after all - and will always act to prop it up, unless or until you tell them explicitly that you have serious misgivings, want help or want out. They may be scared of alienating you by criticising him. I know so many people whose strategy with unsatisfactory or worrying child and friend partnerships is 'stay close, so we're still there to catch our loved one when it all goes wrong'.

I don't need to tell you to take care of your baby - it looks absurd even typing that. As if you'd forget. As if you will ever put your own wants before the needs of that baby, ever, for the rest of your life.

(Wants vs wants, sure, there's a lot of future negotiation to be done there).

Good luck OP.

*In this case, its need not to have its mother topple over on busy public transport, because she has no hands free to hold on with.

I would say that, practically, you could have dumped the flowers. The free hand was more important. Then you'd have felt upset with him about the wasted flowers.

Feeling upset is entirely rational, logical and reasonable, in your situation. You were let down. You were scared of topping over. Don't let ANYONE tell you otherwise.

Don't let ANYONE divert all discussion onto the way you reacted - as if that somehow magically time-travels, to cancel out his prior, unkind, unreasonable action.

Isaidnoalready · 26/08/2022 09:10

Goldbar · 26/08/2022 09:03

I am also a bit perplexed about why you needed the help. I'm also heavily pregnant, have a 4yo and took my 4yo and two relatively heavy bags on the train by myself last week (2 changes) to go away for a few days with my parents as DH was working. And it was fine and I wasn't worried about it.

But... you're not me. And people endure (and at the stage it is very much endurance!) pregnancy differently. You felt you could use some extra help, you asked for it, he agreed and then he blew you off. That would make me feel annoyed too. Because even if it was inconvenient, he'd agreed to help and he should have put you first. I do think you overreacted though, but he didn't behave well and I agree with pp who have said that this may be a red flag if typical behaviour. Unfortunately selfishness is a poor quality for a coparent.

She asked if he was going to be able to help her he agreed then bailed without telling her nothing there to be perplexed about she didn't say she couldn't cope she just wasn't expecting to need to cope its a big difference

UWhatNow · 26/08/2022 09:05

Caroffee · 25/08/2022 22:35

Usually find I agree with the majority but not this time. YANBU. He's been an arse. He can find his own way to join you for the holiday just like you found your own way home with a bump, a bag, an umbrella and a large bunch of flowers.

I agree. I think there are a lot of posters who have a low bar. If I was 7 months pregnant and asked for a rare moment of help I would be highly pissed off if he said ‘nah, I’m off the pub’. Fuck that.

Goldbar · 26/08/2022 09:03

I am also a bit perplexed about why you needed the help. I'm also heavily pregnant, have a 4yo and took my 4yo and two relatively heavy bags on the train by myself last week (2 changes) to go away for a few days with my parents as DH was working. And it was fine and I wasn't worried about it.

But... you're not me. And people endure (and at the stage it is very much endurance!) pregnancy differently. You felt you could use some extra help, you asked for it, he agreed and then he blew you off. That would make me feel annoyed too. Because even if it was inconvenient, he'd agreed to help and he should have put you first. I do think you overreacted though, but he didn't behave well and I agree with pp who have said that this may be a red flag if typical behaviour. Unfortunately selfishness is a poor quality for a coparent.

Meraas · 26/08/2022 08:55

LookItsMeAgain · 26/08/2022 08:44

@billy1966 speaks a lot of sense here.

If your dad wants him there for the holiday, he can collect him. You stay put. Rest up.

You asked for his help on your regular commute home which he regularly does at the same time as you, he agreed to help and then he bailed when he got a nicer offer.

I know it's only a small thing in the grand scheme of things but if he really wanted to go out, he could have seen you home safely and then gone back out to meet up with his work colleagues/friends/mates/whoever at that point. Except he didn't do that.

I hope you manage to work through this but you're not a bitch and you weren't being unreasonable to be pissed off at his behaviour yesterday when you needed his help.

As for those who say how will you manage with a baby and a buggy and a changing bag - well the baby can go in a sling if needs be, the changing bag could be a rucksack and then that just leaves a buggy which folds up. It gets easier without a pregnant bump too. It is like comparing apples and oranges to be fair. A full sized golf umbrella (that's what I think you were referring to) is awkward as it is not compact and with the metal bit at the end of the umbrella is just difficult to carry, then add to that a bunch of flowers, which I'm guessing came in a cardboard container as they usually do from florists as they put the stems in water so that's an awkward shape to be carrying too and then there is everything else.

Hope you're feeling a bit better today about the situation. Best of luck to you both!

Agreed 💯