Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think rooms and carpets will come back into fashion

254 replies

Arbesque · 25/08/2022 15:32

The current fashion for wooden floors and open plan layouts has been popular for years. I'm start to find myself drawn to separate rooms and very large rugs or carpets.
Do you think the fashion will change soon? Especially with heating bills soaring?

OP posts:
SeemsSoUnfair · 25/08/2022 18:44

I don't think closed rooms, or carpets will come back into "fashion", anyone with any sense, or lucky enough to have space didn't follow the "fashion" in the first place.

"Open plan" is a con to sell people tiny homes or in offices a way to cram more people uncomfortably into smaller and therefore cheaper spaces. Both are impractical and not particularly pleasant to be in.

As for carpets being an issue because they are unhygienic 🙄, how many of you are licking your carpets anyway!

Violinist64 · 25/08/2022 18:42

Sartre · 25/08/2022 16:38

I hate carpets personally. We only have one on the stairs /upstairs hallway and DS was sick all over it the other night trying to run to the bathroom. It’s horrible to clean up off carpet compared to wooden floors. I just feel like it’s really unhygienic too, I can’t clean it in the same way I do the rest of the house.

This is another reason we are a shoes off household. It keeps a lot of outdoor dirt out of the house. I know this is a contentious topic here but it works for us. Slippers keep our carpets clean along with regular hoovering. Much warmer, too.

FangsForTheMemory · 25/08/2022 18:32

Not carpets, they are disgusting esp if you have pets. But the first thing I did when I moved into my house was get some extra doors put in. Fortunately, it was built with doors but at some point someone took all the downstairs ones out to make it open plan.

allinatizzy · 25/08/2022 18:30

Open plan works well for us. Food smells escaping the kitchen are occasionally an annoyance, but it doesn't happen often, and I'm not sure a door would make that much difference, tbh. We have a quiet dishwasher, the washing machine is closed off in the utility room, and it's rare that one of us is cooking noisily while the other is trying to watch read or watch TV in the lounge.

We're fortunate to have other rooms we can retreat to if we feel the need for privacy or time apart. Once in a while one of us will do something (play music) that might slightly annoy the other with the noise level, but in that case, we can use headphones, go to one of the rooms with doors, or take a walk. I will concede, however, that if we had teenagers I'd prefer to have more room separation.

Charlize43 · 25/08/2022 18:27

Open plan isn't really a problem as I've noticed a trend of people putting in Crittall glass partitions to construct rooms like in the one below.

https://nylonliving.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Print_6.jpg

I'm guessing the fashion for succulents and cacti will go out as rooms become colder.

MarshaBradyo · 25/08/2022 18:25

I’m not keen on open plan anyway although I do like room for dining table in kitchen rather than separate

I wouldn’t replace wood floors though

We do have massively thick curtains triple lined, which I appreciate in cold but also in those really hot days as blocked heat

cushioncovers · 25/08/2022 18:24

Kitchen/dining room I like but I need a separate lounge. But as for carpets downstairs nope I hate them. I like them upstairs though as it makes the bedroom seem cosier.

PurBal · 25/08/2022 18:24

I didn’t know my house was out of fashion 🤷‍♀️
I have a few house pet peeves: open plan living area being one. I stopped cooking when I had an open plan living area because everything stank so fish and curries were off the menu. I don’t want to smell the residual odour when I sit down of an evening to relax. I don’t want to hear the dishwasher/washing machine. I want somewhere to be able to dry my clothes indoors. I want to have privacy that doesn’t mean going to bed. There is nothing to recommend open plan to me.

AntlerRose · 25/08/2022 18:24

My last house was open plan with wood floors. My current one is small rooms with carpet in one room. I miss the wood floor but i dont miss open plan one bit.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 25/08/2022 18:21

Maybe I'm just a huge slattern, but I don't really understand the whole 'carpets are unhygienic' thing. Sure I get it if it's in a bathroom or kitchen (which is pure madness anyway) but anywhere else, no one's eating off the floor, and if you're regularly hoovering then what's the problem? Are some people getting ill from their carpets or something?!

PeloAddict · 25/08/2022 18:19

chillipenguin · 25/08/2022 15:56

Carpet in the bathroom used to be a thing. I hope that never comes back.

My neighbours have it. Also carpeted kitchen
They chose this as it was built 15 years ago Confused
I mean WTF do you do if you drop a pint of milk?!

woodhill · 25/08/2022 18:17

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 25/08/2022 16:18

Never went out of fashion as far as I am concerned.

Nor me, have a separate front room with carpet

Wexone · 25/08/2022 18:16

Had open plan with pocket doors to separate the living room if we wanted to close it. Never once had an issue with cooking smells in my loving room nor the noise of the dishwasher. My washing machine was in the utility room at the other end of the house. Now in a house with every room separate and bloody hate it, i feel so shut off when people are over and even when am on my own. More than three people in the kitchen and it feels cramped. Pain in the arse when hoovering too.
It has wooden floor all over the house and even with a rug down it feels cold and horrible. Plus every bit of dirt shows up on it and am hoovering sometimes twice a day. Love carpets they make a room felle so snug and warm plus are a great sound insulator. Dont see them as dirty, why cant you just do a good hoover. New house will be built with a long kitchen dinner living area loads of space and big doors at one end, do have a snug living room to one side that can be closed off when need too. Can not wait

WireSkills · 25/08/2022 18:07

I don't disagree.

We're looking to knock our kitchen and dining room together as it's currently very impractical, whereas currently the living room and dining room are knocked together. There's a wooden floor running between them now too.

When I'm finished I'll have a carpeted living room with pocket doors to the dining room and a kitchen diner with either wooden or tiled flooring.

I thought I'd love a wooden floor and it is practical when a pet or child throws up or drops something, but it's so, so cold in there and a carpet (and doors) will make it cosy again.

Wishyfishy · 25/08/2022 18:06

AnybodyAnywhere · 25/08/2022 17:14

We’re both retired and when you’re both in the house a lot you need to be able to get away from each other!
I love going into ‘my’ room and get away from the 500th repeat of Wheeler Dealers or Salvage Hunter!
We also have plain beige carpet everywhere except bathroom and kitchen but no kids or pets and DH loves using the carpet shampooing machine.
I couldn’t live open plan, I love my solitude too much.

Yes, I also find it allows me to have space from DC. I don’t mean never seeing them, but never even being in a different room to them would just be too much for me.

Often on a weekend they’ll be watching TV, DH and I will be cooking in the kitchen and sharing a bottle of wine and having a catch up. Obviously we’re all close enough to check on them regularly but it’s all the space from them that I need every now and then.

If I could magic up another room in my house it would be another family room / sitting room etc over another bedroom. It’s great to be able to have space from each other - watch separate TV programmes, or quietly read away from people wanting to chat or kids do homework etc - without having to go up to a bedroom.

BogRollBOGOF · 25/08/2022 18:01

I knew someone who'd split their open planned semi back into seperate rooms to improve heating. While the rooms were small, there wasn't a practical gain on losing the divide anyway and when they put the wall in, they actually built it as bookshelves so gained much more storage.

I've been watching organisation type videos on youtube and most of them tend towards minimalism, open spaces and a limited repetoire of decor, and on some of them, the background echo is awful. Being able to shut doors and block noise from other members of the household is so important to sanity!

I'll do lino in the kitchen/ downstairs wet spaces, and tiles are fine in an upstairs bathroom (too cold for downstairs), but otherwise it's carpet everywhere else. The previous occupants had a laminate obsession and it was so good to finally get back to carpet in the bedroom at long last. Having to get up in the night for feeds onto cold, hard laminate was not fun.

Open plan and hard surfaces would be a major reinvestment to make a house back into a comfortable, functional home again.

silverclock222 · 25/08/2022 17:58

Never felt the need to follow 'trends' so still have rooms.........

JackandSam · 25/08/2022 17:58

Fashion's almost always come back round, so yes, it's likely. I can't imagine people wanting small kitchens though.

I'm fortunate that my house has both - a large open plan kitchen/ living room and a separate playroom (or dining room depending on what you like) and separate lounge. I wouldn't want totally open plan.

queenMab99 · 25/08/2022 17:58

We knocked our tiny Kitchen and the dining room in to one 40 years ago, I have never regretted it, I hated being shut away in the kitchen while cooking. When we retired, we had a multifuel stove installed, so that we could keep one room warm without using cental heating. The washer and dryer are in a separate utility room. It is a lovely sunny room with French windows to the garden, I have practical Karndean flooring with rugs, I love it and will not be changing. I do have another room which is cosy, but still hard floors, as I hate the dirt and dust which collects in carpets.

whirlyhead · 25/08/2022 17:57

I got rid of all my carpet as I have cats that projectile vomit everywhere. Wooden flooring is way easier to clean cat hurl off.

Wishyfishy · 25/08/2022 17:57

I understand open plan in small flats - loads of small rooms wouldn’t be as good. But in a house that can take rooms, rooms all the way.
Our house needed a big refurbishment and some structural changes when we bought it. A few years later the original estate agent came round to revalue and eagerly asked if we’d opened it up to be one big room… I have never once regretted keeping the rooms separate.

Charlize43 · 25/08/2022 17:55

I did wonder in 1930s style heavy tweed suits, big coats that you could then put on your bed and thick woollen wear will all be making a comeback?

Obviously rooms and public places will be colder.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 25/08/2022 17:53

RayneDance · 25/08/2022 17:38

@EmbarrassingHadrosaurus

What a fabulous Idea!

With very cheap wooden frame I'm sure it wouldn't be hard to do?

That's what I'm trying for the screens (it also helps that I managed to pick up a cheap bifold door in a sale that I should be able to convert).

The 4 poster frame might be a bit trickier as I want them to take curtain weight rather than 'bed veil' weight, for warmth, IYSWIM. I've seen some very flimsy arrangements with plastic plumbing fixtures that didn't look good (although would be improved with fabric wrapping) and wouldn't take much weight. But, for a king size bed, I've got my eye on cutting down a metal pergola that one of my neighbours doesn't want. If I put in some connectors and extra braces, it should be strong enough to take proper hangings or some papier-mâché panels.

LondonLovie · 25/08/2022 17:52

Good God I hope not. Flooring so much cleaner and better with under floor heating. Added rug if required.

Open plan v separate rooms depends on your layout, but I'm in no rush to add doors, shut out the light and partition things off.

penelopeisland · 25/08/2022 17:50

As long as carpets in bathrooms doesnt come back in fashion. Its disgusting..

A bit of both would be nice, I personally like to not have a separate kitchen from a dining room. it’s more social.
But separate rooms also were very handy in lockdown, and saving energy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread