Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Best before dates removal cynical ploy

37 replies

MeetthemoveratDover · 24/08/2022 11:24

So now ASDA along with Tesco, Waitrose, Morrisons etc. is the latest supermarket to remove best before dates.

In theory this should help reduce waste as we all know fruit and veg lasts longer than the bb dates on them.

But does anyone else think this is just a cynical ploy to sell produce on the turn? It’s going to be a licence for supermarkets to sell almost gone-off stuff.

At least with a best before date you can expect to get a good few days or even week in the fridge out of fruit and veg. Whereas with no date, you could get it home and it’s started to turn off or mouldy within a day or two. Will there be shelves of slightly dodgy fruit and veg now?

Surely given the price of food we should have some guarantee of its freshness when we buy it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThatsMsAtomicBob · 25/08/2022 16:23

Strawberries last a week if you store them in a glass container.

Anyway, best before does not equal use by. And food can go off before a use by date so people need to learn what food looks and smells like when it's off. And how to store it properly.

Food waste is a huge environmental issue.

TorviShieldMaiden · 25/08/2022 16:17

Sandinyourshoes · 25/08/2022 14:17

This annoys me as we get 3 2-pint bottles of milk a week, if there aren’t any dates we wont know in what order to use them so will end up pouring milk down the sink which they claim to be trying to avoid. If there is a use by date that would be ok, however at present it’s a use by date on milk so it looks like that’s what they are getting rid of.
I have heard mention of a QR code - are we gonna have to crouch in front of the milk crates with our phones to read the codes?
Similar for cheese, are we gonna have to freeze it to make sure it doesn’t go overripe before opening? I have different cheeses on the go, open at once.
And cheese doesn’t always smell off even when it is off, as I discovered to my cost. Not everyone has a good sense of smell either.
Maybe we’ll have to write the date of purchase on with a sharpie to at least give us a clue, although that’s no guarantee how long its been on the shelf before purchase.

DATES ON MILK WILL STAY, because they are use by dates, not best before dates. And this is the issue. People don't know the difference.

Giveaschitt · 25/08/2022 15:53

I think this is just indicative of how many people have lost the ability to judge freshness/quality themselves (confirmed by how many people throw things away based on an arbitrary date!). As a pp says, how would you cope with buying fruit and veg from a market stall where there are no dates at all? You go by look, feel etc. And yes, in a supermarket some items come in packs - but you can still always see what they look like, and usually give them a good squeeze as well.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 25/08/2022 15:28

I think it's a good idea. For things like strawberries, I only ever buy if I'm going to eat them that day or the next day. Buying them to eat three days later is just silly as they don't last- they aren't meant to, and I'd rather have some that go off quickly as opposed to chock full of chemicals to keep them going longer.
For other produce, its easy to tell if they are fresh or not, but again I will only buy fresh fruit and veg according to how much I will use and eat.

InsertPunHere · 25/08/2022 15:21

The number of grown men and women who don’t know the difference between Best Before and Use By is shameful.

Use By is about food safety.
Best Before is about quality and freshness. Food can be used perfectly safely after Best Before dates if stored well.

Bubblebubblebah · 25/08/2022 15:16

It's not like it's a brand new concept. How does tesco do it? I think they gor rid of bb on veg a while ago

sst1234 · 25/08/2022 14:33

Of course it is. Just like introduction of plastic charge was. These retailers save millions now as a result of not giving out bags. Nothing to do with the environment.

overitall1 · 25/08/2022 14:32

How will they do 'yellow stickers' if they don't know how close it is to going off?

Sandinyourshoes · 25/08/2022 14:17

This annoys me as we get 3 2-pint bottles of milk a week, if there aren’t any dates we wont know in what order to use them so will end up pouring milk down the sink which they claim to be trying to avoid. If there is a use by date that would be ok, however at present it’s a use by date on milk so it looks like that’s what they are getting rid of.
I have heard mention of a QR code - are we gonna have to crouch in front of the milk crates with our phones to read the codes?
Similar for cheese, are we gonna have to freeze it to make sure it doesn’t go overripe before opening? I have different cheeses on the go, open at once.
And cheese doesn’t always smell off even when it is off, as I discovered to my cost. Not everyone has a good sense of smell either.
Maybe we’ll have to write the date of purchase on with a sharpie to at least give us a clue, although that’s no guarantee how long its been on the shelf before purchase.

c3pu · 24/08/2022 22:56

This annoys me, I don't use the date to judge when I should eat/chuck out the food, I use it guage the freshness of the stuff when I buy it in the shop so I have the best chance of eating it before it declines.

I see the articles say the produce will have a code of some sort so the staff can guage "quality and freshness" - hopefully mere muggles like myself shall be able to decipher this mysterious code so I too can guage the quality, and freshness of what I'm buying...

MeetthemoveratDover · 24/08/2022 17:10

I’m also quite stringent about fruit and veg.

If you’re unlucky you can end up with strawberries or raspberries that go off in 24 hours. Ie. you start seeing mould on them the next morning. Or asparagus within 48 hours going slimy on the tips (yuk). All those mostly come in packages.

Usually I look for the longest BB dates it often does make a difference. Of course I’m capable of telling if it’s ok or not to eat it. I just want it as fresh as possible with the highest nutrient content and you get variations even now. I just think it’s going to get worse and be a license for shops to sell stuff right up to the point of being well past it’s best.

As pp said it’s more that it’s a guarantee of a few days freshness.

OP posts:
Mountainhike · 24/08/2022 12:58

This thread has just proved exactly why best before dates need to go.


  1. many don’t know the difference between bb dates and use by dates

  2. people a lost the ability to use all their senses when shopping.


look at the food you’re buying. People are saying how will they know if the foods good without a date on it. I’ve had to throw away food during the heat wave that was still within its use by date. It had gone off prematurely due to the heat. If I’d followed the best before date I’d have made myself sick eating spoiled food. Other times I’ve used food after it’s bb date because The food was fine.
The dates are meaningless.

Bluesky2507 · 24/08/2022 12:31

But surely you just look/feel the fruit and veg when you pick it? I mainly buy loose fruit and veg and never had any problem with it going off quicker.

Sparklingbrook · 24/08/2022 12:30

I think it’s a good idea to get rid of Best Before dates on some stuff.. And from what I can gather staff will still be looking at the fruit and vegetables etc to see if still in good condition.

NCHammer2022 · 24/08/2022 12:26

Dotjones · 24/08/2022 11:40

YANBU. When buying milk for example I can look at the use by date to tell whether I can buy four pints now to last me the week, or if I need to buy two pints today and come back for more in a few days. Without the date information I have no idea whether the milk is going to be OK for a week or will turn tomorrow.

At least with fruit and veg I can handle them to gauge how fresh they are. Can't see Morrison's being happy with me opening up the milk to sniff it before I buy, even if I do, that's shortened the life of it anyway.

And that’ll still be there, because that’s a use by date. This is about bbe dates. People not being able to tell the difference is precisely why they’re being done away with.

ComtesseDeSpair · 24/08/2022 12:25

If you buy anything from a market or grocer (or the loose section of the supermarket fruit and veg) then you’re reliant on your eyes to gauge freshness. Perhaps it will be a good thing and push more people to buy that way rather than wrapped in lots of wasteful plastic.

NCHammer2022 · 24/08/2022 12:25

Use your own judgement when you’re picking your fruit and veg. Nothing goes from not-quite-ripe to past it overnight (except sometimes avocados, temperamental bastards). You can tell by the look and feel of stuff roughly how long it’s going to last.

TorviShieldMaiden · 24/08/2022 12:24

A woman in my office throws out everything at best before date. Drives me nuts- I had to put labels on my stuff to say not to throw it out. I will eat yoghurts past the use by date as long as they smell/taste ok.

She once threw chocolate away. Scandalous!

Bubblebubblebah · 24/08/2022 12:24

Firty · 24/08/2022 12:23

Mixed feelings… DH always insists on throwing away veg/fruit when ita reached the best before date even if it is completely fine. Drives me nuts.

But yes I expect the shops are doing this so they can sell older food without consumers noticing. ☹️

People like your dh are exactly the reason for this 🤷🏻

Firty · 24/08/2022 12:23

Mixed feelings… DH always insists on throwing away veg/fruit when ita reached the best before date even if it is completely fine. Drives me nuts.

But yes I expect the shops are doing this so they can sell older food without consumers noticing. ☹️

Bubblebubblebah · 24/08/2022 12:21

Cheeselog · 24/08/2022 12:20

Pears only come loose don’t they?
Salad and berries are not meant to last all week.

Yup

Bubblebubblebah · 24/08/2022 12:21

Honestly, it's because half a population couldn't figure out the clear difference between best before and use by dates. It will prevent waste. Just look at the veg and that's it. Nice plump strawberries will not go mouldy next day.

Cheeselog · 24/08/2022 12:20

Pears only come loose don’t they?
Salad and berries are not meant to last all week.

SparklyLeprechaun · 24/08/2022 12:16

RealBecca · 24/08/2022 11:55

Yabu. You can tell how fresh something is by looking at it. Want a ripe and ready pineapple - buy one which releases its leaves easily. If you want one to last, buy one that doesn't. Want an apple that will last? Buy one that isnt wrinkling and put it somewhere cool and dark (many are harvested from last year before they hit the shops). Want a banana to last? Buy one that's green.

Just get back in touch with what the produce tells you rather than BBE dates which were invented by M & S to market freshness.

Sure, that works for potatoes, pineapples, bananas and apples, but when was the last time you bought loose salad, strawberries or grapes or pears? Stuff like apples or potatoes or carrots are not an issue anyway, as they last for ages, but I really want to know that the strawberries that look fine in their box today won't go mouldy tomorrow.

The BB date may have been invented by M&S, but society is not going to go back to the shopping habits of 60 years ago, when housewives were shopping for produce several times a week. When I buy food, I want some guarantee that it will last for a few days, then I'll happily eat it if it looks fine after its BB day.

L0bstersLass · 24/08/2022 12:10

Dotjones · 24/08/2022 11:40

YANBU. When buying milk for example I can look at the use by date to tell whether I can buy four pints now to last me the week, or if I need to buy two pints today and come back for more in a few days. Without the date information I have no idea whether the milk is going to be OK for a week or will turn tomorrow.

At least with fruit and veg I can handle them to gauge how fresh they are. Can't see Morrison's being happy with me opening up the milk to sniff it before I buy, even if I do, that's shortened the life of it anyway.

It's the best before date they're removing, not the use by date.