Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to stay home with our daughter

293 replies

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 07:39

My husband has landed a new job whilst I am on maternity leave (I am due to return to work in March 2023) and it has more than doubled his income (which was more than my full time wage) - is it unreasonable not return to work? We have survived off statutory mat pay so far and I think it’s manageable financially. My mother and father in law would be our childcare so no additional costs there. My husband is concerned with the cost of living crisis and bills and energy bills rising that it makes more sense for me to return to work so we can be more financially secure. I think we will be fine and I could simply get a new job if not. AIBU?

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 28/08/2022 08:19

My only advice is be open to your feelings changing- babies are lovely, toddlers are hellish. Part time working I found ideal (not that it was sustainable for us)- but you get that adult time, that break and still have time with your child in the week. Good luck with whatever u decide

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 28/08/2022 08:18

denvi · 27/08/2022 23:37

I've been a SAHM for 20 years. Absolutely brilliant! No regrets whatsoever. 'Kids" are now 19 (off to uni soon), 17, 15, 12. Very grateful to my husband and he's very grateful to me. We have lived the lives of our choosing and supported each other to do so. Of course I'm not bored. Who would I be? No I'm not financially vulnerable. either. My husband has made a lot of money over the years. It was worth supporting him. Yes he could have done it in his own, but not had a family as well. We didn't want to use childcare. No thanks - not for us. Everything is family money. We have invested for our future and the kids. That's it really. Nothing to see here and I couldn't give a hoot what anyone in here thinks, I very much doubt I'd swap lives with them, put it that way. I know loads of families such as ours and those marriages have lasted far more than the average. That my observation. As a pp said above - "Sorry not sorry." Live your own lives. Some women are SAHMs and they're doing great - get over it.

Why are you still a SAHM out of interest? Your youngest is old enough to walk home from school and look after themselves a bit.

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/08/2022 08:14

denvi · 27/08/2022 23:37

I've been a SAHM for 20 years. Absolutely brilliant! No regrets whatsoever. 'Kids" are now 19 (off to uni soon), 17, 15, 12. Very grateful to my husband and he's very grateful to me. We have lived the lives of our choosing and supported each other to do so. Of course I'm not bored. Who would I be? No I'm not financially vulnerable. either. My husband has made a lot of money over the years. It was worth supporting him. Yes he could have done it in his own, but not had a family as well. We didn't want to use childcare. No thanks - not for us. Everything is family money. We have invested for our future and the kids. That's it really. Nothing to see here and I couldn't give a hoot what anyone in here thinks, I very much doubt I'd swap lives with them, put it that way. I know loads of families such as ours and those marriages have lasted far more than the average. That my observation. As a pp said above - "Sorry not sorry." Live your own lives. Some women are SAHMs and they're doing great - get over it.

@denvi

what do you do all day?
when your teens are are at school?
u not get bored?
what stimulates your brain?

MissTrip82 · 28/08/2022 02:30

It’s not unreasonable to want to stay home longer but it’s not an option unless the person bankrolling it is on board.

I imagine that with such a big increase in salary there are more expectations in terms of responsibilities and working hours? A good discussion will be needed on how you will manage that around your shared parental responsibilities of hands on childcare and financial provision for your child.

It may be that you working part time works best for him also if he is honest about what hands on contribution he’ll be able to make.

ittakes2 · 28/08/2022 01:02

I have always been a stay at home mum (twins now almost 16). Having watched the other mothers at school eventually get jobs - one thing I would say to you is it’s not about the money I think. It sounds like you have a career / good job. Don’t assume you can take a few years off and pick up where you left off. You’ll be going up against candidates who didn’t have a break. Plus some mums I know who tried to get their careers back had to take on very full time roles to show they were valuable employees and then cross fingers they could ask to go part time. If you have an established employer you could ask to go part time now you will be in a stronger position.
also at 7 months you are in the honeymoon phase with a new baby and still have lots of hormones. If you had a career you might find you eventually need some mental stimulation and adult company.
I think it’s really important you consider part time to keep your options open. You could always quit part time if after a while you really think you want to be a SAHM but it’s harder to reverse that decision if you leave your job now

denvi · 27/08/2022 23:37

I've been a SAHM for 20 years. Absolutely brilliant! No regrets whatsoever. 'Kids" are now 19 (off to uni soon), 17, 15, 12. Very grateful to my husband and he's very grateful to me. We have lived the lives of our choosing and supported each other to do so. Of course I'm not bored. Who would I be? No I'm not financially vulnerable. either. My husband has made a lot of money over the years. It was worth supporting him. Yes he could have done it in his own, but not had a family as well. We didn't want to use childcare. No thanks - not for us. Everything is family money. We have invested for our future and the kids. That's it really. Nothing to see here and I couldn't give a hoot what anyone in here thinks, I very much doubt I'd swap lives with them, put it that way. I know loads of families such as ours and those marriages have lasted far more than the average. That my observation. As a pp said above - "Sorry not sorry." Live your own lives. Some women are SAHMs and they're doing great - get over it.

Autumndays123 · 27/08/2022 22:50

I couldn't think of anything more unattractive than a SAH partner. I find it bewildering that those on MN think posters who dislike the concept of SAHP must be 'jealous'. I could not think of anything worse. Mind numbingly boring and in all honesty, quite lazy. I would lose all respect for a partner with no career goals or ambition, it's not the 1920s anymore.

Foxglovers · 27/08/2022 21:50

So many ‘what ifs’ - what if your child starts school and you regret not being home…what if child is suddenly 16 and you think you’ve missed out in loads of of their childhood? You need to do what you want and what feels right to you in the moment, whatever that is! You will know in your gut

Babycakes6 · 27/08/2022 21:42

SausagePourHomme · 25/08/2022 07:42

I wouldn't make yourself completely dependent on a man, no. It's wiser to have some finances of your own as well as keeping your career going.

This!! If anything goes wrong with your marriage, you would be in so much trouble.
Also what if you husband loses his job/ gets injured or ill? You are also responsible for the child, including financial security of that child.

Foxglovers · 27/08/2022 21:35

i never planned on being a SAHM but I felt anxious about leaving my baby (now babies) too. My DH is a good earner and we share everything and there’s no “asking for money” or whatever.
I’m now a few years in and honestly I’ve never regretted it for a moment. You won’t get the time back with them.
mumsnet is so anti SAHM but to me they just sound money obsessed? I had a good “high earner” job before and I wouldn’t care if I couldn’t get that back if DH and I split up? I’m choosing to do it because I love being with my children - not because I’m hoping to be some kind of lady who lunches with someone else’s money.
mid you guys did split up or whatever in the future you’d never revere being with your child if that’s what you really wanted? People would only regret it if they did it for other reasons?

ThinWomansBrain · 27/08/2022 21:32

whatever the decision, it needs to be a joint one - you'd be better off discussing it with DH rather than here.

NotYouAgain · 27/08/2022 21:29

My husband encouraged me to give up work after our second child, which I compromised with and went down to a 10 hour contract.
He walked out when they were 2 & 4.
Please don't compromise your own financial future, I had to rapidly go from working 2 short days a week, to 50 hours just to make ends meet.

UrethraFranklin90 · 26/08/2022 15:12

Autumnmoons · 25/08/2022 21:30

Sending loads of love to you and hoping your transition back to work goes really well. I know loads of parents on 4 day weeks and they’ve said how much more they enjoy the time with LO as it’s totally focused on them xxx

Aww thank you! That's what I'm hoping :) plus it will only be 3 days per week every other week (study day as I'll be doing a postgraduate qualification whilst working) I'm going to study at night and see my little one during the day!

Glad you've come to an agreement! Sounds like you've got a great relationship x

homarr · 26/08/2022 12:20

As your husband is worrying about the financial side of things then I would drop down to part time.

ShandaLear · 26/08/2022 12:19

We are entering (have entered) a period of intense economic uncertainty and there is no guarantee that your husband will keep his job. Secondly, if you give up work the balance of power between you and your DH will change. When I was on extended mat leave it became expected that I would do everything-housework, life admin - renewing insurance, booking dental appointments, and all sorts of other boring things - cooking, etc. and you basically become the hired help. It was so tedious. Third, your DH is not supportive (this is really important), and finally you will lose out on pensions and promotions. In your shoes I would try to negotiate part time with your DH - 3 days a week, for example, for a few years. At least that way your skills and expertise will remain up to date.

rainbowmilk · 26/08/2022 12:19

Bunnycat101 · 26/08/2022 12:05

@rainbowmilk I’m not a sahm but I think you’re being a bit harsh to say there is no societal benefit. At our school, my child benefits from the sahps who come into read, help with trips, organise the PTA etc. There are lots of sahps with older children who volunteer, provide caring support etc.

There is obviously a balance but I don’t think it’s true to say there is no societal benefit.

Helping out on class trips and the PTA is not a societal benefit, nor is it exclusive to SAHMs as WOHMs also do these things. Volunteering is a societal benefit but it’s not exclusively provided by SAHMs and therefore is not a reason to place societal value on them over anyone else. You can say the same of part time workers who do PTA and volunteer work, but there isn’t a societal benefit to part time workers that would justify them getting a topped up works pension from the state.

I’m not being harsh, but as I said previously I find SAHMs tend to overestimate their benefit to wider society, rather than just saying it’s what suits their family, and therefore will come up with strange ideas like being financially compensated by the state.

loveacupoftea18 · 26/08/2022 12:09

Christ people can be awful.

OP, your scenario happened to me. I have relished the time with my babies, despite giving up a great job (sorry not sorry mumsnet). I get that it's not for everyone, but it is for me.

And I trust the man that I married so I feel comfortable in this position. Not everything is worst case scenario in life!

Bunnycat101 · 26/08/2022 12:05

@rainbowmilk I’m not a sahm but I think you’re being a bit harsh to say there is no societal benefit. At our school, my child benefits from the sahps who come into read, help with trips, organise the PTA etc. There are lots of sahps with older children who volunteer, provide caring support etc.

There is obviously a balance but I don’t think it’s true to say there is no societal benefit.

hettie · 26/08/2022 10:55

Hmme, well if you're an "anxious mum' then I might give different advice...... I've done sahm, PT and now ft. DH has always worked ft. Since things to think about. Being a bit anxious about your child is normal but let it get a grip and it won't be good for you or them. Whatever you decide you should think about how you'll get to a place where you will be comfortable to leave your child with someone suitable. Are you likely to have more children? Will you feel the need to offer them the same? This could mean 6-8 years out of work? Unless you're trained in annum demand profession you will find it very hard to get back into work that you are currently doing. There are many many threads of women struggling with this
It is much much easier to get part time work from in the work place. When I was part time lots of people told me I was lucky to get the hours I had. It wasn't luck it was strategic. I retrained in a family friendly proffesion that was/is in demand. I took bank/zeroe hrs work to get into the organisation. Then negotiated the hours I wanted from there. It's moving sideways/retraining/ part time an option.
Lastly don't underestimate the change in dynamics and impact on a relationship that going down very divided roles can bring. You're common ground diminishes and both roles have stressors that can be hard for the other to minimise. I have an excellent relationship and my sahm time was the most testing time for the two of us (we had financial constraints that apparently you don't, bit to be clear it really wasn't all about that).

rainbowmilk · 26/08/2022 10:31

^I am not remotely suggesting that it’s a societal responsibility to value family work (although, I actually believe it is and should be more respected - as someone who is both a mum and has a career and worked all of her life) but I meant more that it’s a tragedy that so many women who do stay at home and offer all this family care aren’t compensated in the same way her husband is when it comes to pensions etc. I am not suggesting I should get it paid to me as a benefit from the state (although…) I’m absolutely suggesting it be paid to me by my husband - who benefits the most from my home work and whose life is made exceptionally easier by my choice to stay home and raise our wonderful daughter.*

Your “although…” suggests that as I suspected you’ve confused ‘societal benefit of a SAHM’ (which doesn’t exist) with ‘family benefit of a SAHM’ (which does). I’m not saying that domestic work shouldn’t be respected as a choice, but it shouldn’t be respected as something which gives value to society because it doesn’t. Having a family has societal benefits but whether the mum is at home or at work makes no societal difference. I’d be very opposed to the state paying for a works pension for women to stay at home raising their kids when this offers no wider benefit and is a matter for them and their family. In such circumstances, husband should pay for it, not the taxpayer.

Bunnycat101 · 26/08/2022 10:00

Mumsnet tends to be very anti sahms. There is a balance to be had as arguably there are benefits to a parent at home. I’ve worked through but there have absolutely times I’ve wished I was at home. With my first I went back at 13ms after mat leave. With my second, it hit at the time of the pandemic so my little one was 18m before she went to nursery. It felt much nicer tbh although juggling the children and work was no fun at all. I would say though that even if I wasn’t working, I’d want some nursery time. It has been absolutely beneficial for both of my girls from about 2. Grandparent care can be brilliant but also can be a bit tense. Id think quite seriously about a pre-school/nursery as well as family care.

the other thing to consider is how hard it can be to negotiate part time with a new job. 4 days a week is pretty doable but 2/3 days is very difficult unless you’re doing something shift based. I’ve done 3 and 4 days and 4 has been much better job wise. 3 was more stressful.

Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:21

AnnaFri · 26/08/2022 09:15

@Autumnmoons

Why would you have to rely on him for money at all if you have years worth of salary saved

You're bullshitting at this point - give up

I think I will give up on this thread, you’re right. I was an anxious mum looking for a bit of advice and support perhaps? I didn’t realise the vibe of some MNs posters, who just want to shame and witch hunt. I was hoping for some opposite opinions and view points but at this point, I’ve got what I need from some of the lovely posters (both who agree and who don’t but remain kind and respectful) so thank you all. 😘

DH and I both have savings thankfully and perhaps dipping in to them now is worth it to our family at this time, we are very lucky. Ideally we won’t need to and can sail by an extra year on DHs income. It’s there as a back up should we need. We are very fortunate.

OP posts:
AnnaFri · 26/08/2022 09:15

@Autumnmoons

Why would you have to rely on him for money at all if you have years worth of salary saved

You're bullshitting at this point - give up

Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:14

Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:12

This would be as a worst case, say if DH lost his job or was to run off with another woman (as suggested by previous posts!)

I didn’t realise I had to lay absolutely everything out to cover all risks and scenarios and explain why I felt I had the audacity to stay home with my baby a little while longer. I’ll remember this for next time though 🫥

Again I’ve inadvertently not replied to the comment - my savings response was how will I stay independent and my savings would cover me and my baby and DH if needed if it went to pot. DH also has similar savings - we keep them as last resorts obviously. Him running off with his secretary is last resort worth perhaps

OP posts:
Autumnmoons · 26/08/2022 09:12

AnnaFri · 26/08/2022 09:08

I'm calling bullshit on this as your earlier posts mentioned relying on your DH for money

So if you have savings to pay yourself a salary why even mention that?

This would be as a worst case, say if DH lost his job or was to run off with another woman (as suggested by previous posts!)

I didn’t realise I had to lay absolutely everything out to cover all risks and scenarios and explain why I felt I had the audacity to stay home with my baby a little while longer. I’ll remember this for next time though 🫥

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread