Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wtf is with this submissive women trend recently?

154 replies

lousyanxiety · 25/08/2022 19:36

I'm seeing this everywhere on social media atm. Young women talking about returning to the "natural feminine state" of being "submissive" to your partner. It seems to include leaving your job, becoming a stay at home wife (or even girlfriend), cooking and cleaning for your partner, tending to all his needs, and leaving him in control of all the finances and difficulty of life.

Basically, you need to tap into your "divine feminine" energy to bring out a mans "masculine" energy to make him provide for you, take care of you, and stay loyal to you. And a woman who has "masculine" energy (aka provides for herself and is independent) will never truly be happy 🤔
Apparently the idea that women could have it all - career, kids, happy marriage etc was a lie and it's easier to just rely on a partner...
Whats so crazy about this is its WOMEN saying this stuff.

I mean... I thought we'd got past this mentality a long effing time ago??? Surely this is only going to benefit the man in the long run.

Is this a movement thats stemming from these alpha male podcasts? What is happening?

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 26/08/2022 08:09

sangletea · 26/08/2022 07:59

For years, (my mother and grandmother) women were gaslit into believing men have a hard day at work and the woman's role is to make sure he's well cared for at home. Man earns and woman does everything else. Children, housework, cooking

Bugger that! I know who had the easier day

Depends what the men did. OH's dad was an outdoor manual worker, all weathers hard physical graft. Sounded like a hard day to me. My dad was in engineering, wasn't as physical but it was constant all day every day. MiL was a sahm until DH went to school then she went to work (production line), she definitely thought work was tougher.

I think the tendency for office work and especially wfh has given a false impression of work. FiL used to say You'll never get rich taking your jacket off and getting your hands dirty.

TimetohittheroadJack · 26/08/2022 08:04

lljkk , absolutely. All these submissive wivies seem young and beautiful and not middle aged, round about the middle, slightly grumpy women (ie, me).

My stay at home fantasty extends to a fantasy man who earns x10 my husband, and is delighted to come home to make his own chicken nuggets while I am still out drinking cocktails with my friends. The cleaning and housework was also done by the cleaner, although I might potter about in the garden the odd time.

Upyouranty · 26/08/2022 08:02

Excuse typos 😳

Upyouranty · 26/08/2022 08:02

They are the ultimate pick me girls. Lib debs for you. Check out the house bunny on Tik Tok. She’s a real women - she’ll teach you all you need to know. Only she doesn’t like women much - gets in much better with men. But if you agree with her then she’ll be your Pal.

sangletea · 26/08/2022 08:00

Now we do both. But I think men have a lot
To learn

sangletea · 26/08/2022 07:59

For years, (my mother and grandmother) women were gaslit into believing men have a hard day at work and the woman's role is to make sure he's well cared for at home. Man earns and woman does everything else. Children, housework, cooking

Bugger that! I know who had the easier day

Tgilaura · 26/08/2022 07:58

I think it is a natural response to the idea that women can “have it all”. A husband, a few beautifully behaved children and a fantastic high powered career.
I have the husband, one tantrummy child, and not what I’d call a high powered career - but a career! Like others have said, when you’re running from pillar to post along with all the mental load that comes from running a home and having a full time job and managing your children… I’m also guilty of fantasising of just handing it all off to someone else and not having to worry!
However, I got a small taste of what it may be like when I had my maternity leave and was bored out of my mind.
Grass isn’t always greener!

FindingMeno · 26/08/2022 07:55

I'm not worrying about this. Most women have got to work at least one job atm to keep up with the cost of living.
I would love the luxury of embracing my divine feminine and becoming nurturer and home-maker. I enjoy all of that, and it's how I feel happiest.
But that's all made up fluffy nonsense for most of us.

HeadNorth · 26/08/2022 07:54

I always think if staying at home with the kids and handing all the financial earning & power to someone else was so great, men would do it.

brookstar · 26/08/2022 07:54

BashfulClam · 25/08/2022 19:37

Look at the Facebook page ‘transformed wife’ it will make your jaw drop!

I wish I hadn't looked.
It's just made me angry

lljkk · 26/08/2022 07:50

It’s a bit of a fantasy though isn’t it?

that was one of my big thoughts about surrendered wives.
Surrendered until.... he cheats, gambles money away, supports the wrong politics, goes to a weird church, invests in bitcoin, starts Morris Dancing.... The women most saying they are reborn submissives are among the strongest willed people out there, they aren't genuinely compromising sorts.

sjxoxo · 26/08/2022 07:48

@bellac11 not man hating. The cause is capitalism rather than ‘men’. We have a society that values money above all else including repopulating. Tricky times lay ahead as the birth rate in the west declines further & further. X

midgetastic · 26/08/2022 07:48

If it's such a great ideal why aren't women fighting men for the privilege to stay at home ?

sangletea · 26/08/2022 07:45

Are these women American though?

TimetohittheroadJack · 26/08/2022 07:42

It’s a bit of a fantasy though isn’t it?

You have got up of a cold wet winter morning, got the kids up, made breakfast, threw some ham sandwiches together, wrestled everyone to school, got to work (slightly late and you can see your boss frowning) spent all day at work, come home to a messy house, stuck chicken nuggets and chips in the oven , helped with homework….

The thought of packing the kids of to school with a prefect lunch then had time to leisurely tidy up, go to the gym, lunch with friends and make a home cooked dinner sounds great.

anotherpotoftea · 26/08/2022 07:34

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 25/08/2022 20:32

Well it's a natural consequence of believing that there is such a thing as 'feeling like a woman'. Trans ideology was always going to take us here.

I don’t think these are connected, but this is MN so there’s always someone around to mention it.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 26/08/2022 07:32

It's just so dangerous for women - especially in the UK which is so pitiful about spousal maintenance, you could do this for 10 or 20 years and walk away with basically nothing for dedicating your life to supporting your husband, while he's had a willing servant doing everything for him just for the cost of board and lodging.

Who would take that risk? I note they don't make sure to advocate that the women should have an equal pension and savings set up in their own name by their protector and provider. That the woman's expected to submit to everything, but there's no standard required from the men, no minimum salary required.

Franklyfrost · 26/08/2022 07:25

It is a lie. Imagine if wages were adequate for one person to stay at home, or both part time, and do the childcare and house work. It’s would be bliss. You’d have spare time. It should however be men who tap into their divine energy to run the house and raise the children because then it would be given serious work status.

forinborin · 26/08/2022 07:08

Obviously completely bonkers, but I would agree is also a lie. Not to the extent of relying on the partner for everything, but for the majority of women it is not feasible to do it all by themselves.
Apparently the idea that women could have it all - career, kids, happy marriage etc was a lie and it's easier to just rely on a partner...

WoodlandMummy · 26/08/2022 06:53

Well some women are lazy and want an easy life and they see behaving like this as their meal ticket. Not the life for me or my DH, he would lose all respect for me if I suddenly changed personality and became subservient.

I’d lose respect for me!

maddy68 · 26/08/2022 06:52

I tend not to judge other people's relationships. Tbh

goldfinchonthelawn · 26/08/2022 06:45

Theanswersarewithin · 25/08/2022 20:09

Oh this is interesting to me…mainly because I fit the kind of stereotype homemaker you’re kind of describing.

In my 20s I forged a successful professional career and was definitely an ‘equal as such’ to my husband, financially. It left me feeling empty though. I experienced anxiety depression and panic attacks due to work load, pressure etc

Once I had my daughter at 32 everything changed. I honestly find joy in serving the people I love most in the world, rather than serving a career/boss that doesn’t really value me. I am so valued at home and it has built my confidence immeasurably. I am so content, in a way that working and financially contributing couldn’t give me.

I think submissive is not how I’d describe myself. My husband is my equal in terms of most things - we make decisions together, respect each other etc. Being a SAHM requires a lot of trust in my husband. If I felt he didn’t value the work I do it would be hard.

I am happy to embrace that he has strengths that enable him to lead and earn and provide. I have strengths that enable me to support, guide, protect and nurture.
I guess it just depends on your personality and what you want out of life :-)

You sound very different from them. You sought personal satisfaction in life and it came in the form of homemaking. IMO that's as liberated and feminist as being a high-flying careerist. You are not evangelising for women to be obedient to selfish, disappointing, misogynistic men.

Loki64 · 25/08/2022 22:44

This is to do with spiritualism.
Having masculine or feminine energy is just that....energy.
Its not to do with wether you work, are a sahm, pay ur own bills etc. Its about energy.

Charlize43 · 25/08/2022 22:42

I wouldn't worry about it as economically there's no way most families could survive on a single salary, especially with the cost of living crisis.

I heard two women recently discussing Meghan Markle recently saying how inspirational she is; how lucky she is to have married into great wealth, and to have such a fabulous life on Easy Street. But realistically, that's not going to happen to most women is it? Their reality is going to be very different.

Leafy3 · 25/08/2022 22:28

bellac11 · 25/08/2022 22:19

Oh my god, the 'patriarchy'

Such a victim mentality.

Women have agency and choice about how they live their lives and what they believe in. If women choose this for themselves thats up to them. It has its pros and cons as many have identified on this thread.

Like it or not, in the UK we do actually live in a patriarchy:

Primogeniture still exists ✔️
The majority of positions of power and influence are held by men ✔️
Gender pay gap exists (in favour of men) ✔️
Glass ceiling hasn't been fully smashed in many industries ✔️
Safety features designed for the male body and not the female ✔️
Female bodies still excluded from medical and scientific research and testing, skewing the results in real terms ✔️

I could go on, but you get the gist.

Do I live with a victim mentality? No, I don't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread