Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want a little celebration for the lower achievers at GCSE?

216 replies

FunnysInLaJardin · 25/08/2022 21:05

DS1 got three 6's and three 4's at GCSE. He failed history and biology.

He could have done better, but amidst the nine 9's I feel like saying a small well done to the other kids who did well - even if they didn't blow the roof off!

GCSE's are a stepping stone and as long as your DC are happy, any grades are cause for celebration.

DS1 can now move on to college and start the next stage in his life, and for that I am very thankful.

OP posts:
cadburyegg · 25/08/2022 23:24

YANBU OP. I got 7 passes at GCSE. Many of my friends got all A grades. I'd had an awful year. My parents were very proud of me and I'm grateful they never had unrealistic expectations. Also agree that effort doesn't necessarily equal high grades. I was awful at maths and worked very hard to get a C. I got an A in English with much less effort.

Coatdegroan · 25/08/2022 23:23

I teach people retaking maths GCSE
Some got their 4, none believed they could get it after several tries.

Some moved from a 2 to a 3. In our department that's seen as just as significant as moving from a 3 to a 4.

I think that high fliers don't realise what barriers so many people have to push through. I have so much admiration for many of my students.

Brigante9 · 25/08/2022 23:23

My biggest win today was a student who overachieved his target of a 4 and got a 5 and was all fired up to do my subject for A level! I had to say no, he wouldn’t cope, but I was so chuffed for him.

fUNNYfACE36 · 25/08/2022 23:23

Sideorderofchips · 25/08/2022 21:06

I went to our year 11 results day and spoke to alot of our students. No matter what they got we told them we were proud of them and everything they had achieved

That mustn't have made the low achievers feel patronised at all Hmm

PeekAtYou · 25/08/2022 23:21

My ds is another Mr Average. His grades are all in the 4-6 range which is great for someone who was below expected in primary school SATS. He was expecting to have to retake maths but got a 5 in Higher which is fab.

His grades mean he can go onto his first choice courses so it's been a massive relief all round.

PickAChew · 25/08/2022 23:19

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

Ah, now I know why Ds2 finished year 11 with a hand full of AQA unit awards and having a go at entry 1 maths. He should have turned off alphablocks and put the hours into studying. 😏

BearPunter · 25/08/2022 23:19

My beaut got 1s and 2s - if you'd asked me at Easter if he'd even get into the exam hall to sit them I wouldn't have been able to call it, he was struggling to even get into the school building at that point.

He did it - sat every exam, no thanks to his school who were spectacularly unhelpful and unsupportive. Every mark he got is testament to him and his determination to get in there and at least try and he was well resigned to this year being a year to consolidate and retake while working on his longer term goals.

Starts college next week and the future is most definitely bright - I couldn't be prouder 😎

PMAmostofthetime · 25/08/2022 23:17

@FunnysInLaJardin
So I just checked and 6's and 4's are B's and C's in Wales. These are amazing grades and ones to be proud off. I have never had an A in my life all B's and C's I have a university degree and a professional job.
I really don't understand this culture where nothing but the highest is the best?
After all, all job applications and universities ask for is 5 4's (c's) and above.

I would definitely be celebrating your DC's achievements. It's disappointing about the two failed but I'm sure they feel disappointed enough themselves without further emphasis on this.

Poppiesway1 · 25/08/2022 23:15

Ds1 unfortunately did not study for any of his GCSE’s he had no drive to revise at all.. no matter how much I tried to talk to him.. I even (stupidly) offered him £100 for every A he got.. results day came… he got A*’s and A’s. No bloody revising.. he just went in and sat the exams off the hoof. So there are some who will just sit back and sail through and pass exceptionally well (frustratingly!). Ds2 on the other hand has revised so so much, gone over and over past papers, attended extra revision sessions.. he did get 5’s & 6’s and is gutted he didn’t get the predicted grades. Each child is different, and as other posters have said it doesn’t matter how much work some put in, they are just not going to get the high scores. Trying to stop ds2 comparing himself to ds1 is hard.. he forgets he’s done these during covid.. lockdowns,, bubbles being excluded from school... extra bits added to exams that they were told would be removed from the papers.. I’m proud of his results and I’d have loved to have gotten his results myself at his age!

SheilaWilde · 25/08/2022 23:15

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

That's simply not true.

Rutland2022 · 25/08/2022 23:12

Absolutely agree @FunnysInLaJardin

I work in widening participation in HE and we take a lot of students that have to work hard to get what is perceived as “average/poor” results but are actually an incredible achievement for them. All success is celebrated.

Academically I am one of those that aced GCSE, A Level, undergrad and several postgrad with absolutely no effort whatsoever. I totally recognise the success of others that worked their socks off, regardless of grades. My DB has dyslexia and ADHD and he would never have got better than C’s and D’s in old money no matter what he did.
My best friend’s daughter has complex disabilities and achieved 5 x 4’s last year and she is absolutely thrilled as she was not in mainstream school and it wasn’t clear she would ever pass anything.

Oldcottoneye · 25/08/2022 23:11

notanothertakeaway · 25/08/2022 22:27

@Hellenbach that's brilliant. Well done to your son x

Well done to him!!! That takes some fight and courage. I wish him every success.

MrsLeBouef · 25/08/2022 23:11

I was a teacher and always had top set and bottom set - for most of the girls in top set it didn't take much to get a top grade but for the bottom set some of them worked their socks off and their lower grade was more of an achievement.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 25/08/2022 23:10

To me it seems unfair that a child who struggles academically has to sit the same exam as someone who breezes through study. I am old enough to do have done O' levels/CSE's and both lots of exams were celebrated. As adults we recognise that for some students 3's and 4's are a huge achievement and are rightly proud of them. Yet that student will be collecting results alongside others who have 8's and 9's. Surely it must be upsetting?

I am full of admiration for all the kids who have been studying since the pandemic began but I think the ones who have struggled the most deserve a special well done for what they have achieved.

BooksAndHooks · 25/08/2022 23:10

I couldn’t be prouder of DS today, he has several SEND, struggled throughout school to just be there. The stress of exams made him extremely unwell and needing hospital visits. We didn’t think he would sit all the exams, he certainly wasn’t in a fit state to.

He got far higher grades than we thought, those 4s, 5s and 6 in maths were an achievement worth being proud of. He can do the higher level of the course he wants to do. The only 3 he got was English language, he had a huge panic attack in the exam. He has always struggled with this subject as his autism means he finds writing about other people, writing fictional accounts about imaginary holidays or things he hasn’t experienced virtually impossible.

His younger brother will no doubt sail through and get much higher grades without trying as he doesn’t have social, emotional challenges. He finds school easy. That doesn’t mean we should Celebrate his results more than his brother. If they have achieved their full potential then that is definitely a cause to celebrate.

Oldcottoneye · 25/08/2022 23:10

Showmethefood · 25/08/2022 23:07

But you’ve come along and said “what about the 9’s?” 😳

I know. God help the poor son.

Oldcottoneye · 25/08/2022 23:09

Academia is NOT IN ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM a measure of intelligence, effort or discipline.

Showmethefood · 25/08/2022 23:07

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:47

It's no different to a degree. You start uni and the lecturers tell you that you get what you put in. I remember being advised not to have a boyfriend and not to have a job as distractions take away your grades.

So yes my dd who has always worked hard, never had a detention, never been sent to isolation, read books in the library at lunchtime and went above and beyond all of the time did work harder then those who didn't.

My ds does bare minimum. He will get bare minimum results. It's not a judgement it's a fact.

I don't actually agree with the education system we have and think dcs have way too much work to do in a time in their life where they don't know what they want. Their brains are growing like toddlers and rism taking and independent behaviour is coming out. However, my dds hard work shouldn't be diminished by saying others worked as hard when they didn't. We can celebrate academic achievement without diminishing it for them by saying what about the 4s.

But you’ve come along and said “what about the 9’s?” 😳

Oldcottoneye · 25/08/2022 23:07

Many who weren't academic are reeling in fortunes. He deserves a celebration 100%. For effort and success and here's to more success!

Wishihadanalgorithm · 25/08/2022 23:06

I’ve taught children who achieved 3s and boy did they work hard for those 3s. It’s brilliant when young folk achieve the highest grades but this shouldn’t detract from those who struggle. Often, the hardest working students are the ones who find it so difficult and will never achieve the higher grades. These tend to be the students I am super proud of.

PMAmostofthetime · 25/08/2022 23:06

All achievements should be celebrated- I'm in wales so we still have letters I've celebrated today and gotten Welldone cards and little gifts for young people who have got A's B's C's D's and E's they all tried their best and achieved their target grades. They all got on to the college course or apprenticeship they wanted with these grades. As long as they are happy and they tried their best that's all we can ask and that should be celebrated x

Lannielou · 25/08/2022 23:03

@hedgehogFC I completely agree, my daughter has a spld and no matter how hard she works, would never get 8's or 9's. I celebrate her as I know she has given her best.

Tornado70 · 25/08/2022 22:54

Totally agree OP!
my DD gained 1 GCSE, and a few other level 2 vocational certificates.
College have supported her through her level 3 studies: she was awarded A A A* equivalent to A Levels.
She’s s off to Uni!
There are plenty of alternative routes to HE or employment.

Softplayhooray · 25/08/2022 22:53

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 22:15

I had my dd when I was 17, no GCSEs and straight out of foster care. We live in a council house, we've moved around and my dd has had a chaotic childhood full of ACEs unfortunately. We are not a privileged academic family. I went to uni when she was in year 7.

I don't believe others have worked as hard. Comparing skating by and getting As isn't the same thing as 9s. A 7 is an old A. Yes my dd worked harder than others academically. Why is that such a bad thing to say? My ds isn't academic and does better in things he puts his time into, my dd spent hours learning things because she loves learning. She learns new codes and writes books for fun. She put the hours in to be academically successful in her exams and not just in yr 10 and 11, she has always loved school and has always wanted to learn more. I'm glad she's been rewarded for that work she put in.

I do understand that there needs to be a natural aptitude and yes people have different intelligence levels (not just IQ) but when I think back to uni, the one's that got firsts (me included) did seem to work harder, research more and turn up to lectures.

This is 100% true... If your data set was 2, as it reflects the situation between your two kids.

But a data set of two is not big enough to generalise to a wider population!

Countless kids won't be able to get high marks no matter how hard they will work - my two are ND and smart but don't gel well with the standard academic way of learning/testing. I wouldn't be that surprised if they do not too well at all grade wise but later in life achieve some amazing things when they can create their own path. They deserve to be as proud as your daughter and if they get the same grades as your son, for example, it's not because they haven't worked damn hard every day, and then some, and at least as hard as your daughter. They have to do extra classes just to do what comes naturally to a lot of kids - (ND related - incidentally they both have a high IQ).

There's so many reasons why a lot of kids will just never get high marks....let's just stop judging and be happy for them, and for those with high marks too and also realise this isn't the only arena to excel academically. There is lifelong learning these days, and the chance for apprenticeships, Masters, PhDs and all sorts. We all suit different paths.

Gherkingreen · 25/08/2022 22:41

A 6 is equivalent to an old grade B, right? How is that anything other than a brilliant grade by anyone's standards? A C or B is excellent - they've passed the exams they had to sit, and they've opened the door to the next stage. After a global pandemic. Suffering from covid and long covid. In a turbulent and stressful world and under immense pressure that I couldn't have imagined when I was 16.