Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to stay home with our daughter

293 replies

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

OP posts:
donkeydonk · 25/08/2022 10:18

In a situation where you have enough income to pay for Childcare and your dh wants you to work it's unwise to not go back.

Moonface123 · 25/08/2022 10:05

Do what you think is best, what feels right for you.
I took out a part time job in the evenings, approx 3 evenings a week so l could be at home in the day with my sons and l never regretted it.

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 10:01

fizzythedog · 25/08/2022 09:57

OP - this is MN. You are not going to get a balanced view about SAHMs on here. Just know that.

There are women drawn to these threads who, to put it bluntly, know they are not cut out to be SAHMs themselves, so they find the fact that other women are, and that some families highly value the SAHM role, to be bewildering and even threatening.

There are even more women who can't afford to SAH even if they wanted to. So this sort of thread is always going to provoke a degree of angst and jealousy from some (well, quite a lot, to be fair).

There are women on these threads whose husbands won't even have shared finances with them. No wonder they can't comprehend the concept of a SAHM!

There are women who have been brainwashed into thinking you can't be "equal" in a marriage if you don't both work. In other words, they have come to equate "value" with income. Again, that is about them, not you.

There are women in here who have been with horrendous men and who have been left very bitter following divorce. Their sentiments are understandable but, equally, not everything needs to be viewed through a doomsday lens - nor does everything need to be a race to the bottom either.

Anyway, amid all the projection (which is 95% of these threads), there may be the odd poster who is genuinely not projecting and has an actual salient point - ie. think about the impact on your pension; ease of getting back into the workplace etc.This however, is not rocket science and it sounds as if you are eminently capable of considering these issues as they pertain to you. All the anecdotes about so-and-so's cousin's neighbour who struggled to get back after x years is neither here nor there. They are not in your role or industry!

In the real non-MN world, of course millions of women take a few years out to care for their children pre-school - to great success and to the benefit of the whole family. It's hardly compulsory to put your kids in daycare, or with other people. Not should it ever be.

I agree your DH needs to be on board but, the point is, it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks. It's your family. Of course your feelings count. Talk to your DH. Point out the benefits of your child having his / her mum around for a few more years. It's not as if you're saying you will never work again!

You will work out what is best for your family in YOUR circumstances. But no, in principle, of course YANBU to want to be with your own child!

Thank you so much @fizzythedog

this has really cut through the BS for me and aligns with the advice I would give others (and myself now)

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:58

Classicblunder · 25/08/2022 09:52

I wouldn't go into negotiations with work with that mindset.

I have had promotions working part time.

Go to them with a proposal for how you could make it work.

Think about compressed hours, maybe a jobshare partner etc

I don’t mean to discredit PT work or the ability to do it and do it well, My company has a bad habit of throwing PT workers to the wayside. Im willing to tackle that culture and push back but ultimately, it’s a bit uphill. Ideally, 2/3 days is palatable for me. 4/5 isn’t right now.

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 09:57

Thanks...flipping autocorrect!

fizzythedog · 25/08/2022 09:57

OP - this is MN. You are not going to get a balanced view about SAHMs on here. Just know that.

There are women drawn to these threads who, to put it bluntly, know they are not cut out to be SAHMs themselves, so they find the fact that other women are, and that some families highly value the SAHM role, to be bewildering and even threatening.

There are even more women who can't afford to SAH even if they wanted to. So this sort of thread is always going to provoke a degree of angst and jealousy from some (well, quite a lot, to be fair).

There are women on these threads whose husbands won't even have shared finances with them. No wonder they can't comprehend the concept of a SAHM!

There are women who have been brainwashed into thinking you can't be "equal" in a marriage if you don't both work. In other words, they have come to equate "value" with income. Again, that is about them, not you.

There are women in here who have been with horrendous men and who have been left very bitter following divorce. Their sentiments are understandable but, equally, not everything needs to be viewed through a doomsday lens - nor does everything need to be a race to the bottom either.

Anyway, amid all the projection (which is 95% of these threads), there may be the odd poster who is genuinely not projecting and has an actual salient point - ie. think about the impact on your pension; ease of getting back into the workplace etc.This however, is not rocket science and it sounds as if you are eminently capable of considering these issues as they pertain to you. All the anecdotes about so-and-so's cousin's neighbour who struggled to get back after x years is neither here nor there. They are not in your role or industry!

In the real non-MN world, of course millions of women take a few years out to care for their children pre-school - to great success and to the benefit of the whole family. It's hardly compulsory to put your kids in daycare, or with other people. Not should it ever be.

I agree your DH needs to be on board but, the point is, it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks. It's your family. Of course your feelings count. Talk to your DH. Point out the benefits of your child having his / her mum around for a few more years. It's not as if you're saying you will never work again!

You will work out what is best for your family in YOUR circumstances. But no, in principle, of course YANBU to want to be with your own child!

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 09:57

Ah, OK, thales for clarifying, OP, and apologies for the misunderstanding.

Butteryflakycrust83 · 25/08/2022 09:56

Its natural to get upset at just the thought of leaving baby at first.

Your DH isnt comfortable, and I think that would lead to resentment.

I also would hate to rely on someone else for money.

I think find some middle ground and ask work if you can return part time?

Anewdayanewdawn · 25/08/2022 09:56

You should consider PT - so that when you are ready to go FT you give yourself the best chance of doing so…

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:55

toomuchlaundry · 25/08/2022 09:52

Do you only get statutory maternity pay?

I received enhanced mat pay, if I don’t return I would need to pay this back and I would from savings so not an issue if it came to it. I’d be happy to pay this from my personal savings even. Perhaps a risky decision but there we are. I’d have to return for 12 months to avoid paying it back.

OP posts:
Anewdayanewdawn · 25/08/2022 09:55

I wouldn’t be financially dependent on another person, man or woman. You need to think about pensions and savings.
if you go down this route I would speak to your DH about paying into a pension for you.
if you retire together, he still benefits. If you split up you have your own pension.

Adversity · 25/08/2022 09:54

I’m in my fifties and looking at all the women in my family or close friends I have known for many years the way our lives have turned out is so variable. I would say a third have ended up in decent long term marriages or partnerships where money is not an issue. The rest is a mixed bag of ok to really terrible struggles with money and awful men of varying levels.

Its an unpalatable truth but the only person you can truly rely on is yourself and I say that as one of the lucky with a really lovely DH of almost 27 years and no money worries.

Please remain working at least PT, even if partners are a positive delight I have met a few widows in my life and some of them were widowed at tragically young ages.

Hugasauras · 25/08/2022 09:53

Part-time works great for me/us as a family, but I've never wanted to be a SAHP. I think when you're in that newborn bubble you can't imagine leaving them but with DD1 I was absolutely ready to get back to work when she was around 9 months and expect I'll be the same with this one too. I'm back in April 2023 but actually already looking forward to doing my keeping in touch days later in the year!

Classicblunder · 25/08/2022 09:52

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:49

DH is totally fine with PT, perhaps I trial this. It would likely mean stepping down at work (if they have the PT work to offer!)

I wouldn't go into negotiations with work with that mindset.

I have had promotions working part time.

Go to them with a proposal for how you could make it work.

Think about compressed hours, maybe a jobshare partner etc

toomuchlaundry · 25/08/2022 09:52

Do you only get statutory maternity pay?

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:52

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 09:34

Mat leave is totally different though. Taking a short time out of the workplace and then going back is not the same as opting out of the workforce for a much longer period and expecting someone else to take on the financial responsibility.

It was me that said you might not be happy being the main breadwinner if that was your actual reality and I stand by that. It's a massive responsibility to carry alone, and many people would find that very stressful. If it isn't a realistic prospect for you to have to take that on, it's pretty easy to say that you wouldn't mind, but you might well feel differently if you actually had to do it. I guess we'll never know.

Sorry I’m finding my feet with replies!

I meant he will be on board with doing more of the CC and around the house if I return to work, it may be confusing as I hadn’t quoted the message I was replying to who was asking about household workload

OP posts:
whiteonesugar · 25/08/2022 09:52

@Autumnmoons In terms of career and maintaining a senior position, my line manager is a very senior director and she works PT. She has done since her first child was born and he is 10 now. When she took the role at our place she specified she wouldnt be doing 5 days - initially they were reluctant but she's been there 3 years now and manages it perfectly. It can work.

I work 4 days per week, I have done since my first son was born. I have fridays off and I feel it really gives me a good work/life balance. I've had 3 promotions in the time I've worked PT. I think you could make it work without any detriment to your career. The drop in salary is something to adjust to but it doesn't feel like you're being short changed when you get a long weekend and more time with your child. A friend of mine used to have Wednesdays as her non working day to break up the week.

If anyone can organise their working week into 4 days then its a mum!

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 25/08/2022 09:49

What I'd do

Doubling salary doesn't usually mean double disposable income because of scaled tax bands, so you might miss your salary more than you think.

Go to work, save your salary to try living off just his, and see how it goes and make a decision after 6 months.

Every mother on mat leave feels like they want to stay at home, and cries when they go back and have to leave their baby (at least yours is with family so you dont have the settling in at nursery guilt!). But being at home with a toddler is a bit different to a baby, they need a lot more stimulation and lots of people have gone back to work. Personally I didnt realise I wasnt feeling myself until I went back to work and settled back in after a few months, and realised I felt like 'me' again.

If you do decide to stay off, make sure your husband is on board, talk about how finances will be set up and how you split spending money, and put some money aside from his salary into your pension. Also talk about how much he will help with house chores and how much hobby time you will have. Lots of men seem to assume that it's their money if their wife isnt working, so they dont have to lift a finger and they can spend all weekend playing golf and make all the financial decisions

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:49

whiteonesugar · 25/08/2022 09:46

I think part time is a good compromise.

DH is totally fine with PT, perhaps I trial this. It would likely mean stepping down at work (if they have the PT work to offer!)

OP posts:
whiteonesugar · 25/08/2022 09:46

I think part time is a good compromise.

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 09:45

Thank you for all the well wishes, I really appreciate it.

I can see it from both sides, being a SAHP and a breadwinner both have their burdens and heavy weights. Neither is easy. One does come with lunch breaks and solo trips to the toilet and a start and finish time however… but I digress.

I am not thrilled by the idea of not having access to my own money / career so it’s not a case of not wanting to work (I have since I was a kid) but solely about craving my time with my daughter. I don’t subscribe to the ‘they need time away from you’ theory for infants and small children. I know she will be in safe hands with her beloved grandparents but I resent having to go back to work. There may be a thousand reasons my DH might feel the same about me needing to return to work, both feelings can be valid.

if I return to work then he will need to step up in other ways too, I don’t think this is unreasonable even on PT hours.

my job is fast paced and stressful, I’m not sure how feasible PT but I know they are keen for me to return (I manage a team who are a brilliant bunch but it’s a very male dominated industry and let’s just say… I’m the peace maker?) but on a FT basis ideally. Perhaps I look for lower paid work PT but I’d resent working for less money and being away from my baby for essentially pocket change.

Still get used to MN so sorry for not replying and tagging peoples names!

OP posts:
JustLyra · 25/08/2022 09:45

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 08:49

Non working parents (predominantly mothers) take a huge hit to pension contributions etc that their husbands / partners don’t. My husband will continue to fill up his pension while mine sits dormant, even part time I will take a bit to contributions. It’s a huge issue I feel, women are almost punished financially overall for being the main childcare if they don’t return to work FT

With higher earning husbands that doesn’t have to be the case though.

One of the agreements with us was that we could afford to keep paying into my pension when I went part time, then eventually SAH.

that should be one of the costs taken into account when making the decisions.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 25/08/2022 09:43

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

What if he lost his job? Your family would be in trouble.

Where would you be without adult interaction? It is good for you.

What about your pension etc?

Mariposista · 25/08/2022 09:42

Go back to work.

Longdistance · 25/08/2022 09:42

I would’ve loved to have gone back to work after having dds. We moved to Oz for a few years with dhs job, so had to give up my job. My confidence was very low and I found it hard to go back to working when we came back to the Uk. I found it very difficult and by that point my earning power dropped. I’m still not earning as much pre dc.

Can you not go pt for a bit?