Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To wonder how people will financially survive?

829 replies

Cupcakeicecream · 25/08/2022 14:00

To think that many people are struggling already. Food price rises, gas and electric costs. The general cost of living due to inflation from either brexit since the pandemic and Ukraine war. But come on some people were struggling before any of those factors. Financially people will be pushed to breaking christmas will be off the cards general life will stagnate no meals out leisure activities cinema socialising new clothes treat foods. The threat of blackouts and wondering how we will pay bills to keep warm or keep a house running. Never mind buying food the price of it plus the large gaps on shelves. Winter will be miserable. It's becoming impossible to live in this country.

OP posts:
TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 15:10

Teand · 30/08/2022 14:15

I have been away from my home for 5 days and my pre-payment metre has used £10 of electric :(

The only things left on where the TV extension plugs (should have turned off) and my fridge.

£10 in 5 days without me cooking or showering or watching TV or charging my phone or boiling a kettle using the toaster...

@Teand that's a lot and doesn't feel quite right, it might be worth investigating your meter and / or what's using energy further (perhaps the other devises using energy and / or your fridge has an issue - or is very old - causing it to draw down a lot of energy) as you're likely over paying.

By comparison and incase helpful, recently my electricity spend on a typical day (two working from home using laptops and DSE, washing machine - but no tumble dryer, dishwasher, sky/tv used approx 1 hour a day else on standby) is approx £1.80 so yours feels very high in comparison.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2022 14:32

I don’t think anyone who isn’t properly wealthy should have to deal with these levels of household fuel increases. They should assist everyone with the exception of the top 1%. They such then put a heavily tax the astronomical profits of the energy producers and put that money back into the public purse as an interim measure to re-nationalisation. Essential services should not be run for profit otherwise situations like this are almost inevitable.

Democracy disagrees with you. This is almost the exact initiative Labour put forwards back in 2019 before being soundly told to go fuck themselves by an electorate that couldn't get enough of Boris and the Boys.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 14:29

@anniegun please can you help me understand your thinking in terms of:

  • how do you define"properly wealthy"?
-why would you exclude the top 1%? Why not 5%/10%/17%/35.6%... you get my point? It's an arbitrary line that you've drawn. Why not either include all or exclude all? Surely that is fair and equal. -why would you tax companies so heavily that they'd likely pull out of the market? What would we do then? -how would you define "astronomical profits"? What level do profits become "astronomical"? -were you so keen for the public purse to intervene when energy companies were making astronomical losses? I suspect not btw -why would you take energy companies in-house knowing there's a lot of investment -that the government doesn't have- needed to modernise them? -why would you want to apply treacle-esque heavily unionised public sector approaches to energy production? What would you do when they all go on strike? Would we just wait a while till our lights came back on? -do you realise a lot of energy producers are overseas and / or global corporations? Ie not easily nationalised... -how would you value companies you want to nationalise? Would the public purse be able to afford to purchase companies that are presently generating "astronomical profits"?
Teand · 30/08/2022 14:15

I have been away from my home for 5 days and my pre-payment metre has used £10 of electric :(

The only things left on where the TV extension plugs (should have turned off) and my fridge.

£10 in 5 days without me cooking or showering or watching TV or charging my phone or boiling a kettle using the toaster...

ivykaty44 · 30/08/2022 13:57

ShelfyMcShelfface men have 50% responsibility in their actions - nothing to stop them wearing a condom regardless if they don't want to pay for a child and the holidays.
Parents bring babies into he world not just mothers and woman tricks a man to not wear a condom

AnnieSnap · 30/08/2022 13:22

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 12:55

@AnnieSnap nope, that's why I have my head in my hands every time I hear government commit "more help" or "commit to investing" as there's no money tree so ultimately it's our pockets that are funding it.

I believe the stat is £37 per household on average for each £1Bn the government spends. Think about it, that's on average and given less than 50% of households are net contributors that means it costs those that are approx £74 per Billion.

So surely you can empathise with those families that are struggling to pay their own bills every time they hear the government announce they're "committing £xBn in help" that they're exlcuded from as (in someone's arbitrary calculation) they can "help themselves". It's not right.

I don’t think anyone who isn’t properly wealthy should have to deal with these levels of household fuel increases. They should assist everyone with the exception of the top 1%. They such then put a heavily tax the astronomical profits of the energy producers and put that money back into the public purse as an interim measure to re-nationalisation. Essential services should not be run for profit otherwise situations like this are almost inevitable.

ShelfyMcShelfface · 30/08/2022 13:20

@ivykaty44

Can men give birth now?

Mumsnet is a place of denial when it comes to women choosing to have children and expecting the state to provide. I realise that choices are limited sometimes. Some women leave school with few qualifications, so the choice is a minimum wage job or having children and working part time, topped up by the state. A high proportion of women I went to school with have done exactly this - deprived area.

ivykaty44 · 30/08/2022 13:07

TakeTheOffPisteRoute

you've linked to an article about the real living wage and the national living wage

I asked whats the difference between the NMW and living wage

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2022 13:03

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 29/08/2022 23:43

@Blossomtoes I think you might be confusing living wage with minimum wage... easily done I'm sure, somehow?

Nope. It’s not me confusing them.

ivykaty44 · 30/08/2022 13:02

There is an issue with women who have children, expecting the state to provide for them for life. They think they should be paid to be a mother and that pay should cover things like holidays.

you misspelt parent twice

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 13:00

ivykaty44 · 30/08/2022 12:57

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · Yesterday 23:43
@Blossomtoes I think you might be confusing living wage with minimum wage... easily done I'm sure, somehow?

www.gov.uk/national-minimum-wage-rates can you explain what the difference between living wage and minimum wage is? I can't see a difference

You've fallen for the Conservative government ploy of renaming the highest national minimum wage band as the "living wage", without actually changing is such that it is a real living wage.

There's plenty of articles on the internet that explains why, here's just one of them:

www.livingwage.org.uk/news/real-living-wage-vs-national-living-wage-whats-difference%3F

ivykaty44 · 30/08/2022 12:57

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · Yesterday 23:43
@Blossomtoes I think you might be confusing living wage with minimum wage... easily done I'm sure, somehow?

www.gov.uk/national-minimum-wage-rates can you explain what the difference between living wage and minimum wage is? I can't see a difference

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 12:55

@AnnieSnap nope, that's why I have my head in my hands every time I hear government commit "more help" or "commit to investing" as there's no money tree so ultimately it's our pockets that are funding it.

I believe the stat is £37 per household on average for each £1Bn the government spends. Think about it, that's on average and given less than 50% of households are net contributors that means it costs those that are approx £74 per Billion.

So surely you can empathise with those families that are struggling to pay their own bills every time they hear the government announce they're "committing £xBn in help" that they're exlcuded from as (in someone's arbitrary calculation) they can "help themselves". It's not right.

AnnieSnap · 30/08/2022 12:40

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 10:15

No, I assume many will rightly accept it as a way to claw back some of the money they've already handed over to the state to pay for someone else's kids....

Many will also accept it as they realise it's not a real handout, they'll be paying for it over the next x number of years as they continue to pay their taxes... that's unless the government has finally found the magical money tree that many seem to think it has

Jesus, what an appalling view. No doubt you are an admirer of Thatcher and her “there is no society, just men, women and families” 🙄 I’m guessing you haven’t noticed that the Tory Government find the magic money tree when they want to waste huge amounts of public money on vanity projects, or in giving huge contracts to their mates who are completely inexperienced at providing the services required when existing, experienced people/companies (who are not their mates) can provide the services much cheaper. Test and Trace and Ventilators for the NHS anyone!

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 10:41

ShelfyMcShelfface · 30/08/2022 10:28

I assume that those who are against children being provided for by the state refuse any and all help that they themselves may be offered? I expect they have already written to their MP to decline the £400 off their £8000 energy bill for 2023?

Hyperbole again.

You do realise that the welfare state was set up so that everyone paid in and everyone got something out. That was done deliberately so that everyone felt they had a stake in it.

Perhaps you'd like to explain why you think that one part of the population should only pay in and get nothing back and why another part of the population should never contribute but just take out? Maybe you could really sell your idea to those who you expect to pay in.

Exclude those who are too disabled to work from your answer, as we've already established that they should be well looked after by the state.

How does the government paying part of your energy bill fit into that?

ShelfyMcShelfface · 30/08/2022 10:28

I assume that those who are against children being provided for by the state refuse any and all help that they themselves may be offered? I expect they have already written to their MP to decline the £400 off their £8000 energy bill for 2023?

Hyperbole again.

You do realise that the welfare state was set up so that everyone paid in and everyone got something out. That was done deliberately so that everyone felt they had a stake in it.

Perhaps you'd like to explain why you think that one part of the population should only pay in and get nothing back and why another part of the population should never contribute but just take out? Maybe you could really sell your idea to those who you expect to pay in.

Exclude those who are too disabled to work from your answer, as we've already established that they should be well looked after by the state.

the80sweregreat · 30/08/2022 10:24

I'm grateful for the £400 , I had child benefits stopped years ago when those rules changed ( rightly so ) but I was grateful for that too when the children were small. It really did help.
I'm lucky we live in a society that does help people , plus I can't give the 400 away as it'll be on my energy account , but I can do other things to help ( charity donations , the food collections in the supermarket , give blood , support the local school)
If I didn't receive the 400 it would be tough , but lucky that we both work and can keep our energy account fairly healthy , for now anyway. Many won't be able to or are already in debt with it and people will struggle. It is going to be bad for many people .

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 10:15

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 10:08

I assume that those who are against children being provided for by the state refuse any and all help that they themselves may be offered? I expect they have already written to their MP to decline the £400 off their £8000 energy bill for 2023?

If you put your current direct debit in here you'll get a look at where your energy bill is headed.
www.which.co.uk/news/article/energy-price-cap-rises-to-3549-how-will-it-affect-your-bills-aZkHR2p2t2P7

No, I assume many will rightly accept it as a way to claw back some of the money they've already handed over to the state to pay for someone else's kids....

Many will also accept it as they realise it's not a real handout, they'll be paying for it over the next x number of years as they continue to pay their taxes... that's unless the government has finally found the magical money tree that many seem to think it has

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 10:08

I assume that those who are against children being provided for by the state refuse any and all help that they themselves may be offered? I expect they have already written to their MP to decline the £400 off their £8000 energy bill for 2023?

If you put your current direct debit in here you'll get a look at where your energy bill is headed.
www.which.co.uk/news/article/energy-price-cap-rises-to-3549-how-will-it-affect-your-bills-aZkHR2p2t2P7

antelopevalley · 30/08/2022 09:59

Honestly nobody expects that.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 30/08/2022 09:58

ShelfyMcShelfface · 30/08/2022 09:12

So should people sell or kill their children that they had when they were earning a lot but because of say disability or redundancy now can't do that job anymore?

Always some hyperbole on mumsnet.

The disabled should be well looked after, not many people would disagree. As should those who have paid in and are made redundant, there should be a better safety net until they are back on their feet.

There is an issue with women who have children, expecting the state to provide for them for life. They think they should be paid to be a mother and that pay should cover things like holidays.

Well said @ShelfyMcShelfface !

verdantverdure · 30/08/2022 09:54

The Which? calculator gives a good idea of what our household bills are going to look like:

www.which.co.uk/news/article/energy-price-cap-rises-to-3549-how-will-it-affect-your-bills-aZkHR2p2t2P7

ShelfyMcShelfface · 30/08/2022 09:12

So should people sell or kill their children that they had when they were earning a lot but because of say disability or redundancy now can't do that job anymore?

Always some hyperbole on mumsnet.

The disabled should be well looked after, not many people would disagree. As should those who have paid in and are made redundant, there should be a better safety net until they are back on their feet.

There is an issue with women who have children, expecting the state to provide for them for life. They think they should be paid to be a mother and that pay should cover things like holidays.

InWalksBarberalla · 30/08/2022 09:09

People don't seem to realise that if energy cost get too high manufacturing will have to shut down and there'll be less jobs and less exports. The government likely doesn't give a shit about people not being able to afford to heat their houses or eat but they will care when the whole economy tanks.

Kashmirsilver · 30/08/2022 08:29

blahblahblahspoons · 30/08/2022 05:22

I've done a number of jobs in my life from cleaner and carer to relatively high flying executive and I can tell you that the 'lower paid' jobs are the ones in which I worked hardest. Currently, having returned from being a SAHM I'm doing an office job being paid about half what my DH (with no career gap) earns and I work far, far harder than he does. For a lot less money.

I think that 'personal responsibility' could extend to employers paying proper wages. Pay rises have been artificially suppressed so the rich 1% can get richer for years. Wages have been falling in real terms since 2010, quite precipitously.

For an example, nurses are essential, they have had below inflation pay rises for years and there are 40k vacancies. It's supposed to be the case in a free market that if there's vacancies, then you pay more, but instead of doing this the government has cut and cut until the reality is that there aren't enough nurses. Nurses on their income alone can't afford to live a reasonable life (.e.g where I live you can't rent a single bed flat within a reasonable commute of the hospital on a Nurse average salary), and we're relying on imported nurses and the very young for the NHS to stagger on with even the semblance of providing care.

Problem is, with the crisis looming, those Nurses from abroad will all be going home. We've seen with fruit pickers work in the UK is becoming less and less attractive as our currency falls against theirs. It's only worked up to now because people could work here for a few years (or for part of the year) and earn what was - in their local currency - a lot of money. But if their wages won't even cover the most basic living costs in a shared house here, they won't come.

It's about time people were paid properly. This has started to happen a bit with the lorry drivers, but wages need to rise a lot and the government (all parties I believe, not just the Tories) have ignored this reality because they're the 1% that benefit from things as they are.

It's a joke that so many MPs have second jobs, board positions etc - it suggests a lot of them don't do their MP job properly. People working jobs like paramedics, nurses couldn't do second jobs even if they wanted to, they just don't have the physical capacity and time.

Much like the min wage-public, sector wages aren't governed by market forces. Wages/salaries are rigid and non-negoitiable when a government decides.
Private sector remuneration is always open to negotiation.
Government actions are always arbitrary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread