Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want a little celebration for the lower achievers at GCSE?

216 replies

FunnysInLaJardin · 25/08/2022 21:05

DS1 got three 6's and three 4's at GCSE. He failed history and biology.

He could have done better, but amidst the nine 9's I feel like saying a small well done to the other kids who did well - even if they didn't blow the roof off!

GCSE's are a stepping stone and as long as your DC are happy, any grades are cause for celebration.

DS1 can now move on to college and start the next stage in his life, and for that I am very thankful.

OP posts:
Eselch · 26/08/2022 09:11

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 26/08/2022 07:58

What??

Why would you say that?!

Bloody hell, that's the sort of crap teachers told me all my life.

If your student wants to do the A level bloody well encourage them!!

The jump from GCSE to A Level is HUGE though. I got A*, A & A in my GCSEs for my chosen A Levels and I still found the jump in work to be immense and very difficult in one subject (foreign language). I fully understand why students with a 5 wouldn’t be likely to do well at a level.

DD wanted to do maths last year but she “only” got a 6 - school required a 7 or above to continue to A Level. She picked something else. She is a naturally bright kid, but the first year of sixth form has been a huge wake up and she has really struggled to keep up. I’m glad they didn’t let her continue with maths because I’m 90% sure she would have dropped it/refused to continue and it would have been a wasted year!

Hercisback · 26/08/2022 09:04

@Girliefriendlikespuppies I think it does matter. Students only get one shot at free level 3 schooling so it would be prudent to make the most of it.

English and History are slightly different as the content has still been covered at G5 or G9. Students scraping a 5 in GCSE Maths won't have covered enough high level content to access the A level.

Minfilia · 26/08/2022 09:03

My DS(twins) are not academic and spent the past year in constant after school lessons to try and get their passes. They worked REALLY hard.

They both got 8 passes, 4 or higher, one twin got a fail but only in history, and he made up for it by getting an 8 in English! Last year he was unlikely to even pass so I nearly fell off my chair 😂

We are just delighted they don’t need to do any resits!

Willyoujustbequiet · 26/08/2022 09:00

Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 00:55

@PyongyangKipperbang there’s absolutely nothing dysfunctional about expecting your child to live up to their individual potential, factoring in any SEN or other issues.

If you can pass the majority of GCSEs you should be able to pass them all.

That's nonsense. My dc has a language disorder which means they struggle with figures/scientific vocabulary. Her mocks were 8 in most subjects and 3 in Maths.

MrsMitford3 · 26/08/2022 08:56

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

I can not believe you have posted this.
Very shitty and entitled attitude-so much so that I hope you are not real-

Not everyone is capable of 8s and 9s and some ppl can get them with little or no work my DS but lots of students work very very hard to achieve their 4s and 5s and they should be equally proud.

You don't know students circumstances-their homelife, health etc or what is going on behind the scenes.

This is exactly why I hate when ppl post their DC results.
It is so insensitive and unnecessary.

Congrats/so proud etc. that's it.
And I also hate when other parents ask for results.
Why do you need to know? to compare?
Can't we just celebrate together?????

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 26/08/2022 08:56

Hercisback · 26/08/2022 08:09

@Girliefriendlikespuppies For A level (especially maths and science), you will struggle to achieve an E at A level if you have scraped a 5 at GCSE. The most common A level maths grade awarded to students who got a GCSE grade 5 is a U. As teachers it would be unfair to set students up to fail.

Does it matter? My dd loves history, it's her favourite subject and she has talked about wanting to be a History teacher or archeologist one day. She got a 5 in her exam Ystd which she was delighted with.

If she wanted to do History A level I would 100% support her.

I had teachers telling me at school that I'd fail my science GCSE (I didn't, I passed despite getting crap teaching) and not to do English A level as I wouldn't cope (I did do the A level and coped just fine....)

I also now have a degree and have done a lot of further post grad studying.

You can tell a student to think about it and that it will take a lot of work but if that's what they really want to do then go for it.

MrsWhites · 26/08/2022 08:54

This thread just makes me feel sorry for the children of the posters on here claiming things like ‘if you are prepared you don’t bottle it in exams’, ‘if you don’t get a 9 you haven’t worked as hard as others’, etc, etc.

Imagine being those children and feeling that pressure from your own parents!

Willyoujustbequiet · 26/08/2022 08:50

@FunnyNC

You are utterly wrong to presume you get out what you put in.

There are kids like my dd who have multiple sen diagnoses/EHCP who could not put more effort in if they tried. She is a model pupil, has extra tuition several times a week, revises every night and barely socialises but will struggle to get a 4 in Maths next year.

If I broke your leg then asked why you hadnt won the 100m whilst praising the one you did hopefully you would understand how ridiculous you sounded.

DrBlackbird · 26/08/2022 08:48

And teachers telling students to not study their preferred subject at A Level because they’re not capable might reflect on Sir John Gurdon whose teacher called his ambition to devote himself to science ‘ridiculous’ because he was last out of the 250 boys in his year group at biology, and was in the bottom set in every other science subject. Fortunately he ignored this teacher, went on to study science and was ultimately awarded a Nobel Prize for his pioneering work on cloning.

Chakraleaf · 26/08/2022 08:41

DisneyDisneyDisney · 26/08/2022 01:40

Can I say how proud I am of my daughter. She took her GCSES last year (assessed grades) and I think got a worse deal than if she had sat her exams. She got a 3 in maths and had to re-take it this year at college. We found out today that she has passed and got a 4!! She has worked so hard for that GCSE!! Am so proud of her.

Well done!

DrBlackbird · 26/08/2022 08:36

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/08/2022 23:34

No one has suggested that however this is a thread celebrating those who worked just as hard but their results don't reflect that

It’s unfortunate that some PP are missing the point of this thread. Some spectacularly so and can FOTTFSOFO. I’m not even appreciating what feels like the stealth boasting, but thank you @FunnysInLaJardin for starting the thread. And well done to every child celebrating their achievements, whatever they are for them, in this messed up educational system and for persevering during unprecedented hard times both personal and national.

hugefanofcheese · 26/08/2022 08:09

Not reading the full thread but very good point OP and well done to everyone! Even those without stellar grades have got through a tough and stressful exam period and can move on to do whatever they want in life.

Hercisback · 26/08/2022 08:09

@Girliefriendlikespuppies For A level (especially maths and science), you will struggle to achieve an E at A level if you have scraped a 5 at GCSE. The most common A level maths grade awarded to students who got a GCSE grade 5 is a U. As teachers it would be unfair to set students up to fail.

x2boys · 26/08/2022 08:06

justfiveminutes · 26/08/2022 06:39

I haven't rtft but am a teacher and wanted to say that, despite it often being the high achievers celebrated in the media, we in school celebrate every single success and are so proud of our hard-working students regardless of grade. So many lovely stories at school yesterday, my favourite being a very challenging student who was predicted 1s and 2s but achieved 4s and rang her mum, crying, to say she passed them all. I heard her mum scream. Well done to all of your dc, on to the next stage, whatever that might be.

Aw that made me a bit tearful as the parent of a non academic boy whose about to go into year 11 and trys his best I'm hoping and praying he gets some fours .

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 26/08/2022 07:58

Brigante9 · 25/08/2022 23:23

My biggest win today was a student who overachieved his target of a 4 and got a 5 and was all fired up to do my subject for A level! I had to say no, he wouldn’t cope, but I was so chuffed for him.

What??

Why would you say that?!

Bloody hell, that's the sort of crap teachers told me all my life.

If your student wants to do the A level bloody well encourage them!!

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 26/08/2022 07:43

Teacher here - spent lots of time punching the air in pleasure at loads of 4s yesterday because they could quite easily have been 2/3! Nothing like seeing my kids do extremely well and exceed expectation, even if they follow it up with ‘and I don’t ever have to do <this subject> again!’

theknave · 26/08/2022 07:04

badhappening · 26/08/2022 01:06

@PyongyangKipperbang
It’s better to ignore ignorant posters or trolls.

Unfortunately this type of positive thread is a huge magnet for them to stick the boot in.

They crave attention, so ignore and they usually go away 😁

This. It's a shame because this could have been a really positive thread to celebrate those students who don't get the recognition despite having had to put in so much more effort. I'd much rather hear about the ones who've got one low grade and nothing else but had the struggle of their life to get there than someone who's got all 8s and 9s and breezed through private school being spoon-fed. Why can't they give media coverage to the real success stories for a change? I ended up refreshing the other GCSE thread multiple times yesterday because I wanted to find out how the Mumsnetter with the autistic daughter got on and I was so delighted when she posted again and said the daughter had succeeded. All the other GCSE headlines in the news I ignore because they're just 'little Charles just got 100 grade 15s at private school and the examiner said his script was the best he'd ever seen in every subject'.

notyourmummy · 26/08/2022 07:02

My children aren't at GCSE age yet, but my first ever 1:1 child got a 4 and a 6, alongside a pass in Functional Skills of English and Maths, and I cried with joy and pride. She's faced and come through so much adversity, and even though it was 12 years ago when I supported her, I'll never stop being proud of her!

MinervaTerrathorn · 26/08/2022 06:56

Study will improve grades but every child is starting from a different point, or different levels in different subjects.

DS was average at writing and ahead of all his classmates in maths at the age of 4. His GCSEs have followed the same English/humanities, maths/science split 12 years later. I'm happy about the 7 to 9 grades he got, but just as proud (and much more relieved) about his 6,4 in English.

Softplayhooray · 26/08/2022 06:41

If your child has got all A stars, why not just be super happy with that, and not need to make sure you're 'reminding' other parents that your kid must've worked harder than their children. That's an awful attitude!! Competitive , vicariously living through your child, and other ugly stuff. It's amazing how well your child will have done, and everyone will see that, and that's enough.

Back to the original point of this thread, OP I love that your intention is to celebrate all kids as some will have to have worked so hard for 4's, etc. Well done them, they're amazing.

Didn't Steven Spielberg get kicked out of school and fail everything in his early teens? Without him we'd have no Marty McFly and Back to the Future but he was an academic failure. He'd have been savaged on this thread. Every kid can excel whether academic, or in many other ways. We should big them all up.

justfiveminutes · 26/08/2022 06:39

I haven't rtft but am a teacher and wanted to say that, despite it often being the high achievers celebrated in the media, we in school celebrate every single success and are so proud of our hard-working students regardless of grade. So many lovely stories at school yesterday, my favourite being a very challenging student who was predicted 1s and 2s but achieved 4s and rang her mum, crying, to say she passed them all. I heard her mum scream. Well done to all of your dc, on to the next stage, whatever that might be.

alloalloallo · 26/08/2022 06:30

OriginalUsername2 · 26/08/2022 00:06

That’s very judgmental! Everybody’s brains work differently. Some people have adhd, ASD, dyslexia, bad home lives..

Yes!

My DD has severe dyslexia, Tourette’s, ASD and FND.

She had to re-take her maths and English GCSEs this year at college alongside her level 2 diploma.

She got 4 for English and I’m so ridiculously chuffed for her. Unfortunately she didn’t get her maths this time, but 1 down, 1 to go.

She worked so bloody hard to get that 4

Her brain works differently - she passed all the BTechs she took in year 11 with merits and distinctions and she passed the 1st year of her diploma course with merits and distinctions. GCSEs don’t work for her, no matter how hard she worked or how much revision she did.

I’m over the moon for all those kids who got their 8s and 9s yesterday, but celebrating those lower grades doesn’t take anything away from those with higher grades, how ridiculous

Lougle · 26/08/2022 06:17

@DisneyDisneyDisney and @PollyEsther congratulations to your children.

MinervaTerrathorn · 26/08/2022 06:06

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

8s and 9s do not necessarily mean more effort. DS is not the studious type but put in a lot of effort in his last year to get a 6,4 in English and had extra help in a small group in class. He got an 8 in maths with no study at all.

Questionaboutjoboffer · 26/08/2022 06:02

The thing which annoys me at the school where I work and at my kids’ school, is that it is only the high achieving students who were asked to be in photos with SLT - photos that will go on the website and on social media.

Where I work lots of teachers were praising all the students regardless of their results, and I know my daughter’s A Level teacher praised her for her C in History (huge improvement on where she was in January), but overall what seems to matter most to schools is the fact that there are students who raise their attainment scores etc… I guess this trap is not of the schools’ making.

Education seems to be about this quite narrow hierarchical
outcome that doesn’t treat the person holistically and doesn’t recognise the other strengths they might have outside of the quite narrow focus of heavily examined academic subjects which force teachers to teach to the test.

Why can’t all the students be photographed for the website??

(Disclaimer - this is based on two schools - maybe others did photograph everyone!)