Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want a little celebration for the lower achievers at GCSE?

216 replies

FunnysInLaJardin · 25/08/2022 21:05

DS1 got three 6's and three 4's at GCSE. He failed history and biology.

He could have done better, but amidst the nine 9's I feel like saying a small well done to the other kids who did well - even if they didn't blow the roof off!

GCSE's are a stepping stone and as long as your DC are happy, any grades are cause for celebration.

DS1 can now move on to college and start the next stage in his life, and for that I am very thankful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sashh · 28/08/2022 01:55

JudgeJ · 27/08/2022 11:54

It should have been Guild, typo. Wasn't it supposed to be an event that occurred every 75 years? It was a common phrase in the NW where I grew up.

It happens in Preston every 20 years. I was working in Preston for one, it's quite a big deal.

Being academic is not the be all and end all thankfully and too much emphasis is put on those exams - I'd love to see more vocational training starting at 14 for those who are just not interested in Henry VIII, An Inspector Calls or French verb conjugations but want to fix a car or plumb a house.

You can actually go to an FE college at 14. Schools tend not to tell you this

@listsandbudgets and @FlorettaB I was like that with English. I managed to get O Level English early and then dropped literature sp I had time to study other subjects.

Bluevelvetsofa · 27/08/2022 17:09

I taught for many years and celebrated or commiserated with so many students over the years. The one that I’ll always remember though, is the boy who couldn’t read or write much at all, but was a genius with machinery.

We got him a place at college to do a mechanics course in Year 10 and 11 and he had a TA to support the written element. He did Resistant Materials GCSE and he support for the written part of that too. He achieved a good grade for that and for his college course. He may not have the basics of English or Maths, but if I wanted someone to take the engine out of a car and put it back with all the bits in the right place, he’s the one I’d go to.

ExtraOnion · 27/08/2022 16:21

DD missed almost all of Y10 and Y11 - anxiety brought on by undiagnosed autism. She got 5 grade 4s, and is going to study a L3 BTEC. Her new college have been amazing, so fingers crossed

springisaroundthecorner · 27/08/2022 16:13

Thank you OP for recognising the lower achievers.
DS got one grade 3, a grade 2 and two grade 1.

FlorettaB · 27/08/2022 15:33

They struggled with some of their A Level Maths work

FlorettaB · 27/08/2022 15:21

listsandbudgets · 27/08/2022 12:30

@FlorettaB Are you me? I got my GCSE results 30 years ago - a string of As, a couple of Bs.... but I didn't give a damn about those.. I got a C in maths and was dancing round the room shouting "I'll never have to do maths again, I passed maths".

When DD got her results this week I thought back to my own experience and all I could remember was this absolute euphoria about giving up maths 😂

I just loathed it listsandbudgets. It gave me true joy to drop it. I always felt like I was right at the limits of my capacity to understand. Seeing friends who got A*s in maths GCSE struggle with some of their A Level work only confirmed it for me.

staceyflack · 27/08/2022 12:50

Last year, my daughter passed English, Science and functional Maths.

She has dyspraxia, dyslexia, chronic fatigue syndrome, hypermobility, anxiety and depression and recently was diagnosed with ptsd. We lost her nan and uncle (my mum and brother) in that time, her uncle to suicide. Her dad split up with his long term partner (a step-mum she loves) and she changed schools twice.
Oh and there was a pandemic.

I have no idea what grades she got, and I remain absolutely delighted by her achievement.

So yes, congratulations to your youngster and to all the kids doing their best to navigate this crazy thing call life. And if you didn't pass... up you get, and try again. 😘

balalake · 27/08/2022 12:37

OP, I agree with you that it should not be the grade 9s that in many cases should be celebrated. Your DS has the grades needed for college which is what matters.

I failed biology too, indeed I have not got any 'ology'. So your DS has company!

listsandbudgets · 27/08/2022 12:30

@FlorettaB Are you me? I got my GCSE results 30 years ago - a string of As, a couple of Bs.... but I didn't give a damn about those.. I got a C in maths and was dancing round the room shouting "I'll never have to do maths again, I passed maths".

When DD got her results this week I thought back to my own experience and all I could remember was this absolute euphoria about giving up maths 😂

listsandbudgets · 27/08/2022 12:09

Hercisback · 26/08/2022 08:09

@Girliefriendlikespuppies For A level (especially maths and science), you will struggle to achieve an E at A level if you have scraped a 5 at GCSE. The most common A level maths grade awarded to students who got a GCSE grade 5 is a U. As teachers it would be unfair to set students up to fail.

My DD was told she'd have to get a 8 in any science she wanted to do for A level and a 7 in maths to do that. She got the grades but it seemed a pretty steep offer.

Some of her friends didn't get what they needed but it was lovely to hear their friends buoying them up and pulling them into the celebrations, talking about how hard they'd worked and helping them plan for the future. DD had a party of sorts and we had guests who had everything from straight 9s down to 2s and 3s and they were all lovely, intelligent people who just happened to be good at variety of different things and also had had different backgrounds and chances.

Being academic is not the be all and end all thankfully and too much emphasis is put on those exams - I'd love to see more vocational training starting at 14 for those who are just not interested in Henry VIII, An Inspector Calls or French verb conjugations but want to fix a car or plumb a house.

JudgeJ · 27/08/2022 11:54

sashh · 27/08/2022 08:21

LOL it's years since I heard, 'Preston Guild' referenced, in fact I think it was Preston Guild the last time I heard it.

It should have been Guild, typo. Wasn't it supposed to be an event that occurred every 75 years? It was a common phrase in the NW where I grew up.

sashh · 27/08/2022 08:21

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 13:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s.

Why does this thread seem to produce more utter nonsense than any other? I could study brain surgery from now until the next Preston Guild but I could never do it!

LOL it's years since I heard, 'Preston Guild' referenced, in fact I think it was Preston Guild the last time I heard it.

Appledrop · 26/08/2022 14:00

My son had mainly Bs and Cs in his GCSEs (Wales), no As, none of his papers that he was put in for allowed for that unfortunately, anyway, his A levels he came out with ABCC (His first 'A' grade and it was a science, Biology).

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 13:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s.

Why does this thread seem to produce more utter nonsense than any other? I could study brain surgery from now until the next Preston Guild but I could never do it!

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 13:25

If your student wants to do the A level bloody well encourage them!!

What nonsense, no-one should be encouraging a student to set themselves up for a fall, few 16 years olds are aware of the vast difference between GCSE and A level. The teacher did the right thing, scraping a higher grade isn't good enough for A level.
Hopefully the World Cup team won't be selected on the lines of Oh, but he really, really wants to play for England!

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 13:21

Keyansier · 25/08/2022 21:08

Not that it matters, but does anyone know why they changed it from A's, B's etc to numbers?

At a guess, I think that with 9 grades they are able to clarify the grades a bit more, an old C could have been almost a B or almost a D, although any system with grade boundaries can't be perfect, until the schools share the raw marks and the grade boundaries studfents won't know how close they were, either way. I think this is the first years that schools will have access to marked scripts.

FunnysInLaJardin · 26/08/2022 13:13

Just caught up with the thread and a huge well done to all of the DC on their achievements.

To answer a poster way upthread, DS1 is going to do a BTEC in Digital Game Development which should really suit his artistic and techy abilities.

He was going to do a' levels but decided not and and TBH I am relieved as although he is bright, academic study is really not for him.

Things have changed so much since I sat my O'Levels - many years ago!. Most people got B's and C's with an A grade being quite out of the ordinary. Now I have the sense that anything less than straight 9's is somehow failing, which of course it isn't at all!

OP posts:
OneForestOne · 26/08/2022 12:09

DD got some really good grades but the one she is most proud of was the lowest one being a 5 in maths. She could not have put more effort in to achieving that and spent hours seeking out support and studying to get it. It's sad to read that for some anything less than an 8 or 9 creates an assumption that she was down the park or pissing about. She wasn't!! I could not be happier or prouder of her for getting "only" a 5.

MrsAvocet · 26/08/2022 12:05

I would agree that taking A levels, particularly in maths and science if you've not gained high grades at GCSE is probably not a good idea unless there is some reason as to why the GCSE grade was lower than the teachers feel the pupil was capable of.
My elder DS got a 7 at GCSE for maths and did A level, finishing with a C. But it was really hard. People talk about the jump from GCSE to A level but I don't think he'd realised quite how big it was, tbough of course covid played it's part too.
Younger DS has just also got a 7 - slap bang in the middle of a 7 on the grade boundaries - and is doing A level so I have booked a tutor right from the beginning. For the degree he wants to do, he is going to need at least a B in maths and he knows that is going to be a challenge. He really wants it and is prepared to work (he was studying yesterday before we went out for his GCSE celebrations) but, as has been discussed on this thread already, hard work, on it's own, isn't always enough. It's conceivable that DS2 won't have the capability to achieve what he wants, but there's a reasonable possibility that he can, and he's likely to find his other two A levels a bit less challenging so it's worth him aiming for his dream. But if he had got a 5 I would have been saying "Look, you have other talents. There's different things you can do that you are more likely to succeed in and that will probably make you happier long term."
It's true you don't want to write youngsters off, and sometimes people do change later, but as a general rule I think it's wrong to let pupils embark on A levels where they are very likely to fail. The whole Disneyesque "you can be anything you want to be" ethos is damaging because, for most of us, it's just not true. And the double whammy is that it can lead to those who don't reach their dream feeling it's their own fault as they mustn't have tried hard enough, when that's usually not true either.
We need to value people for who they are, celebrate more diverse achievements than merely the academic, but don't shove square pegs into round holes - or indeed let those square pegs damage themselves by trying to make themselves round.

FlorettaB · 26/08/2022 12:04

Well done to your DD. I was so happy after my GCSEs when I realised that I’d never have to do maths again!

5128gap · 26/08/2022 12:03

FunnyNC · 25/08/2022 21:28

The issue I find with this OP is that the ones with 8s and 9s did put more time and effort over the years than the 4s and 5s. My dd got 8s and 9s. She worked so hard to get those results, when her friends were down the park or pretending to work online during covid my dd was actually doing her school work. Yes it's great for everyone who passed but lets not do participation awards/celebrations and take away the hard work over the years of the high achievers. I say that as a parent of a yr 11 this year and a parent of another going into yr 11 in September who's predicted 4s and 5s - his dedication to school work is not the same as my eldests so no his achievement won't be so great. That's life, you put in what you get out!

For the high achievers, success, and the options it affords is its own reward. I think its a bit much to expect less academic students who already know their achievements are less valued generally, no matter how hard won, to sit around applauding the high achievers with no recognition themselves. Hard work and effort should be recognised over outcome.

maeveiscurious · 26/08/2022 11:51

My dc got 4s in the results in 2020. They now have ABB in a BTEC. I think when they find their subject it's easier

alwaysfactor50 · 26/08/2022 11:49

@FunnysInLaJardin my daughter got an 8 in history BUT she is more proud of the 5 in Spanish (bitch of a teacher said she would be lucky to get a 3 as she didn't work hard- so untrue and unfair)

She's also more proud of the 6 in maths too as she has always struggled, extra tuition really did pay off.

I'm a teacher and like others on here I feel more proud of those who have tried and achieved than those students who could breeze through everything (although of course I'm pleased with those too just differently)

Wineaddict · 26/08/2022 11:32

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 26/08/2022 08:56

Does it matter? My dd loves history, it's her favourite subject and she has talked about wanting to be a History teacher or archeologist one day. She got a 5 in her exam Ystd which she was delighted with.

If she wanted to do History A level I would 100% support her.

I had teachers telling me at school that I'd fail my science GCSE (I didn't, I passed despite getting crap teaching) and not to do English A level as I wouldn't cope (I did do the A level and coped just fine....)

I also now have a degree and have done a lot of further post grad studying.

You can tell a student to think about it and that it will take a lot of work but if that's what they really want to do then go for it.

Whilst I do agree with you to an extent, sixth forms and colleges have a criteria that needs to be met, just like Unis do.
For maths and sciences these are usually set higher than other subjects at 8s and 7s as they are not likely to do well or even fail at A level if they haven’t achieved higher grades at GCSE level.

So if a child really wanted to study a certain subject at the next level, then first they’ll need to resit previous exams to try to get themselves on to the course - so yes, if they want it badly enough, they should go for it!

Itsbritneybitch22 · 26/08/2022 11:10

DisneyDisneyDisney · 26/08/2022 01:40

Can I say how proud I am of my daughter. She took her GCSES last year (assessed grades) and I think got a worse deal than if she had sat her exams. She got a 3 in maths and had to re-take it this year at college. We found out today that she has passed and got a 4!! She has worked so hard for that GCSE!! Am so proud of her.

@DisneyDisneyDisney

Shes amazing 💖 well done to her.