I went on my first one aged 22 with my bf and parents, I didn’t think I’d like it like others I thought they were for old people but I loved it . I’ve done 3 now all Caribbean with P&O, Riyal Caribbean and NCL
They are a great way of see the islands without committing to a full holiday there.
Excursions are varied from cultural to active to simple beach trips or full island tours
Do some research before you go (cruise critic forum is great) and do your own beach trips/excursions, I now know the islands well enough to know which ones I’d do my own taxi to the beach and which ones I book an excursion
Dining options are great …self serve buffet, romantic meal for 2 in a speciality dining, sat with a group of randoms in the main restaurant have been fun and some of the best nights or even room service.
Confession I’ve never been to the shows!! Always spent time doing something else
the kids club is fantastic much better than any 5 star hotels I’ve been to
Ive done inside cabin and balcony, if you have loads of ports and not many at sea days save the extra and go inside.
lots to do on an at sea day. Pool, spa, movie, bingo, casino, talks on art/jewellery, Q&A with the captain, dancing, cooking presentations, live music etc etc
theres loads more but let’s just say we’ve booked our 4th for our honeymoon ☺️