Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it petty or reasonable to not want to give birth in this hospital for this reason?

156 replies

Nobabyno · 24/08/2022 16:41

I'm pregnant with our first child and me and DH were discussing where I'd give birth.

There is a smaller hospital quite close to us (10 min drive) which has a good maternity unit, alternatively there is a hospital around 40 mins away which is also good (city centre very large hospital).

This is where my AIBU comes in!

My husband's ex is a midwife at the local hospital! They have a child together, my step child. We do get on okay, she knows about the pregnancy even and has always been perfectly pleasant toward me. I'm not her hugest fan for a couple of reasons but all in all we rub along very well.

I've told DH there's no way I want to go there to give birth and want to go to the other hospital because of this. He thinks I'm being silly. She wouldn't be able to be my midwife anyway because of the connection (don't know how true that is but I'm sure she'd request not to be anyway!) so there's no big deal.

It doesn't matter to me though, I'm nervous as it is. The last thing I want is it playing on my mind that she will be there or whoever my midwife is ends up being her friend or something. It's a vulnerable time and I just don't want the stress of it.

It's not a big deal to go to the other hospital but is he right, would you find this silly or reason?

YABU - it doesn't matter.

YANBU - I'd hate it too and go somewhere else!

OP posts:
QuebecBagnet · 24/08/2022 18:12

I understand what you mean.

I’m a midwife and my ex and his new gf had a baby where I work.

I obviously didn’t look after her but every woman on the ward is discussed at handover so yes I was aware of some stuff about her such as mode of birth and some issues afterwards. I also saw her quite a few times on the ward as she was walking around.

however there was no gossiping, etc. but I can still see your view.

TurkishDelightForTheLittlePrince · 24/08/2022 18:07

PersonaNonGarter · 24/08/2022 16:43

It’s really about the baby’s safety though.

Actually it’s about the mother and baby’s safety, not just the baby’s.

OP, I kind of understand where you’re coming from. This is one of the most, if not the most, vulnerable time in your life. You want to feel as secure as possible and if you have other options that make you feel that, go for it. It’s up to you, not your husband, and it makes little to no difference to him anyway.

Maray1967 · 24/08/2022 18:04

Your DH does not get to decide this, you do. Nor - and this is very important- does he get to tell you that you’re being. ‘silly’.
You need to be as happy as you possibly can be. Any form of stress is not good. I would also personally always go for the larger unit but I was fortunate to live ten minutes away from Liverpool women’s. A friend of mine gave birth there despite living very close to Arrowe park on the Wirral because she always felt looked after during earlier treatment at the LWH so she was prepared to deal with potential Mersey tunnel delays.

Cakecakecheese · 24/08/2022 17:57

I gave birth a few weeks ago and one of the midwives who delivered my baby was a friend of mine. She asked me if I was OK having her there, I said yes but if I refused they would have found someone else so it's fine to do that. However I can see that even just the idea of the ex being around somewhere might cause you anxiety that you really don't need so it's understandable that you'd want to go elsewhere.

Peashoots · 24/08/2022 17:56

Crazykatie · 24/08/2022 17:26

The local hospital is probably a midwife led unit which is fine until you need a c section in a hurry, finding an ambulance and travelling 40 mins or whatever is not great. For a 1st baby the main hospital is safest but it’s your choice.

Also, for a first baby in a low risk pregnancy, homebirth is statistically as safe as hospital birth. Delivering in an obstetric led unit increases your risk of instrumental birth and c sections. So a bigger consultant led unit is NOT always the safest option.
obviously this varies for high risk pregnancies.

Gooseysgirl · 24/08/2022 17:54

YANBU, go to the bigger hospital. I had a choice of hospitals - the nearest was five mins away, I went for the one that was 30 mins away and that's where I had DC1. Lots of women are even further away 🤷🏻‍♀️ I would feel the same as you if I were in this situation.

Peashoots · 24/08/2022 17:53

Crazykatie · 24/08/2022 17:26

The local hospital is probably a midwife led unit which is fine until you need a c section in a hurry, finding an ambulance and travelling 40 mins or whatever is not great. For a 1st baby the main hospital is safest but it’s your choice.

Absolute rubbish. I work in a small hospital that doesn’t have an MLU, only alongside midwifery led rooms on a delivery suite.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 24/08/2022 17:52

I would feel exactly the same as you. she probably won't be anywhere near, but you don't want to potentially be gossiped about. My midwife ds didn't give birth in her local hospital / workplace for that same reason. You have to go where you feel comfortable, this is your medical appointment.

ChunkyLegsandKinderEggs · 24/08/2022 17:50

If the hospitals aren’t part of the same trust, you may have to attend the further away hospital for all sorts of reasons such as blood tests, scans, any consultant appointments, and then after the baby is born for any follow up that might be required. If you get a wound infection for example, will you want to sit in the car for 40 minutes with a (possibly) screaming newborn?

I booked at a hospital 40ish mind away (I work there) and it was fine, but I went in fully aware of the drawbacks.

Iwonder08 · 24/08/2022 17:47

There is no way I would go to a small hospital with my husband's ex as a midwife even if she is not your midwife. What if they have someone ill on the day or on holiday or shortage? I also wouldn't appreciate anyone discussing my medical details with the ex.
Go for the bigger hospital, 40 min is not that bad. Also it is you who is giving birth and what you think counts. Your husband has no right in this decision

MintJulia · 24/08/2022 17:43

To give birth, you need to feel safe and secure. Any reason why that is not so, is a good reason to go elsewhere. Your husband's views are not relevant, he isn't the one trying to deliver a baby.

However, if you can talk to the closer maternity unit and gain assurances that you are happy with, then that may be a compromise. It's worth asking.

You want to put the baby's safety first and not having to travel for 40 mins helps, but feeling safe yourself is part of that, so don't let anyone tell you it is irrelevant. If it is worrying you, it matters.

wonkylegs · 24/08/2022 17:42

I chose to go to a hospital further away than my local one because it's the hospital my DH works at so it worked better for us, visiting, appointments etc but also because I had a high risk pregnancy and the larger hospital had better facilities if there was a problem with the baby.
The larger hospital may be better if things go wrong, touch wood they won't but just in case.

Firty · 24/08/2022 17:37

Anything that makes you feel stressed/tense, slows labour and can cause problems. If going to that hospital makes you tense, you need to go elsewhere. It doesn’t matter why you feel tense, it isn’t a logical thing that your husband can debate.

That your husband does not understand this, is not great. During your labour he needs to be the person getting rid of anything/anyone that’s stressing you. Talk to him - if necessary email him! About this, and maybe send him some articles on birth to read. If he doesn’t know that stress is the worse thing for the baby’s welfare then really he knows nothing about birth at all.

ForkedIt · 24/08/2022 17:36

Just go where you feel comfortable. Nobody else’s feelings matter.

IF there was an emergency, or the head starts emerging as you pull off the driveway you can still turn up at the closer hospital. They can’t turn you away.

Ponderingwindow · 24/08/2022 17:32

40 minutes in the best circumstances with several significant traffic pinch points along the route was the only option when I gave birth. No one thought anything of it.

where I am now, the closest maternity hospital is still 30 minutes away, though no bridges or tunnels to contend with here.

Monr0e · 24/08/2022 17:32

I completely understand your reasons and don't think you are unreasonable to want ti give birth in the environment where you feel the most comfortable.

However, if you are able to look round both units, you could possibly do this before making a final decision. Most midwives working in hospital rotate to the different wards, so she may not even be working on the delivery suite anyway unless she is a permanent ds midwife. However, that does mean that you might see her in triage or on the postnatal ward so it'd worth thinking about how you would feel about that also.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 17:30

I would feel the same as you. The birth is
First and foremost about safe delivery, as you've said both options have excellent mat units.
Thereafter it's your choice.

For all the reasons you've mentioned, not a hope in hell would I book into the closer one where ex works.

The birth & newborn love bubble is a special time for you and you as a couple. I just wouldn't want to share that moment in any way with his ex
(I know she wouldn't be your midwife but as you say she could be on the ward or her friends could be)
It's a special private time for you.
You will have to share so much with her in the past & moving on as your kids are siblings.

The birth of uour first child should not be one of those times imho

Crazykatie · 24/08/2022 17:26

The local hospital is probably a midwife led unit which is fine until you need a c section in a hurry, finding an ambulance and travelling 40 mins or whatever is not great. For a 1st baby the main hospital is safest but it’s your choice.

NotYourOscarSpeech · 24/08/2022 17:24

I get why you wouldn’t want the nearby hospital. My only issue is I would assume you wouldn’t be able to have a home birth with the one that’s further away (currently pregnant and that’s important to me!) and I wouldn’t give that option up to avoid the smaller hospital - but assuming that’s not relevant to you.

Wouldloveanother · 24/08/2022 17:24

Pick the hospital you would feel most comfortable at. In a proper emergency you’d just go to the nearest one anyway but it probably won’t come to that. Do you have risk factors?

Calmdown14 · 24/08/2022 17:22

I get you and I would feel the same.

You have another reasonable option so it makes sense to use it and avoid awkwardness.

I'm sure she'd be totally professional (as in not discussing, corridor passing) but will probably be equally delighted to avoid the situation. You don't want to have to think about it and neither does she

Crunchymum · 24/08/2022 17:18

I assume you are early pregnant and have not yet had your booking appointment?

Just self refer to to hospital you want.

mam0918 · 24/08/2022 17:17

I am equadistant from half a dozen hospitals across 3 counties due to where I live, its half and hour too each (well 1 doesnt have a maternity unit anymore so 5 option).

I have been pregnant 4 times and the journey was fine each time and we had to travel in a severe storm once.

Very few people spontaniously fire out a baby (and I did have spontanious PPROM with one of mine, my body was desperately trying to get him out because the cord was compressed, still took 12 hours from the start point) with zero warning, usually its a case of people ignoring warning sign until the last minute.

You'll most likely be fine going 40 minute if you choose that and you know should the worst come to the worst and you dont realise until your crowning you can still go to the near one anyway.

WoodlandMummy · 24/08/2022 17:14

Oh god go with the larger hospital ! I decided to go with a hospital 40 mins away as I prefer the town it’s in (salubrious, lovely area) to the town the hospital 30 mins away is and wanted my son to be born in that town as opposed to the other (average, boring town). So, my reasons are really shallow but I don’t care what anyone but DH thinks and he agrees with me!

As it happens the hospital I’ve chosen is amazing. It’s always calm and a lovely atmosphere with incredible staff. The ‘other’ hospital is v busy and not a v nice vibe (I had to go yesterday for an unrelated issue).

Sprogonthetyne · 24/08/2022 17:10

Even if it is her best mate, they won't be discussing it over coffee. Firstly because of confidentiality, but also because births aren't that interesting to people who are involved in several a day. There won't be anything about yours that they haven't see before, so they won't be discussing their patients any more then cashiers discuss their customers.

Having said that, how small is the small hospital? Dose it have a theater or would you need to transfer in an emergency? If so, that would put me off far more then who works their.