Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cruise or not to cruise

255 replies

Summerslam · 24/08/2022 12:39

Would you? Assuming you had the money and could afford it, does the idea of floating around the Mediterranean or Caribbean, for a week or two, appeal?

I've heard so many differing opinions. Personally, I think I'd like it. Just me and DH, on an adults only cruise.

What do you you think? Relaxing holiday visiting different places with no effort? Or akin to a sojourn on a prison ship, trapped with passengers you can't escape from?

OP posts:
AngelsWithSilverWings · 24/08/2022 14:38

Always thought it would be a nightmare. Was invited on a free cruise by my in-laws and although I was actually dreading being on a cruise ship and sharing a cabin with two under 5s but it was absolutely brilliant. We ended up going on another two cruises after that.

I would whole heatedly recommend for parents with young toddlers desperate for some downtime and luxury as the kids clubs and night nurseries are fantastic.

Wouldn't bother now as there are so many other experiences we can enjoy as a family now the kids are teenagers.

Dinoswearunderpants · 24/08/2022 14:38

I love cruising but do notice the difference now I have a little one.

Agree that you really do need a balcony. If LO goes to bed early, you can sit outside with a drink and still enjoy your evening.

I love the ability to get off the ship for a few hours in a new country and explore. I also like exploring the sh

LetsGoNorth · 24/08/2022 14:28

I've only done a 4 night Europe cruise but I loved every second. We went with Celebrity - the food was amazing, service exceptional. The ship was so massive and so much entertainment and events that I could easily imagine spending a month on board without being bored.

Personally for a long cruise I would only choose a balcony cabin though. Other than a quick coffee we didn't actually use ours much, but that was only 4 nights. I'd imagine that with a longer cruise there would be more times you'd want to sit and relax with a drink and a book and of not want to be stuck in a cabin for that.

These threads always make me laugh though, they're always packed with posts saying how they're awful, tacky, like butlins etc - and clearly from those who've never been near a cruise ship! I love butlins with the kids, it has it's place - but I can assure you it's nothing like my experience on a ship!

amicissimma · 24/08/2022 14:27

"You’ll get a lot of people on here who have never been on a cruise telling you how awful cruises are though."

Yup. I was one of those! Then DH dragged me onto one and I absolutely loved it. Now I'm completely hooked.

As PP say, you can treat them as you like. You can have a suite and private dining or an allocated table where you meet the same people every night, or turn up, as you would at a restaurant, or use the buffet. You can always find a quiet corner, or throw yourself into all the activities, or something in between.

In port, some people stay onboard and have a whole ship to themselves, some go on organised tours, some head for the nearest bar and drink themselves horizontal (popular in Caribbean ports and great fun to watch them being helped back on board!), some arrange their own sightseeing, some wonder around the port, some take public transport to explore further affield.

It's possible, but I should think hard, not to meet anybody on a cruise, so I don't think it would suit the sort of people you see on MN who can't bear to spend a minute in the company of anyone who has different views to theirs - all sorts of different people cruise.

I've never caught norovirus on a cruise.

Sugarcube84 · 24/08/2022 14:26

I went on my first one aged 22 with my bf and parents, I didn’t think I’d like it like others I thought they were for old people but I loved it . I’ve done 3 now all Caribbean with P&O, Riyal Caribbean and NCL

They are a great way of see the islands without committing to a full holiday there.

Excursions are varied from cultural to active to simple beach trips or full island tours

Do some research before you go (cruise critic forum is great) and do your own beach trips/excursions, I now know the islands well enough to know which ones I’d do my own taxi to the beach and which ones I book an excursion

Dining options are great …self serve buffet, romantic meal for 2 in a speciality dining, sat with a group of randoms in the main restaurant have been fun and some of the best nights or even room service.

Confession I’ve never been to the shows!! Always spent time doing something else

the kids club is fantastic much better than any 5 star hotels I’ve been to

Ive done inside cabin and balcony, if you have loads of ports and not many at sea days save the extra and go inside.

lots to do on an at sea day. Pool, spa, movie, bingo, casino, talks on art/jewellery, Q&A with the captain, dancing, cooking presentations, live music etc etc

theres loads more but let’s just say we’ve booked our 4th for our honeymoon ☺️

basilmint · 24/08/2022 14:21

I think it's a good way to see lots of different places in one trip but I don't feel it would be for me. I don't like being surrounded by lots of people - we don't holiday in hotels for the same reason. My PIL went on one - supposed to be an upmarket one to the Norwegian fjords - they didn't like sharing a table at dinner and said some people took absolutely loads of food from the breakfast buffet so there wasn't enough for everyone.

omnishambles · 24/08/2022 14:20

Yeah I was horrified by the whole idea - after all aren't cruises for those sorts of people. Not MN people anyway. Then we went on one and I once again raised an eyebrow at my judgemental previous self.

I found it incredibly relaxing, punctuated with strenuous activities like hiking and kayaking. Plus it was low stress as teenagers could eat what they wanted and do what they wanted all day. Marvellous.

DoraSpenlow · 24/08/2022 14:16

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 24/08/2022 14:06

Also, I lived in the Caribbean for a while. When you're docking at a cruise port you're seeing nothing of the real place. Everything around the cruise dock exists to cater for cruise passengers. They're horrid places flogging overpriced tat and food catering for bland palettes, made even worse when hundreds of people descend en masse.

But you don't have to stay there. It is so easy to get a local taxi driver to take you on a tour of the island.

Wexone · 24/08/2022 14:12

Love love cruises - Going on my third one to Hawaii in a few weeks time. Done the med and the Caribbean. Its a great way to see places , without having to lug all your luggage each time, wake up every morning to a different port. I prefer Royal Caribbean and NCL over MSC . Staff are lovely too plus i tip them all. You can either sit and do nothing all day and night or party all day or night. There is enough food to cater to all taste's. I prefer the all inclusive as you have paid for everything up front so i know where i am budget wise. We got to see so many places that we wouldn't have seen other ways . I make sure now that we have a few days at sea or some overnight port stops. Like people said depends on what you want for a holiday but i love them and hope to go on more

burnoutbabe · 24/08/2022 14:08

I loved ones to Norway and through Alaska. And to Russia once with all Scandinavian capitals.

Love the variety of new place every day. Would hate a 1week in med one.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 24/08/2022 14:06

Also, I lived in the Caribbean for a while. When you're docking at a cruise port you're seeing nothing of the real place. Everything around the cruise dock exists to cater for cruise passengers. They're horrid places flogging overpriced tat and food catering for bland palettes, made even worse when hundreds of people descend en masse.

DoraSpenlow · 24/08/2022 14:04

abovedecknotbelow · 24/08/2022 13:56

I like the idea but imagine it's like AI even more contained. My parents love it, DH calls it a floating Petri dish of germs. I'm torn!

I don't understand why people think that a cruise ship is any more of a petri dish than any other hotel where there are lots of people. Yes, I've had noro on a ship but I've also had at an hotel.

The standard of cleanliness on ships has always been way, way higher than hotels I've stayed in.

2anddonefornow · 24/08/2022 14:03

We went pre children for 2 weeks P&O in the Caribbean, way too busy for us. Would love to cruise again but would need a more upscale/able to get your own space option. We were lucky to get into the quieter relaxing/swimming area and paid for a La carte meals each night else we’d have left early. Food was fabulous as was service & entertainment.

Appleblum · 24/08/2022 14:00

Yes definitely. Shell out for a suite and private dining and you're all set. It's very relaxing and because you dont have to plan itineraries and everything is at your doorstep.

ethelredonagoodday · 24/08/2022 13:59

We went on a Virgin Voyages test cruise (friend is a member of staff) and it was fun. Fully adults only, and high standard of accommodation and service.

Deadringer · 24/08/2022 13:57

I have only done Mediterranean ones and they included tips which was great, though we did give extra at the end to people who had been extra nice/helpful to us. We didn't do any days at sea so we spent a fair bit of time in each place, mostly Italy, Spain, the South of France, and some of the Islands, no organised itinerary at all, just wandering around seeing the sights and trying the local food. Bliss.

abovedecknotbelow · 24/08/2022 13:56

I like the idea but imagine it's like AI even more contained. My parents love it, DH calls it a floating Petri dish of germs. I'm torn!

KimberleyClark · 24/08/2022 13:55

can't see that I'd enjoy it - it seems like you'd only see the port city in each place and not much else, no time to visit the surrounding countryside, village markets, monasteries

Most cruises have a variety of excursions ranging from sporting/outdoor activity/hiking to city tours to countryside tours

DoraSpenlow · 24/08/2022 13:55

Hbh17 · 24/08/2022 13:42

Not for me. The large ships are just so ugly - like floating multi-story car parks.
All those people - the horror - especially if I'm expected to be sociable.
Evening "entertainment" and organised "fun" - shudder!
Not being able to see places properly - just herded off in a large group & taken round en masse wearing headphones - shoot me now!
Maybe when I get very ancient & decrepit (like about 90) I might change my mind but, for now, you couldn't pay me to go on one.

You've not been on one have you. The entertainment/activities are there for you to partake should you wish. No one rounds you up, straps you to a seat and leaves you there until said entertainment/activity has finished. Jeez.

There are tours from the ship if you want the security of being taken places. Personally DH and I usually either walk around a local town/attaction, get a coffee/ice cream and people watch, go to a local restaurant for lunch or get a taxi to take us to a beach or whatever.

brookstar · 24/08/2022 13:54

You’ll get a lot of people on here who have never been on a cruise telling you how awful cruises are though.
You were right!! 😂😂

My friend is on a cruise at the moment and she's been sending me pictures and videos.
It looks absolutely amazing!

It's made us want to do one for our holiday next year.

WireSkills · 24/08/2022 13:52

ItsSnowJokes · 24/08/2022 13:29

No! Depends on what cruise line you book with but I have never ever felt its like Butlins. I find them the most relaxing holiday and can just sit and chill as much as you want or go and do activities if you want.

Same. We use the daily itinerary that's put in your cabin each night to decide what we either want to do, or what we want to avoid (belly flop contest?? no thank you very much!).

We do lots of varieties of holidays:

  • UK self catering
  • US fly drives - some self catering, others in hotels
  • European package holidays
  • Cruises
We love all of them for different reasons.
  • The UK holidays are great, kind of relaxing, but never feel like we've truly been away
  • The fly drives tend to be full on and fun, but not relaxing
  • European package holidays are relaxing and no cooking required, but tend to get a bit "samey" and boring after a few days, even with lots of trips out
  • Cruises is a bit of the best of all of the above. Sailing from Southampton, so for us it's a 90 minute travel day then you're on holiday. A few sea days to truly relax (nothing like an afternoon nap on your balcony), sightseeing round lots of different places. Excellent dining (there are main dining rooms as well as a buffet if you want to avoid people piling their plates up!), excellent shows and entertainment.
They're really good family holidays if you go with the right cruiseline too. We've always sailed Royal Caribbean and love it. Would give P&O a try too though and we're currently researching a trip for next year.

P&O are more purse friendly - no separate tips to pay (though you might want to give extra to specific people), regular UK pub prices for drinks, you can bring your own drink on board if you want. RCI are more expensive as all of the opposite is true for them.

You could try a short UK cruise beforehand, but these do tend to be expensive per night and attract quite a lot of booze cruisers out for a party, so it's not really representative of a "true" cruise holiday.

Back to the "Butlins at sea" comment. Would I go to Butlins on an adult only holiday? Not a chance in hell. Would I go on a cruise? Abso-bloomin-lutely!

KimberleyClark · 24/08/2022 13:52

Not for me. The large ships are just so ugly - like floating multi-story car parks

Smaller ships look like ships.

All those people - the horror - especially if I'm expected to be sociable.

You're not.

Evening "entertainment" and organised "fun" - shudder!

You don't have to do any of that.

Not being able to see places properly - just herded off in a large group & taken round en masse wearing headphones - shoot me now!

Most attractions have audio tours whether or not you're a cruise passenger.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 24/08/2022 13:52

It's not for me because I like solitude on holiday so being around people isn't for me. I also absolutely hate being on a schedule and would feel really stressed by having a deadline to be back on board the ship.

ThreeKneeRepeater · 24/08/2022 13:51

Definitely give it a try, OP.
I wasn’t sure when we first started, but now I struggle to do a land based trip.
We have been all over the world and seen places I never dreamt I would see, such as Alaska, Antarctica, The Arctic Circle including the Northern Lights, Russia, seen glaciers and watched whales from my balcony, lain on Caribbean beaches and sailed round Cape Horn.
Have a think about what sort of cruise you think you’d like, what facilities you want on board, budget etc, then go and see a TA who specialises in cruises.
We started on Celebrity, which is still our ‘go to’ line, but there are so many types of cruise line all offering something different, and it’s crucial you try and get it right. I’d hate to be on a party party party ship, while other people love that.
Unpack once and open your curtains to a new place every day.

countrygirl99 · 24/08/2022 13:49

My mum convinced I would love a cruise but I don't even like staying in hotels, I'd rather camp or self cater and I like to go for long walks in the countryside and try small local restaurants so I'm sure she is wrong. What I have noticed is that people who like cruises are convinced that if someone doesn't fancy one it's purely because they haven't been on one. My mum is convinced I would be just as happy taking a walk on deck as hiking up.a mountain🤷‍♀️.