Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want a little celebration for the lower achievers at GCSE?

216 replies

FunnysInLaJardin · 25/08/2022 21:05

DS1 got three 6's and three 4's at GCSE. He failed history and biology.

He could have done better, but amidst the nine 9's I feel like saying a small well done to the other kids who did well - even if they didn't blow the roof off!

GCSE's are a stepping stone and as long as your DC are happy, any grades are cause for celebration.

DS1 can now move on to college and start the next stage in his life, and for that I am very thankful.

OP posts:
MrsWhites · 25/08/2022 22:08

@FunnyNC sorry I just can’t agree with that. Congratulations to your daughter, those are fantastic results but some children could work til they are blue in the face but not be academically gifted enough or mentally strong enough to get through the absolute shit show that was Covid education.

My daughter was predicated grades 8-9 right through from year 7, she worked exceptionally hard throughout school but unfortunately didn’t deal well with Covid and home learning so those predicated grades went out of the window.

Achievements should be celebrated on an individual basis and not be criticised because ‘if they’ve worked as hard as Wendy down the road they might have got 9’s’!

CatLadyDrinksGin · 25/08/2022 22:06

Much more than a thick as mince privately educated tutored to the end spoon fed child. There is such a disparity between the support given to the richest and poorest students, it’s very far from a fair playing field. And mine have been state educated as have we as parents.

savehannah · 25/08/2022 22:04

Although my daughter didn't work as hard as I would have liked overall, and still got two 8s and a 9 in her favourite subjects, the grade I'm most proud of is the 5 in maths which she finds really hard, and really worked hard for after getting a shock to the system realising she might fail and if she did she wouldn't get on the college course she wanted.

High grades are a mix of natural ability and hard work. You can be proud of either or both. I'm proud of her natural ability in certain subjects and also of her hard work in maths.

A child who worked hard and achieved the best they could, even if that was a 4 should be congratulated.

CatLadyDrinksGin · 25/08/2022 22:01

Absolutely. So many privileged kids on here with academic parents, high achieving schools, lots of support, no emotional problems and it’s the kids with loads of problems at home, absent or busy non academic parents at shit schools that deserve the most praise.

FrecklesMalone · 25/08/2022 21:59

Out if my well off friends 4 of them left school with a out 5 GCSEs between them. They are in a mix of creative and construction jobs and enjoy what they do. Academia was not for them!

TattiePants · 25/08/2022 21:57

@FunnyNC why do you think it's only the kids that get 8s or 9s that read books, revise, do their homework, don't get detentions etc. Do you honestly believe that every child has the ability to get the highest grades if only they applied their self more.

SammySueTwo · 25/08/2022 21:57

FarFarFarAndAway · 25/08/2022 21:44

@SammySueTwo it may be the issue is not wanting to engage though, and that's a whole other thing. The good news is that people can come back into education later on, especially at local colleges. It may be they have to leave, though, and find another path right now. I don't mean to sound like I'm dismissing your problems.

Actually I think that’s spot on. Not ready to learn. It’s tough as a parent when you tried all sorts of tactics, offered tutors, tried bribery (haha) and tried to make your child understand.
I think a lot of children have a lot to celebrate - some worked hard for their 4s and 5s. It’s wonderful for them.
Mine worked hard for a fortnight and only attended 2-3 months in years 10 and 11 combined. But would have passed based on mocks.

Horcruxe · 25/08/2022 21:55

Effort usually translates into grades but not always.
By posting here we aren't diminishing anyones achievement.

It's a safe place to trumpet our childrens achievements.

I did great in my GCSE's, but admit I put in little effort. With the amount of effort I put in, i didnt deserve the grades.

Some people put in hours but were never gonna reach the top grades.

FarFarFarAndAway · 25/08/2022 21:55

@FunnyNC I teach degree level and I can tell you that every year I have one or two students crying because they simply cannot get a first, whatever they do. They have been taught you just have to work hard and then you get the top grades. This is not true in my area where you need BOTH natural aptitude and hard work. Degree classifications are not just a function of hard work, and I have had many students over the years from disadvantaged backgrounds or for whom English is not their first language who have done fantastically to get a low 2:1 or 2:2.

It is wrong (IMO) to teach students that all that matters is hard work. These students, nearly always girls, often struggle when its revealed to them later on in life that this is not true, and there are lots of things, from cultural capital, gender, natural aptitude, luck as well as hard work that predict success. Academic success and strings of A*'s don't always translate into later life achievement, or even brilliance at degrees or obtaining a first great job, and that can be very hard for them to take.

Hercisback · 25/08/2022 21:55

Congratulations on those results @Lougle@Lougle

Hercisback · 25/08/2022 21:54

@FunnyNC
No one is diminishing your child's achievements. There are students out there who worked as hard as your DD and their absolute best was a grade 4. I know because I taught them.
Some students who got 4s and 5s won't have worked as hard as your DD, others will have worked harder.

MrsHamlet · 25/08/2022 21:53
  • 2 grade 7s
MrsHamlet · 25/08/2022 21:52

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s.
What a load of nonsense. One of my girls who got 2 grade 4s worked far harder than the student with 3 grade 7s.

cassgate · 25/08/2022 21:50

DS today got 4 and 5s today. I am so proud and pleased for him. He has never found academic work easy and has always worked hard at school. He worked harder for his results than my Dd who got all 7-9’s. He worked consistently during lockdowns and during isolation periods. He went to extra lessons after school and during the Feb half term and Easter. No such dedication from DD as it just came naturally to her so no effort required. The notion that those that got 8’s and 9’s are somehow more deserving because they worked harder is just not true. In some cases yes but certainly not all.

Rockhopper81 · 25/08/2022 21:50

Posted too soon!

My nephew got a 5, the rest 4s, except for maths where he got a 3. He worked really, really hard, had a tutor for maths, and is gutted he didn't get a 'pass' in maths - he'll retake it, and I'm sure he'll pass next time - but considering he was achieving 1s and 2s around mocks time, that 3 was earned!

user1483473283 · 25/08/2022 21:50

Oh give it a rest. I’m in my 30s now (and a secondary maths teacher). Spent most my time at school pissing around and not putting any effort in and left with all As and A*s. I 100% did not deserve them based upon effort at all. My little sister worked her absolute arse off and got Cs on her resits in year 12 for Maths GCSE. Out of the two of us she absolutely deserved the higher grades.

OP congratulations to your son for his results, I hope he is as proud as you are for the hard work he put in to achieve them. The biggest advice I give any students now is that as long as you get yourself to the next step in what you want to do, that’s all that matters as absolutely no one cares or remembers how far above that threshold you get in the long run.

Lougle · 25/08/2022 21:49

I posted on another thread but DD1 got her results today, too. She has SEN and went to special school. She had a terrible year 9/10, as she was severely unwell and was admitted to hospital in January 2021, then didn't return to school until May, part-time, then went back full time in July of 2021 (year 10).
She got entry level 2 certificates in English and Maths, entry level 3 in performing arts, level 1 awards in science, hospitality, and skills in sports, and GCSE grade 1 in art.

We're so proud of her for plugging away despite her challenges.

She will go on to the SEN department of a college and do a life skills entry level 2 course. She has an EHCP, so she can take her time building up her levels.

Dotcheck · 25/08/2022 21:48

Perhaps the YABU is because 6’s are not ‘lower achievers’ .
6 really isn’t a low grade

Rockhopper81 · 25/08/2022 21:48

@Simonjt - was about to say the same thing, I got As across my GCSEs, except for one D (which was bizarrely the only subject I actually revised for), and I didn't revise or work all that hard. I mean, turns out I had undiagnosed ASD and ADHD, but aside from that I've always been naturally academic. My best friend, conversely, worked her arse off for the Cs and Ds she achieved, went on to do a coursework based course in sixth form, then a mostly coursework based degree, and is now doing really well in HR - who really worked the hardest there @FunnyNC ??

My nephew got a 5, the rest 4s, except for maths where he got a 3. He worked really, really hard, had a tutor for maths, and is gutted he didn't get a 'pass' in maths - he'll retake it

ByeByeMr · 25/08/2022 21:48

I left school in 1998. Nowadays if you get less than a 4 does that mean you've failed?

cheninblanc · 25/08/2022 21:48

Hellenbach that's a fantastic achievement

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:47

It's no different to a degree. You start uni and the lecturers tell you that you get what you put in. I remember being advised not to have a boyfriend and not to have a job as distractions take away your grades.

So yes my dd who has always worked hard, never had a detention, never been sent to isolation, read books in the library at lunchtime and went above and beyond all of the time did work harder then those who didn't.

My ds does bare minimum. He will get bare minimum results. It's not a judgement it's a fact.

I don't actually agree with the education system we have and think dcs have way too much work to do in a time in their life where they don't know what they want. Their brains are growing like toddlers and rism taking and independent behaviour is coming out. However, my dds hard work shouldn't be diminished by saying others worked as hard when they didn't. We can celebrate academic achievement without diminishing it for them by saying what about the 4s.

Hellenbach · 25/08/2022 21:46

I'm thinking of all the 'ghost children' today who didn't return to school after the lockdowns. What happened to them?
My DS suffered from anxiety and depression and missed most of Y10 and didn't return to school full time last September for Yr 11.
At one point I thought he was too unwell to ever take his GCSEs.
Today he got his results. He passed every exam he sat. He didn't get the high grades he had been predicted pre-Covid.
He doesn't care and neither do I. He's achieved so much and I'm
so proud of him for walking back into that building for the last time today. He enrols at college tomorrow.
Let's remember those poor, struggling pupils who didn't get the right support or just couldn't cope. There's so many of them out there.

ByeByeMr · 25/08/2022 21:45

Those are good grades in my opinion. Bit of a shame he failed two but not the end of the world and at least it wasn't Maths and English.

FarFarFarAndAway · 25/08/2022 21:44

@SammySueTwo it may be the issue is not wanting to engage though, and that's a whole other thing. The good news is that people can come back into education later on, especially at local colleges. It may be they have to leave, though, and find another path right now. I don't mean to sound like I'm dismissing your problems.