Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to stay home with our daughter

293 replies

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

OP posts:
glittereyelash · 25/08/2022 09:38

I never planned to be a stay at home parent but life happened and it ended up being my only option for a few years. Parts I really enjoyed and others were so difficult. Once baby starts moving it's a whole new game. My son was crawling from seven months and walking by 10 months and stopped napping at 15 months so it was a very busy house! I'm now back working part time and prefer it overall just feels more balanced to me I have some independence, adult conversation and an identity outside of being a mum. Best of luck whatever you decide x

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 09:34

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:27

I’m referencing that currently, it works for us whilst I am on mat leave to be the main carer and it not being DH on long term pat leave. Two different subjects being discussed, the poster suggested I wouldn’t be happy if he were the main carer and I the BW. I disagree with that

Mat leave is totally different though. Taking a short time out of the workplace and then going back is not the same as opting out of the workforce for a much longer period and expecting someone else to take on the financial responsibility.

It was me that said you might not be happy being the main breadwinner if that was your actual reality and I stand by that. It's a massive responsibility to carry alone, and many people would find that very stressful. If it isn't a realistic prospect for you to have to take that on, it's pretty easy to say that you wouldn't mind, but you might well feel differently if you actually had to do it. I guess we'll never know.

MangyInseam · 25/08/2022 09:34

I stayed home after my eldest was born. Once I looked carefully at what would involved in going back - how much time we would actually spend with her, it was not a difficult decision. When she was a little older I did some part time and later FT childcare.

I never considered that somehow this meant that I was "living off someone elses work", since I was doing work that was necessary for the family and which made our QOL much better.

I'd keep the option of going back, in a different position or even sector, in mind, given the financial uncertainty of the moment.

SophieIsHereToday · 25/08/2022 09:29

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 08:02

It’s essentially exactly the 60-120k wage difference, nearly bang on ha ha!

I’m concerned about about my pension and savings taking a huge hit (unfair I feel, for SAHMs) as I don’t think this would be viewed as a priority for our household.

I think part time is the best option, I feel any time away isn’t time I want. I’d be more than happy to move back to working once DD at school etc.

I did this jump recently. There's a lot of tax between 100 and 120, as you also have to return your personal allowance. So good take home salary does not double at all.

On the first 60, you pay around 25% in tax and on the second 60 you pay around 50% tax. Which is an extra £15k on tax, which means it feels like earning £105k which is good but worth considering post tax affordability with prices rising.

Your husband might have imagined his hard work would translate to some nice perks

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 09:29

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:25

I haven’t remotely said he’s on board?

Ok, sorry, I am confused then. I was referring to your post at 9.14am which seemed to be expressing confidence that your DH would get on board with the idea. Apologies if I misunderstood.

Anyway, if he isn't on board, then SAH clearly isn't an option for you, so I guess you'll need to think about Plan B.

Cakeandcardio · 25/08/2022 09:28

I've seen a comment about not pulling your weight. Don't buy into this. What could be 'pulling your weight' more than raising your own child? Children grow quickly and the time can never come back. If you have a secure relationship with your husband, there should be no worries. He might just be anxious but should him how it could be affordable. Or could you go part time? That's what I've done and it's great.

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:27

I’m referencing that currently, it works for us whilst I am on mat leave to be the main carer and it not being DH on long term pat leave. Two different subjects being discussed, the poster suggested I wouldn’t be happy if he were the main carer and I the BW. I disagree with that

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:25

I haven’t remotely said he’s on board?

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 25/08/2022 09:25

Go back part time. You and your DH will benefit from two incomes.
Bur make sure he knows he will have to take some days off to cover illness too.

Canyousewcushions · 25/08/2022 09:25

The flip side is they will also be professions with good career prospects and salaries- I certainly wouldn't be putting my kids off them!!

Canyousewcushions · 25/08/2022 09:23

RayneDance · 25/08/2022 08:40

Brookstar if a career is that inflexible that someone could not take out one /two/three years to raise your own child to a verbal level where they can tell you about their day then it's not a career I would choose or choose not to have children

I'd be interested to know what it is because I'd like to alert my girls to never go into it because there is zero flexibility and it will be a prison sentence.

Sometimes people need time out for all sorts of reasons not just children. Seriously ill partners,burn out, mental health.

It's the issue of falling behind on current practice, and would probably apply to a lot of careers which require high levels of education and training.

For me, if I took 6 years out to get 2 children from birth to school, I'd be coming back into a work environment where standards and legislation had moved on, research would mean that what I thought was best practice is now outdated, and software would have developed to the extent that I'd need to relearn everything.

I might have left the industry at a point where I could supervise others and support their development, but would be going back so out of date that I couldn't answer the questions of more junior staff and would need a high amount of training.

If I were an employer, taking on a new graduate who is up to date would be a better and a cheaper bet than me.

It would be dependent on the profession, but a lot of high earning professional jobs may well be similar, particularly anything with links into using standards, legislation and technology.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 09:23

Louise0701 · 25/08/2022 09:16

I always see on these threads “don’t be financially dependent on a man” would it make a difference for a lesbian couple? Is it ok to be financially dependent on a woman?

Of course it wouldn't

People shouldn't be financially dependent on anyone, posters add the man because the OP has made it clear she is in a relationship with a man

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 09:21

So if you're confident that he will be on board, OP, what exactly are you looking for from this thread?Confused

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 25/08/2022 09:19

RayneDance · 25/08/2022 08:36

Why does his resentment trump ops?

Money comes and goes, but what about ops resentment if she goes back and deeply resents her husband?
You literally cannot buy back these younger years?
What value can you place on that?

Ops husband could be pacified as money starts to roll in again from op but op might never get over loosing that time?

His resentment ultimately trumps OPs because you can't make someone fully financially support you if they don't want to. Which means if it comes down to it, the person not wanting the SAHP wins. Obviously it would be better all round if that weren't the premise for the decision to be made, but if it is then it's quite clear who has top trumps here.

But I agree with a lot of PPs, the obvious compromise to look at here is part time work.

GlitteryGreen · 25/08/2022 09:19

I don't think you can do this without your husband being 100% in favour, and he's not. I wouldn't be happy if my DP unilaterally decided he was stopping work to stay home with our child and I'd be financially supporting all of us from now on.

Have another chat with him and go through his reservations, you should get a feel for what he truly thinks.

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:18

I can honestly say, if my 120k earner husband leaves me for another women, I can’t take that on 🤷‍♀️

he’s a an adult man who makes choices, nothing I say or do impacts that (working or not) but I actually see this comment coming from a place of kindness. It does happen and can leave some people in terrible position. I don’t fear this from a financial sense at all

OP posts:
Aozora13 · 25/08/2022 09:16

Do you need to decide now? I’m on mat leave with DC3 from quite a stressful job and was desperate to quit for a change of pace, spend more time with the kids etc etc but I would have to pay to not return! Actually now the baby is 11 months old, the prospect of putting her in childcare doesn’t feel so bad, and I’m starting to get brain rot and looking forward to going back to work.

It’s a moot point but we can just about afford for one of us not to work. However, with the economy as it is right now, we want that safety net of 2 incomes. Plus I’m mindful of my pension - although if you’re only planning to take a couple of years out it’s probably neither here nor there.

Previously I was the sole breadwinner for 18 months. I didn’t mind at all and didn’t really feel pressure. Until I got made redundant. Then I got another job and was really sick with Long Covid. That was extra scary and I definitely went back too soon because I was worried about our finances. So I can see where your DP is coming from too.

Louise0701 · 25/08/2022 09:16

I always see on these threads “don’t be financially dependent on a man” would it make a difference for a lesbian couple? Is it ok to be financially dependent on a woman?

pistachi0nuts · 25/08/2022 09:15

If you want to stay home and look after your daughter, and you can afford to, then follow your mothers instinct and stay and look after your daughter. You won't get these early years back.... you can get back to work when your little one is older. Staying home and looking after your child is as full on as working full time (in fact arguably much harder) but you are providing your daughter with the only thing she really wants (you). Nursery can be tough for mother and child. Go for it x

edwinbear · 25/08/2022 09:14

The huge increase in WFH has also made lots of work much more flexible. I can do drop offs/assemblies/sports fixtures etc much more easily than I could pre pandemic. Our combined incomes have also meant we can put 2 DC though private school, which isn't something everyone wants, or is right for their DC, but worth considering before you give up work. With a combined income of £180k it's just about feasible, on £120k, it probably isn't.

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:14

I assure you, he certainly will be. When I gentle dropped this in, I saw his eyes widen at the idea of it all. He will be on board but his life is certainly going to change when / if I return to work, even PT.

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 25/08/2022 09:13

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 09:10

I’m concerned about about my pension and savings taking a huge hit (unfair I feel, for SAHMs)

arghh. You claim Child Benefit. You don't get money but you get your statutory pension contributions.

If you're talking about taking a huge hit to a private pension - why do you think so many of us work? and again all this talk of "missing milestones" - utter piffle. Or is this going to turn into yet another working outside the home mothers bashing thread (or SAHM bashing thread, I'm not sure)

If there are no working parents in your team then it seems to me it would be a good time to give that tree a shake?

Not necessarily a tree that needs shaking. It might just be that no one is at that life stage. In my team everyone either hasn't had kids yet or has adult DC. A couple if years ago we had someone part time with DC but she got a promotion to a different team.

AndSoFinally · 25/08/2022 09:12

Remember also, doubling a salary from £60k to £120k doesn't come anywhere near doubling take home pay.

The whole increase will be in the higher tax band and he'll lost virtually all his personal tax allowance, meaning he pays effectively 60% tax on some of that.

He'll be lucky to take home about 1.5 x his current amount once all deductions are considered.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 09:12

Yabu on multiple fronts

Firstly your DH isn't for it, so it's likely to build resentment. Both parties need to be 100% aligned for this to work

Secondly you'll be financially reliant on someone else - never a good position to be in

Thirdly think of the impact on your child themselves. I personally really benefited to seeing my mother work hard and enjoy it too, it's what drove me to have a career myself. Most of my friends growing up who had a mother working part time or being a SAHP have much lower aspirations for themselves.

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 09:10

I’m concerned about about my pension and savings taking a huge hit (unfair I feel, for SAHMs)

arghh. You claim Child Benefit. You don't get money but you get your statutory pension contributions.

If you're talking about taking a huge hit to a private pension - why do you think so many of us work? and again all this talk of "missing milestones" - utter piffle. Or is this going to turn into yet another working outside the home mothers bashing thread (or SAHM bashing thread, I'm not sure)

If there are no working parents in your team then it seems to me it would be a good time to give that tree a shake?