Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my mum and brothers relationship is fucking bizarre?

64 replies

TheSnowball · 25/08/2022 14:28

My brother and I are in our 30s. He still lives at home with our mum. I've moved out (thank god!), but had to live with their odd relationship and routine for many years, and according to them, it's still ongoing.

He's always competed with me for her favour, ever since we were kids. But it got worse when our parents separated, it's almost like he's took on the role of being her surrogate husband?

They set their alarm clocks to wake up at the same time as eachother, if one of them has to get up earlier for work, the other one will set their alarm accordingly. They spend hours talking every morning, drive off to work together, drive back home together and then spend 1-2 more hours talking about their day. They don't go anywhere without eachother. They go shopping together, they visit people together. Etc etc.

He agrees with everything she says, hangs onto her every word, she's never in the wrong in his eyes, they slag people off all the time (including me!) and egg eachother on. It's bizarre. I feel awful anxiety speaking to them now because I know when I walk away they're gonna be slagging me off, as always.

Any kind of argument I had with her as a teenager (just normal arguments teenage girls have with their mums), he'd aggressively square up to me, shouting in my face, calling me every name under the sun. She'd then thank him for 'standing up for her', then come and ask me if I was okay and tell me he was out of order ??? Hmm
I felt suffocated and stifled in my own home for years.
Now I'm not allowed to have any kind of disagreement with her without him involving himself and getting aggressive with me.

I'm not being nosey, it wouldn't bother me at all if it wasn't for the fact that I'm not allowed to have a normal relationship with my own mother. I can't speak to her on her own, she's always with him. He makes it a them vs me situation all the time, and gets confrontational and competitive with me. I have to walk on eggshells and watch what I say.

I lived with them and their behaviour for so long and whenever I tried to bring it up they made out that I was the weird one. But surely it's not just me that thinks this is completely fucking abnormal?

OP posts:
traumahell · 25/08/2022 16:46

Codependency/emotional incest .

I’m currrently being given therapy for being the child in a similar situation, it is exceptionally hard to cope when that relationship is no longer possible for whatever reason, I’m left with a hundred different feelings from anger to sadness to guilt to terror . I wish to God someone had spotted it sooner . I don’t know if your brother would be receptive to you talking to him . It was a GP and therapist that pointed it out to me . Circumstances have meant that the relationship in my case is no longer possible at all (parent is dying of dementia) but I suspect it’s going to have an effect on me for the rest of my days .

Sierra1961 · 25/08/2022 16:35

Sounds like an enmeshed relationship, it’s called emotional incest I believe - research it

Ace56 · 25/08/2022 16:29

This is very odd OP but probably more usual than we think. I too know a family like this - the mum has a husband but he’s got mental health issues so isn’t particularly useful/emotionally present, so she’s converted it all to her eldest son. They go everywhere together, make decisions together etc. The husband and the youngest son just seem to accept this. Very strange!

I would try and spend time with you mum alone, without your brother and see what her reaction is.

UniBallEye · 25/08/2022 16:23

@ChristinaRussell Grin
they are weird, aren't they!! I was trying to be nice as it's ok for a son to have a photo with his mum or buy her flowers but there's something just 'off' about these.

In photos he puts his arm around her shoulder (that's ok) but she snuggles in with her head on his shoulder and her had on his chest - it's VERY couple-y

And the flowers are always over the top huge arrangements, often with a soft toy or balloon with love hearts etc and always red roses not a generic bunch of flowers.

It creeps me out! And she always captions them like 'My Dave spoiling me again' (his name is not Dave)

CrapBag39 · 25/08/2022 16:11

extricate yourself from this toxic dynamic, they are abusive weirdos. Ghost and block them both.

ChristinaRussell · 25/08/2022 16:03

she posts weird photos of her draped over this chest (as you might your bf / dh); every Valentine's Day she posts photos of bouquets of red roses he buys her.
None of these things are weird in themselves

Oh yes they are! The photos and roses are creepy as hell <shudder>

Softplayhooray · 25/08/2022 16:02

Draughtycatflapreturns · 25/08/2022 14:45

Are they called Norma and Norman?

I thought this!! OP all I can say is avoid, avoid, avoid.

UniBallEye · 25/08/2022 15:46

I know someone like this. She left her husband and father of her 3 kids to have an affair with a guy who was only barely 20 and not more than a few years older than her kids. She had a kid with him and he left her.

Since then she has leaned HEAVILY on her son. He's become in lots of ways her surrogate husband and now in his 30s he still lives at home. He's only recently got a girlfriend and she is about 18 and like a mini-carbon-copy of his mum!

The mum is very dependent on him and he indulges it, he takes her on holidays and she posts weird photos of her draped over this chest (as you might your bf / dh); every Valentine's Day she posts photos of bouquets of red roses he buys her.
None of these things are weird in themselves I know but there's a strangeness and intensity about it all that it makes me feel like shuddering. It's all very odd.

weeme02 · 25/08/2022 15:43

Draughtycatflapreturns · 25/08/2022 14:45

Are they called Norma and Norman?

Grin
Djeofnekdn · 25/08/2022 15:38

Google Emotional Incest or Covert Incest. There's a very good book called The Emotional Incest Syndrome too. You've basically just described my brother and mum's relationship, right from the idolising one another, spending all their time together, him getting in on any arguments the rest of us had with her, and refusing to let any of us near her. He's 50 and has never had a relationship. Also, if any of us dared argue with the chosen brother, she'd be down on us like a tonne of bricks.
Our mum didn't divorce our dad but he was emotionally abusive and an alcoholic, so she basically expected my brother to provide the support she should have got from her husband.

For years, I didn't have a name for it, and it properly messed our family up.

TheSnowball · 25/08/2022 15:30

Basket20 · 25/08/2022 15:23

My MIL and BIL have the exact same type of relationship and my BIL is aggressive towards my DH about his Mum that can do no wrong. As an outsider, I think it is messed up and also that it is of the MIL making. It suits her to have her DS live with her and hang on her every word. She doesn't care that he has no friends or job or anything in his life other than her. She pitted the children against each other thus the competition. I feel sorry for my BIL even though it looks like he is the problem and my MIL is trying to be supportive. You seem to see your Mum as the victim. Maybe think about it more.

Yep, this sounds like a very similar situation.

I don't think of my mum as the victim, I think they're probably both narcs in their own ways tbh. They're a match made in heaven, really.

OP posts:
Alondra · 25/08/2022 15:29

They are in a codependent relationship. Many people believe codependency only happens in marriages/partnerships, but it can happen in any type of relationship, including parent/adult child.

Just be glad you are out of that dysfunctionality.

Basket20 · 25/08/2022 15:23

My MIL and BIL have the exact same type of relationship and my BIL is aggressive towards my DH about his Mum that can do no wrong. As an outsider, I think it is messed up and also that it is of the MIL making. It suits her to have her DS live with her and hang on her every word. She doesn't care that he has no friends or job or anything in his life other than her. She pitted the children against each other thus the competition. I feel sorry for my BIL even though it looks like he is the problem and my MIL is trying to be supportive. You seem to see your Mum as the victim. Maybe think about it more.

TheSnowball · 25/08/2022 15:21

Comedycook · 25/08/2022 15:15

Does your brother have any special needs? Is he NT?

Not that we know of.

OP posts:
TheSnowball · 25/08/2022 15:20

Dotjones · 25/08/2022 14:58

It sounds like he felt he had to step up to the plate and support his mother when she separated. That may or may not have been a deliberate decision. He's grown into this role and they're both happy with it. Rightly or wrongly he sees your moving out as confirmation that you are happy with that arrangement.

You say he always competed for favour when a child. That's interesting, because it implies that you were also involved in the competition too. It's hard for someone to "compete" against someone who is not interested in the competition.

I don't think their situation is particularly "abnormal" by any means. It's not the standard behaviour but a lot of adult children stay at home with their parent(s) and provide mutual support.

"You say he always competed for favour when a child. That's interesting, because it implies that you were also involved in the competition too. It's hard for someone to "compete" against someone who is not interested in the competition."

No, what I mean by that is whenever I got any kind of attention from my mother as a child, he would get very angry and upset and cry about how I "didn't deserve it". Bear in mind he's 5 years older than me so I would've needed more attention, being so young at the time.
He used to tell me stories of how he tried to 'suffocate me' in my sleep as a child out of jealousy Hmm I think he was lying because I definitely would've known if this happened, but it's still a bizarre thing to say.

I do think that's why he's so hostile and nasty to me now, because I think in his mind I used to be our mums favourite.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 25/08/2022 15:15

Does your brother have any special needs? Is he NT?

ThanksAntsThants · 25/08/2022 15:12

In my parents relationship, which sounds exactly the same, my mother isn’t afraid of my dad. My mother is very narcissistic. My dad is controlling and aggressive to others, including me and my sibling, but he is very flaky and weak willed when it comes to my mother. does this sound familiar to you OP?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 25/08/2022 15:07

Gosh I think my DS would happily stay co- dependant with mammy in his mind aged 7, thankfully once teenagers most boys change their mind.

DitzyBluebells · 25/08/2022 15:06

It's not only down to your brother though OP, your mum is choosing to remain in this messed up relationship with him and not have a normal relationship with you. You don't have to be part of this toxic dynamic, you can walk away from it all.

Your mum failed both of you as a parent. As a child/teenager she could have put a stop to the aggression and verbal abuse towards you. Instead she chose to reward that behaviour and the competitiveness too. Maybe she likes it. Makes her feel important or something? Narcissistic tendencies? Sounds like the golden child/scapegoat dynamic.

She's been gaslighting you by encouraging his bad behaviour towards you then apologising for it on his behalf. She's the parent! She shouldn't have been apologising on his behalf, she should have been apologising for her own behaviour in allowing it to happen the first time. Then learning from her mistake and ensuring it never happened again.

Definitely messed up that your brother is spousified and TBH that's your mum's doing, she's the parent, she should have stopped it not encouraged it.

Maybe your brother is controlling now but your mum encouraged that personality trait and doesn't seem concerned by it. She's made no effort to get some distance by living separately from him, dating, building friendships, seeing other family members without him present. She seems fine with how things are. I'm not sure I'd paint her as a victim in all this. Seems to me she's getting something from this messed up relationship.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/08/2022 15:05

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 25/08/2022 14:59

Oedipus complex

That’s when you want to kill your father so you can ( sc….w) your mother. So not really.

10HailMarys · 25/08/2022 15:04

Yes, that does seem odd.

As you say - the closeness itself, while weird, wouldn't be a problem for you if it didn't impact on your own relationship with your mum, but it clearly does and that's why it's a problem. It's really strange for you not to be able to talk to her without your brother being there.

You are absolutely not the weird one here - they are. I think I would probably be greatly reducing the contact I had with them. I'm not surprised it makes you feel anxious.

Sunnyqueen · 25/08/2022 15:02

Very weird. Does sound like the premise for a good thriller though.

ThanksAntsThants · 25/08/2022 15:01

It sounds exactly like the dynamic between my parents and their treatment of me and my sibling, which is bad enough, but mother and son? No, that is odd, unhealthy for them and toxic for you. I fear you’ll end up being one of us who ends up going NC.

Mumsafan · 25/08/2022 15:01

My husband is the second child. His Dad died when he was fairly young, and he had a younger brother . This brother is now in his 50s and still lives at home with my MIL. I think she made it difficult to leave , even though he has tried a few times. Both my DH and I find it very weird but it won't change. My DH's elder sibling has often claimed the mother ruined the life of the youngest , having used him as a subsitute for her late husband.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 25/08/2022 14:59

Oedipus complex