Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cruise or not to cruise

255 replies

Summerslam · 24/08/2022 12:39

Would you? Assuming you had the money and could afford it, does the idea of floating around the Mediterranean or Caribbean, for a week or two, appeal?

I've heard so many differing opinions. Personally, I think I'd like it. Just me and DH, on an adults only cruise.

What do you you think? Relaxing holiday visiting different places with no effort? Or akin to a sojourn on a prison ship, trapped with passengers you can't escape from?

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/08/2022 18:21

Felt Carrot at 56 you'd probably be among the younger set on "Fred", but that doesn't mean you wouldn't enjoy it; you might want to check out lots of reviews before you book though

If someone offered to pay for me to go on a cruise for free, or I won one in a competition or something, I'd certainly go and be grateful

Somebody did for me; I "won" one on Holland America's Ryndam through a cruise forum, on condition of doing a daily blog and photos.
Trouble is they probably wished they hadn't; it was a ghastly ship, 20 plus years old and showing every second of it, complete with constantly reheated food, curly sandwiches and god knows what else - a horrible experience I certainly wouldn't repeat even if they paid me

gogohmm · 25/08/2022 14:57

@XelaM

The ships are far more stable than ferries so I don't get seasick. We had 6m seas and it barely moved when I crossed the Atlantic (Queen Mary 2 is a liner rather than cruise ship so is shaped differently hence stability) whereas I felt terrible in similar seas going to Shetland on the ferry!

10HailMarys · 25/08/2022 14:45

If someone offered to pay for me to go on a cruise for free, or I won one in a competition or something, I'd certainly go and be grateful. But I can't imagine ever actively choosing a cruise over another holiday. Absolutely nothing against cruises and I can see why they would be perfect for some people, but just wouldn't be my ideal way of taking a holiday.

For me, the good elements would be being surrounded by the sea and stopping off at lots of locations. And I guess the convenience of just having all the facilities in one place and the all-inclusive type element would make everything feel pretty relaxing and hassle-free? I've never been all-inclusive so I'm not sure but that's what I'd assume.

But then I would really hate only having a limited time at each stop-off and having to back on the boat for a certain time. I probably wouldn't be at all into the entertainment either - I know it's all ultra professional and they put on proper full cast musicals and everything, but I'm usually really keen on that type of thing - and I'm also not really keen on sunbathing or lying by a pool for long periods, or doing organised group activities, so I think I would be bored. I like being able to explore places, being able to choose from loads and loads of different restaurants and cafes, wandering off the beaten track, not having to keep to a timetable etc. Basically I'd just want a lot more freedom than a cruise provides.

I also don't like the idea of being on the ship with the same people all the time and not being able to avoid them if they wanted to make conversation.

DuchessDarty · 25/08/2022 14:21

Thank you @lightisnotwhite that's very helpful!

burnoutbabe · 25/08/2022 14:20

I felt sick most times we did the North Sea from Southampton round to Stockholm or Norway. Passes after a day and now I just take tablets and plan a quiet day in cabin with ginger biscuits.

Snoken · 25/08/2022 14:12

KimberleyClark · 25/08/2022 13:38

Do you mean "our children" as a generalisation, ordo you actually have children? If the latter your post is a little ironic.....

I meant it in a general way. My children are adults now, and when I went on cruises as a child it was the 80's and nobody talked about the effect it had on the environment. Now that we do know how it impacts our oceans, I couldn't bring myself to do it. That's all I'm saying.

Blossomtoes · 25/08/2022 14:09

no one is trying to convince you.

They are. All my cruising friends incessantly tell us how wonderful they are and how much we’d enjoy them. No, we wouldn’t. Just shut the fuck up and leave us alone, we like the holidays we have, we don’t want yours!

ItsRainingPens · 25/08/2022 14:05

XelaM · 25/08/2022 09:30

How do people on this thread who love cruises deal with sea sickness?

I am very prone to travel sickness (car, buses, boats, planes), but I have never been sick on a cruise ship. I take a tablet before the ship sails and I usually find that by the time it’s worn off, I’m OK

KimberleyClark · 25/08/2022 14:03

Blossomtoes · 25/08/2022 13:40

akin to a sojourn on a prison ship, trapped with passengers you can't escape from?

That’s what we think it would be like so we wouldn’t do it. Another thing that puts us off is how evangelical repeat cruisers are. Please go on numerous cruises, enjoy them, have the time of your life but stop trying to convince me I’d love it. I wouldn’t because hell is other people - especially people like you!

As pp have said no one is trying to convince you. We just get fed up of people spouting crap about something they actually know nothing about.

Blossomtoes · 25/08/2022 13:40

akin to a sojourn on a prison ship, trapped with passengers you can't escape from?

That’s what we think it would be like so we wouldn’t do it. Another thing that puts us off is how evangelical repeat cruisers are. Please go on numerous cruises, enjoy them, have the time of your life but stop trying to convince me I’d love it. I wouldn’t because hell is other people - especially people like you!

KimberleyClark · 25/08/2022 13:38

Snoken · 25/08/2022 13:17

I have been on cruises as a child and really enjoyed it. Nowadays I am more environmentally conscious, so I would never set foot of one. It's heartbreaking the destruction they are causing. It's clear most people on this thread doesn't care about the fact that our oceans are dying, but I personally do as much as I can do not speed up the process so that maybe our children can have a better life for slightly longer.

Do you mean "our children" as a generalisation, ordo you actually have children? If the latter your post is a little ironic.....

DontBlameMe79 · 25/08/2022 13:34

Snoken · 25/08/2022 13:17

I have been on cruises as a child and really enjoyed it. Nowadays I am more environmentally conscious, so I would never set foot of one. It's heartbreaking the destruction they are causing. It's clear most people on this thread doesn't care about the fact that our oceans are dying, but I personally do as much as I can do not speed up the process so that maybe our children can have a better life for slightly longer.

Funniest thing I’ve read in a while 😂😂😂😂

TopGolfer · 25/08/2022 13:32

*It’s more likely to be a “party” cruise like a cheap long weekend.

I’ve found they attract a different demographic to longer cruises. Still I hope you enjoy it*
I did a short cruise this year over the May bank holiday, it was first P&O cruise. At first I thought it may be a bit cheap and cheerful but it turned out to be a lovely mini break. I paid to have dinners in different restaurants each night as a treat and did a fabulous trip in sunny Guernsey on an old fashioned bus which included some interesting stops and then an afternoon tea in a beautiful hotel with stunning views. Then after the trip my DH and I took regular bus around the whole island and I acted as tour guide telling him all the facts the actual tour guide had told us earlier. While i was having the cream and scones etc my DH had been on a walking war history tour and then we met up. It was such a fun day.
There were some excellent musicians on board, I particularly enjoyed the guy who sang Billy Joel songs. I went to a few different health seminars, an art auction for the free bubbly and had a couple of naps on the balcony.
The cruise cost £299 each!

gogohmm · 25/08/2022 13:29

Cunard all the way for us, like a bit of glamour

gogohmm · 25/08/2022 13:27

It's great. It's a road trip but you bring your hotel room with you and don't need need to do the driving! Added bonus is they drive it overnight so you wake up in a new place each day (often, check itinerary!) and you get stuffed with great food and you can dance the night away (to justify that foodGrin)

TopGolfer · 25/08/2022 13:23

I wouldn’t worry if the ship is full of older people, in my experience they are the most lively and fun the parents with young DC who are knackered and in bed early.

Snoken · 25/08/2022 13:17

I have been on cruises as a child and really enjoyed it. Nowadays I am more environmentally conscious, so I would never set foot of one. It's heartbreaking the destruction they are causing. It's clear most people on this thread doesn't care about the fact that our oceans are dying, but I personally do as much as I can do not speed up the process so that maybe our children can have a better life for slightly longer.

lightisnotwhite · 25/08/2022 13:04

thereisonlyoneofme · 25/08/2022 12:20

Ive booked on a short cruise next month. Im on my own and its my first cruise so Im doing a taster, think I can stand 4 days. Its on an adult only one, (old farts probably like me .) I looked at the Fred Olsen Norway ones and nearly booked but they are 7 days or more so might do that next if I enjoy this one.

It’s more likely to be a “party” cruise like a cheap long weekend.
I’ve found they attract a different demographic to longer cruises. Still I hope you enjoy it.

EarlofShrewsbury · 25/08/2022 12:50

FeltCarrot · 25/08/2022 12:33

@Puzzledandpissedoff It was me who mentioned Fred Olsen! We are 56, does that make us too young? 😂🤞🏻

Probably.

I've never sailed with them but I know people that have.

Most of their passengers are over 65 with most in the 75-80 range.

KimberleyClark · 25/08/2022 12:42

Fairislefandango · 25/08/2022 10:45

Why are some posters so defensive about cruising? If you like it, go enjoy yourself and don't worry about those of us who think it would be awful.

Because its annoying when people make things up about what they think it would be like and completely ignore all the information from people who have actually been on cruises! Choosing not to go on cruises is fine. Saying "Cruises are x, y or z' when you've never been on one and expecting cruise-goers to just nod along is silly. Especially on a thread where the OP is trying to ascertain whether they'd like one or not!

Well said.

FeltCarrot · 25/08/2022 12:33

@Puzzledandpissedoff It was me who mentioned Fred Olsen! We are 56, does that make us too young? 😂🤞🏻

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/08/2022 12:25

Plenty of places where you can book your own tours for much cheaper then the cruise line tours -ie alla tours in St. Petersburg

I just knew someone would mention Alla, who well deserve their excellent reputation - another is the brilliant Cosol Tours in St Lucia, and while the lines get a lot of sales out of suggesting you risk missing the ship with independents, a moment's thought teaches that anyone who stranded their tour guests would quickly be out of business

For whoever mentioned Fred. Olsen (god, that unnecessary full stop irritates me!!), do be aware that it has a more elderly demographic than many.
Once again this is where research is so important, since what suits one may not work for another

Another tip for newbies is to avoid the buffet on embarkation day and go straight to the main dining room for lunch ... so much more relaxing and a greater feeling of "I'm on board at last!!"

thereisonlyoneofme · 25/08/2022 12:20

Ive booked on a short cruise next month. Im on my own and its my first cruise so Im doing a taster, think I can stand 4 days. Its on an adult only one, (old farts probably like me .) I looked at the Fred Olsen Norway ones and nearly booked but they are 7 days or more so might do that next if I enjoy this one.

haggisaggis · 25/08/2022 11:36

Had our first cruise with MSC this year. Was not sure what to expect but we did enjoy it. Agree that you don't get enough time in port to really explore a place but it does give sufficient time to decide whether you will want to return. WE loved Stockholm so will definitely go back. We are not into organised entertainment. All our holidays for past 20 years have been self catering, self organised. But there is no pressure to get involved in anything. It is easy to find space around the ship for a quiet drink. The food was good in the restaurants. We found the buffet too busy for us but the food was good there - not motorway service station quality at all! You can opt out completely - we had pizza in our cabin one night as we fancied a chilled evening watching a movie in our PJs. No issue.

TopGolfer · 25/08/2022 10:48

Where is this mythical Butlins, I need to book
it? Does it move around, is it in Alaska, the Virgin Islands or closer to home?