Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think inflation is used to Scare us?

32 replies

Tinkerblonde1 · 24/08/2022 23:38

Wondering other people's opinions, really.

Also how many of us just don't understand. I am no economics expert. I am not stupid. I have a Physics degree so not totally stupid, anyway, but I have tried to read about economics. It is really difficult.

I have read a lot about modern monetary theory. Ok it's a theory, which economics is! It's a man made concept. So all theory but I do feel the government oversell the fact the economy is like a household budget so we think there is no money.

They don't want to increase the minimum wage. They are worried about inflation. They don't want to increase wages for rail staff, barristers. Inflation!

We are a rich country with a solid infrastructure and a fairly well educated population. We are not Zimbawe.
AIBU to think inflation is a big excuse to keep us in our places? It doesn't need to be this way?

Does it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tinkerblonde1 · 25/08/2022 18:59

Thank you to those who have given sensible interesting replies.

OP posts:
Tinkerblonde1 · 25/08/2022 18:55

OldKingCole · 25/08/2022 18:17

Are you absolutely sure you have a physics degree OP?

this!!

Why are people questioning my intelligence without looking into it themselves? Really weird. I have found MMT to be really interesting.
Plus whether you agree or not you can't argue we currently have a particular choice of austerity. There are better ways than what we are currently facing.

Glad everyone is an economics expert though.

OP posts:
MintJulia · 25/08/2022 18:52

The trouble is once inflation gets going, it's very hard to stop,

I earn £100 but prices are going up by 10% a year, so I want £110 to maintain my standard of living. I get a payrise, which puts up my company's product prices by 10%.

All the companies who buy from my company, need to earn 10% more in order to be able to afford supplies from my company, so they put their prices up by 10%. And all of their staff also need a 10% pay rise in order to maintain their standard of living, and so it goes on, snowballing year on year.

It happens when countries print money, like during Covid, to pay for all the things we needed. The countries are perceived as less wealthy because they have racked up so much debt, so they are a bigger risk, so are charged more interest.
Tax take needs to go up to pay the extra interest.

The only ways out are either for everyone to have less (shareholders, employees, taxman) until the country's debt is paid down (not popular or comfortable) or to increase national production by 10% more than costs (not easy).

It is a long and miserable process, involving bitter wrangling between govt, employers and employees.

MarshaBradyo · 25/08/2022 18:40

Runaway spiralling inflation is something to be concerned about

caringcarer · 25/08/2022 18:34

@notlabled, has got it spot on. A couple of years of bad policy can be reversed quite quickly. Expecting tax payers to pay tax credits instead of businesses paying a decent wage was a bad policy. It is now ingrained. Large companies like Amazon pay low wages then expect government to top up workers wages, then they pay little tax so double whammy. We should have invested in nuclear power 20 - 25 years ago. Successive governments have ignored the problem and now it is critical. The global power crisis is causing inflation to spike. We need to build reactors and try to economise on using so much energy by better insulation. The government was way too generous during furlough giving 80 percent salary. Many other countries offered 65 or 70 percent. Also Sunak gave self employed too much money that we later find they were not entitled too, by not running proper checks on where funds were going. Now sky high pay rises will make inflation worse.

OldKingCole · 25/08/2022 18:17

Are you absolutely sure you have a physics degree OP?

this!!

Tinkerblonde1 · 25/08/2022 18:15

ThisWomamsWork · 25/08/2022 02:44

Are you absolutely sure you have a physics degree OP?

But of course. How rude!

Ok it was 20 odd years ago. Give me special relativity, Shrodinger or Smith charts any day.
Economics a minefield! I have read a lot recently and still it's worse than quantum mechanics.

OP posts:
mateysmum · 25/08/2022 12:03

You clearly didn't live through the 70s OP like some of us did.

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 25/08/2022 12:00

gatehouseoffleet · 25/08/2022 10:45

The point is they don't have to pass it all onto the consumer, their shareholders can make a few billion less. And yes, I know that affects pension funds to some degree.

And the millions of small and medium businesses that have no shareholders?

gatehouseoffleet · 25/08/2022 10:48

RayneDance · 25/08/2022 09:58

I don't know how many people are on minimum wage though? Would it trigger more problems if those at the bottom has a pay rise?

Loads of people are, or very close to it. For example, nursery workers, lifeguards/leisure assistants, library assistants. Retail workers are usually paid a bit more, eg £10-11 an hour.

I am assuming hospitality staff are paid the minimum and expected to make it up with tips (which the owners/managers then cream off anyway).

1dayatatime · 25/08/2022 10:46

ThisWomamsWork · 25/08/2022 02:44

Are you absolutely sure you have a physics degree OP?

😂

gatehouseoffleet · 25/08/2022 10:45

AgentJohnson · 25/08/2022 03:15

Wait wat? If you are a business and the cost of employing someone goes up, who do you think the business is ultimately going to pass that cost onto? I understand why people demand higher wages but ultimately it only fuels the problem.

The point is they don't have to pass it all onto the consumer, their shareholders can make a few billion less. And yes, I know that affects pension funds to some degree.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/08/2022 10:43

Increasing wages, in line with inflation, doesn't result in further inflation. This is all people are asking for.

Of course it does. It perpetuates the cycle. How the heck can it not?
Maybe things would be better now if wages had risen more in the past (not just the public sector by the way) and we'd be in a more robust situation and able to deal with a one off bump. Maybe they'd be better if there hadn't been massive house price inflation. Maybe....all sorts of things. But we are where we are.

StillGoingStrongToday · 25/08/2022 10:37

RayneDance · 25/08/2022 09:58

I don't know how many people are on minimum wage though? Would it trigger more problems if those at the bottom has a pay rise?

Yes, in general, because those on the lowest wages have the greatest marginal propensity to consume.

An extra pound to a low-income family gets spent, an extra pound to a very high-income family probably gets invested.

StillGoingStrongToday · 25/08/2022 10:35

Lunar270 · 25/08/2022 08:32

I believe inflation is used as an excuse OP but as Mick Lynch says, it's total nonsense.

Inflation is going out of control but wages have been flat for the last 10 years or so. Therefore there's clearly no correlation with the current crisis.

However, under more normal circumstances it is probably true

That doesn’t follow at all.

Inflation is driven by a range of factors, and increasing wages is one of them.

Notlabeled · 25/08/2022 10:01

sst1234 · 25/08/2022 00:48

Inflation is real and a very bad thing, unless you withdraw from using fiat money and start your own currency. Being rich and well educated has nothing to do with it. The Weimar Republic wasn’t poorly educated when it crumbled under the pressures of inflation and look where that got us.

For the monetary system to work and for society to function, we have to believe there is a finite supply of money. However, that is not an absolute fact. This notion is manipulated all the time by those who control money supply. Who have been printing tons of it since 2008 and then printed more of pay for the lockdowns than the previous 12 years. At the same time supply was suppressed. Locking up healthy people and paying them to do nothing did not work out well in the end.

This particular cycle of Inflation isn’t somehow suppressing wages. That happened a long time ago. The welfare culture and subsidizing of low wages saw to that. Raising wages now would be futile because prices would just follow by the same level, and then some. To get out of this mess, you have to increase supply of home grown essentials - namely energy and food. While exporting more to correct the trade deficit. It takes 25 years of bad policy to get where we are today. Of course, it’s a global problem, but the low wage culture, lack of home grown energy and a dormant economy don’t happen overnight. So they take decades to correct.

There is no point questioning the reality of inflation now, it is real. The time to question to ask questions was when generation defining bad choices were made, like introduction of tax credits instead of making employers pay market rate wages, scaling back energy storage and not building nuclear power facilities earlier, printing £450bn during Covid to pay for lockdowns when healthy people were locked up.

This. 1000% this. One of few sane posts amongst all these energy/inflation/wages doom threads.

maeveiscurious · 25/08/2022 09:59
Biscuit
RayneDance · 25/08/2022 09:58

I don't know how many people are on minimum wage though? Would it trigger more problems if those at the bottom has a pay rise?

Lunar270 · 25/08/2022 09:56

ErrolTheDragon · 25/08/2022 08:44

Inflation is going out of control but wages have been flat for the last 10 years or so. Therefore there's clearly no correlation with the current crisis.

The immediate cause of inflation at the moment is largely external factors such as fuel price but if it is followed by wage rises then that will inevitably cause an upward spiral of continuing inflation rather than one bump.

There is no easy answer, but it's not a scare tactic.

So are you suggesting if public sector staff had received inflationary wage increases, over the last 10 years, it would have resulted in a perpetual cycle of inflation? I don't think so.

Increasing wages, in line with inflation, doesn't result in further inflation. This is all people are asking for.

Although I appreciate that suddenly giving people backdated increases to make up for past years is a different thing altogether.

Yet despite what the government are saying, my police friend has just received a 10% rise. So they're clearly saying one thing and doing the complete opposite.

titchy · 25/08/2022 09:02

AIBU to think inflation is a big excuse to keep us in our places? It doesn't need to be this way

Absolutely! Everyone knows that the Gov decides the price of a tin of beans and not the supermarkets!

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 25/08/2022 08:54

Most people on here seem to think I'm tin hat crazy but I agree that the narrative of newspapers is that of fear.

'The people don't want war, but they can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. This is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked' The Nazis realised it, religion realised it, control of the masses is easier through fear

We are led to fear something all the time and manipulated until we do so.

Global warming, now climate change as it wasn't warming enough
terrorism, which has taken the back burner since pandemic which is now over so inflation and energy .
Energy is an interesting one, it is never the price per until that is quoted which is indeed going up but the maximum possible amount for the biggest family/house so that people in one bed insulated flats seriously believe their bills will be 6k come April.

Weefreetiffany · 25/08/2022 08:46

It seems like all the news does these days is fear monger and manipulate to their own interests so I wouldn’t be surprised if reporting on inflation is being used to scare. But actual inflation and the mechanisms of it is really happening. They have the power to make it easy or hard for the population. They’re choosing hard to keep a few super rich people rich. The fear mongering papers encourage people to feel disempowered and depressed instead of able to contest this. Stop doom scrolling and write to your mp?

ErrolTheDragon · 25/08/2022 08:44

Inflation is going out of control but wages have been flat for the last 10 years or so. Therefore there's clearly no correlation with the current crisis.

The immediate cause of inflation at the moment is largely external factors such as fuel price but if it is followed by wage rises then that will inevitably cause an upward spiral of continuing inflation rather than one bump.

There is no easy answer, but it's not a scare tactic.

Lunar270 · 25/08/2022 08:32

I believe inflation is used as an excuse OP but as Mick Lynch says, it's total nonsense.

Inflation is going out of control but wages have been flat for the last 10 years or so. Therefore there's clearly no correlation with the current crisis.

However, under more normal circumstances it is probably true

sst1234 · 25/08/2022 08:16

Nat6999 · 25/08/2022 02:38

Raising wages will not increase inflation, unless wages go up there will be less money to spend which will mean less money to spend after all bills are paid & could mean loss of jobs in the areas people spend disposable income. Companies can afford to increase wages but they choose profits instead & pay themselves massive salaries & dividends. They should be investing in their workforce through training, equipment & paying them a good wage. Inflation is caused by the increasing energy costs, the price of oil, raw materials, food production, the rise in house prices, transport & public transport. The retail price index uses the prices of a selection of goods to gauge how much prices have increased.

Wow such little grasp of basics

Swipe left for the next trending thread