Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wtf is with this submissive women trend recently?

154 replies

lousyanxiety · 25/08/2022 19:36

I'm seeing this everywhere on social media atm. Young women talking about returning to the "natural feminine state" of being "submissive" to your partner. It seems to include leaving your job, becoming a stay at home wife (or even girlfriend), cooking and cleaning for your partner, tending to all his needs, and leaving him in control of all the finances and difficulty of life.

Basically, you need to tap into your "divine feminine" energy to bring out a mans "masculine" energy to make him provide for you, take care of you, and stay loyal to you. And a woman who has "masculine" energy (aka provides for herself and is independent) will never truly be happy 🤔
Apparently the idea that women could have it all - career, kids, happy marriage etc was a lie and it's easier to just rely on a partner...
Whats so crazy about this is its WOMEN saying this stuff.

I mean... I thought we'd got past this mentality a long effing time ago??? Surely this is only going to benefit the man in the long run.

Is this a movement thats stemming from these alpha male podcasts? What is happening?

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 25/08/2022 22:24

bellac11 · 25/08/2022 22:19

Oh my god, the 'patriarchy'

Such a victim mentality.

Women have agency and choice about how they live their lives and what they believe in. If women choose this for themselves thats up to them. It has its pros and cons as many have identified on this thread.

You keep telling yourself that.

In the meantime 51% of the world's population are disproportionately raped, murdered, subjected to domestic violence, aborted, lack equal (or any) medical care, lack equal pay and opportunity with men and even in the so superior and advanced West women still pay the lifetime maternity tax even if they immediately return to work after giving birth.

But yes all so boring - stick to tiktok, it might fit your attention span.

bellac11 · 25/08/2022 22:19

C8H10N4O2 · 25/08/2022 22:11

No of course not any more than advertising of any kind tells you you smell, you are fat, ugly or in any way deficient. It simply tells you your life will be better with their products, subtly undermines your confidence in yourself and your decisions and plants the seed. It works.

You ask why it comes around in cycles - because we live in a patriarchy which will never give up trying to push women into our "place". The costume may change, the medium may evolve but the objective remains the same.

Oh my god, the 'patriarchy'

Such a victim mentality.

Women have agency and choice about how they live their lives and what they believe in. If women choose this for themselves thats up to them. It has its pros and cons as many have identified on this thread.

Hawkins001 · 25/08/2022 22:16

With all due respect, that sounds very very woo thinking, especially these days with how faithful, ect people are.

But at the same time, if that's their beliefs, then that's up to them.

Weefreetiffany · 25/08/2022 22:13

I see what you're saying here. Women shouldn't have to act like men to be successful and success shouldn't be measured in one way. You're forgetting though, that many women genuinely love doing and are interested in tasks/activities that are stereotypically masculine. And these women aren't adopting these interests or doing these things because they feel it's the only way to get ahead. Examples: some women love bodybuilding, or working hard in a corporate job, and it's not because they feel like they have to. Some women are very strong willed and are natural leaders, and they aren't faking it to try be accepted by society. Im all for women making their own choices, and it's sad that some women feel they have to be stereotypically masculine to be successful.

well I am a woman with a stereotypically masculine career history, but then again a lot of the interesting jobs were stereotypically masculine until recently. And the ways of doing them have been stereotypically masculine too. This is changing and so is the binary where masc has been strong and fem therefore weak. We have to bring the balance and that means valuing the female and woman stereotypes.

My job includes carrying heavy things and delegating to men and being delegated to! And it’s not without complications. Of course women aren’t faking their leadership or wilfulness, but it’s disingenuous to say it’s all smooth sailing for them being shoehorned into a masculine paradigm, in how they’re received and how they progress and the standards they’re measured against. Like I said it’s not my way of thinking, the trad wife thing feels like an equal and opposite extreme to the be your own pimp girlbossing. But I do like championing female things and re-examining my own biases.

A lot of the women I've met don't feel that way, instead they feel pressure to be feminine when they aren't naturally very feminine.

because “woman” and “feminine” has become a performance rather than a state of being. It doesn’t serve the current state of things for us to be connected to our bodies as owner and enjoyers, womens health is still sidelined, the reality of ageing inconvenient because we become unfuckable in the eyes of men we shouldn’t give a minute to. Wouldn’t it be nice if being a woman was just feeling comfortable in and enjoying your body as it goes through all the constant fucking changes we deal with and having society support that and value it. To me that’s the goal of “being in your feminine energy.” Feeling like I’m enough as I am, not like a failure for not having it all and being perfect/ all things to all people all the time.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/08/2022 22:11

lousyanxiety · 25/08/2022 19:50

Hmm the backdoor fundamentalism thing is interesting. But the videos I'm seeing don't appear to have religious themes, they seem more like the female version of alpha male podcasts 🤔

No of course not any more than advertising of any kind tells you you smell, you are fat, ugly or in any way deficient. It simply tells you your life will be better with their products, subtly undermines your confidence in yourself and your decisions and plants the seed. It works.

You ask why it comes around in cycles - because we live in a patriarchy which will never give up trying to push women into our "place". The costume may change, the medium may evolve but the objective remains the same.

Notlosinganyweight · 25/08/2022 22:01

Apparently the idea that women could have it all - career, kids, happy marriage etc was a lie and it's easier to just rely on a partner...

Well that is kind of true isn't it? Except it is easier to rely on that partner if they are good at breadwinning and are decent at home too, but I think this theory falls short when the man isn't bringing in much money or is hoarding most of it for himself, is pretty much absent as a father and is a repulsive, abusive shit. Most of the men that go for this idea are unfortunately like that.

WhatI want to know is how this theory works when one income barely covers your gas bill or mortgage? How does it work with only one person working at a time like this?

bellac11 · 25/08/2022 21:58

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 21:50

I don’t know about this whole trend thing but I agree that ‘we can have it all’ is a lie… women rushing back to work largely benefits men in the grand scheme of things. Most of the profits made in the world are for companies owned by men. Also paying for childcare - again a chance for profit to be made! I’m not saying being ‘submissive’ as you name in your post is good - of course it isn’t! But I think young women these days are awake for the fact they can’t have it all really. I saw my mum struggle with ‘having it all’ and in reality what none of us had was any time with her. There’s definitely a middle ground to be found! x

In your eagerness to be anti men you've overlooked that women not working is more beneficial for men.

Ilovemycatalot · 25/08/2022 21:52

I think most men these days prefer the woman out earning as well especially with the cost of living. I see many threads on here where the woman is a SAHM and the husband wants her to go back to work and doesn’t want responsibility of being the main breadwinner. Maybe it was a thing in previous generations but I wouldn’t say it is now.

Amortentia · 25/08/2022 21:50

Diverseopinions · 25/08/2022 21:44

I suppose it's the oil prices, and cost of living, that makes staying at home and being 'looked after' seem attractive.

See how far that goes when the natural male state is revealed to be having several partners at once , like the lion with its pride, and the natural feminine state is defined as accepting this man's needs. Can't see this trend lasting.

Also think that men like the fact that the partner is prepared to help with the earning.

Which is all well and good when the kids are young, but once they hit late teens and the husband leaves you're up a financial shit creek without a paddle.

I used to volunteer for an organisation that helped people sort out their financial problems. I got the fright of my life dealing with loads of single mothers who had no work history and who’s benefits stopped once the kids got to 16/18. Putting yourself in this situation by choice is utter madness and I say that as someone who had no choice but be a sahm because I had a child with a disability.

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 21:50

I don’t know about this whole trend thing but I agree that ‘we can have it all’ is a lie… women rushing back to work largely benefits men in the grand scheme of things. Most of the profits made in the world are for companies owned by men. Also paying for childcare - again a chance for profit to be made! I’m not saying being ‘submissive’ as you name in your post is good - of course it isn’t! But I think young women these days are awake for the fact they can’t have it all really. I saw my mum struggle with ‘having it all’ and in reality what none of us had was any time with her. There’s definitely a middle ground to be found! x

TambourineOfRepentance · 25/08/2022 21:46

Curiosity101 · 25/08/2022 21:35

The 'masculine' energy thing bugs me. My MIL was talking about it ages ago. And how exhausting it is having to project it if you work in a male dominated industry. And how I should really read this book on how to be feminine and successful in the workplace because when she worked in a male dominated sector she found it so draining.

It never occurred to her for one second that times may have changed and that perhaps my 'masculine' energy is just my personality. But then she also mentioned how her exH (my FIL) never changed a single nappy so... Yeah...

Yes! If I had a pound for every time I'd heard "You're trying to act like a man!" or similar inanities, I'd be able to support a couple of trad wives of my own.

Terfydactyl · 25/08/2022 21:46

AprilHeather · 25/08/2022 21:25

I’m sure I read an article recently that said it tended to happen during times of austerity, recession, etc. But I’ve forgotten why. I’ll see if I can find the article again tomorrow…

Oh that makes sense.
I remember surrendered wives and looking back I'm sure it was in a time of austerity.

I watched half a programme on a surrendered wife and honestly I dont know how she lived like that. She was completely beholden to him. I remember thinking , if he just fucks off to be with another woman, the wife is completely screwed, depending on his generosity. I could see he loved it, he made her wear a blindfold when he drove the family, so she couldn't say anything about how he drove. Ffs.

This sounds like more of the same. I'm all for women doing whatever makes them happy, I just want them to cover themselves if it all goes wrong and keep themselves employable by whatever means.

Diverseopinions · 25/08/2022 21:44

I suppose it's the oil prices, and cost of living, that makes staying at home and being 'looked after' seem attractive.

See how far that goes when the natural male state is revealed to be having several partners at once , like the lion with its pride, and the natural feminine state is defined as accepting this man's needs. Can't see this trend lasting.

Also think that men like the fact that the partner is prepared to help with the earning.

mackthepony · 25/08/2022 21:44

"don't argue with your husband!!!"

😂😂😂😂

AprilHeather · 25/08/2022 21:43

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 25/08/2022 21:27

@AprilHeather

I’m sure I read an article recently that said it tended to happen during times of austerity, recession, etc. But I’ve forgotten why. I’ll see if I can find the article again tomorrow…

Makes sense. When resources are scarce men want to try and corner them as much as possible. Economically independent women are in the way.

Yes, I think you’re right!

lljkk · 25/08/2022 21:41

Surrendered wife was big in about 2006. Meh.

Curiosity101 · 25/08/2022 21:35

The 'masculine' energy thing bugs me. My MIL was talking about it ages ago. And how exhausting it is having to project it if you work in a male dominated industry. And how I should really read this book on how to be feminine and successful in the workplace because when she worked in a male dominated sector she found it so draining.

It never occurred to her for one second that times may have changed and that perhaps my 'masculine' energy is just my personality. But then she also mentioned how her exH (my FIL) never changed a single nappy so... Yeah...

bellac11 · 25/08/2022 21:34

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 25/08/2022 21:27

@AprilHeather

I’m sure I read an article recently that said it tended to happen during times of austerity, recession, etc. But I’ve forgotten why. I’ll see if I can find the article again tomorrow…

Makes sense. When resources are scarce men want to try and corner them as much as possible. Economically independent women are in the way.

I dont think its led by men is it? Nothing to do with how they view women, its because the feelings of life being scary, hard work, overwhelming come to the fore more.

And as someone set out above, culturally its much easier for women to say they will be the stay at home housewife/homemaker than it is for men.

The equivalent for men I think is that they drift further into conspiracy beliefs, prepper type outlooks.

TambourineOfRepentance · 25/08/2022 21:31

A woman I was at school with went down this route, as did a friend's sister. I knew both quite well. Both had been quite academic but not had a great deal of common sense. There's probably a better way of putting that but I'm not sure what.
Both went into high paying, corporate roles after never having had any other sort of job. These were careers which really were just making your boss more money. They were not socially useful, except in the sense of providing tax revenue.

They ritually complained about this but made no move to change it despite being financially comfortable with a lot of family support. After all, they were very well paid and weren't emotionally or physically demanding jobs. Their biggest problem was that they were dull and unfulfilling. Which could have been predicted, to be honest.

They've married rich men with big egos, gotten pregnant and found an emotional fulfilment in their babies that they didn't find in their jobs, and blamed feminism for all their past woes. Feminism has made them now down to the corporate, capitalist machine (which they seem to appreciate as consumers) and repress their natural femininity (?!).

They aren't religious or especially political. There's nothing hugely more complex here than women who chased top dollar without a huge amount of critical thought and couldn't be arsed to change anything about it themselves so waited for someone else to subsidise them. And then blamed feminism.

Whyyes · 25/08/2022 21:29

'I interpreted it as a backlash to the idea that women have to act like men to be successful. When often that can backfire just as much and lead to a loss of identity and connection. It’s enough to be a woman and take pride in it and removing the trivialisation of feminine interests. That the starting point shouldn’t be “you can do this almost as well as a man, just work twice as hard as them for half the recognition” it’s saying it’s ok if you want to be a mum and or have a job that isn’t a Career when capitalist patriarchy is encouraging you all your friends to prioritise overtime at the office and freeze their eggs to start motherhood at 39 and not value the idea of a family unit.'

I see what you're saying here. Women shouldn't have to act like men to be successful and success shouldn't be measured in one way. You're forgetting though, that many women genuinely love doing and are interested in tasks/activities that are stereotypically masculine. And these women aren't adopting these interests or doing these things because they feel it's the only way to get ahead. Examples: some women love bodybuilding, or working hard in a corporate job, and it's not because they feel like they have to. Some women are very strong willed and are natural leaders, and they aren't faking it to try be accepted by society. Im all for women making their own choices, and it's sad that some women feel they have to be stereotypically masculine to be successful. A lot of the women I've met don't feel that way, instead they feel pressure to be feminine when they aren't naturally very feminine.

Beezknees · 25/08/2022 21:29

Well fuck that, from a single parent on a low income who gets UC. I'd rather be on the bones of my arse than cook and clean for a man and have him in charge of my finances. And I have been on the bones of my arse many a time in my 14 years as a single mum!

Foldingchair · 25/08/2022 21:27

I remember the surrendered wife stuff. Sometimes, when I've had a shit week and I'm juggling everything and it's 10 o fucking clock and I'm still at it and one of the kids suddenly remembers hw and I haven't sorted a babysitter for the weekend yet and there are relatives I need to check on but I can't b'cos work is nuts, I think how nice it would be just to let it all be someone else's problem, or at least let someone else do the brain work and just tell me what to do.

But then... what if they did it wrong?

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 25/08/2022 21:27

@AprilHeather

I’m sure I read an article recently that said it tended to happen during times of austerity, recession, etc. But I’ve forgotten why. I’ll see if I can find the article again tomorrow…

Makes sense. When resources are scarce men want to try and corner them as much as possible. Economically independent women are in the way.

AprilHeather · 25/08/2022 21:25

I’m sure I read an article recently that said it tended to happen during times of austerity, recession, etc. But I’ve forgotten why. I’ll see if I can find the article again tomorrow…

remiss · 25/08/2022 21:19

Leafy3 · 25/08/2022 21:09

Maybe psychologically there's an element of some ppl being overwhelmed with our f*ed world and finding a sense of security in being looked after?

I mean, still wtaf but at least from this angle I can kind of understand it.

Maybe this is it for me.

If I compared living in a cabin in the woods where my "job" was to look after the actual physical needs of my husband and children + some added manual labour to help..

VS what we have now where almost every single part of living comes with a massive mental load (I don't even have to include the career and the fact the washing still needs to be done at the end of the day), then I would take the first option every day of the week so long as I had a good, hardworking husband.

Swipe left for the next trending thread