Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable here?

114 replies

Telivania · 24/08/2022 16:31

Kitchen area has had some work done. 2 tradesmen were in the house working on it for a whole day. Obviously they had breaks in between (went for lunch, etc).

Person A and Person B are married and live together. A was the one at home while the tradies were in, while B was out at work.

A told them they were welcome to make their own drinks (tea, coffee, etc), but wouldn't personally be serving them anything.

B thinks A was rude and had no manners, as making drinks and food for tradies is basic hospitality and costs nothing.

A insists it's not about the cost, but about the principle. A refuses to act as a 'servant' to random men who are simply doing their job (and being paid a lot of money for it).

B still disagrees and thinks A was being disrespectful.

Who is BU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Boredsoentertainme · 25/08/2022 21:24

My point is making drinks, foods, snacks, etc all day for random people who have been given all the facilities to do it themselves would make me a servant

lol. Bet staying round yours is a blast 😂

MajorCarolDanvers · 25/08/2022 18:51

It's just basic manners to make them a cup of tea or coffee.

EL8888 · 25/08/2022 18:38

B is unreasonable. Of course they can make their own drinks?!

bloodyplanes · 25/08/2022 18:37

A was inhospitable and rude!

Telivania · 25/08/2022 17:54

Boredsoentertainme · 25/08/2022 17:17

Ffs you’re not acting as a servant to random men when making someone who is working in your house a cup of tea. Dial it down.

@Boredsoentertainme

Not one cup of tea. My husband was making the point that I should've made all the drinks, food, snacks, etc throughout the day for them myself, when they were given all the facilities to do it themselves. That's the servant part. Maybe you lack reading comprehension?

OP posts:
Telivania · 25/08/2022 17:51

Surplus2requirements · 25/08/2022 17:14

Very overly defensive. I never told you any such thing.

I never accept food and prefer to be told to help myself to hot drinks.

It's the weird not being a servant to random men thing thats weird and would be equally so from a man so I don't know how you think that's sexist.

@Surplus2requirements

That's literally exactly what you said 😂

I think you're being overly defensive here because your profession has been mentioned.

My point is making drinks, foods, snacks, etc all day for random people who have been given all the facilities to do it themselves would make me a servant. I'm not hosting them, they're here to work.

Never mind though, eh? Agree to disagree - me and my husband already have.

OP posts:
Boredsoentertainme · 25/08/2022 17:17

Ffs you’re not acting as a servant to random men when making someone who is working in your house a cup of tea. Dial it down.

Surplus2requirements · 25/08/2022 17:14

Telivania · 24/08/2022 20:39

@IncompleteSenten I've clarified multiple times what I said and how I said it

@Surplus2requirements "It's the attitude I struggle with." And I struggle with you telling me I should be happy to serve random men food and drink in my house all day, when they had full access to food and drink themselves. Sexist.

Very overly defensive. I never told you any such thing.

I never accept food and prefer to be told to help myself to hot drinks.

It's the weird not being a servant to random men thing thats weird and would be equally so from a man so I don't know how you think that's sexist.

girlmom21 · 25/08/2022 11:12

JackieQueen · 25/08/2022 11:02

If B is so bothered he should wait on them himself! 😝

While he's out at work?

JackieQueen · 25/08/2022 11:02

If B is so bothered he should wait on them himself! 😝

Telivania · 25/08/2022 10:49

Anyway, the posts on here seem split 50/50, like me and my husband Grin
So I think we'll just agree to disagree on this occasion!

OP posts:
Telivania · 25/08/2022 10:49

ImpartialMongoose · 24/08/2022 23:19

OP is a massive wanker, she's just been back tracking since. What's the point of asking AIBU, since she clearly believes she is right

@ImpartialMongoose

A massive wanker? Hmm bit harsh.

I've been backtracking ever since? 😴 Stop exaggerating. I haven't "backtracked" on anything. I did however correct one poorly-worded sentence in my OP.

@IncompleteSenten It was just poorly worded on my behalf!

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/08/2022 00:45

I think it’s totally fine to just point anyone working in your house in the direction of the kettle, tea coffee etc, and say help yourself. I usually make an initial cup and then say, please help yourselves to more. Would often leave biscuits too.

When I had a loft conversion they weren’t big drinkers of hot drinks for the most part, so I ended up getting a load of cans of soft drinks, which was very welcome but also much easier!

I do the same thing with my cleaner, ask if they want a drink on arrival, which they often say no but sometimes yes, and then say “ oh please help yourself if you change your mind/ want anything” and they know they can help themselves to a drink if I’m out.

JonahAndTheSnail · 25/08/2022 00:31

YANBU, give them the stuff they need to make their own drinks as they would at home and leave them to work uninterrupted. I honestly hate the faff of 'I'm making a drink, do you want one?' and then being presented with a cup of milky water which has barely winked at a teabag but feeling obliged to sip it down. It's not so much a case of not wanting to 'serve' a man but why would you overcomplicate something so simple as making drinks during the day?

kittenkipping · 24/08/2022 23:24

Lollol- you are entirely right! I didn't make it clear that the first one is the only one expected/ hoped for! All trades are grateful and once you've done the one- effectively show and tell, you are right! Help yourself after that point is appreciated and my post is overly salty. Even if you offer none it's fine and you aren't a bad person- whereas my examples are. It's fine not to even offer help yourself! It's certainly not something trades should judge their customers on! People are busy, shy, different, and varied. Not bad customers which is what I've described. Those are different things. It's been a long day for me, and I shouldn't let a few negative experiences overshadow the overwhelming positive experiences we get. The vast vast majority are wonderful and indeed, meeting people is the best part of the job in many ways

ManateeFair · 24/08/2022 23:23

YABU for saying ‘tradies’.

A is BU in my opinion. I’d always offer drinks and snacks to anyone working in my house. If I’m putting the kettle on for myself, to me it’s just normal to offer anyone else a cuppa as well. I would probably also show them where everything was so they could make their own teas/coffees in between, but I’d still offer whenever I was making one and I’d probably put biscuits and some packets of crisps on the side for them for whenever they wanted them.

I’m not saying this is some kind of formal obligation, but I was brought up to be nice to people and to me, that’s just being nice. If I’m in the office I’ll say “Anyone want a cuppa?” to my colleagues when I put the kettle on so it seems natural to me to do the same to anyone working in my home.

When discussing this with other people I have noticed quite a divide between people who have, or could easily have, family and mates who are tradespeople and people who think anyone with a van is a different species from them and would faint at the notion of a relative doing manual work. The former just treat people working in their house like they’d treat anyone else, while the latter treat tradespeople as some sort of ‘other’ who can’t be trusted with the nicer mugs, and consider it beneath themselves to serve a tray of teas to them.

ImpartialMongoose · 24/08/2022 23:19

IncompleteSenten · 24/08/2022 22:30

That wasn't my question.

I know you clarified it.

I'm asking why you put it that way in the first place. It made A sound like a massive wanker and it wasn't actually what they'd said even though you said it's what they told the workmen.

OP is a massive wanker, she's just been back tracking since. What's the point of asking AIBU, since she clearly believes she is right

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 24/08/2022 23:11

kittenkipping · 24/08/2022 23:06

I'm a female trade. It's not sexist. Both men and women do me tea through the day (honestly more often than not unwelcome tea- once on arrival and again if you bother us and interrupt our workspace to make your own- which is irritating because our insurance means we should down tools whilst your there, but at the same time is entirely fair as our workspace is your HOME)

I'd not make my own tea. I neither have the time nor the belief in people that they mean it when they say it (years ago I did- but I have then been called a slacker for doing so, and worse, later someone tried to charge us 25p a tea bag, £1 for milk, rental of the mugs and then cleaning charges, wanting £10 off their invoice- I don't set the price, British Gas do, what your saying is you want me and my mate to stump £5 for the privilege of working for you!)

Sorry but those examples are not fair to the majority of us! I make first cup of day, then it's very clear that they help themselves, I'll joke about them having a nice biscuit, they'll be shown where everything is!

I have never found that they've not helped themselves as "instructed".

I've had two extensions, loads of different trades and not once have I found them not having a drink etc.

kittenkipping · 24/08/2022 23:06

I'm a female trade. It's not sexist. Both men and women do me tea through the day (honestly more often than not unwelcome tea- once on arrival and again if you bother us and interrupt our workspace to make your own- which is irritating because our insurance means we should down tools whilst your there, but at the same time is entirely fair as our workspace is your HOME)

I'd not make my own tea. I neither have the time nor the belief in people that they mean it when they say it (years ago I did- but I have then been called a slacker for doing so, and worse, later someone tried to charge us 25p a tea bag, £1 for milk, rental of the mugs and then cleaning charges, wanting £10 off their invoice- I don't set the price, British Gas do, what your saying is you want me and my mate to stump £5 for the privilege of working for you!)

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL · 24/08/2022 23:04

lamby12 · 24/08/2022 21:23

Am I the only person that would never say 'help yourself' to trades people?! I don't want them rifling through my cupboards or making their own drinks on my worktops, always messy buggers!

Also if they are not working in the kitchen I wouldn't expect them to be traipsing round the house. It helps that I have a dog that I'd keep in there and say 'don't go in the kitchen or let the dog out' (he'd only lick them to death but they don't know that).

I always make them one on arrival and maybe offer 2-3 throughout the day, but would never ever suggest they help themselves. They're doing a job, not setting up house.

Thankfully our last builders obviously learnt if they want more than 2-3 teas to bring their own flasks for the day.

God, I'm glad I'm not a trades person and have to deal with you!

They're all messy buggers? How would you know that?

"Rifling" through your cupboard, or you just leave stuff out.

Are they allowed to wee and poo in your house, or do they bring a camping toilet?

alwaysmovingforwards · 24/08/2022 22:49

I let them bring their own drinks or sit in their van or whatever.

IncompleteSenten · 24/08/2022 22:30

That wasn't my question.

I know you clarified it.

I'm asking why you put it that way in the first place. It made A sound like a massive wanker and it wasn't actually what they'd said even though you said it's what they told the workmen.

ShirleyPhallus · 24/08/2022 22:26

lamby12 · 24/08/2022 21:23

Am I the only person that would never say 'help yourself' to trades people?! I don't want them rifling through my cupboards or making their own drinks on my worktops, always messy buggers!

Also if they are not working in the kitchen I wouldn't expect them to be traipsing round the house. It helps that I have a dog that I'd keep in there and say 'don't go in the kitchen or let the dog out' (he'd only lick them to death but they don't know that).

I always make them one on arrival and maybe offer 2-3 throughout the day, but would never ever suggest they help themselves. They're doing a job, not setting up house.

Thankfully our last builders obviously learnt if they want more than 2-3 teas to bring their own flasks for the day.

ALL tradespeople are “messy buggers”??

presumably it’s different if you’ve got someone working on your garden / loft extension vs fitting a new kitchen though

lamby12 · 24/08/2022 21:23

Am I the only person that would never say 'help yourself' to trades people?! I don't want them rifling through my cupboards or making their own drinks on my worktops, always messy buggers!

Also if they are not working in the kitchen I wouldn't expect them to be traipsing round the house. It helps that I have a dog that I'd keep in there and say 'don't go in the kitchen or let the dog out' (he'd only lick them to death but they don't know that).

I always make them one on arrival and maybe offer 2-3 throughout the day, but would never ever suggest they help themselves. They're doing a job, not setting up house.

Thankfully our last builders obviously learnt if they want more than 2-3 teas to bring their own flasks for the day.

BEAM123 · 24/08/2022 21:21

Telivania · 24/08/2022 20:51

@MissMaple82

What's dramatic about telling guests they're welcome to make as many coffees/teas/etc throughout the day as they like? 🙄

The premise I'm not happy with is my husband telling me I should've made all the teas, coffees, snacks, lunches, etc myself as it's "basic hospitality". I don't agree with that at all.

They are there to do a job and don't need to be entertained as guests. I think the British generally struggle with the concept of having people in the house to work. That's why those who have cleaners tend to have to clean before the cleaner arrives.

I would ask your DH if he would be running around after them with a pinnie on, making tea and cakes if he was at home. If he wouldn't, it's a sexist thing.