Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH letting 5 month old shout / call

94 replies

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 10:45

Here is the scene setting.

Baby just turned 5 months
Me working full time but from home
DH on SPL looking after baby

DH tends to leave baby shout or call (not actually crying but shouting loudly) now and then. Basically he puts baby down and then goes off to do something. When the shouting continues and also keeps getting louder I very often come and pick up the baby. DH is annoyed saying baby needs to ‘learn’ and if DH was here alone there would be no-one to pick the baby up anyway as DH would need to finish what ever is he doing.

Me: not sure how much will a baby learn at this age from being left unattended

DH: I’m interfering and keeps repeating the line if he was here alone

Who thinks the baby will learn anything from this?

Who thinks if you have a small baby you need to accept that certain things you just will need to do in a rush or half do whilst being interrupted?

At what age do you think you can start thinking about ‘trying to teach the baby something’ such as you need to learn to wait.

OP posts:
MyneighbourisTotoro · 24/08/2022 12:51

YABU your dh is doing just fine! Babies make noise. I cared for both of mine with 0 help, when I had my second I had to leave one of them to shout, moan or even cry sometimes as I had to finish what I was doing with the other.
If your baby is safe then there’s no harm in what your DH is doing.
I also find it odd that you are referring to your child as it?

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 12:41

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 11:09

DH is not neglecting the baby and I agree in general with the views that I should DH let get on whit it.

However, at times it turned out baby was actually hungry but it was being assumed that it’s just being loud.

And also agree it should be enough to just pop in and reassure the baby, push toys closer, but DH probably does that 50/50 maybe less. I’m not saying to pick up straight away but if shouting is escalating intervene?

No, don’t intervene. Your DC and DH need to establish their own communication patterns. Your DH needs to learn when louder noises tip over into distressed sounding calls, so he can respond to them. Your DH is never going to learn this if you constantly intervene.

Your DC also needs to learn that his calls can and will bring his dad to him at a certain point. This builds a trust bond between your DC and DH…which if you keep inserting yourself into won’t happen.

In addition, you are inadvertently teaching the DC if he wants YOU and not dad, he need only to shout that much louder. And at 5mos old they know the difference between mum and dad and will express a preference if offered a choice. They also are clued in enough to understand that doing x will bring me mum or bring me dad. They also are quite good mimics and will have undoubtedly noticed you calling loudly to each other in the house even though they do not have language/words yet.

You may be encouraging the loud calls because the DC now thinks that’s how I get the mum when dad is busy.

rainbowmilk · 24/08/2022 12:41

dworky · 24/08/2022 12:31

If it was the father working from home, the mother would be doing everything in her power to keep the baby quiet, but no, it mustn't be expected of a revered man, must it?🙄

I saw one thread on this and the DH was roundly recommended to get back to the office and that the home was for his children, not for him. So don’t worry, your imagined scenario is just that.

Hugasauras · 24/08/2022 12:40

Also I WFH in the evenings when I'm not on mat leave and also accept there will be noise while he's doing bedtime etc. Unless it sounds like the apocalypse I leave them to it.

Hugasauras · 24/08/2022 12:39

DH works from home a lot of the time and we behave no differently whether he's here or not! If it's too loud for him he can go to the office 🤷‍♀️ but he accepts that he is working in the family home with two young kids present.

Tiredalwaystired · 24/08/2022 12:38

You’re at work, he’s parenting, baby not distressed.

You’re being unreasonable.

luxxlisbon · 24/08/2022 12:35

dworky · 24/08/2022 12:31

If it was the father working from home, the mother would be doing everything in her power to keep the baby quiet, but no, it mustn't be expected of a revered man, must it?🙄

I actually don’t think that is true, nor should it be anything to aim for. OP is working in their home, he isn’t looking after the baby in her office. If normal domestic life is too loud and distracting for OP she should go into an office.
A baby will make noise, sometimes it will cry, sometimes shout. It’s just part of life.

StillGoingStrongToday · 24/08/2022 12:34

dworky · 24/08/2022 12:31

If it was the father working from home, the mother would be doing everything in her power to keep the baby quiet, but no, it mustn't be expected of a revered man, must it?🙄

Can you please start your own thread to discuss your issues?

girlmom21 · 24/08/2022 12:33

dworky · 24/08/2022 12:31

If it was the father working from home, the mother would be doing everything in her power to keep the baby quiet, but no, it mustn't be expected of a revered man, must it?🙄

You shouldn't do everything possible to keep a baby quiet. I certainly didn't. They're learning to communicate.

dworky · 24/08/2022 12:31

If it was the father working from home, the mother would be doing everything in her power to keep the baby quiet, but no, it mustn't be expected of a revered man, must it?🙄

rainbowmilk · 24/08/2022 12:29

What do your workplaces think about this? You’re paid to be working but seem to spend half your time parenting, and he’s paid to be parenting leave but seems to spend half of his time not parenting as you’re trying to do it for him.

There’s a real lack of trust that you have in him as a parent, which is weird because presumably you decided he’d be a good one when you both decided to have a child together. He needs to learn what you already know, and he can’t do that if you keep interfering. It must be driving him bananas.

(And yes, everyone I know with a baby has watched not-kids TV with said baby yelling in their arms.)

StillGoingStrongToday · 24/08/2022 12:28

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 11:09

DH is not neglecting the baby and I agree in general with the views that I should DH let get on whit it.

However, at times it turned out baby was actually hungry but it was being assumed that it’s just being loud.

And also agree it should be enough to just pop in and reassure the baby, push toys closer, but DH probably does that 50/50 maybe less. I’m not saying to pick up straight away but if shouting is escalating intervene?

But why, when he is the one looking after the baby, should your way precedence?

Seriously, you are interfering with his parenting and undermining him, you need to stop this.

LoveMeForARaisin · 24/08/2022 12:21

Lol my daughter used to shout and bawl at me when she was that age. Not unhappy, not needing anything. Just experimenting with her new found voice. I remember taking her out to the garden in her bouncy chair to put the washing out and the neighbours laughing because she was shouting to me and clearly really believed she was talking. Ah I miss those days 💔

now she’s 7 and actually does shout at me 😂

PinkButtercups · 24/08/2022 12:21

Also why do you keep referring to your child as an it? Wtf

PinkButtercups · 24/08/2022 12:19

The baby is not crying? He isn't distressed just shouting like most 5 months old do.

Hugasauras · 24/08/2022 12:18

GiftIdeasAlwaysNeeded · 24/08/2022 11:27

Ok, I’m going to give this one away as well, sometime DH is actually holding the baby but DH is watching TV (not kids TV) and baby is shouting in his arms.

There's nothing wrong with this! I'm currently on ML and sometimes DH works from home. If he started on me because the baby was making noise while I'm trying to watch Hart of Dixie on catch up he'd be given short thrift from me Grin

Ha I am on mat leave and just finished bingeing Hart of Dixie Grin

Tbh god only knows the noises DH hears when WFH! He wisely stays out of it unless it sounds like someone is being murdered then he offers assistance Grin But yes, sometimes one or other child (or both) is shouting or annoyed while I finish doing something or make myself some food or a cup of tea 🤷‍♀️ But I wouldn't get anything done otherwise. I'd be annoyed if DH appeared to make helpful remarks for 5 mins and then pissed off back to his office with closed door and no kids screaming at him.

greywinds · 24/08/2022 12:17

How much longer is DH on leave for? You have different parenting styles and it's so hard to wfh with the baby there.

Is your dh generally playing with the baby and taking them out? Is it one point in the day when he's expecting to do chores or have downtime?

No, I wouldn't like it either if I felt my baby was escalating for attention and nobody was responding - ok for one hour of the day, not ok if it's multiple times per day.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 24/08/2022 12:13

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 12:07

Serious question. How many parents leave their babies shout and let them escalate the shouting (emphasise yet again escalate) whilst they watch TV themselves (This one is not about my DH now).

Genuinely curious.
They don’t pass them a toy to play with, they don’t check why the shouting is escalating, they just continue watching the TV (probably not being able to hear properly anyways through the shouting).

Are there many?

I would because i probably know why they are shouting if i am looking after them. To be honest at that age i would have probably plonked DD back on a play mat on the floor with some toys instead of holding her.

If she wasn't crying or upset then leave them to it

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 12:07

luxxlisbon · 24/08/2022 11:59

Ok, I’m going to give this one away as well, sometime DH is actually holding the baby but DH is watching TV (not kids TV) and baby is shouting in his arms.

This can’t be serious!

Serious question. How many parents leave their babies shout and let them escalate the shouting (emphasise yet again escalate) whilst they watch TV themselves (This one is not about my DH now).

Genuinely curious.
They don’t pass them a toy to play with, they don’t check why the shouting is escalating, they just continue watching the TV (probably not being able to hear properly anyways through the shouting).

Are there many?

OP posts:
NCHammer2022 · 24/08/2022 12:05

You’re undermining your DH’s parenting. If the baby is not actually crying, not actually distressed, I think you either need noise cancelling headphones or to work outside the home.

converseandjeans · 24/08/2022 12:05

I don't think I could work with a noisy baby in the next room.

Why not have a set feed time so he doesn't get worked up? We did this and they never had to call out for food. Might also be getting hungry if you're sticking to guidelines of 6 months for solids. Maybe try some baby porridge.

girlmom21 · 24/08/2022 12:04

Sometimes because it was offered the bottle already, it is assumed it is not hungry but actually probably just needed further calming down…

I don't think shared parental leave is working for you. You're not prepared to let your DH learn what you already have.

Innocuousname · 24/08/2022 12:03

"It"? Saying he or she is not going to out you.

I think you need to back off and let them establish their own routines and relationship. If being there but not being in charge is too distressing for you then deal with that, can it be changed? Do you resent your roles? It must be hard if you wish it were the other way around.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/08/2022 12:02

luxxlisbon · 24/08/2022 11:59

Ok, I’m going to give this one away as well, sometime DH is actually holding the baby but DH is watching TV (not kids TV) and baby is shouting in his arms.

This can’t be serious!

Important skill for future life, shouting at the telly. It equips them for the world of social media, too.

luxxlisbon · 24/08/2022 11:59

Ok, I’m going to give this one away as well, sometime DH is actually holding the baby but DH is watching TV (not kids TV) and baby is shouting in his arms.

This can’t be serious!