Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to stay home with our daughter

293 replies

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:34

sangletea · 25/08/2022 13:15

Oh no. Think very carefully about stepping off the career ladder and becoming the dependent wifey

Maintain your independence

I will, no matter what, remain independent. Not all SAHPs are fawning useless saps when it comes to finances. I wouldn’t allow this to happen, simply because DH is the sole earner. It doesn’t work like that anymore (not for my marriage anyway)

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:32

rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 12:52

Non working parents (predominantly mothers) take a huge hit to pension contributions etc that their husbands / partners don’t. My husband will continue to fill up his pension while mine sits dormant, even part time I will take a bit to contributions. It’s a huge issue I feel, women are almost punished financially overall for being the main childcare if they don’t return to work FT

Well, yeah, they don’t get paid a works pension for not being at work. Who do you think should pay for you to have a work pension if you’re at home, if not your husband?

The problem here is that none of this was discussed before you had a child and now you’re playing resentment top trumps. You cannot force someone to pay for you not to work, even if it makes you and your child very sad. The best way to avoid this is to pick a man who wants a SAHM. You didn’t, so now you have to live with that. PT sounds a good way forward.

You seem like you’d be lots of fun at parties. We did discuss it, we were in a different financial situation then as he didn’t have this better paid job then. Now it’s changed (and so have I, having had our baby and cared for her for so long) and so I am guilty of changing my mind about something. It’s not unheard of and it’s not that I picked the wrong person to have a family with. It’s a normal part of becoming a parent. Some women who think they’ll never want to return, rush back to work with glee and the opposite can be true too. I won’t be shamed by you, for feeling differently and assuming that we have never discussed this. Previously DH has said he would love for me to be a SAHP if we were in a better financial situation. Now we are, so I opened up the conversation with him again.

OP posts:
sangletea · 25/08/2022 13:15

Oh no. Think very carefully about stepping off the career ladder and becoming the dependent wifey

Maintain your independence

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 13:06

APoll16 · 25/08/2022 12:58

Ive been a SAHM for 4 years now (2 daughters 4 & 6m) and it has been amazing. I feel really lucky to have had all this time with them and that my husband has been happy to support this. If you can chat to your hubby about this and get on the same page, and can afford it, I would totally go for it! Its hard work but they are beautiful years that you wont get back x

But he isn't on the same page and he doesn't want to be the sole breadwinner.

APoll16 · 25/08/2022 12:58

Ive been a SAHM for 4 years now (2 daughters 4 & 6m) and it has been amazing. I feel really lucky to have had all this time with them and that my husband has been happy to support this. If you can chat to your hubby about this and get on the same page, and can afford it, I would totally go for it! Its hard work but they are beautiful years that you wont get back x

rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 12:52

Non working parents (predominantly mothers) take a huge hit to pension contributions etc that their husbands / partners don’t. My husband will continue to fill up his pension while mine sits dormant, even part time I will take a bit to contributions. It’s a huge issue I feel, women are almost punished financially overall for being the main childcare if they don’t return to work FT

Well, yeah, they don’t get paid a works pension for not being at work. Who do you think should pay for you to have a work pension if you’re at home, if not your husband?

The problem here is that none of this was discussed before you had a child and now you’re playing resentment top trumps. You cannot force someone to pay for you not to work, even if it makes you and your child very sad. The best way to avoid this is to pick a man who wants a SAHM. You didn’t, so now you have to live with that. PT sounds a good way forward.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 25/08/2022 11:29

if I return to work then he will need to step up in other ways too, I don’t think this is unreasonable even on PT hours.

Absolutely!

Your DH is entitled not to want to be the sole earner, and that's fine, but equally he will also have to accept the consequences flowing from that decision not just the extra income. Being the working parent of a small child has challenges.

GalactatingGoddess · 25/08/2022 11:17

Personally I wouldn't want to be 100% financially depending on a man. But each to their own and it works out well for some.

Won't you have to pay your Mat leave back though?

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 11:17

@fizzythedog I think your post is spot on. It’s important to stay balanced you’re exactly right on the doomsday/paradise thinking! Of course there’s a middle ground. X

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 11:09

Women are definitely punished financially if you don’t go back to work- unless your DH can transfer you the equivalent of your salary so you personally can still pay into a pension & savings in your name.

That's not punishment. That is a result of not being in paid employment and not paying into private pensions. The state pension contributions are kept up if you claim CB. But how is it punishment?

TBH i really don't think enough people discuss the realities of family life with children when they're planning a family (or just even TTC or pregnant by accident or whatever). It's not just about SAHP and how finances / pensions work. It is also about when both of you work how the childcare is divided up. Who does what and when, and any expectations that it is the mother, or the lower earner who drops everything every time. It's about having reliable childcare and a reliable back-up plan. And even though some things happen unexpectedly, it is building up robust plans to handle the unexpected.

We didn't get everything right, but one thing we did was both be a bit flexible about who was giving the bad news to their boss that they'd have to be off for a few days with a sick DC. Knowing each other's schedule so that, for eg, my DH didn't take on extra shifts at quarterly closing and so on.

It is all about both being fully on board with whatever decision you (both) make (together).

Weenurse · 25/08/2022 11:08

This is a couple decision and what works for one couple may not work for another.
A friend has always been the primary earner with her DH as SAHP. She has always said that she has to plan for providing pension income for both of them. That was a decision that they made as a couple and has allowed her to work overseas because of his support.
In our case, I went back to work at 6 weeks with DC 1 and 8 months with DC 2. Both times part time. Stepping up to full time when they were 4 and 2 when DH lost his job. He works construction so has been job free about 10 times in our 30 year marriage.
i remember being resentful, at one point, with his spending as he hadn’t earned the money so why was he spending that way! I needed an attitude adjustment.
it has also meant DD’s have seen parenting shared ( taking in turns to stay home when DD sick) and that no one’s job was more important than the others. I have worked part time when they were in primary school and wanted Mum there for school activities, and full time when they hit high school and didn’t want to know you. ( Also scaled up and down depending on if DH had a job).
I would suggest going back full time until you no longer owe mat leave money and then make a decision. Also save everything you earn when you go back so you have a buffer down the track.
Good luck with whatever you decide as a couple.

UrethraFranklin90 · 25/08/2022 11:01

If you can get your husband on board I say go for it. I'm just about to go back to work myself and I'm absolutely dreading it, even though it will be 4 days a week. Sadly I'm the main earner so have no option. I would love the chance to stay with my little boy.

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 10:58

Not necessarily a tree that needs shaking

not necessarily but may be something OP could think about if she wants to go back part-time? or even full time.

The thing for me is this: so many women get stuck into being a SAHP unwillingly (not saying this is true for OP , clearly she wants to) or going part-time. And part (a huge part) of that is because people don't rock the boat a bit. Men in my company (not UK) take a few months or weeks parental leave at a time, and it is celebrated. Women tend to take a year ML (they could take more) and then come back so they can keep career progression going (it's a good employer, there is flexibility i wish i'd had when my DCs were small).

This happens because people rock the boat, and don't buy into the expectation that "well he earns more" (because historical reasons why men earn more).

As it happens i was the higher earner for many many years. DH had either precarious jobs, or high-stress for relatively shit-pay jobs (it's his industry to blame - also that is improving now we're approaching retirement). But it meant that i was under a LOT of pressure to keep my job, work overtime back when i got that paid, and get promotions (and then no overtime paid but the hours were the same). Don't underestimate that pressure. Looking back now i can identify the exact point where i was very close to a burn out and shouted "STOP!".

Having a SAHP works only when both partners are on board, and there are clear expectations around responsibilities, free time, money etc. In OPs case - the DH isn't on board, and frankly, i don't blame him. At least wait until he is over any probationary period or the shiny-new-job-glow before major decisions are made.

pinkyredrose · 25/08/2022 10:51

Fixyourself · 25/08/2022 08:39

Also if he wants you to go back to work then is he prepared to share time off for when your child is sick?
Will he be sharing childcare on school holidays?
Will be doing equal childcare at weekends/evenings/nights?
Will he be doing his equal share of house work?

This

cushioncovers · 25/08/2022 10:47

See how your dp gets on first in his new job. There may be a probationary period, he may not like it etc. you dont have to make any decisions yet. How old is your baby op? Most new mothers often can't bear the thought of leaving their tiny babies but months later are ready to work part time.

Calmdown14 · 25/08/2022 10:46

I felt like you but agree with others that mat leave is very different to stepping out of the workforce. You have none of the worries about employability, losing skills and confidence etc.

I'd stick in a request for two days a week (start low) and see what they say. It is often easier to drop hours than get a part time role.

I'm glad I went back to work but I have no intention of ever going back to full time.

I would plan for long term. You say you wouldn't mind once at school but then they have school events, activities after school etc and you want to be there for those things too.

A short working week passes amazingly quick and you make more effort on the days you spend with your child because it's special.

You can also treat them without guilt or go for a coffee, to softplay etc. Spending someone else's money is an odd feeling, even when they don't mind. I couldn't enjoy it the same.

Personally I opted for shorter working hours over more years rather than just the baby stage but every household is different.

Namenic · 25/08/2022 10:45

each situation is different, but in your shoes I would aim to go back to work PT (ideally at the same company - at least for the 12 months). Reasons:

  1. cost of living increass
  2. husband not 100% enthusiastic for sahp - risk of resentment
  3. reduction in your savings and pension - made worse by having to pay back enhanced mat leave if you don’t go back for 12 months. you would also have to consider life insurance etc - in case DH became ill.
  4. in many companies you accrue annual leave during Mat leave - so in your 12 months that you return - you would get double your usual annual leave
  5. child can develop a good relationship with grandparents. I think it is lovely when this develops.
  6. in U.K. tax system favours 2 parents working (your DH will be taxed 50% on his earnings above upper threshold - better to put more into his pension, so can retire earlier). Whereas you can make use of your tax free allowance And above this can be taxed at 20%.
  7. it is likely that you will find it easier to get a higher paying job if you were working part time than if you had a full career break.

I’m really pro sahps, but you would be missing out a lot financially and DH is not 100% in favour. So that would make it more rational to do at least PT (and make use of accrued A/L) - especially with cost of living etc. think about it like - if you did this you may be able to retire or finish paying your mortgage earlier.

gamerchick · 25/08/2022 10:39

Now's not the time to be quitting jobs if you don't want to and if your bloke isn't on board, resentment will breed.

hoorayandupsherises · 25/08/2022 10:37

I'd really put your energy into a plan to make your job work as a PT role to present to your work. Ten years ago, I applied to WFH when no one else was doing it in a section of over a thousand staff (the director was very anti). Everyone told me not to even bother applying. I applied, got a renewable trial period of three months, really high targets that I had to meet to keep my "privileges", but I was the most productive team member, had a good reputation for quality and in the end they came round to the idea. It just takes one or two people in the organization to change their minds about these things for the culture to tip the other way.

If it doesn't work out in your current job, you can look at something else PT, but it sounds like it would be worth your time and energy making the current job work better for you.

Give some consideration to whether it wouldn't be better for you to do a compressed schedule. Everyone I know who does PT as four or five half days really struggles to keep to their hours. Not the case for those on compressed schedule. If you did two days compressed for example, with your DH doing pick up and drop off and your DD with DGPs the rest of the time. Also, I know someone who does compressed Monday and Thursday so that problems don't build up/hang around for ages while she's not in the office.

I am sole earner at the moment through no fault of DH's, but it is really stressful, especially with the current climate and my health is starting to wear down because of it. I have every sympathy with you too wanting to stay with your DD, but I just can understand that he might not feel able to cope with the worry of being sole earner.

Rinatinabina · 25/08/2022 10:35

I’m a SAHM (trailing spouse) it’s quite boring tbh. You may enjoy it but if I were you I’d try for part time as a compromise. That way you can also see both sides and make a more informed decision.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 10:33

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 10:19

Women are definitely punished financially if you don’t go back to work- unless your DH can transfer you the equivalent of your salary so you personally can still pay into a pension & savings in your name.

There’s nothing wrong with looking after your own DC if you want to and if you’re fortunate enough to have the choice to have one adult with more time at home it’s an option not all families have. We have chosen that because my DH couldn’t do his job and have a family without live in childcare really due to lots of travel. As a team it makes better sense to support that job because of the financial gain overall to our family. Me going back to work would be a ‘less efficient’ choice because we’d be working more hours collectively for less money. With our current set up we have a far less stressful lifestyle which I also think is important to everyone’s health & well being. My DS will be going to nursery 2 days a week from September so I can work on our house renovation which also makes financial sense as we will be increasing the value of our house - there’s probably a years worth of work left and the increase in value would be more than my annual salary.

I also have a few things that I feel give me some protection- I am not in the UK - I have good savings in my own name which I continue to contribute to & I could go back to my job quite easily as I worked really hard to secure my place before I left.

Its a really personal choice - I don’t think there’s a right or wrong answer. It’s not a free ride being a SAHP - I feel many of the comments here suggest it is. If you’re really a team, then it makes very good financial sense to capitalise on the fact you have some ‘freedom’ during this time and you could do some training or a course that boosts your earnings long term. That way you’ve economised childcare, made the most of it and are better off long term on all counts. xo

I agree that there's absolutely nothing wrong with it if both partners agree. If that's how you choose to organise your family life and it works for your family, great. The problem here arises because the OP's DH doesn't want to be the sole breadwinner. The OP cannot force him into that position and it would be wrong for her to try.

This has nothing to do with other women being jealous or bitter or any of the other nonsense spouted by @fizzythedog above. It's simply about saying that there is no absolute right for anyone to SAH with their kids if their partner/spouse is unwilling to support that arrangement.

The default position is that both partners are equally responsible for earning a living, taking care of the children and managing the home. It is fine to negotiate an arrangement whereby those tasks are divided between you so that one person takes on more responsibilities in one area while the other takes on more responsibilities in another, but nobody gets to make those decisions unilaterally. This is just common sense, surely?

whumpthereitis · 25/08/2022 10:28

It’s unwise to do it if your husband isn’t fully on board.

From his perspective, he’s just got this pay increase and it’s removed a lot of stress from him in regards to income and being able to weather the cost of living crisis that’s underway. However, you’ve now turned around and put a new financial stressor on him by wanting for give up your job and have him fully financially responsible for the family.

if it’s a decision you make unilaterally/pressure him into agreeing with, then it’s very likely to result in resentment, which in turn can send a relationship spiralling.

it’s one thing deciding between staying at home and going to work when both are options you’re fully supported in, but that’s not your situation.

Isonthecase · 25/08/2022 10:27

I think you'd be sensible to consider part time work, even if just to give you a focus outside the home. It's a lot of pressure on your child to be your sole focus, especially if you're fairly driven anyway. I've been the child in that situation and would not recommend.

Part time would also take some of the pressure off your husband. I'm the main breadwinner in our family at the moment and, whilst it's the right thing for our family for now, it is a lot more pressure than I anticipated. That's even more the case at the moment with projected rises for, well, everything. Don't forget that with inflation your savings are also shrinking. If I'd been forced in to that situation I'd be pretty resentful of the person doing it.

The last thing I'd suggest you think about is if you'd actually be properly fulfilled longer term as a stay at home parent? Because I don't know anyone who is, but plenty of the mums I've met are when working a couple of days a week. This is predominantly those with children on reception age and below, it seems like most people enjoy it the first year or two. Obviously this is a limited sample size, and it's important to note that the full time ones aren't any happier.

Hymnulop · 25/08/2022 10:19

dribblewibble · 25/08/2022 07:40

I would go back to work. For the longer term career and pension benefits.

You never know what might happen and it's sensible to have an income.

I would do this,I'd just go part time.

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 10:19

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 08:49

Non working parents (predominantly mothers) take a huge hit to pension contributions etc that their husbands / partners don’t. My husband will continue to fill up his pension while mine sits dormant, even part time I will take a bit to contributions. It’s a huge issue I feel, women are almost punished financially overall for being the main childcare if they don’t return to work FT

Women are definitely punished financially if you don’t go back to work- unless your DH can transfer you the equivalent of your salary so you personally can still pay into a pension & savings in your name.

There’s nothing wrong with looking after your own DC if you want to and if you’re fortunate enough to have the choice to have one adult with more time at home it’s an option not all families have. We have chosen that because my DH couldn’t do his job and have a family without live in childcare really due to lots of travel. As a team it makes better sense to support that job because of the financial gain overall to our family. Me going back to work would be a ‘less efficient’ choice because we’d be working more hours collectively for less money. With our current set up we have a far less stressful lifestyle which I also think is important to everyone’s health & well being. My DS will be going to nursery 2 days a week from September so I can work on our house renovation which also makes financial sense as we will be increasing the value of our house - there’s probably a years worth of work left and the increase in value would be more than my annual salary.

I also have a few things that I feel give me some protection- I am not in the UK - I have good savings in my own name which I continue to contribute to & I could go back to my job quite easily as I worked really hard to secure my place before I left.

Its a really personal choice - I don’t think there’s a right or wrong answer. It’s not a free ride being a SAHP - I feel many of the comments here suggest it is. If you’re really a team, then it makes very good financial sense to capitalise on the fact you have some ‘freedom’ during this time and you could do some training or a course that boosts your earnings long term. That way you’ve economised childcare, made the most of it and are better off long term on all counts. xo