Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to stay home with our daughter

293 replies

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

OP posts:
rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 21:36

Well, if it was as simple as posting a MN thread to german your husband to change his mind then hurrah for that.

The second reply to me on pensions just seemed to be nebulous waffle about how it’s unfair that SAHPs don’t get a work pension. Which it isn’t. So.

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 21:36

@Thepeopleversuswork what do you mean ‘lifelong’??? I don’t know anyone who is a SAHP for ‘life’ 😂 I think these days SAHP’s are typically at home for the first few years or until teenage years. I’ve never heard of anyone never ever ever working ever again. I don’t think that’s what is being debated here! I think op is talking about a few years off- not being off work for the rest of her life!

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:35

Lavendersummer · 25/08/2022 15:44

What about approaching it as a career break/sabbatical ? You and DH agree you will take a certain period of time out of paid employment- being at home is still work. It’s just not paid or really particularly valued sadly.
Say 2 years. 6 months before the end date you relook at it. What’s working, what’s not etc.
However it has to be clear from the get go that any income coming into the house is family income. Not his. Family income. Purchases over a certain about of ££ to be discussed on a case by case basis.
Only you and he know if that will work for your marriage. It is very true you will never get that time back again with your baby. DH is the higher earner in our house. Me being at home has enabled him to really concentrate on his job - no sharing collecting the kids from nursery or looking after them when sick. It also means we get to enjoy our weekends more as I deal with anything that would have usually been saved for the weekend had we both had paid jobs.

This is how I’m viewing it, as a sabbatical. I plan to return to work once DD is around 2ish anyway as I do enjoy my work and I can rejoin the industry as it’s robust (even during economic crisis)

we have come to an agreement today (prompted by my browbeaten DH 😉) that works for us. He was feeling understandably overwhelmed initially but just needed some time. We are lucky that our comms are always very open and loving and we see each other’s perspectives which helped. We have a very similar agreement to yours and others posters regarding savings / pensions. We will see how it goes

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:30

UrethraFranklin90 · 25/08/2022 11:01

If you can get your husband on board I say go for it. I'm just about to go back to work myself and I'm absolutely dreading it, even though it will be 4 days a week. Sadly I'm the main earner so have no option. I would love the chance to stay with my little boy.

Sending loads of love to you and hoping your transition back to work goes really well. I know loads of parents on 4 day weeks and they’ve said how much more they enjoy the time with LO as it’s totally focused on them xxx

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:28

Ok?

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:28

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 25/08/2022 19:33

So much for marriage being a partnership if you browbeat him into agreeing for you to be a SAHM. He doesn't want it. End of. You will get usedto leaving your child and she will happily skip off to nursery with you safe in the knowledge she is well looked after.

Are you ok? This energy is wild.

We’ve costed it out tonight and looks way better than we were hoping financially, which is great news. He is feeling way more relaxed about it now.

it’s just up to me to decide if I want to return PT or stay at home with baby. Sometimes it does work out and no one is browbeaten, we have a great, fun relationship with great communication and I really respect my DHs fears and feelings as he respects mine. Sometimes it’s a clearing of the air that’s needed. Crikey, some of these comments are 😬😬😬😬

OP posts:
Brefugee · 25/08/2022 19:45

Further more to this, I am not a foot thinking I should be paid a pension by some mysterious source. I’m simply commenting that SAHPs are penalised for this financially and women, who make up the majority of SAHPs, suffer most.

No OP. I'm not having it. The point is that people who don't work and pay into a pension, or have someone pay into a pension miss out. It is related to your decision to work and/or have a pension.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 25/08/2022 19:33

So much for marriage being a partnership if you browbeat him into agreeing for you to be a SAHM. He doesn't want it. End of. You will get usedto leaving your child and she will happily skip off to nursery with you safe in the knowledge she is well looked after.

Namenic · 25/08/2022 18:19

Get a spreadsheet and cost it out. Going back to work FT vs PT vs not going back (including the pay-back of enhanced mat pay). Calculate how much take home pay differs in each scenario. plus how much pension contributions are in these situations.

This would be the opportunity cost. It might be enough to wipe a few years off mortgage or a good starter for uni fund for child; or allow you to retire early. You have to decide as a couple whether it is worth it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/08/2022 18:04

@fizzythedog

I take issue with your definition of the motivation of people posting about women choosing to stay at home.

Its a standard, inaccurate and rather insulting line that this is all driven by jealousy. In the vast majority of cases people who post on this topic post from real experience and sadly a lot of us know that the single biggest risk you can take as a woman is to rely on the lifelong financial support of a man. It’s just extremely risky.

But leaving this aside, the motivation for these posts isn’t relevant. What’s relevant are the facts. The facts are:

  • Close to half of all marriages fail
  • Even among those that don’t fail, a large proportion of women end up significantly financially disadvantaged and disenfranchised in their marriages.

It’s not automatically a bad idea to choose to be a SAHM. But to choose to do it when the one variable you absolutely have to have in place, ie a supportive spouse, increases the risk factor massively.

cptartapp · 25/08/2022 16:17

I went back pt at four and five months. They're now 19 and 17 and it was the best decision I ever made. Preserved the power balance in our marriage, my skills, my sanity and my pension looks great.
Think long term. In reality, I 'missed' very little.
Not one regret.

Cotton55 · 25/08/2022 16:06

We're all facing into a very unstable financial future. Your dh has just started this job. If the company has to issue redundancies due to a downturn in the economy, he might not be eligible for much of a pay out. Financially things will end up pretty bleak for some people in the next year or so. I wouldn't give up a stable job right now because of that alone. You also need to think of your pension contributions. When our kids were younger, there was a time when it was barely worth our while me working due to the huge cost of childcare. However, I continued because of my pension. I now work part time and feel it's the best of both worlds.
Also, I took a year off with each of my kids and I thought I wouldn't be able to bear leaving them when the time came but actually, work was like a break! (Almost!)

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 16:00

TiddleyWink · 25/08/2022 15:52

OP you’re not addressing the fact that your husband doesn’t want this so it’s not an option. You can’t just quit your job and just tell someone else that they now support you. Not without a strong chance of them divorcing you anyway. So I’m not sure what you’re wanting from this thread? Being a SAHP is a perfectly valid choice, so is working. You’re not unreasonable to want to stay at home, not at all. But it simply isn’t an option available to you and this thread isn’t going to change that. It’s just going to turn into the inevitable SAHP versus working parent bunfight. No one here can find a solution to your problem which is that you want to not work but your husband isn’t willing to fund that. We can all say yes you’re absolutely right but that changes nothing for you.

It’s still an option for us, he quite likes the idea but is naturally concerned about finances (as am I) and wants to get a gauge on that

OP posts:
Girliefriendlikespuppies · 25/08/2022 15:59

Can't you go back part time? It doesn't have to be all or nothing.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 15:54

@Autumnmoons

Hardly upset

Just bemused about you seeing it as being penalised when you've made an active decision - there are sadly financial consequences to said decision

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:53

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 15:42

@Autumnmoons

SAHPs aren't penalised

They suffer the consequences to their actions

You seem very upset about this whole concept. I’m sending love your way

OP posts:
TiddleyWink · 25/08/2022 15:52

OP you’re not addressing the fact that your husband doesn’t want this so it’s not an option. You can’t just quit your job and just tell someone else that they now support you. Not without a strong chance of them divorcing you anyway. So I’m not sure what you’re wanting from this thread? Being a SAHP is a perfectly valid choice, so is working. You’re not unreasonable to want to stay at home, not at all. But it simply isn’t an option available to you and this thread isn’t going to change that. It’s just going to turn into the inevitable SAHP versus working parent bunfight. No one here can find a solution to your problem which is that you want to not work but your husband isn’t willing to fund that. We can all say yes you’re absolutely right but that changes nothing for you.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 15:52

Penalised is an odd choice of word. It implies a degree of unfairness that I don't think is really there.

Am I being "penalised" for choosing to work in a sector which gives me considerable job satisfaction but pays less than the sector where I used to work? I don't think so, I am just accepting the consequences of the choices that I have made about how I want to live my life.

Or am I being penalised for choosing to work at all because it results in me having less free time than someone who doesn't work?

Life is full of choices. All of those choices have consequences. People who genuinely don't have any agency over their lives may well feel penalised by the circumstances that deny them the ability to make free choices, but most of us are constantly evaluating options and deciding what to prioritise.

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:52

Lavendersummer · 25/08/2022 15:44

What about approaching it as a career break/sabbatical ? You and DH agree you will take a certain period of time out of paid employment- being at home is still work. It’s just not paid or really particularly valued sadly.
Say 2 years. 6 months before the end date you relook at it. What’s working, what’s not etc.
However it has to be clear from the get go that any income coming into the house is family income. Not his. Family income. Purchases over a certain about of ££ to be discussed on a case by case basis.
Only you and he know if that will work for your marriage. It is very true you will never get that time back again with your baby. DH is the higher earner in our house. Me being at home has enabled him to really concentrate on his job - no sharing collecting the kids from nursery or looking after them when sick. It also means we get to enjoy our weekends more as I deal with anything that would have usually been saved for the weekend had we both had paid jobs.

I think this is sensible, I think he has started to come round to the idea of it all but it needs to be agreed 100% before we go ahead (by both of us) and we agree where the lines are and who is expecting what etc etc . We are open and have great communication so ultimately, it will be a joint choice no matter what. He’s not tight with money or mean in any way. I think the current climate has him worried, as it does for us all at the moment so that is impacting his thoughts in it all. Very valid concerns. I’d be happy to forgo any big spending etc for a few years to stay at home, he would be too

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:49

KarmaStar · 25/08/2022 15:46

You can't dump all the financial responsibility on your dh if he is not 100% in agreement.
Plus cost of living,savings,pensions,you need to seriously think this through sensibly,not with a self indulgent head on.

Again, not entirely sure what’s self indulgent about nurturing my children whilst I don’t work outside the home but… ok?

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 25/08/2022 15:46

You can't dump all the financial responsibility on your dh if he is not 100% in agreement.
Plus cost of living,savings,pensions,you need to seriously think this through sensibly,not with a self indulgent head on.

Lavendersummer · 25/08/2022 15:44

What about approaching it as a career break/sabbatical ? You and DH agree you will take a certain period of time out of paid employment- being at home is still work. It’s just not paid or really particularly valued sadly.
Say 2 years. 6 months before the end date you relook at it. What’s working, what’s not etc.
However it has to be clear from the get go that any income coming into the house is family income. Not his. Family income. Purchases over a certain about of ££ to be discussed on a case by case basis.
Only you and he know if that will work for your marriage. It is very true you will never get that time back again with your baby. DH is the higher earner in our house. Me being at home has enabled him to really concentrate on his job - no sharing collecting the kids from nursery or looking after them when sick. It also means we get to enjoy our weekends more as I deal with anything that would have usually been saved for the weekend had we both had paid jobs.

AnnaFri · 25/08/2022 15:42

@Autumnmoons

SAHPs aren't penalised

They suffer the consequences to their actions

lilroo87 · 25/08/2022 15:39

I ended up not returning to work at the end of my maternity leave and it is something I had always been 100% sure I would never do. I loved working and earning my own money but honestly, I absolutely love being home with my daughter and I can't imagine not being at home with her now.
If you're able to do it and your DH supports your decision and you figure out your finances, then I would say go for it.
I'm currently pregnant with my 2nd (not planned) which swayed our decision for me to stay home as we have no family for childcare and it would mean spending over £2k a month and we didn't see the point. I'll go back to work when they're at pre-school and it means I get to really enjoy their early years x

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:36

rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 12:52

Non working parents (predominantly mothers) take a huge hit to pension contributions etc that their husbands / partners don’t. My husband will continue to fill up his pension while mine sits dormant, even part time I will take a bit to contributions. It’s a huge issue I feel, women are almost punished financially overall for being the main childcare if they don’t return to work FT

Well, yeah, they don’t get paid a works pension for not being at work. Who do you think should pay for you to have a work pension if you’re at home, if not your husband?

The problem here is that none of this was discussed before you had a child and now you’re playing resentment top trumps. You cannot force someone to pay for you not to work, even if it makes you and your child very sad. The best way to avoid this is to pick a man who wants a SAHM. You didn’t, so now you have to live with that. PT sounds a good way forward.

Further more to this, I am not a foot thinking I should be paid a pension by some mysterious source. I’m simply commenting that SAHPs are penalised for this financially and women, who make up the majority of SAHPs, suffer most. It’s sometimes a behind the scenes additional hit that mums take if they stay home when it comes further down the line. Yes ‘go back to work’ is I’m sure, the solution to that but I was maker a wider point really.

OP posts: