Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas issue already!!!

169 replies

Hymnulop · 24/08/2022 13:22

Please tell me if AIBU and help me word this

I'm on mat leave and everything has gone up/going up so much that savings are dwindling. I want to write a message to friends and family who usually buy for our 3 kids to say we basically can't afford to exchange gifts this year (they all have kids too or grandparents etc that usually buy for our DC) at all and would like for you to not buy for our DC as we can't afford to reciprocate.

DH has said thats rude as fuck as we shouldn't send it (most of my family and his start buying early so I want to send this message soon- would feel to awkward for us and them to discuss this in person hence the idea of sending a message) and they can buy for our DC If they want - yes this is true but I think they need to know we can't afford to reciprocate this year as we always do.

AIBU and how would you word this?! Thanks

YABU - don't send the text just let people decide what they want to do and they won't mind if we don't reciprocate

YANBU and I'll help you word the message.

OP posts:
Maytodecember · 24/08/2022 17:55

Shoxfordian · 24/08/2022 13:27

Yanbu, send something like:

We’re always very grateful for your kind presents for us and our dc at Christmas but unfortunately we won’t be in a financial position to reciprocate this year to the same degree.

As @Shoxfordian says. It’s polite, to the point. You can add that you don’t wish to receive gifts this year, if family wish a donation to local food bank bank or their favourite charity would be nice.

I’m doing the same this year —- small handmade stuff for close friends ( things I already had in the house) and don’t want to receive gifts, donation to charity if they really want to.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 24/08/2022 17:51

@TopGolfer Are you my SIL?

She pulled that trick the very first year our DS was born after our spending the last 20 years being given precise instructions as to what to buy her 3 kids, (even down to the page/item no in the argos catalogue)

You might not have had any funny comments to your face but I certainly said a few about "D" sil

MummyJ36 · 24/08/2022 17:50

What is your DH suggesting you do if you don’t send the text? Surely this is going to be way more awkward in person at Christmas time? If a friend sent me a message saying money was super tight and could we forego presents this year I’d 100% understand. I don’t understand why somebody wouldn’t be understanding? Regarding family, why not speak to them in person? It’s likely they’ll still offer to buy the kids something which is fair enough, and maybe you could make a little craft present for them from the kids? Honestly genuinely is the best policy in this situation.

rnsaslkih · 24/08/2022 17:50

Your dh is crazy. Absolutely mental that he would cut a necessary food budget to buy a bunch of kids presents. Most of those kids will have mountains of toys anyway.

You should send messages to people (I'd send them personally rather than a blanket message) and just say: I know it's August but I'm on mat leave and we will be unable to afford to buy presents for anyone this christmas. We don't therefore expect presents for us or our dc and hope you understand. I'd add the bit about the food bank to some people.

If I received that and had the money and inclination to buy you presents, I'd still do it. If I was a close relative, I'd hand over some cash as a present to help out. However, I have already chopped my present list right down. It's an expensive ball ache. Nobody needs the 3 for 2 shit at Boots. Nobody.

Nekomata · 24/08/2022 17:49

I agree that if you say no gifts and then turn up with homemade gifts, it will muddy the waters. Plus, homemade gifts can actually work out expensive unless there is something you are good at doing and already have the supplies.

Also, if someone does give you a gift, just say something like "Wow, that's so kind of you. You really didn't have to do that, but thank you". Whatever you do, don't feel obliged to reciprocate.

I only do presents for my own kids and a small token gift each for my mum and dad plus something for me. I don't give stuff to nieces and nephews or friends and co-workers. I don't even give to my brother, but that's because he has no interest in Christmas or Christmas presents. It's fine and we have a lovely Christmas without so much stress and expense.

LondonLovie · 24/08/2022 17:48

If you can't afford it, you can't afford it. It's really straight forward. If the money isn't there and you need it for essentials don't go spending it on presents.

YANBU

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 24/08/2022 17:47

We are doing this this year and drastically cutting down, however both DH and I have both spoken to those involved about it face to face.

If we are close enough to buy them a gift in the first place, then they are close enough to be told in person.

I'd never send a text.

Runwalkskijump · 24/08/2022 17:43

Sswhinesthebest · 24/08/2022 17:33

Hey guys,
As I’m only on maternity pay this year, and with all the doom and gloom about energy price rises, I’m just giving you the heads up that we won’t be able to buy the presents for everyone that we normally do. Just letting you know early so that there is no danger of any you organised types, buying us anything. Hope you understand. Love x

Needs to be mentioned nothing for DC.

I would read that and think nothing for adults but DC ok.

Bickles · 24/08/2022 17:41

I’d happily do this but only have one so feel I can’t be the one to suggest and can afford. Just feel they get so much!

TopGolfer · 24/08/2022 17:38

I wouldn’t go for the homemade or secret Santa options. One text and it’s done, don’t mention it just being for this year either. Years ago I watched a Martin Lewis thing where he advised to stop all the for example £20 present swapping and he illustrated how much money could be saved.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 24/08/2022 17:33

It would not be rude at all to send a message. And I agree, easier than in person.
I would word it as « let’s not buy gifts this year, we’ll still bring you a little something homemade » which can be anything: biscuits, beads bracelet, tree ornament…
This way the message is not about « not making gifts » but more about affordability (and sustainability!)

Sswhinesthebest · 24/08/2022 17:33

Hey guys,
As I’m only on maternity pay this year, and with all the doom and gloom about energy price rises, I’m just giving you the heads up that we won’t be able to buy the presents for everyone that we normally do. Just letting you know early so that there is no danger of any you organised types, buying us anything. Hope you understand. Love x

AprilRae91 · 24/08/2022 17:26

If you can I would talk to people in person when you next see them. It’s less awkward than? I’m asking family for no gift exchanges please this year as we’re having a baby and won’t have spare money

EL8888 · 24/08/2022 17:11

Not rude at all. Just sensible l think. I’m sure lots of people are making cut backs at the moment. I have recently found out lm pregnant and will only be getting statutory pay. We will need to make lots of these kind of cut backs to make things work financially

TopGolfer · 24/08/2022 17:08

About 20 years ago I sent messages to everyone I used to buy for saying I’m only buying for my DC and parents/PIL from now on. I had no funny comments, it caused no stress and I’ve never looked back.

EveningOverRooftops · 24/08/2022 17:01

Just tell them as honestly as you can.

And state you can’t afford to do anything except pay the bills until you can return to work in the spring(or whenever it is) and with the looming bills rises you don’t want to commit to anything that could put you in a bit precarious position and will stick to swapping cards. Handmade if you like.

mamabear715 · 24/08/2022 16:57

Sigh, I'm sure others feel the same as I do, I'd love little token gifts & a church service, Christmas dinner & a walk.. (no little ones, all grown up).
Buying for family outside our home isn't too bad, but my DD has ASD & it's the highlight of her year.. she saves her PIP & spends an absolute fortune, which I would feel bad if I didn't try to at least match.. it all gets too damn much.
Do let people know, OP, I'm sure others will be struggling too. It will probably make their Christmas, knowing they can afford a turkey & not turkey burgers with the money they save! :-)

Brideandpredjudice · 24/08/2022 16:53

Hi friend/family member
Just wanted to send you a text to let you know that with me being on may leave and all of the price increases, we won't be in a position to buy Christmas gifts this year. Of course we don't expect you to buy us gifts either. We look forward to a Christmas centred around celebrating the festivities this year and hope to share our time with you.

Mouldyfeet · 24/08/2022 16:43

I've done this and so has my family at various points.
We now only buy token gifts.
I think Christmas presents for anyone other than kids is bloody ridiculous anyway and wouldn't care if I ever got any again tbh.
Most people are skint. Just send a text as I bet you are not the only one.

It's not bloody rude to say you can't afford this, that is clearly said by a bloody person that has no idea about actual poverty!!!

mam0918 · 24/08/2022 16:43

Friends fine - I dont get friends that buy for each other past teenage years, once me and my friends had kids we all focus on our own priorities which often means we dont even get to see each other round xmas, sometimes not until months later so the whole exchanging gift was farsical very quickly.

Family rude - grandparents etc... arent giving your kids gifts because the expect it back. I buy for my siblings every year but they have never bought me gifts, they are more the kind of 'love language' that help out with tasks rather than buy gifts and I have zero expectation of stuff back - I still like to buy thing I know they'll like though.

rwalker · 24/08/2022 16:42

I think some people would be relieved to receive a text like that

imagine if you got one how relieved you’d be as financial things are tight

Bbomb · 24/08/2022 16:38

If I received this message I'd not only be sympathetic and understanding but also relieved I wouldn't have to spend all that extra money in return.

You're DH thinks it's rude but what does he suggest as an alternative??

Porcupineintherough · 24/08/2022 16:35

I think it's totally fine for all but the very closest relatives. Those I'd make something like peppermint creams for (literally) a couple of quid in December. But honestly this winter is going to be hard for a lot of folk, people will understand. Your priority is to keep food on the table and the lights on and if you need the food bank to do that then it would be madness to be buying for other people.

Ruby0901 · 24/08/2022 16:35

Nobody should EXPECT you to buy a gift at Christmas. Especially family who should understand your situation and be supportive.
Trouble is most people care too much about what other people think, thats probs why your other half is against it.

Nekomata · 24/08/2022 16:34

I think a lot of posters are missing that the OP is flat broke and using food banks, so she doesn't have the ability to negotiate or do Secret Santa, so I think a text is fine.

"Hi Fred, we've decided with the current economic climate we won't be exchanging gifts this Christmas! We're mentioning it early in case you are early bird shoppers"

I think this is fine but I might say environmental and economic climate as people will be less likely to argue with the environmental concern.