Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Demand for minimum wage hike is too high?

85 replies

worriedniece · 24/08/2022 19:26

I just read this article which demands minimum wage be put up to £15 an hour. www.opendemocracy.net/en/labour-silent-minimum-wage-15-pounds-keir-starmer/

I am a little flabbergasted. I worked out that working 52weeks a year on £15 an hour would equate to a salary of 31k Now given that newly qualified teachers earn £25k a year, a junior doctor is on £29k it seems comparably high. It sort of makes me wonder what's the incentive to go and train for a job/go to uni when you can earn nearly as much working in Tesco. I might be being naive, b it surely a minimum is just that- it's a bare minimum and employers should incentivise the best workers by offering more?

OP posts:
RedRiverShore2 · 25/08/2022 07:57

It needs to be enough so the likes of Tesco, Amazon and other like companies are not being subsidised by government handouts, the problem with this is the many small companies are not going to be able to afford paying a higher minimum wage and it affects everyone as the teacher upthread states

sweetkitty · 25/08/2022 07:43

@Theimpossiblegirl can I ask why you would consider leaving teaching if this goes through? I’m a teacher and I would fight for a minimum wage hike to £15 an hour. Like I said I work with people getting £9 an hour and it’s horrible listening to them. Yes I’ve been to uni got 2 degrees pay a student loan, do a bit more planning and paperwork my annual salary is 42K which equates to just over £24 an hour. Yes I’m worth that but they are worth a lot more too. It’s not a race to the bottom. They deserve to be able not to be terrified of this price cap that’s coming of feeding their families.

I am no better than the janitor who picks up the litter or the bus driver who brings the kids to school they are all essential workers who deserve a living wage.

Facecream · 25/08/2022 00:47

Try living off carer’s allowance solely and DLA for child’s care- you’d fight for minimum wage to be higher regardless of how many small/medium or massive businesses fail.
I’m saying so because this country, bein if Tory mind, cannot fathom that business success isn’t everything

Theimpossiblegirl · 25/08/2022 00:42

If this goes through I'm leaving teaching. I'm only hanging on in there because I can't afford to leave. I went be the only one for sure.

eeeeeeeeee · 25/08/2022 00:19

I earn just over minimums, and I work in retail. It's really sad to see the idea perpetuated that "anyone can work at Tesco" and that it's a go-to for people without skills, or people who want an easy job. To be frank that's just perpetuating the way people look down on us as less-than. And you certainly can't just apply for full time work in a supermarket, those roles don't exist. 8h per week is the norm (and you, OP, would probably be unsuccessful, lack of 24/7 flexibility just for a start).

I got rewarded up from 8h to 30h, thanks to absolutely working my tail off and winning awards. That's my reward - no such thing as pay rises. And 40h will never happen. Is there any special reason that you don't think I deserve more than £15k to live on? Did I do something to hurt you? We all need retail workers. We're kind of important.

I don't think you really meant to say minimum wage roles aren't important. But I do think it's a common perception. I do think maybe it's a consequence of the ridiculous "university is king" idea that we all got raised with. Plumbers out-earn both of us, and when we need them they are incredibly important people!🙂

Can I suggest that instead of us all tearing down people who work incredibly hard for a pittance (also, cleaners, bin collectors, care workers) and suggesting that we don't deserve £15 per hour because someone more important doesn't get much more, maybe we could just focus on the whole point. That minimum wage isn't enough to really survive on, especially since they're rarely even full time jobs. Jobs that, just like the dentist and the nurse and the teacher, are actually needed. And that current laws allow employers to laugh all the way to the bank. As do the politicians who love to see the poor blame each other rather than holding ministers accountable.

DdraigGoch · 24/08/2022 23:27

Tangled123 · 24/08/2022 21:10

In my opinion, minimum wage should be what you get when you leave school with no qualifications and are looking to build up experience. Once you get that, you should automatically get more money either by getting promotions, qualifications or just annual pay rises from your employer. I think it’s very unethical to pay minimum wage to adults who have been working for years and have families to support.

Yep, minimum wage should just be for teenagers who are getting their first taste of the workplace while they still have support from their parents. Anyone old enough to live independently deserves a living wage.

DdraigGoch · 24/08/2022 23:24

alwpj · 24/08/2022 19:58

It will fuel inflation, if minimum wage increases so much how do companies pay for it? By putting up prices even further!

Why is it always worker wages which apparently must never be raised lest it will "fuel inflation", whereas in just one year, the average salary of a FTSE 100 CEO has jumped by 39% from an already eyewatering £2.5m without a peep from the government or the Bank of England? Why doesn't that fuel inflation too?

Let's face it, no one needs a seven figure salary (what on earth would you even spend that sort of money on?), so perhaps they could reduce their remuneration to a more sensible level in order to provide funds for their employees to have a living wage.

sweetkitty · 24/08/2022 23:01

Employers have gotten away with paying ridiculous wages for too long topped up by tax credits from the government. It’s ridiculous that someone working full time has to claim benefits because their wages are deemed not enough to live on. How can that be sustainable for a country?

The assistants at my work are on just over £9 an hour it’s a hard physical job, most are women with children and it suits them as it’s term time only. They make just over £900 a month most either have a second job or UC. They are going on strike soon as they haven’t had a wage rise in 4 years. They were offered 3% when inflation is over 10%.

worriedniece · 24/08/2022 22:53

Rosebel · 24/08/2022 21:28

Most people can't live on the minimum wage. I earn slightly above the minimum wage as does my husband.
I trained for 2 years to do my job but am now having to look for a second job despite doing 40 hours a week, sometimes a bit more. We just can't afford to live otherwise.
Doesn't help our childcare bill for one child is nearly £1000 a month. Is it fair that I'll barely see my children because I'll be working so many hours a week? Or do I deserve it because I wasn't clever enough to go to university?

I went to University, also have to pay a bill of £1000k + for nursery, work approx 50hrs a week.

OP posts:
worriedniece · 24/08/2022 22:48

luxxlisbon · 24/08/2022 19:33

What is your salary OP?

£36k

OP posts:
Rosebel · 24/08/2022 21:28

Most people can't live on the minimum wage. I earn slightly above the minimum wage as does my husband.
I trained for 2 years to do my job but am now having to look for a second job despite doing 40 hours a week, sometimes a bit more. We just can't afford to live otherwise.
Doesn't help our childcare bill for one child is nearly £1000 a month. Is it fair that I'll barely see my children because I'll be working so many hours a week? Or do I deserve it because I wasn't clever enough to go to university?

empireemmy · 24/08/2022 21:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the poster.

Tangled123 · 24/08/2022 21:10

In my opinion, minimum wage should be what you get when you leave school with no qualifications and are looking to build up experience. Once you get that, you should automatically get more money either by getting promotions, qualifications or just annual pay rises from your employer. I think it’s very unethical to pay minimum wage to adults who have been working for years and have families to support.

FitAt50 · 24/08/2022 20:56

rainbowunicorn · 24/08/2022 20:26

Where are you getting 48 weeks from?

I believe they are forgetting that we get PAID holiday.

HelloThereObiWan · 24/08/2022 20:29

It's funny, I'm old enough to remember when minimum wage was introduced and the same old arguements were had then about inflation and yada yada yada.

God forbid we actually give poor people enough money to live on. They'll be wanting actual affordable houses to live in soon and everything!

70billionthnamechange · 24/08/2022 20:28

My business would go under. It's not that it isn't a viable business as PP said, but with the horrific energy costs and stock costs now, if I had to increase by 5 an hour for every member of staff, I would be fucked. No answers here, just saying. And obviously I wish I could pay more but £10 per hour is the going rate where I am for hospitality and that's what all my budgeting was based on so it's not about not being a viable business if you can't afford a massive increase over night, if you can't pay the going rate, that's different.

QuestionableMouse · 24/08/2022 20:27

Then maybe teachers and doctors and such should be paid more. £15/h is barely a living wage at the moment!

rainbowunicorn · 24/08/2022 20:26

Mangogogogo · 24/08/2022 19:29

It would be 48 weeks a year wouldn’t it? But I still get your point. Everyone needs to be paid more! My friends who live in countries where the cost of living is brutal, get paid a wage that would make your eyes water over here.

Where are you getting 48 weeks from?

LuaDipa · 24/08/2022 20:22

I think minimum wage should increase. People are already having to use food banks and costs are only increased. They need to earn a wage they can live on.

I don’t really buy the people leaving highly qualified jobs or not bothering to train because they can earn as much at Tesco. I’ve done retail and hospitality jobs when I was a student. These types of roles might not require any qualifications but that doesn’t mean they are easy. I wouldn’t go back to working those long unsociable hours and being on my feet all day/night for twice what I earn now.

womaninatightspot · 24/08/2022 20:17

I’d agree with a Pp wages are artificially low as UC allows people to work and claim for children/ childcare/housing. Wages should be high enough to pay for your living costs. Look at the refuse worker strike in Edinburgh, average rent on a one bed flat in Edinburgh is now over 800. Add on council tax plus bills plus food plus transport costs and the sums don’t add up on a basic wage of £20,500 which is 40 hours at current real living wage of £9.90ph.

These are physically challenging, often grotty, jobs that often leave workers with back problems over the longer term. Surely people who work full time should be able to support themselves without top up benefits?

Strulch · 24/08/2022 20:15

Flutterbybudget · 24/08/2022 19:43

A salary of £31,200 (before tax) that’s £25,000 take home, and service bills in excess of £6,000, not counting housing costs, water, council tax, childcare costs, etc, etc

Currently, many are earning low wages, topped up by the taxpayer, through Universal credit and housing benefits. The question is, who should pay the “real” wage of a worker? The taxpayer, or the employer? My argument is that if your business doesn’t bring in enough for you to pay a wage sufficient for your employees to survive on, then you don’t have a viable business. Why should YOU (not aimed at any individual, general question) be taking home huge sums of money, while the tax payer subsides your wages bill/ running costs?

I absolutely agree with everything you have said here. Any business that is unable to pay a decent living wage to it's staff isn't viable and shouldn't exist. Why should the government top up their staff's wages.

MsPincher · 24/08/2022 20:11

I agree that’s far too much as a minimum. It will never happen anyway but if it did it would cause huge inflation

HEPolicy · 24/08/2022 20:01

Mangogogogo · 24/08/2022 19:29

It would be 48 weeks a year wouldn’t it? But I still get your point. Everyone needs to be paid more! My friends who live in countries where the cost of living is brutal, get paid a wage that would make your eyes water over here.

Why would it be 48 weeks?

pointythings · 24/08/2022 20:01

I'd like to see the gap between the highest and lowest paid narrow very substantially so I'm on board with this. The wage rise/inflation rise spiral isn't an inevitability if we stop prioritising endless economic growth and move away from our raw capitalist model towards something more equitable for everyone.

alwpj · 24/08/2022 19:58

It will fuel inflation, if minimum wage increases so much how do companies pay for it? By putting up prices even further!