Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to stay home with our daughter

293 replies

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

OP posts:
AnnaFri · 26/08/2022 09:08

Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:06

I have savings that marked out for this that roughly amount to around 3.5 years of my pre-Mat leave salary, I could make it last probably 7-8 years if I were to pay myself a better than minimum wage salary for those years. I plan to be back working by then - I therefor remain independent despite not technically earning. I have other savings pots for other things. I appreciate again, this is better situations than most. I have saved from every job I have ever had

I'm calling bullshit on this as your earlier posts mentioned relying on your DH for money

So if you have savings to pay yourself a salary why even mention that?

Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:07

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/08/2022 08:12

@Autumnmoons

it’s true that I staying home only benefits you, your husband and your daughter (though she’d be fine if you did work)

it’s not a societal contribution let’s face it

The patriarchy thanks you for your work here 😂

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:06

I have savings that marked out for this that roughly amount to around 3.5 years of my pre-Mat leave salary, I could make it last probably 7-8 years if I were to pay myself a better than minimum wage salary for those years. I plan to be back working by then - I therefor remain independent despite not technically earning. I have other savings pots for other things. I appreciate again, this is better situations than most. I have saved from every job I have ever had

OP posts:
AnnaFri · 26/08/2022 08:29

Hettythechicken · 26/08/2022 08:22

@RayneDance I am a teacher but a few years ago I did supply in nurseries to fill a career gap and unfortunately I concur with what you’re saying. The baby rooms were a shock to me in some of the settings (one of which my own children had been to!!).

I can’t believe the negativity on this thread about wanting to stay at home with your child - really bizarre to me when OP has clearly thought it through and can afford it. There is so much evidence about the importance of one-to-one attachment being better in the first 18 months of a child’s life. (And as I said my kids did go to nursery before then but I still did the research and knew it wasn’t the ‘best’ option.)

It doesn't matter if they can afford it if her DH isn't on board

Also him doubling his salary isn't doubling the take home so they'd still be at a net loss of income

Plus the damage OP will do to her earning potential which for some women they never recover from during their careers

Hettythechicken · 26/08/2022 08:22

@RayneDance I am a teacher but a few years ago I did supply in nurseries to fill a career gap and unfortunately I concur with what you’re saying. The baby rooms were a shock to me in some of the settings (one of which my own children had been to!!).

I can’t believe the negativity on this thread about wanting to stay at home with your child - really bizarre to me when OP has clearly thought it through and can afford it. There is so much evidence about the importance of one-to-one attachment being better in the first 18 months of a child’s life. (And as I said my kids did go to nursery before then but I still did the research and knew it wasn’t the ‘best’ option.)

RayneDance · 26/08/2022 08:13

"your own desires"!!

What about the actual baby!

I think mumsnetters need to go under cover and work in a few nurseries and get a real idea of what's going on and whether that's acceptable to you.
I have had nursery experience and I know how hit and miss good care can be even within one setting.
One half of the room may have excellent care but the others,don't because they have the totally disinterested bored lowly paid worker doing the job because there is nothing else they could do.
It's babies or older adults and they don't want to work with older adults.
It's probably the easiest part of the day when the parent's come and big smiles.."he's had a wonderful day today" the actual reality is baby y was screaming all day demanding all the attention of thinly stretched staff and your baby has been left alone except for the bare minimum done re nappies.

Yes there is some excellent work going on but by the very nature of humans it's always patchy.
One poor worker let's down the whole team. One bad manager or owner let's everyone down.
My own DC went at 3 to pre school Nursery and one has the most warm, caring older ladies who were amazing.
No 2 had a slight speech delay and her key worker was doing a degree in child care so initially I was v hopeful she was in excellent hand's.

Even with me passing on tips from salt, telling her key things about my child i see now she wasn't up to the task. She was absolutely useless, always chatting when I popped in ,never engaged with any children and a lack of basic understanding of children.
She also badly let down another child who needed interventions early.
This went on under my nose; with me observing . Yet I know the other key worker was brilliant.
When a child is a baby and non verbal they simply can't tell you what's going on.
They are vulnerable.

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/08/2022 08:12

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 22:04

Interesting that you choose to spend your days here, discussing such topics with such vehemence. I think people who don’t have children can have opinions on any and all topics. But choosing to engage negatively in this forum seems odd? Or am I just so very new to MN? Is this the norm here? What value does it have for you?

you know what they say, opinions are like arseholes. We all have them and some are shitty.

I am not remotely suggesting that it’s a societal responsibility to value family work (although, I actually believe it is and should be more respected - as someone who is both a mum and has a career and worked all of her life) but I meant more that it’s a tragedy that so many women who do stay at home and offer all this family care aren’t compensated in the same way her husband is when it comes to pensions etc. I am not suggesting I should get it paid to me as a benefit from the state (although…) I’m absolutely suggesting it be paid to me by my husband - who benefits the most from my home work and whose life is made exceptionally easier by my choice to stay home and raise our wonderful daughter.

@Autumnmoons

it’s true that I staying home only benefits you, your husband and your daughter (though she’d be fine if you did work)

it’s not a societal contribution let’s face it

LuckySantangelo35 · 26/08/2022 08:09

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 15:34

I will, no matter what, remain independent. Not all SAHPs are fawning useless saps when it comes to finances. I wouldn’t allow this to happen, simply because DH is the sole earner. It doesn’t work like that anymore (not for my marriage anyway)

@Autumnmoons

how will you remain independent though? U won’t be bringing in any money

op u r in a luckier position than most in the sense u have relatives offering to care for ur kid.

Crack on and get back to work!

RayneDance · 26/08/2022 08:00

Sceptre, good post, except the "just because you can't bare to be separated from your baby"

Is this what we have come too?

What about baby? No one ever mentions the actual baby and what's best for them?

Sceptre86 · 26/08/2022 07:53

There's a lot to think about. This baby is clearly your first. Are you wanting more, with short age gaps or bigger? More kids equals more expenses. Your inlaws might be happy to do childcare for one child but would they do it for more? Would they be up to it healthwise?

You're at the stage where baby is probably in a good routine and it's not a slog anymore and quite fun. It is a nice stage. They then enter toddlerhood and once again you will be presented with different challenges basically what in getting at is that it won't always be the same as it is now.

Your pension will take a hit, you'd need to sit down with your oh to discuss access to a joint account or him giving you a monthly income. How would you negotiate it, what would be fair?

The part that stands out to me is that your oh isn't on board and that to me means this should not go ahead. You don't get to railroad him into it because you can't bare to be separated from your baby.

I'd talk about it gain listen to his concerns but definitely voice your own desires too. Then see where to go from there, ask your employer for flexible working if they knock it back or won't consider it then start job seeking. It isn't fair to make him shoulder all the financial burden for your family when he doesn't want to.

Glittertwins · 26/08/2022 06:56

Namenic · 25/08/2022 23:31

@Autumnmoons - fantastic that you’ve costed it out! And good that your DH and you are on the same page - which is the important thing. Everyone has so many different variables - and I think sahp can be a great thing if precautions are taken and provisions made - which it sounds like you are doing. Just double check things like life insurance, travel insurance, private healthcare (some of these come as perks of jobs and can be extended to family). Wishing you all the best!

As long as the fabulous new job is still in place this time next year.
You don't need to make decisions now, you still have plenty of time.

Namenic · 25/08/2022 23:31

@Autumnmoons - fantastic that you’ve costed it out! And good that your DH and you are on the same page - which is the important thing. Everyone has so many different variables - and I think sahp can be a great thing if precautions are taken and provisions made - which it sounds like you are doing. Just double check things like life insurance, travel insurance, private healthcare (some of these come as perks of jobs and can be extended to family). Wishing you all the best!

girlmom21 · 25/08/2022 22:22

I’m absolutely suggesting it be paid to me by my husband - who benefits the most from my home work and whose life is made exceptionally easier by my choice to stay home and raise our wonderful daughter.

Is he going to benefit that much as you said you do everything at home anyway?

Be really wary of becoming the 24/7 default parent/housekeeper

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 22:17

I’m absolutely suggesting it be paid to me by my husband - who benefits the most from my home work and whose life is made exceptionally easier by my choice to stay home and raise our wonderful daughter.

Well, I guess that's something that you can negotiate with him then. If he agrees with you, I'm sure that he'll be happy to oblige.

AbreathofFrenchair · 25/08/2022 22:08

If you cant leave them at this age, will you be able to leave them at 2?

And will be able to spend money as you wish or will you need to ask for money to buy things and buy non essentials? I ask as I've known people who decide to be a sahp and then it's gone wrong as the working partner has begun to resent the other parent spending freely. Also arguments over division of household chores (some think the sahp is responsible for all cooking, cleaning and childcare etc while some think the sahp should only be doing 50% and the working parent also doing 50%) stuff like they needs to he talked about and made clear too to prevent later arguments

And the obvious conversations about savings, pensions, returning to work full or part time and what childcare to be used on return to work etc

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 22:04

rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 21:52

I’m not remotely angry, and I don’t have children so no view on SAHM vs WOHM. I do think that SAHMs have a tendency to over-confuse the value of their work to society as opposed to their individual family. Hence why I think waffling on about it being unfair SAHMs don’t get a work pension is, well, waffle. Get your husband to pay you one as he’s the one benefitting from your work, nobody else is. Then everyone’s happy.

Interesting that you choose to spend your days here, discussing such topics with such vehemence. I think people who don’t have children can have opinions on any and all topics. But choosing to engage negatively in this forum seems odd? Or am I just so very new to MN? Is this the norm here? What value does it have for you?

you know what they say, opinions are like arseholes. We all have them and some are shitty.

I am not remotely suggesting that it’s a societal responsibility to value family work (although, I actually believe it is and should be more respected - as someone who is both a mum and has a career and worked all of her life) but I meant more that it’s a tragedy that so many women who do stay at home and offer all this family care aren’t compensated in the same way her husband is when it comes to pensions etc. I am not suggesting I should get it paid to me as a benefit from the state (although…) I’m absolutely suggesting it be paid to me by my husband - who benefits the most from my home work and whose life is made exceptionally easier by my choice to stay home and raise our wonderful daughter.

OP posts:
YellowPlumbob · 25/08/2022 21:55

eatsleeprepeat123 · 25/08/2022 21:50

I made this choice last year.

My salary wasn't great although I loved my job. My hubby got a promotion which was basicallly equivalent of my salary.

I decided to be a SAHM and absolutely love it. I can't imagine my little one (now 20 months) being in nursery all the time, and I would be miserable being apart from him all day 5 days a week. Don't get me wrong - some days are HARD, but I wouldn't change a thing. He'll be off to pre school next year and I already can't imagine it!

If you have the option enjoy it. A lot of people don't have a choice and need two incomes. They're only little once, and you can always find a job when they start school? I don't see why it's so bad to rely on your husbands income (according to half of Mumsnetters).

Her DCs are school age…

rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 21:52

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:43

Less about MN, more about us having a real life interaction and discussion I suppose and mulling it all over as a family. Isn’t it nicer that it’s work out to a happy conclusion? I don’t understand your seeming anger. I understand I’ve posted on MN but Fizzy Dogs comments seem to be ringing loud and true here…

I suppose we view childcare and work in the home very differently, I see it as a broader subject about societies treatment of work in the home and the devalue of it and you see it as waffle. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.

I’m not remotely angry, and I don’t have children so no view on SAHM vs WOHM. I do think that SAHMs have a tendency to over-confuse the value of their work to society as opposed to their individual family. Hence why I think waffling on about it being unfair SAHMs don’t get a work pension is, well, waffle. Get your husband to pay you one as he’s the one benefitting from your work, nobody else is. Then everyone’s happy.

eatsleeprepeat123 · 25/08/2022 21:50

I made this choice last year.

My salary wasn't great although I loved my job. My hubby got a promotion which was basicallly equivalent of my salary.

I decided to be a SAHM and absolutely love it. I can't imagine my little one (now 20 months) being in nursery all the time, and I would be miserable being apart from him all day 5 days a week. Don't get me wrong - some days are HARD, but I wouldn't change a thing. He'll be off to pre school next year and I already can't imagine it!

If you have the option enjoy it. A lot of people don't have a choice and need two incomes. They're only little once, and you can always find a job when they start school? I don't see why it's so bad to rely on your husbands income (according to half of Mumsnetters).

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:50

Namenic · 25/08/2022 18:19

Get a spreadsheet and cost it out. Going back to work FT vs PT vs not going back (including the pay-back of enhanced mat pay). Calculate how much take home pay differs in each scenario. plus how much pension contributions are in these situations.

This would be the opportunity cost. It might be enough to wipe a few years off mortgage or a good starter for uni fund for child; or allow you to retire early. You have to decide as a couple whether it is worth it.

We did exactly this! It really helped and if anyone is reading this in a similar boat I highly recommend getting all there in black and white. We feel much better about it all now and have worked out what will be paid into my savings / pensions as well as DHs

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:48

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/08/2022 18:04

@fizzythedog

I take issue with your definition of the motivation of people posting about women choosing to stay at home.

Its a standard, inaccurate and rather insulting line that this is all driven by jealousy. In the vast majority of cases people who post on this topic post from real experience and sadly a lot of us know that the single biggest risk you can take as a woman is to rely on the lifelong financial support of a man. It’s just extremely risky.

But leaving this aside, the motivation for these posts isn’t relevant. What’s relevant are the facts. The facts are:

  • Close to half of all marriages fail
  • Even among those that don’t fail, a large proportion of women end up significantly financially disadvantaged and disenfranchised in their marriages.

It’s not automatically a bad idea to choose to be a SAHM. But to choose to do it when the one variable you absolutely have to have in place, ie a supportive spouse, increases the risk factor massively.

If it helps you rest at ease, in my case, I have enough saved money to fall back on if he does turn out to be a total arsehole.

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:46

sjxoxo · 25/08/2022 21:36

@Thepeopleversuswork what do you mean ‘lifelong’??? I don’t know anyone who is a SAHP for ‘life’ 😂 I think these days SAHP’s are typically at home for the first few years or until teenage years. I’ve never heard of anyone never ever ever working ever again. I don’t think that’s what is being debated here! I think op is talking about a few years off- not being off work for the rest of her life!

Exactly! It’ll likely be less than two years. My industry is bullet proof to an extent as is my experience within in (being a woman in this industry helps too, as there is a huge push for women to join but not many are!!)

We have decided as a family to take this time to enjoy and then I’ll happily rejoin the workforce at a later date. I like working, I love being a mum right now and that trumps it. Thankfully being SAH is an option for us x

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:43

rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 21:36

Well, if it was as simple as posting a MN thread to german your husband to change his mind then hurrah for that.

The second reply to me on pensions just seemed to be nebulous waffle about how it’s unfair that SAHPs don’t get a work pension. Which it isn’t. So.

Less about MN, more about us having a real life interaction and discussion I suppose and mulling it all over as a family. Isn’t it nicer that it’s work out to a happy conclusion? I don’t understand your seeming anger. I understand I’ve posted on MN but Fizzy Dogs comments seem to be ringing loud and true here…

I suppose we view childcare and work in the home very differently, I see it as a broader subject about societies treatment of work in the home and the devalue of it and you see it as waffle. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:37

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 19:45

Further more to this, I am not a foot thinking I should be paid a pension by some mysterious source. I’m simply commenting that SAHPs are penalised for this financially and women, who make up the majority of SAHPs, suffer most.

No OP. I'm not having it. The point is that people who don't work and pay into a pension, or have someone pay into a pension miss out. It is related to your decision to work and/or have a pension.

Ok?

OP posts:
rainbowmilk · 25/08/2022 21:37

German?! Get your husband, I mean.

Swipe left for the next trending thread