Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why posters think MN is MC

41 replies

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 11:53

I've been wondering this for a while and two threads I've posted on today have prompted me to ask the question.

I always see posters trot out that MN is very middle class

But from being on here in various guises over the years I just don't understand why

There are threads going about high earners and the majority on there are saying anything over £50k a year is a high earner

The thread about pay rises and the majority laughing at the concept

The competitive PIP and UC posts that often crop up a few times a year

There was a thread a few months ago where the OP considered anyone on 30k plus a year to be wealthy

Plus the many others where it's clear the majority posting aren't well off at all

AIBU to think MN is definitely not middle class at a majority level, and it's most likely due to so many low earners being on here that gives that impression?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ComtesseDeSpair · 25/08/2022 21:04

SilverDragonfly1 · 25/08/2022 17:25

This. Class is about attitudes and mores, not money. Otherwise the Beckhams would be upper class (clue, they're not).

But surely this sort of definition is becoming absolutely meaningless where increasingly we will have people who think of themselves as middle class unable to afford heating in winter or even a basic grocery shop? If you can’t afford to feed your children properly, your “values” are meaningless. How can you be middle class?

SilverDragonfly1 · 25/08/2022 17:25

JenGin · 25/08/2022 12:06

Just as an aside...wealth and class aren't the same thing, are they? You can be working class and wealthy, or at least come from a working class background and be wealthy.

This. Class is about attitudes and mores, not money. Otherwise the Beckhams would be upper class (clue, they're not).

HRTQueen · 25/08/2022 17:04

itsnotdeep · 25/08/2022 12:00

It's not middle class anymore. It was when it started. It's full of daily mail readers and benefits bashers these days.

So mc people don’t read the DM or bash those on benefits 😆

its still quote largely mc compared to the general population and leaning to the left

JamieFrasersBigSwingingKilt · 25/08/2022 17:02

maddiemookins16mum · 25/08/2022 16:59

Someone yesterday said that anything less than a 100K salary in the SE would be impossible to live on.
That screams MC to me when hundreds of thousands of families earn much less and yet still manage to live (and even buy a house) in the SE.

That screams idiocy rather than any particular class.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 17:01

maddiemookins16mum · 25/08/2022 16:59

Someone yesterday said that anything less than a 100K salary in the SE would be impossible to live on.
That screams MC to me when hundreds of thousands of families earn much less and yet still manage to live (and even buy a house) in the SE.

But that's one person

Yes there are people who are well off on here

But to think the majority are MC is where I get a bit confused as if anything, it's the opposite

The majority on here are not well off, thus posters, as you describe stand out

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 25/08/2022 16:59

Someone yesterday said that anything less than a 100K salary in the SE would be impossible to live on.
That screams MC to me when hundreds of thousands of families earn much less and yet still manage to live (and even buy a house) in the SE.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 16:26

Sartre · 25/08/2022 16:22

I’d say a lot more posters are educated and literate on MN than other similar forums. There’s certainly a plethora of very middle class problems on here too. Issues with cleaners, au pairs, private schools, gousto subscriptions etc.

I’d say the majority of posters are MC because I don’t think it’s the sort of thing lots of WC people do, you know sit around on an online forum whinging about their neighbours parking skills. Maybe I’m wrong though…

I'd definitely agree with the part around literacy (maybe not reading ability and comprehension but that's for another thread!)

Having had the pleasure of being on that peanut app a year ago - lord there are a lot of people in this country that shouldn't be having children! It was eye opening especially compared to on here. People asking for advice on how to tell their Midwives they take cannabis, asking whether breast milk is better for a baby, whether they can eat white bread etc.

I'd also say it's maybe related to average age on here over MC status, the older people get they tend to be more literate than younger generations (and that's said as a millennial myself) As AIBU especially skews older than other topics (especially baby names etc.)

OP posts:
Sartre · 25/08/2022 16:22

I’d say a lot more posters are educated and literate on MN than other similar forums. There’s certainly a plethora of very middle class problems on here too. Issues with cleaners, au pairs, private schools, gousto subscriptions etc.

I’d say the majority of posters are MC because I don’t think it’s the sort of thing lots of WC people do, you know sit around on an online forum whinging about their neighbours parking skills. Maybe I’m wrong though…

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 16:17

TabithaTittlemouse · 25/08/2022 15:34

I think if you joined mn now you wouldn’t consider it at all middle class.

It changed a lot a few years ago. For better or for worse?

I think its fascinating and refreshing. If mumsnet was just full of MC women, I wouldn't bother hanging around. It also exposes my mind to the poverty that people experience in the UK. I am a much more knowledgeable person because of Mumsnet.

alphons · 25/08/2022 16:10

I’ve been on here for over a decade. The demographic has changed as times have changed. Money was easier to come by. The very people who used to ask for Boden coupon codes are now the people worrying about whether to heat or eat.

MN has been very educational for me. I’ve learned a lot about people outside my economic / social / cultural experience. I know it’s skewed, but my own experience is also skewed. I’m grateful to have people educate me. I’ve learned to appreciate how hard some women have it, what awful things some women put up with in relationships just because they’re women, how hard some parents have to work to earn £40k between them and STILL feel comfortable (I don’t know much about life outside London where this is a practical
impossibility), not to mention the input from farming families and families dealing with PIP and UC, grappling to access social welfare for disabled children or parents.

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 16:09

There are threads though where the poster has a budget of £1.4 million for her first property and where they budget £200-300 a month for their labrodoodle's doggy daycare so I think these are the posts people remember.

I think on any internet forum, there is always going to be a disproportionate number of people asking for advice on how to deal with difficult situations (and financial problems is a subset of many bigger problems). I mean, thats why they are on a support forum right?

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 15:58

MoistBandana · 25/08/2022 15:57

90% of what people put on here is bollocks.
The other 20% is bad maths.

Grin
OP posts:
MoistBandana · 25/08/2022 15:57

90% of what people put on here is bollocks.
The other 20% is bad maths.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 15:53

JamieFrasersBigSwingingKilt · 25/08/2022 15:26

This thread is fascinating: http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4610834-to-think-this-income-savings-and-wealth-calculator-might-give-people-some-perspective-on-where-they-fit-in
It shows that many people who completed the survey and commented on the thread are middle or below average earners. It's a self-selecting group of course, but supports your theory OP.

Ver interesting, and yes the majority of posters are bottom 50%+ so definitely seems to be a trend

OP posts:
TabithaTittlemouse · 25/08/2022 15:34

I think if you joined mn now you wouldn’t consider it at all middle class.

It changed a lot a few years ago. For better or for worse?

Arbesque · 25/08/2022 15:27

I think it was quite middle class back in the day. But it's changed a lot.

JamieFrasersBigSwingingKilt · 25/08/2022 15:26

This thread is fascinating: http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4610834-to-think-this-income-savings-and-wealth-calculator-might-give-people-some-perspective-on-where-they-fit-in
It shows that many people who completed the survey and commented on the thread are middle or below average earners. It's a self-selecting group of course, but supports your theory OP.

Fifife · 25/08/2022 15:22

Class isn't just about wealth. It's a mentality, I've never heard class being discussed in real life as much as on MN some are obsessive. Middle class is about keeping up with the neighbours and comparing yourself. The WC and UC don't care about this. I'd say middle class is the worst thing to aspire to be, I'm WC and we earn good money I'm confident in my choices and if I want a tacky crushed velvet sofa I will buy one !

dockspider · 25/08/2022 15:10

I once met a group of MNers IRL (under a different username) and it was very mixed.
I think it is mixed here - you can ask for advice on high budget holidays/house reno etc and get it, but obviously there are also people really struggling to make ends meet.

But I guess the reputation is from early days as others have said.

ReadtheReviews · 25/08/2022 15:06

No, seems like a vast proportion of mn children play out on the street from the age of 7 which is a more wc thing. I think there's quite a good mix actually. Geographically speaking too, possibly Scotland heavy, but not London centric anyway.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 15:04

ReadtheReviews · 25/08/2022 14:57

Absolutely wealth and class are not the same thing at all. That's an American idea.

It's closely linked though

Some roles go outside of this for example tradespeople who often earn very well but are firmly working class via their job. But most of the traditional MC roles are relatively well paid

OP posts:
ReadtheReviews · 25/08/2022 14:57

Absolutely wealth and class are not the same thing at all. That's an American idea.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 14:54

Katyfizz54 · 25/08/2022 12:17

Years ago I came on here and saw a lot of posters with high earnings, and brilliant careers, any threads about income were quite eye opening (even taking into consideration that posters can say whatever they want...), now I am surprised by what comes up in posts, people commenting on the privilege of being able to afford a holiday every year, or assuming a decent income means a lavish lifestyle.

This isn't the point but I'm not even sure what I am? I have been solidly working class (brought up on benefits), started working life on £2 an hour, initially worked up my salary but only through the introduction of minimum wage, retrained and I am now on a solid middle class income. But I am not middle class, I don't feel middle class. But that's the category mumsnet would put me in. The class system isn't great is it?

Yes the holiday threads are always eye opening

But the sheer amount of how to live on £0.40 a day, how does anyone afford a holiday, how do anyone afford childcare etc. threads really paints a different picture of the majority on here

I feel people think it's MC because a large portion are anything but, and therefore think those posters on average but low salaries are rich

OP posts:
AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 14:51

Thelnebriati · 25/08/2022 12:04

Benefits bashing is not a working class occupation, and posters frequently have to explain the realities of being poor to people who are more offended by the title 'poor' than they are poverty.

Who said anything about benefits bashing?

I was referring to the race to the bottom threads almost comparing how little they get on PIP and UC

OP posts:
AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 14:51

itsnotdeep · 25/08/2022 12:00

It's not middle class anymore. It was when it started. It's full of daily mail readers and benefits bashers these days.

This is another point, so many daily mail views on here over the last couple of years.

It seems to have really diversified in the worst way

OP posts: