Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want a little celebration for the lower achievers at GCSE?

216 replies

FunnysInLaJardin · 25/08/2022 21:05

DS1 got three 6's and three 4's at GCSE. He failed history and biology.

He could have done better, but amidst the nine 9's I feel like saying a small well done to the other kids who did well - even if they didn't blow the roof off!

GCSE's are a stepping stone and as long as your DC are happy, any grades are cause for celebration.

DS1 can now move on to college and start the next stage in his life, and for that I am very thankful.

OP posts:
PollyEsther · 26/08/2022 05:45

DS1 got two 5s and I’m delighted for him! He’s only year 10, has ASD and significant associated issues with school (though no learning issues as such). He lost it in one of his exams through nerves and was devastated that he’d failed the entire thing because of that one element. But he still knuckled down and did the rest to the best of his ability and it paid off.

DS2, meanwhile, ‘only’ got a 4. He’s only year 9, did the entire course this year and was (strangely, we all thought) put in for foundation tier so a 4 was the second highest grade he could get. He’s got a whole, pass-grade GCSE already going into year 9.

Neither of them are particularly interested in the uni route, they just need their 5 passes to include English and Maths. I’m more proud of them than my DM should have been of my As and Bs because I did bugger all work for most of my grades, just a natural aptitude for school work. Furthermore, unless you do go to uni, even if you do, once you’ve graduated I don’t find the world gives a flying fuck about what your grades were at GCSE, as long as they were a pass so… why metaphorically flog those who try their hardest and manage that?

Simonjt · 26/08/2022 05:33

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 22:15

I had my dd when I was 17, no GCSEs and straight out of foster care. We live in a council house, we've moved around and my dd has had a chaotic childhood full of ACEs unfortunately. We are not a privileged academic family. I went to uni when she was in year 7.

I don't believe others have worked as hard. Comparing skating by and getting As isn't the same thing as 9s. A 7 is an old A. Yes my dd worked harder than others academically. Why is that such a bad thing to say? My ds isn't academic and does better in things he puts his time into, my dd spent hours learning things because she loves learning. She learns new codes and writes books for fun. She put the hours in to be academically successful in her exams and not just in yr 10 and 11, she has always loved school and has always wanted to learn more. I'm glad she's been rewarded for that work she put in.

I do understand that there needs to be a natural aptitude and yes people have different intelligence levels (not just IQ) but when I think back to uni, the one's that got firsts (me included) did seem to work harder, research more and turn up to lectures.

I was in the paper as that year I achieved 100% in maths GCSE. I also achieved an A at A-level with no revision and many many missed lessons. I’m
not priviliged either, I was homeless for most of my AS year.

x2boys · 26/08/2022 05:13

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 26/08/2022 00:19

GCSEs are pretty easy though. I mean I did the first year (I am 50, just turned 50 recently) and they were definitely easier than O'levels then. We all did better than the previous O'levels the year before. Even then it wasn't too hard to get As if you were reasonably academic. I didn't apply myself that much and got mostly As. Some kids just find academic work more do-able than others do.

A'levels were much harder. University was easier than A'levels and GCSEs ... unless you wanted to get a first which were as rare as hens teeth.

Not for everyone they are not ,I was the third year to do GCSE,s ,my sister was the first we both got a handful of C,s ,you academic ability is variable don't you?

x2boys · 26/08/2022 05:06

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

I mean good for your daughter, but my son will never acheive 8,s and 9,s he could work every hour from now untill he sits his exams next year ,but he just isn't academic ,so if he gets 4,s and 5,s I will be immensely proud of him.

OakTreex · 26/08/2022 04:13

I did absolutely nothing and achieved A*s at GCSE. Coasted it, back of a cereal box scribble revision (if that) the morning of the exam.

I did not work hard. I had natural aptitude.

It's the hardworking kids whose natural abilities lie in areas other than academia that face the biggest struggle, and they should be so proud of their achievements, especially when improving on predicted grades.

Well done to all Flowers

ArcheryAnnie · 26/08/2022 02:02

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

This is absolute nonsense. Of course hard work makes a difference to your grades, given no other variables - but the reality is that there are other variables. Some kids might be capable of A-stars, but can't be arsed to put the effort in. Other kids will not be getting A-stars, no matter how much they try or how many hours they put in.

You can calm down, @FunnyNC , nobody is taking your DD's achievements away. Just other kids have achievements that may look rather different.

DisneyDisneyDisney · 26/08/2022 01:40

Can I say how proud I am of my daughter. She took her GCSES last year (assessed grades) and I think got a worse deal than if she had sat her exams. She got a 3 in maths and had to re-take it this year at college. We found out today that she has passed and got a 4!! She has worked so hard for that GCSE!! Am so proud of her.

OldFan · 26/08/2022 01:26

Most people don’t ‘bottle it’ in exams when they have done enough preparation including practice papers.

I'm lucky, I can do ok in exams, but some people don't perform their best in that format. I found coursework harder.

OldFan · 26/08/2022 01:24

If you can pass the majority of GCSEs you should be able to pass them all.

@Iceballoons Not really, it's such a range of subjects. I'm quite academic but I can't make things look smart (maybe some dyspraxia- it would probably be easier nowadays with computers.) So I was not good at art or CDT. Geography involved graphs and included marks for presentation. So those were the 3 I dropped. Maths I did work hard in towards the end and got a C, B's in science. Hardly anyone is equally good in every subject. I also found it hard to study such a range of subjects; focussing on just one or two things is better for me.

Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 01:23

@badhappening you actually think I’m ‘ignorant’ or a troll because I have a different opinion to the majority? Good god.

Anyway don’t worry that’s it from me, I’m calling it a night.

Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 01:21

@PyongyangKipperbang it sounds like you / your cousin have experienced some kind of draconian parenting.

My kids know they aren’t going to be disowned if they don’t live up to my expectations. However they are aware that expectations exist including putting in a good effort at school and acting like decent human beings.

Most people don’t ‘bottle it’ in exams when they have done enough preparation including practice papers.

Children need active parenting and that imo includes making them aware that expectations do exist. Don’t know what kind of parent, extenuating circumstances aside, wouldn’t expect their children to leave school with a pass in all subjects as a minimum.

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/08/2022 01:15

badhappening · 26/08/2022 01:06

@PyongyangKipperbang
It’s better to ignore ignorant posters or trolls.

Unfortunately this type of positive thread is a huge magnet for them to stick the boot in.

They crave attention, so ignore and they usually go away 😁

You'd think after all these years I would have learned that! Thanks for the reminder!

MrsDS · 26/08/2022 01:10

*No results

MrsDS · 26/08/2022 01:07

Exactly this. Add on neurological challenges, trauma, life experiences, covid and that’s to list just a few! Some students learn in different ways, some thrive in exams others go to pieces. So proud of all year 11’s not result should be made not worthy or judged. X

badhappening · 26/08/2022 01:06

@PyongyangKipperbang
It’s better to ignore ignorant posters or trolls.

Unfortunately this type of positive thread is a huge magnet for them to stick the boot in.

They crave attention, so ignore and they usually go away 😁

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/08/2022 01:05

Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 00:55

@PyongyangKipperbang there’s absolutely nothing dysfunctional about expecting your child to live up to their individual potential, factoring in any SEN or other issues.

If you can pass the majority of GCSEs you should be able to pass them all.

You couldnt be more wrong.
My cousin is a well known academic in her field (you would know her name) and she failed Eng Lit at A level due to, well basically bottling it during the exam. It took her years longer than it would have done if she had passed, to get where she is now. Expectations from parents can be more damaging than any amount of SEN, and I speak for myself on that one.

Its your use of the word "expecting" that concerns me.

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 00:56

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

Thing is that’s not always true. I was too set for all subjects but I absolutely stuffed up some of my GCSEs and got a b because I scraped in over the scoring. Friends of mine were in lower sets and the best they could get was a C by getting a really high score.

top grades do not mean more effort at all

Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 00:55

@PyongyangKipperbang there’s absolutely nothing dysfunctional about expecting your child to live up to their individual potential, factoring in any SEN or other issues.

If you can pass the majority of GCSEs you should be able to pass them all.

BungleandGeorge · 26/08/2022 00:54

There shouldn’t be an assumption that those with lower grades didn’t work hard. There also shouldn’t be an assumption that those with higher grades are naturally gifted, don’t have Sen or other difficult circumstances. I’m sure the parents and teachers are very aware of who has underperformed through lack of application and who worked hard/ just had a bad day. The wider community probably aren’t that interested in what your child got for GCSEs!

OldFan · 26/08/2022 00:53

@FunnyNC We don't all start on a level playing field, and aren't all experiencing the same life circumstances while doing these exams etc.
----
I dropped some subjects at GCSE as I didn't have motivation then and hated school and also had a lot of untreated issues.

But I went on to get a 1st at a good uni eventually.

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/08/2022 00:52

This thread (or rather, certain posters on this thread) have really upset me.

Its like the political rhetocric "The poor are only poor because they wont WORK HARDER!!!"

Peach27 · 26/08/2022 00:51

My niece got straight A*s my nephew got BBCCCD. (NI still uses letters) Both have worked really hard to get to their next step. Both will be getting a card and £20. Equally proud of both.

TakeABowSheila · 26/08/2022 00:38

My son got all 5s.

He had a massive, invasive upheaval during his actual exams and I'm really proud of him.

sashh · 26/08/2022 00:36

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

That's not true for all children though. Some children are naturally more academic than others.

I've taught students who have studied in their second or third language.

I've taught students who are asylum seekers.

I've taught students who have medical issues or whose parents have medical issues.

Well done to your DD but as you said she was doing her school work in lockdown, other children were cleaning a parent's bum and preparing food for a family.

And some children are not as intelligent as their peers, they have to put in much more to get any grade.

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/08/2022 00:34

Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 00:29

Tbh unless my child had a really bad learning disability I would be having words about why they’d failed two subjects. Definitely not a cause for celebration. 🤷‍♀️

I suspect in this case the words should have been had a lot sooner.

Please define "really bad"

And then define a dysfunctional parent/child relationship.