Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Demand for minimum wage hike is too high?

85 replies

worriedniece · 24/08/2022 19:26

I just read this article which demands minimum wage be put up to £15 an hour. www.opendemocracy.net/en/labour-silent-minimum-wage-15-pounds-keir-starmer/

I am a little flabbergasted. I worked out that working 52weeks a year on £15 an hour would equate to a salary of 31k Now given that newly qualified teachers earn £25k a year, a junior doctor is on £29k it seems comparably high. It sort of makes me wonder what's the incentive to go and train for a job/go to uni when you can earn nearly as much working in Tesco. I might be being naive, b it surely a minimum is just that- it's a bare minimum and employers should incentivise the best workers by offering more?

OP posts:
Cheeriyo · 25/08/2022 09:05

Or do we really want to become a state where everyone earns the same wage, irrespective of what we all do? It is an option?

It is if you aren't arsed about having no healthcare service or probably education sector. Surely the better answer is for the government to get a handle on access to affordable housing, investing public money more efficiently, reinstating services that have been cut to not only provide more jobs but to give people a better chance at life, figuring out how to ensure the upcoming energy price apocalypse isn't repeated, and to continue to improve access to education/re training for those who want it.

midgetastic · 25/08/2022 09:00

We would probably need a hard look at what is enough for the basics as it's pretty clear that 2 people with the same income after housing can have widely different ideas as to what is sufficient for basics - one persons barely surviving is another's luxury

Chocolateteabag · 25/08/2022 08:59

Pigsinmuck · 25/08/2022 08:37

Small business owners must be terrified. I know our village preschool just couldn’t afford to pay its staff £15 an hour. It would close in months. They can barely afford the latest wage rise as it is with the rise in cost of electricity too.

Yes many many small, medium and likely large businesses will struggle/close if they have to put wage rates up. Not all businesses have fat cat rich owners.

Which will mean unemployment rates go up as businesses fail or cut staff.
It's going to be a rocky few years ahead - hopefully things can stabilise at a fairer level.

A business should rely on paying low wages for success, but equally, you need something to encourage the entrepreneurs to take the risks in starting or building businesses or the country will just stagnate/decline.

Or do we really want to become a state where everyone earns the same wage, irrespective of what we all do? It is an option?

Rosebel · 25/08/2022 08:55

worriedniece · 24/08/2022 22:53

I went to University, also have to pay a bill of £1000k + for nursery, work approx 50hrs a week.

The point I was making is that in order to afford our nursery bill along with everything else I have to take a second job. I've been qualified in my field for 10 years but still don't earn enough.
I shouldn't have to work 2 jobs, especially as one is full time just so we have enough to get by.

midgetastic · 25/08/2022 08:55

I think we do need to have an economy where no one working full time is supported by the state / unviable business is supported by the state

Just raising NMW probably won't fix this
Wealth redistribution, a more equal society is also needed - valuing the bin man or support worker as well as the accountant

There probably does need to be some reward for hard difficult or dangerous work

A shake up of the economy is needed - people not wealth first

Redqueenheart · 25/08/2022 08:51

Here we go...another ''what about'' thread begrudging the fact that people might actually want a living wage and be able to pay their bills...

We should really stop the Daily Mail propaganda or insist that everything should be a race to the bottom where poor people are expected to know their place and be content with scraps.

That's what got us into the current Tory nightmare.

Nice bit of snobbery as well: I am sure you were grateful when the little people at Tesco made sure you got food and deliveries during lockdowns but now we don't want them to get ideas above their station, do we?

I find it bewildering that people can come up with this type of posts.

Marinamountainzoo · 25/08/2022 08:51

Flutterbybudget · 24/08/2022 19:43

A salary of £31,200 (before tax) that’s £25,000 take home, and service bills in excess of £6,000, not counting housing costs, water, council tax, childcare costs, etc, etc

Currently, many are earning low wages, topped up by the taxpayer, through Universal credit and housing benefits. The question is, who should pay the “real” wage of a worker? The taxpayer, or the employer? My argument is that if your business doesn’t bring in enough for you to pay a wage sufficient for your employees to survive on, then you don’t have a viable business. Why should YOU (not aimed at any individual, general question) be taking home huge sums of money, while the tax payer subsides your wages bill/ running costs?

Exactly!

If employers actually paid decent wages, then we could reduce spending on government top ups and also actually increase tax revenues.

Alexandra2001 · 25/08/2022 08:49

DashboardConfessional · 25/08/2022 08:31

I don't disagree that minimum wage is too low, but here is my real-life example.

I used to be a footwear buyer. We had factories in Portugal. In 2017-2019, the Portuguese government raised the minimum wage, applying to pickers and packers. This meant the wages of the machinists and cobblers had to go up. They were already paying more for their leather because this came from a Poruguese supplier whose wages had increased. So, their cost prices (to us) went up. We could no longer afford their cost prices because Brexit weakened the pound, so we dropped them as a supplier.

It would require an enormous overhaul of the wage structure, rather than just chucking in an extra few pounds an hour at the bottom end.

Well, you may have missed a trick because my partner buys Panama Jack shoes, they have gone up £10 but are great shoes, made in Portugal & hard to get hold off, plenty of people seem to think so too.

Their MW is just 822 euros per month, so quite happy to pay a little extra.

BTW Clarks stopped making shoes in the UK long before the NMW was a significant cost.

crowdedout · 25/08/2022 08:48

Well said @eeeeeeeeee. I'm a tory voting lawyer as it happens (maybe not next time though as I'm flabbergasted at how inept our current government is) but i hate this idea that certain people are more important by virtue of the work they do. You are not a better person because you are a doctor rather than a bin man. All of our lives are precious and we are all hugely important in the running of society.

gatehouseoffleet · 25/08/2022 08:38

the country would be a worse place if the only viable businesses were big business. Many of these provide decent services or add value beyond monetary to places, but they don't bring in tonnes of cash

Indeed. But before covid, I never met anyone running their own business who was hard up. Maybe they were all subsidised by high earning partners.

Covid has changed things I know, but even small businesses need to pay staff fairly.

Pigsinmuck · 25/08/2022 08:37

Small business owners must be terrified. I know our village preschool just couldn’t afford to pay its staff £15 an hour. It would close in months. They can barely afford the latest wage rise as it is with the rise in cost of electricity too.

gatehouseoffleet · 25/08/2022 08:36

we could no longer afford their cost prices because Brexit weakened the pound, so we dropped them as a supplier

I suspect that had much more to do with Brexit than the fact the Portuguese government made provision for staff to be paid fairly.

gatehouseoffleet · 25/08/2022 08:35

My argument is that if your business doesn’t bring in enough for you to pay a wage sufficient for your employees to survive on, then you don’t have a viable business. Why should YOU (not aimed at any individual, general question) be taking home huge sums of money, while the tax payer subsides your wages bill/ running costs

Exactly this. If employers pay their employees fairly, take a smaller cut themselves and the taxpayer saves money on tax credits etc, that money can go into public services instead.

DashboardConfessional · 25/08/2022 08:31

I don't disagree that minimum wage is too low, but here is my real-life example.

I used to be a footwear buyer. We had factories in Portugal. In 2017-2019, the Portuguese government raised the minimum wage, applying to pickers and packers. This meant the wages of the machinists and cobblers had to go up. They were already paying more for their leather because this came from a Poruguese supplier whose wages had increased. So, their cost prices (to us) went up. We could no longer afford their cost prices because Brexit weakened the pound, so we dropped them as a supplier.

It would require an enormous overhaul of the wage structure, rather than just chucking in an extra few pounds an hour at the bottom end.

RewildingAmbridge · 25/08/2022 08:28

The thing is wages above would need to increase and in the public sector they haven't, I work in the CJ system and we're having a nightmare recruiting, admin get paid more to work in retail with less pressure and responsibility, colleagues I work with in other agencies eg probation service practitioners get paid £23k a year to be responsible for domestic abuse perpetrators, non contact sex offenders, parole reports, decisions around recall and release, police officers in my area start on £18k.
So yes minimum wage needs to increase but most of us who work in the public sector are not highly paid fat cats, and there is already a recruitment crisis.

Cheeriyo · 25/08/2022 08:27

I am no better than the janitor who picks up the litter or the bus driver who brings the kids to school they are all essential workers who deserve a living wage.

That's correct you aren't any better than them, but what you earn isn't an indicator or self worth. I am not any better than anyone else, but after accumulating 5 years of student debt, having a high level of responsibility and applying knowledge and skill that someone at entry level wouldn't have I'm not ashamed to say I deserve higher pay than someone in an entry level job.

Alexandra2001 · 25/08/2022 08:27

Within 5 years the NMW will be fast approaching £15 ph, it went up 41p ph this year/6.6% to £9.50.
The unofficial london living wage is currently £11.05 ph, almost £10ph elsewhere.

The LPC has to reflect inflation, cost of living and wage rises across the economy, so will continue to recommend significant increases.

The problem with the MW is that it has eroded wage differentials, or rather employers inc the Govt seem set on paying us all the NMW... quite a socialist concept lol.

HouseofHolbein · 25/08/2022 08:24

@eeeeeeeeee I work in a different supermarket. I had a 10 hour contract but regularly expected to work up to 30 hours. Unless the store needed to save money and then I got 10 hours.

So I pushed for a team leader role. Wasn't bothered about the wage increase (20p an hour) but wanted the 28 hours guaranteed.

I work 36 hours every week but they will not increase my contract hours. No one has full time unless you have been there 20+ years and are legacy staff from the previous company.

Husband works nights at Tesco. He was employed 3 nights a week and is now contracted 5 nights a week. Not sure how he managed that 🤣🤣 but he did.

It's hard work and stressful working in a supermarket. Not the easy job people think it is. People are leaving in droves because the contract hours are crap and the pay isn't brilliant.

We rejected our latest pay offer which would have been 30p an hour for everyone. Waiting to see what they offer us next.

Theimpossiblegirl · 25/08/2022 08:23

Maybebabyno2 · 25/08/2022 07:59

Sh said she would leve teaching as not being a lento afford to leave is the only thing keeping her.

I would assume that means if the minimum wage was set to £15, she could work in a different role without worrying about the wage drop. I imagine she is championing for the change to go through so she can leave a job she doesn't like.

Thank you, that's exactly what I meant. I'd love to do another job but just can't afford to leave, especially at the moment. An increase in minimum wage would mean I could do something else.

Cheeriyo · 25/08/2022 08:20

Flutterbybudget · 24/08/2022 19:43

A salary of £31,200 (before tax) that’s £25,000 take home, and service bills in excess of £6,000, not counting housing costs, water, council tax, childcare costs, etc, etc

Currently, many are earning low wages, topped up by the taxpayer, through Universal credit and housing benefits. The question is, who should pay the “real” wage of a worker? The taxpayer, or the employer? My argument is that if your business doesn’t bring in enough for you to pay a wage sufficient for your employees to survive on, then you don’t have a viable business. Why should YOU (not aimed at any individual, general question) be taking home huge sums of money, while the tax payer subsides your wages bill/ running costs?

A lot of people work for small businesses. I agree there should be a measure in place so that huge companies who do make loads of profit aren't shored up by top ups, but the country would be a worse place if the only viable businesses were big business. Many of these provide decent services or add value beyond monetary to places, but they don't bring in tonnes of cash.

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:16

The solution is simple. On the other thread about a £15 minimum wage, I said that the minimum wage should be about £10, as that would give an annual wage of 60% of the 31K median wage. £10 is about a 10% increase. But we can have a £15 minimum wage, and maintain the current wage structure, all we need to do is give everyone else a 50% increase as well, so the new median wage goes up to just over 46K.

(Of course this is stupid, and will do no-one any good. But it would in theory shut up the people making stupid demands by giving them what they want without actually giving them what they want. I bet there are no economists who think £15 minimum wage is a good idea.)

CeeJay81 · 25/08/2022 08:05

@eeeeeeeeee totally agree. As someone who works in supermarket why should we not get a living wage? Ive gone from a 16hr contract(these days they give out 8 hours) to 32hr contract(hope to get full time soon but I sometimes do full time anyway). I have suffered anxiety most of my life, so was unable to get qualifications and move up the ladder etc but that makes me scum and I should live on pittance because of the crap I had as a child. Why shouldn't we be offered a living wage?

RedRiverShore2 · 25/08/2022 08:02

Large companies that make loads of profits should be taxed more to cover the state handouts to their low paid workers and I don't just mean Amazon

IceCreamTime19 · 25/08/2022 08:01

If the medium salary in the uk is £29k then how the minumum wage be £31k. Only if the medium salary go up too! Then there is no incentive to take up more responsibility at work if you can get £31k just for showing up at work.

Maybebabyno2 · 25/08/2022 07:59

sweetkitty · 25/08/2022 07:43

@Theimpossiblegirl can I ask why you would consider leaving teaching if this goes through? I’m a teacher and I would fight for a minimum wage hike to £15 an hour. Like I said I work with people getting £9 an hour and it’s horrible listening to them. Yes I’ve been to uni got 2 degrees pay a student loan, do a bit more planning and paperwork my annual salary is 42K which equates to just over £24 an hour. Yes I’m worth that but they are worth a lot more too. It’s not a race to the bottom. They deserve to be able not to be terrified of this price cap that’s coming of feeding their families.

I am no better than the janitor who picks up the litter or the bus driver who brings the kids to school they are all essential workers who deserve a living wage.

Sh said she would leve teaching as not being a lento afford to leave is the only thing keeping her.

I would assume that means if the minimum wage was set to £15, she could work in a different role without worrying about the wage drop. I imagine she is championing for the change to go through so she can leave a job she doesn't like.