Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Slow down of Suburbanization- will more people move to flats and small houses in the cities to reduce petrol costs, gas bills and electricity bills

82 replies

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 10:54

My DH is convinced the above would happen. He thinks that the growth of the suburbs (commuter towns and outer london) was accelerated by expensive property prices in central areas but also by relatively low costs of fuel and gas for many years. This would no longer be the case so will people opt for smaller homes in locations where you can cycle and walk everywhere, thereby reducing costs. Did this happen in the 1970s?

I am not so sure...

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 25/08/2022 14:37

WRT flats specifically I think a lot depends on how people feel about being too hot vs too cold. Flat living would concern me because even when I did it a few years back, with lower average temperatures than now, it was often very unpleasant in warm weather. That worries and bothers me more than being cold.

I'd choose a property that was easier to keep cool in summer but meant me having to be frugal with heating in the winter over one that was warmer all year round. Equally, somebody who feels the cold badly and thinks thirty degrees plus counts as lovely weather might find the flat more practical for their temperature preferences.

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 14:31

brob · 25/08/2022 14:17

Not sure what happened to my post (was eating) but hopefully you get the gist.

I got the gist, i agree with that. The British have never liked flats so I guess even high energy bills probably would not change that. Its funny but the only white british people I know who have bought flats in the last 5 years are Jewish (DH included) and that is mainly because the areas they prefer are very expensive.

An older lady I know who owns a flat in hampstead told me that when her flat was built in the 1930s, british people refused to buy it so instead jewish refugees like her grandparents as well as spanish immigrants bought the flats.
Other people I know who have bought flats in London are Japanese, Hongkongers, African (mostly not UK Born and bred).

I do think the 2 up 2 downs might become more popular. My colleague bought such a house and she did a loft conversion and also an extension. Its probably not that expensive to heat as its still quite small. But she has 3 bedrooms- so theoretically good enough for a small family.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 25/08/2022 14:31

Ps those of us not in London don't have this choice, we have to drive to work because there's no public transport. Thankfully for me it's only 6 miles each way but others are much further. It's a trading estate with zero public transport on it (2 miles to bus stop and that route is stopping on 30/9 for goodConfused) and as the only route that's 6 miles is via one junction on the motorway cycling isn't an option (cycling route is 14 miles!)

Caspianberg · 25/08/2022 14:28

It’s no cheaper to heat 1 or 2 or 3 floors. It’s per Sqm size to heat, and obviously insulation and type/ age will affect. But a new build flat that’s 70m2 v new build house at 70m2 will use the same heating.

The only advantage you get is if people underneath heat their super hot, which you probably won’t get in future. Same applies if you live in a terrace house and either side heat loads

gogohmm · 25/08/2022 14:25

@QuebecBagnet

Basically yes. When Putin goes then then hope is the new regime will want to distance them themselves from his policies and rejoin the international community - supplying cheap gas may be a good bargaining chip.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 25/08/2022 14:23

I was saying this to dh, we are planning to move from our 3 bed terrace with a yard to a bigger ‘family’ style home in a couple of years but I was saying that I don’t mind having less space - we will just have to have less stuff, and that’s fine by me! - in order to not have a bigger house to heat, a garden to water, etc. I’d even be happy in a really nice new build eco friendly apartment that’s dead easy to heat with two dc, if we had two big bedrooms or even three, but dh thinks that’s mental.

gogohmm · 25/08/2022 14:22

Suburbs vs city living goes in trends. Growing up no one wanted to live in flats or townhouses in central London (unless second home in country) highly desirable locations now were virtual no go areas. I think the cost of living may force people to live in multi generational housing for financial comfort, it may also make people think twice about detached, especially older houses as they are significantly more expensive to heat but overall people aren't going to make drastic changes

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 14:20

Caspianberg · 25/08/2022 14:15

I actually think the more likely senario is that people will stay in bigger houses, further out, but house share more.

Either multi generation so grandparents old house, children stay and pay household bills and food as no rent, and grandparents help with childcare more.
Or more people share with other friends and family or take in lodgers, all to help contribute to bills, but giving you the garden and social aspect.

A small flat is fine in community areas, but if you have no space to host and can’t afford to go out, I can see many people getting lonely.
A large flat will cost the same as house of same size to heat so it’s irrelevant really

isn't it cheaper to heat one floor as opposed to two floors. Also if on upper floors, you can rely on the heat from bottom floor flats?

I find in winter, i often don't need to switch on the heating for that reason...

OP posts:
brob · 25/08/2022 14:18

@Caspianberg yes multigenerational living will likely become more common.

brob · 25/08/2022 14:17

Not sure what happened to my post (was eating) but hopefully you get the gist.

brob · 25/08/2022 14:15

As I said if the average person is going to be paying 10k a yr bills I don't think whether they buy a flat in z3 or a house further out will be the most pressing worry.

And for the ones that can still afford to buy & pay the high bills there may be some more compromises eg terrace close to a station rather than isolates detached in the home counties however I can't see them swapping the detached for a flat closer in.

can't see them switching who are set on a detached in the home counties

Caspianberg · 25/08/2022 14:15

I actually think the more likely senario is that people will stay in bigger houses, further out, but house share more.

Either multi generation so grandparents old house, children stay and pay household bills and food as no rent, and grandparents help with childcare more.
Or more people share with other friends and family or take in lodgers, all to help contribute to bills, but giving you the garden and social aspect.

A small flat is fine in community areas, but if you have no space to host and can’t afford to go out, I can see many people getting lonely.
A large flat will cost the same as house of same size to heat so it’s irrelevant really

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 14:03

brob · 25/08/2022 13:58

What do you think such high energy bills are going to do to hospitals or schools?

What will be the impact of spending all your money on bills & nothing left for the wider economy?

What is it going to do to businesses?

I think it's very naive to think it's a case of saving up & "Ill be fine". There will be huge ramifications.

Of course there are going to be huge ramifications. None of us like this and our government should be doing something instead of putting their heads in the sand. I have no idea how businesses, hospitals and schools are going to cope. There may be government intervention to help businesses, hospitals schools and the most vulnerable. But there wouldn't be one for me. or for many of the people on this thread (if they are on average or above average household income). Certainly if you are in the position to buy a house or a flat and are of working age, there definitely wouldn't be much help (if any).

As an individual, I can't control what the government does or what the energy price cap is . All i can do is try to protect myself as best as I can.

OP posts:
brob · 25/08/2022 13:58

What do you think such high energy bills are going to do to hospitals or schools?

What will be the impact of spending all your money on bills & nothing left for the wider economy?

What is it going to do to businesses?

I think it's very naive to think it's a case of saving up & "Ill be fine". There will be huge ramifications.

TuxedoJunction · 25/08/2022 13:55

With cost of entry fees, restaurants and cafes increasing, I’m glad we have a large garden and house big enough to host people at ours instead. Far cheaper. My child is entertained most days for free in our garden either alone or with friends visiting, and the local area is open woodlands, for biking and walks.

This!

In a post-Covid world my observation is people are moving further out of London (and other large cities), as they no longer need to commute on a daily basis. I’m not sure we’re going to see a reverse to people moving back to city living as your DH predicts.

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 13:40

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 13:39

I do think it will happen though. For reference, energy price cap was £1137 in Jan 2019. It is now going to be 3554 in October. £6000 in January according to cornwall insights. £10k at end of 2023/beginning of 2024 is a matter of time.

I am preparing my finances in preparation for that. putting away money so I am living as if I have to pay £10k in energy bills yearly (which I probably wouldn't as i live in a 2 bed flat but its better to be safe). The war in ukraine isn't going to be ending any time soon.

we all have to live somewhere, whether its a flat or a house. Whether we are renting or owning, its all the same housing stock...

OP posts:
onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 13:39

brob · 25/08/2022 13:33

and of course people will buy houses if they can afford the £6k/8k-10k energy bills and the 25% inflation!

If energy bills are going to hit 10k a year then I think most people aren't going to be focused on whether they should buy a flat or house!

I do think it will happen though. For reference, energy price cap was £1137 in Jan 2019. It is now going to be 3554 in October. £6000 in January according to cornwall insights. £10k at end of 2023/beginning of 2024 is a matter of time.

I am preparing my finances in preparation for that. putting away money so I am living as if I have to pay £10k in energy bills yearly (which I probably wouldn't as i live in a 2 bed flat but its better to be safe). The war in ukraine isn't going to be ending any time soon.

OP posts:
lightand · 25/08/2022 13:38

Those with jobs will get wary of changing.

Costs of moving too, plus I think certain systems will be on a go slow at best.

I can think if a 3rd reason but I am not putting here.

brob · 25/08/2022 13:33

and of course people will buy houses if they can afford the £6k/8k-10k energy bills and the 25% inflation!

If energy bills are going to hit 10k a year then I think most people aren't going to be focused on whether they should buy a flat or house!

brob · 25/08/2022 13:31

crime stats will become more relevant I think as it's likely to increase!

onthefencesitter · 25/08/2022 13:30

Caspianberg · 25/08/2022 13:22

@onthefencesitter - but it’s easier, especially with young children for them not even to notice the lack of expensive days out and ice creams if they have a garden.
A nice garden can have paddling pool, sandpit, picnics, friends over, ice creams from supermarket in freezer.

A flat you have to take out ideally every day to park, buy ice creams there, take bus or drive to those places.

My 2 year old is just as happy with an ice lolly in the garden, playing with friends and toys out, as the days we take him to a zoo or something.

larger house also means space for dh and I both to work from home. No expensive commute costs or childcare

the kids in my development just play in the communal garden. there is a paddling pool in summer and they play in a somewhat feral pack lol.

A lot of flats in london do have private gardens though, they are maisonettes. warner flats in walthamstow or purpose built edwardian flats. My Dh hates conversions which is why we opt for 1930s purpose built but I am looking at one with garden access now.

I am not saying there are no downsides; and of course people will buy houses if they can afford the £6k/8k-10k energy bills and the 25% inflation! I am sure many of us would buy houses with gardens in Chelsea if we could comfortably afford it! The question is how many homeowners can afford it going forward given that 66% of households would be in fuel poverty by January...

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 25/08/2022 13:27

I think no but for other reasons. Living in leasehold is crap and dealing with management companies or other joint freeholders is too.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 25/08/2022 13:27

The more I think of it the more I reckon suburbs or at least areas in the sort of middle rather than outer or inner rings iyswim might become more rather than less desirable. A middle ground.

brob · 25/08/2022 13:23

I also think gardens are a must have with dc, it doesn't have to be big but some outside space.

brob · 25/08/2022 13:22

and pre pandemic I wouldn't have considered further than z3 but I'm actually tired of so many people 😆