Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Demand for minimum wage hike is too high?

85 replies

worriedniece · 24/08/2022 19:26

I just read this article which demands minimum wage be put up to £15 an hour. www.opendemocracy.net/en/labour-silent-minimum-wage-15-pounds-keir-starmer/

I am a little flabbergasted. I worked out that working 52weeks a year on £15 an hour would equate to a salary of 31k Now given that newly qualified teachers earn £25k a year, a junior doctor is on £29k it seems comparably high. It sort of makes me wonder what's the incentive to go and train for a job/go to uni when you can earn nearly as much working in Tesco. I might be being naive, b it surely a minimum is just that- it's a bare minimum and employers should incentivise the best workers by offering more?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RamblingEclectic · 26/08/2022 16:04

orbitalcrisis · 25/08/2022 09:05

I think what we need to do to start with is to admit that Tax Credits and UC are subsidising the employer, not the employee, and pay the money directly to them. This would then stop the stigmatisation of low wage workers and pass the blame onto where it is due. Imagine the outrage there would be when people heard how many millions companies like Amazon were getting in benefits despite the owner earning trillions. People would then be more happy to accept a higher minimum wage.

The government could continue to subsidise small businesses, but I think there would no longer be an appetite for subsidising huge companies and paying so little to nurses, teachers etc.

This is an interesting concept.

Many people's income are a mix of their employer(s) and the government, and while I agree with other previous posters on how the government needs to work on improving access to housing and other needs and services, something that brings the issue that the 'minimum wage' is already a variable concept between the silly different age ones and the government additions to it in a way that pushed the huge corporations to pay their share while supporting small businesses is an interesting one.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:59

Posted too soon

…if you can avoid significant debt and earn the same.

(this is really why true communism can never work in practice).

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:57

Daisy03 · 26/08/2022 15:54

So just because you've gone to university you'd rather see essential workers such as supermarket staff or refuse workers kept in poverty? It really isn't a race to the bottom you know, and everyone works bloody hard.
For most graduate employees it's their starting salaries that are nearer the bottom end of the scale, and if it isn't then they should be attacking the government for higher wages, not wishing those who they see as doing lower jobs than them to be kept on a low wage and in their place

Of course you don’t want to see them in poverty.

But they also don’t have £50k worth of debt that they have to pay back with interest.

And realistically unskilled Labour is just that. Doesn’t mean you’re less of a person, no. But anybody can’t stack shelves.

Far fewer trained to teach, fewer again trained to be Doctors.

It’s a disincentive to train and incur debt dor a skilled job.

Daisy03 · 26/08/2022 15:54

So just because you've gone to university you'd rather see essential workers such as supermarket staff or refuse workers kept in poverty? It really isn't a race to the bottom you know, and everyone works bloody hard.
For most graduate employees it's their starting salaries that are nearer the bottom end of the scale, and if it isn't then they should be attacking the government for higher wages, not wishing those who they see as doing lower jobs than them to be kept on a low wage and in their place

Alldelicious · 26/08/2022 15:49

I think minimum wage is too simplistic.

Of course everyone should get a proper wage, but put it up to these kinds of levels and almost everyone else is going to need a payrise too. We've already seen it where I work, the lowest bands have had to be abolished because everyone's on the same pay and of course there should be some differentiation for greater slills/responsibility.

Increasing everyone's pay will fuel inflation and get us back to square one anyway where "good" slaries have little buying power and an awful lot of min wage jobs are public sector, so taxes will need to increase to pay for them (or services cut which will put people out of jobs altogether).

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:45

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 19:46

Other wages would rise too .

That's what b"minimum" means. It's the least you should be paid and others should be paid more.

As for how we afford it, ask our government of millionaires. Plenty to go around when that lot want money, isn't there.

Except they wouldn’t would they!
They’d stay the same and then a junior Doctor will be on the same as a shelf stacker.

Then of course the coat of things will skyrocket too.

£15 per hour is a crazy minimum wage.

And that’s a false equivalence comparing them to a govt of so-called millionaires.

Do you understand basic economics.

MidnightMeltdown · 26/08/2022 15:42

I guess what I'm saying is that it should be wealth, rather than income, which is taxed, because taking income is very unfair on younger generations who are struggling to buy homes.

MidnightMeltdown · 26/08/2022 15:36

@stopitstopitnow

I talking about homeowners, and I don't think that it's anymore unfair that increasing tax on people earning over 50k

Say that:

Person A is a young person who earns 60k but has a large mortgage having purchased a house in recent years

Person B is earning 30k but mortgage free or has a tiny mortgage

It's clear that person B is far better off. Perhaps assets should be considered equal to income in terms of taxation.

stopitstopitnow · 26/08/2022 15:06

MidnightMeltdown · 26/08/2022 14:56

Perhaps the over 40s should pay more tax to compensate for the higher housing cost burden placed on younger generations.

many over 40's are on NMW and you want to tax them more????

MidnightMeltdown · 26/08/2022 14:56

Perhaps the over 40s should pay more tax to compensate for the higher housing cost burden placed on younger generations.

MidnightMeltdown · 26/08/2022 14:35

Plantstrees · 26/08/2022 14:23

I don't think we should increase the minimum wage but we should stop taxing people who are only earning that amount. Somebody earning minimum wage working 40 hours a week is going to be paying tax and national insurance. If we raised the tax and NI allowances to £20,000 then people would take home much more of their earnings. Anyone earning over £50,000 should pay more to compensate. This would also remove a lot of the burdon of taxes and bureaucratic nightmare from small businesses and help the economy to get going again.

No thanks. I earn over 50k and pay more than enough tax. 50k is not a high salary anymore given housing costs etc. Why would someone work hard, get qualifications etc only to end up with virtually the same take home pay as someone on minimum wage?

I would support the idea of a maximum wage though. Some people are earning ridiculous amounts including bonuses.

Plantstrees · 26/08/2022 14:23

I don't think we should increase the minimum wage but we should stop taxing people who are only earning that amount. Somebody earning minimum wage working 40 hours a week is going to be paying tax and national insurance. If we raised the tax and NI allowances to £20,000 then people would take home much more of their earnings. Anyone earning over £50,000 should pay more to compensate. This would also remove a lot of the burdon of taxes and bureaucratic nightmare from small businesses and help the economy to get going again.

HouseofHolbein · 26/08/2022 08:53

I get 20p an hour more for being a team leader in a supermarket. Our manager has left and until we get a replacement us 3 team leaders are expected to run the department. For 20p an hour more than the pickers and the same money as the drivers. Only benefit to being a team leader is more hours. Which honestly is the only reason any of us do it.

And I don't want to apply for the actual manager role because I've seen what it's done to our last 2 managers and I've also seen the state of all of the instore managers. Nope.

worriedniece · 25/08/2022 22:23

tttigress · 25/08/2022 10:05

If minimum wage went up to £15, I guess you would get quite a bunching up of salaries. In the 90s there would be at least a noticeable difference between the person on the lowest wage (nmw did not exist) and their supervisor.

Now the supervisor if in catering or child care gets about 50p or £1 per hour more, which begs the question, what is the point of being the supervisor.

That's exactly it, so where is the motivation for promotion. Also, although large companies eg costa can take the hit (but they will probably pass the cost onto customers so no one gains overall), small businesses eg the little coffee shop etc won't be able to afford it.

OP posts:
HelpLeaving · 25/08/2022 18:55

It is ironic (nonsensical) small, mild capitalists are in favour of the tax payer funding in work benefits. Because small employers. Survival.

When did in full time employment but still receiving benefits because wage wasn't sufficient originate?

Why are ordinary tax payers subsidising low wages?

tttigress · 25/08/2022 10:05

If minimum wage went up to £15, I guess you would get quite a bunching up of salaries. In the 90s there would be at least a noticeable difference between the person on the lowest wage (nmw did not exist) and their supervisor.

Now the supervisor if in catering or child care gets about 50p or £1 per hour more, which begs the question, what is the point of being the supervisor.

tttigress · 25/08/2022 10:00

I find it quite interesting that there is talk on this thread of high living costs such as £1000+ for childcare. But what is the price of childcare going to look like if the minimum wage is £15 - probably a lot lot more!!

Endofanera22 · 25/08/2022 09:46

Well I'd quit teaching to pull pints in a flash. It's fucking ridiculous.

Cornettoninja · 25/08/2022 09:41

So some people would rather low wages - low enough to compete with Indian wages

These people

But they don't want to live like the lower paid Indian people do

are not these people.

Alexandra2001 · 25/08/2022 09:39

DashboardConfessional · 25/08/2022 09:13

The company went into administration due to customers not wanting to pay slightly higher prices, and "waiting for the sale". I lost my job with no notice the week of lockdown 1, along with 50 colleagues, and had to claim stat pay from the government.
I would love to see just how many companies have customers willing to pay high enough prices (in one large increase) to support a 57% wage increase.

As for Clarks, they wanted to keep charging £48 for a pair of leather ballet pumps so they moved production to China, Cambodia, India and Vietnam. Perhaps we "missed a trick" not doing that?

Well, you never said any of that did you? You said "We could no longer afford their cost prices because Brexit weakened the pound, so we dropped them as a supplier."

no mention of LD's or your company going bust.. i'm not a mind reader.

Portugal didn't have a MW increase of 57% & Clarks didn't make the bulk of their sales making ballet pumps, they made great shoes in the UK and shifted production to the far east for a huge variety of reasons, not least business rates and energy costs, land values meant building on their former factory space was very profitable too.
Their machinists earned very little.

midgetastic · 25/08/2022 09:17

So some people would rather low wages - low enough to compete with Indian wages

But they don't want to live like the lower paid Indian people do- they want the state to pick up the tab for a western life? With food and fuel security?

There has got to be a better way

Cornettoninja · 25/08/2022 09:15

70billionthnamechange · 24/08/2022 20:28

My business would go under. It's not that it isn't a viable business as PP said, but with the horrific energy costs and stock costs now, if I had to increase by 5 an hour for every member of staff, I would be fucked. No answers here, just saying. And obviously I wish I could pay more but £10 per hour is the going rate where I am for hospitality and that's what all my budgeting was based on so it's not about not being a viable business if you can't afford a massive increase over night, if you can't pay the going rate, that's different.

But with fixed costs going up you’re going to have to raise your prices shrinking your potential customer base. A raise in NMW would affect your customers as well.

I favour concentrating on the affordability of living over raising NMW in a dramatic move that would be turbulent but likely even out over time, but there are wider pros/cons than just your wage bill with a rise in NMW.

DashboardConfessional · 25/08/2022 09:13

Alexandra2001 · 25/08/2022 08:49

Well, you may have missed a trick because my partner buys Panama Jack shoes, they have gone up £10 but are great shoes, made in Portugal & hard to get hold off, plenty of people seem to think so too.

Their MW is just 822 euros per month, so quite happy to pay a little extra.

BTW Clarks stopped making shoes in the UK long before the NMW was a significant cost.

The company went into administration due to customers not wanting to pay slightly higher prices, and "waiting for the sale". I lost my job with no notice the week of lockdown 1, along with 50 colleagues, and had to claim stat pay from the government.
I would love to see just how many companies have customers willing to pay high enough prices (in one large increase) to support a 57% wage increase.

As for Clarks, they wanted to keep charging £48 for a pair of leather ballet pumps so they moved production to China, Cambodia, India and Vietnam. Perhaps we "missed a trick" not doing that?

Weefreetiffany · 25/08/2022 09:08

A better rule is that CEOs can’t make a salary higher that 12x the lowest paid employee. So for 30k that would be 360k if you read that and thought “that’s not fair on the CEO” you’re the problem.

orbitalcrisis · 25/08/2022 09:05

I think what we need to do to start with is to admit that Tax Credits and UC are subsidising the employer, not the employee, and pay the money directly to them. This would then stop the stigmatisation of low wage workers and pass the blame onto where it is due. Imagine the outrage there would be when people heard how many millions companies like Amazon were getting in benefits despite the owner earning trillions. People would then be more happy to accept a higher minimum wage.

The government could continue to subsidise small businesses, but I think there would no longer be an appetite for subsidising huge companies and paying so little to nurses, teachers etc.