Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this my fault as a tenant?

55 replies

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:15

For years I've had issues with damp and severe mould around the windows in my flat, the bedroom window ledge is awful in winter and the pladter literally rots.

Twice during heavy rain I've had leaks that cause water to come into the flat. The last one was bad and flooded my bedroom, I have a mild one going on at the minute with this downpour.

Last time the conclusion was a leaking gutter above the window. The property manager had somebody come out and clear out the gutter. No further issues with water coming in for a while - but then there was no heavy rain until now..

I've woken up this morning and the window ledge is soaked and water is dripping down the wall. On closer inspection I found this, a gap between the window and the frame, and I'm guessing it has been there all along which would explain why I have so many issues around the windows. You have to stand at a certain angle to see it so it's easy to miss if you're looking straight on.

Anyway, I've sent a video to my landlord who said he can't see how a window would be liked that unless it was 'pulled down' which makes me think he's blaming me for it..

So can you tell me what you think? Is this something a tenant is responsible for? Why would a window be like this?

The window is completely closed, clicked shut.

Is this my fault as a tenant?
OP posts:
Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 12:55

AffIt · 25/08/2022 12:44

This happened to us a few years ago (we own a 120-year-old tenement) and it turned out the pointing in the brickwork was damaged, so the building wasn't 'watertight' - nothing to do with the windows!

Like you, the issue only appeared after very heavy rain - it was actually a surveyor friend who was visiting at the time who worked it out.

Anyway, we had been ignoring it for too long and it was very expensive to fix, as we had to have a wall stripped back, damp-coursed and replastered etc. I completely own up to being an idiot here.

Your landlord sounds like a nightmare to deal with, but it might be worth pointing out to them that if this is the case, it gets very costly very quickly.

Oh dear. I hope that's not the case as if so I can't see it being sorted anytime soon.

The outstanding repairs I mentioned upthread are going to be paid for by the property management company i think and not my landlord himself.

He, perhaps understandably, doesn't want to pay out for things that the property management company are liable for so when something goes wrong such as the flood in the bedroom last time and the associated damage it caused, I was waiting about 6 months for all of the checks to be done to prove the damage was caused by the leak which was caused by the badly maintained guttering etc.

It's a nightmare and never straight forward.

OP posts:
Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 12:46

Elleherd · 25/08/2022 12:15

I'm baffled how he can reach the conclusion that the window must have been "pulled down" when there is years of documented issues.

Because the alternative is to acknowledge he's knowingly renting out substandard accommodation and to a tenant with a disabled child.

It's a well known get out with environmental health, along with claims of lack of access by tenant.

It can miraculously explain rising damp meeting falling damp, repeat sewage flooding, massively out of date electrics, you name it, you can get away with it as a landlord if you play the system, and especially if you're a multiple landlord with certain London councils, housing tenants in difficult circumstances.

The only surprise is he hasn't tried to claim it's intentional ventilation.

Either the window wasn't sealed properly in the first place, or things have shifted. Given the evenness of the gap, I'd suspect the former.

Keep your emails logical and unemotional and preferably backed up with professional opinions if you can find any.

(Sending the pictures to large double glazing companies asking their opinion on what you're looking at here, without saying why, might just get you them.)

Do attack the mold with bleach and stay on top of it. Doesn't need to be daily, ime weekly or twice weekly will keep it at bay.

Don't try and seal it with expanding foam or similar without permission.

Thank you that's really helpful

OP posts:
AffIt · 25/08/2022 12:44

This happened to us a few years ago (we own a 120-year-old tenement) and it turned out the pointing in the brickwork was damaged, so the building wasn't 'watertight' - nothing to do with the windows!

Like you, the issue only appeared after very heavy rain - it was actually a surveyor friend who was visiting at the time who worked it out.

Anyway, we had been ignoring it for too long and it was very expensive to fix, as we had to have a wall stripped back, damp-coursed and replastered etc. I completely own up to being an idiot here.

Your landlord sounds like a nightmare to deal with, but it might be worth pointing out to them that if this is the case, it gets very costly very quickly.

OhmygodDont · 25/08/2022 12:28

Looks like the hinge had gone creating the gap which means the window isn’t actually shutting properly and making a complete seal.

we had it with a bathroom window but ours dropped so far you couldn’t close it. It was like less than a five minute job for a handy man fix.

Blowyourowntrumpet · 25/08/2022 12:18

This is not your fault. You need new windows

onmywayamarillo · 25/08/2022 12:16

It really does look like the hinges are out of whack and need fixing.. it's a quick and easy job.
Look for a local window repair place like

Window doctor get a quote and ask the landlord to okay it.

As I say a quick fix

Elleherd · 25/08/2022 12:15

I'm baffled how he can reach the conclusion that the window must have been "pulled down" when there is years of documented issues.

Because the alternative is to acknowledge he's knowingly renting out substandard accommodation and to a tenant with a disabled child.

It's a well known get out with environmental health, along with claims of lack of access by tenant.

It can miraculously explain rising damp meeting falling damp, repeat sewage flooding, massively out of date electrics, you name it, you can get away with it as a landlord if you play the system, and especially if you're a multiple landlord with certain London councils, housing tenants in difficult circumstances.

The only surprise is he hasn't tried to claim it's intentional ventilation.

Either the window wasn't sealed properly in the first place, or things have shifted. Given the evenness of the gap, I'd suspect the former.

Keep your emails logical and unemotional and preferably backed up with professional opinions if you can find any.

(Sending the pictures to large double glazing companies asking their opinion on what you're looking at here, without saying why, might just get you them.)

Do attack the mold with bleach and stay on top of it. Doesn't need to be daily, ime weekly or twice weekly will keep it at bay.

Don't try and seal it with expanding foam or similar without permission.

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 12:11

I'm going to go out shortly and get some mould and mildew spray for around the windows. It gets so much worse in winter so I need to keep ontop of it as the weather changes.

OP posts:
Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 12:08

I've been outside and looked at the guttering/flat roof above my bedroom window and it looks like there's a leak in the gutter piping which is causing water to pool down onto my bedroom window.

That wouldn't be an issue if it was properly installed though surely?

I've been CC'd into the landlords email to the property managers and he has told them that there's a leak in the guttering plus my window is "hanging" and won't close which isn't the case. There's never been an issue with the window closing which I've explained.

I dread having to get in touch about the constant stream of issues with the flat. It must be a PITA for him aswell but several tradesmen (one of which is his friend) has said the place is shit and there's so much wrong with it.

I've noted the advice about the council and environmental health thank you

OP posts:
PrtScn · 25/08/2022 10:36

Keep on at the landlord, there are companies that fix double glazing units so he has no excuse.
In the interim is there anyway you can keep on top of that mould? Wipe it down every morning and leave a rolled up towel on the window ledge to soak up any water? I’d personally look at some kind of flexible sealing strip for that gap as well.
I appreciate this isn’t something you should have to do, but at the end of the day it’s potentially impacting on your health and doesn’t sound like it’s going to get fixed any time soon.

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:36

Sunnyqueen · 25/08/2022 10:35

Do you have family under a different council? You can apply to their council if so.

Unfortunately not, the family I have are under this council and live nearby.

OP posts:
Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:36

DDivaStar · 25/08/2022 10:31

Is that the side of the hinges? it might be they need replacing.

It's not the hinges from what I can tell. I think PP was right about it not being sealed properly.

So many corners were cut when refurbishing this flat, which used to be a taxi office. I'm on the ground floor with 3 or 4 flats above me.

Landlord has essentially bought a shit investment which is just burning money.

It looked lovely when I moved in but it quickly became obvious that it was bodged and rushed in numerous ways.

OP posts:
Sunnyqueen · 25/08/2022 10:35

Do you have family under a different council? You can apply to their council if so.

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:33

In the past 3 months I've had another leak coming in through the bathroom spotlights on the ceiling. Roofer, electrician and plumber came round. The roofer found a hole in the roof above and repaired that and so far no further water coming in from the bathroom but the paint work is fucked and the laminate flooring all bubbled up.

As it stands landlord is waiting for confirmation from the property manager that the roof issue is sorted and then he's going to replace the flooring, repaint etc.

My kitchen is falling to bits and that's on a list to be redone too.

There is literally a never ending list of problems with this place and whenever one gets sorted there's another that crops up.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 25/08/2022 10:33

Definitely call environmental health.
Let them notify the council.
I wonder could you take a civil case against the landlord?
There was a recent case on Ireland where the tenants brought in environmental health and then sued the council for not taking sufficient action to reduce the damp.
They got 1000's.
I'm sorry you and your disabled DS are forced to live like this.

DDivaStar · 25/08/2022 10:31

Is that the side of the hinges? it might be they need replacing.

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:30

Matildahoney · 25/08/2022 10:28

You don't have to disclose to your landlord that you're on any benefits.

I live in london and the rental market is really difficult here. They want bank statements, proof of employment etc.

OP posts:
Sunnyqueen · 25/08/2022 10:30

Get straight on to environmental health, report the fucker. He knows its going to cost and is trying to dodge it.

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:29

TheBeesKnee · 25/08/2022 10:25

How long do you intend to put up with this?

There's nothing I can do unfortunately, short of reporting the issues.

I've gone to the council 3 separate times asking for help to move and they've been useless.

I've called around endless estate agents and private landlords and they won't take me on as I'm on UC.

OP posts:
Matildahoney · 25/08/2022 10:28

You don't have to disclose to your landlord that you're on any benefits.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 25/08/2022 10:28

Not your fault you couldn't cause that damage without further damage.

Professional workmen didn't notice the gap so how would you.

It could have moved from the damp walls and surrounds softening too.

I hate when rentals aren't fit for purpose it is very unfair.

ToppCat · 25/08/2022 10:27

You could try going to Environmental Health if you don’t get anywhere with your landlord. They can force the landlord to do something about it.

Lovvy67 · 25/08/2022 10:27

Hymnulop · 25/08/2022 10:22

What a dump, just move. Mould is so bad for your health and he's already already started to argue and blame you.

I've been trying to save up for a deposit/rent in advance for a long time. I've saved £400 so far but it has taken me a year.

I'm a carer for my disabled child and on UC which adds another layer of issues as most private landlords and estate agents won't rent to me "no DSS"

The council won't help me as I'm "adequately housed" but there is nothing available with them anyway. The council temporary accommodation in this area is even worse than my flat.

My landlord does tend to get jobs done but there has been that much go wrong with this flat it's never ending.

OP posts:
TheBeesKnee · 25/08/2022 10:25

How long do you intend to put up with this?