Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH letting 5 month old shout / call

94 replies

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 10:45

Here is the scene setting.

Baby just turned 5 months
Me working full time but from home
DH on SPL looking after baby

DH tends to leave baby shout or call (not actually crying but shouting loudly) now and then. Basically he puts baby down and then goes off to do something. When the shouting continues and also keeps getting louder I very often come and pick up the baby. DH is annoyed saying baby needs to ‘learn’ and if DH was here alone there would be no-one to pick the baby up anyway as DH would need to finish what ever is he doing.

Me: not sure how much will a baby learn at this age from being left unattended

DH: I’m interfering and keeps repeating the line if he was here alone

Who thinks the baby will learn anything from this?

Who thinks if you have a small baby you need to accept that certain things you just will need to do in a rush or half do whilst being interrupted?

At what age do you think you can start thinking about ‘trying to teach the baby something’ such as you need to learn to wait.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChateauMargaux · 25/08/2022 14:29

@fannyfan It's just a personal observation and obviously a vaste generalisation, but I see parents ignoring their children and anything going on around them, sometimes telling them off when they are hurt, there is a tendency in schools to let kids sort their own dramas out in the playground rather than teaching them skills, parents are not encouraged to stand up for their children and I have seen parents call the police on their teens because they 'needed to learn'.

Chickpea11 · 25/08/2022 13:38

@Calphurnia88 agree with the comments about parenting styles (as also some other posters suggested).

Also a good advice to discuss now what do we think about any future parenting approaches and agree on overall general approach. Funny enough from previous conversations my husband was the one who would be more inclined to bribe with sweets etc whereas I’m more of the idea that once they are able to comprehend the world around them children should learn that they can’t have everything.

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 25/08/2022 12:45

Immaterialatthispoint · 25/08/2022 08:41

I would hate this level of interference and superiority. You come across as sure you know best. Genuine question- do you believe mothers always know best?

you say yourself the child is not neglected. You also say the child isn’t crying or distressed. But it’s not enough for you, is it?

you have to dress up getting involved as “helping” your husband. If you are going to interfere, prove how much better you are at this than him, then at least own it. Don’t jazz it up pretending you are “freeing” your husband up to finish what he was doing.

You seem way too invested in this. If OP was that sure she knew best, she wouldn't be canvassing opinion on here would she?

@Chickpea11 I think this boils down to different parenting styles. I identify more with your approach and thinking i.e. a responsive parent builds a secure attachment, which in turn paves the way for independence (paraphrasing but plenty online about this). Your partner obviously thinks he's teaching baby a lesson by not responding.

This is going to come up many more times as your child grows up, so I think you need to have an open and honest conversation with DP about what is important to you as a parent and what you think good parenting looks like.

Maybe discuss a few examples... What is your stance on sleep training? How would you deal with a tantrumming toddler?

You don't have to follow exactly the same approach but there are probably some fundamentals you need to align on.

Chickpea11 · 25/08/2022 09:29

@Immaterialatthispoint i don’t think mothers always know best. You get mothers who abuse their children and also well meaning mothers who want the best for their child but actually it might not be the best thing for said child. In my view the same applies for fathers.

OP posts:
Chickpea11 · 25/08/2022 09:11

ChateauMargaux · 24/08/2022 22:37

I live in France and have a totoally diffferent take on 'le pause'... but yeah.. if your DH's attitude is to toughen your 5 month old up so he fights for what he needs rather than developping attachments and emotional stability.. he is on the right track.

This also expresses my concern rather well. I would like our child to grow up to be a confident and emotionally stable individual. Which is why when I hear what I consider increasingly escalating calls that are unanswered I go and answer them.

Or we are going to raise a little Donald Trump. Ok - exaggerating of course but liked how the poster put it ‘toughening up, fight for what you need’. Although, I guess, he pretty much got most things he wanted in his life, give him that 😂.

Genuine comment. I can’t quite tell if the posters are saying they feel that for a 5 month old baby or younger (the age is key) not tending to them as soon as possible, in ideal world (not talking about limitations such as other children around etc.) when their shouting and calling continues escalating (continues escalating key again) is beneficial to those babies’ development. Or people got a little too focused on the ‘interfere’ and got a bit wound up.

OP posts:
Immaterialatthispoint · 25/08/2022 08:41

I would hate this level of interference and superiority. You come across as sure you know best. Genuine question- do you believe mothers always know best?

you say yourself the child is not neglected. You also say the child isn’t crying or distressed. But it’s not enough for you, is it?

you have to dress up getting involved as “helping” your husband. If you are going to interfere, prove how much better you are at this than him, then at least own it. Don’t jazz it up pretending you are “freeing” your husband up to finish what he was doing.

fannyfan · 25/08/2022 08:13

@ChateauMargaux can you explain your take on it? Genuinely interested

ChateauMargaux · 24/08/2022 22:37

I live in France and have a totoally diffferent take on 'le pause'... but yeah.. if your DH's attitude is to toughen your 5 month old up so he fights for what he needs rather than developping attachments and emotional stability.. he is on the right track.

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 22:03

Flowersintheattic57 · 24/08/2022 20:06

Your baby has very limited ways of communicating with you and your partner, to shout or not to shout. Ignoring him until he’s distressed teaches him that he needs to make a lot of noise to be heard.
Later on, when your partner is looking after your toddler or small child and asks why does he whinge constantly you can tell him that is due to his early training!
of course there is a line between jumping to attention at every squawk and giving it a few minutes to see if attention is needed. The French call it ‘Le pause.’
If your partner’s friend is talking to him, how many times would they have to say his name before he answered? 22? Why is it different with his child?

I think this pretty much summarises where I’m coming from. Maybe that’s not how it necessarily works but that’s what my instinct is telling me.

OP posts:
Flowersintheattic57 · 24/08/2022 20:06

Your baby has very limited ways of communicating with you and your partner, to shout or not to shout. Ignoring him until he’s distressed teaches him that he needs to make a lot of noise to be heard.
Later on, when your partner is looking after your toddler or small child and asks why does he whinge constantly you can tell him that is due to his early training!
of course there is a line between jumping to attention at every squawk and giving it a few minutes to see if attention is needed. The French call it ‘Le pause.’
If your partner’s friend is talking to him, how many times would they have to say his name before he answered? 22? Why is it different with his child?

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 19:43

@greywinds yep, I’m sure you are right with the first paragraph and agreed with the last.

OP posts:
SultanOfSwing · 24/08/2022 17:43

At five months babies already know a lot and can learn a lot. For parents’ sanity one of the things they need to learn is bed time (and nap time).

I’d say crying babies need to be seen to pretty quickly (like after 5 minutes, waiting a bit just in case they settle themselves) but shouting babies can be left. And I can certainly understand your husband’s irritation as long as you are both agreed that if it actually escalates to real crying one of you will see to him.

greywinds · 24/08/2022 17:38

@Chickpea11 it certainly won't be the last parenting disagreement you'll have! It's always a negotiation.

Btw I tend to agree that a 5 month old can't wait significant amounts of time and that needs must isn't always the ideal standard.

Sometimes it's good to have two parenting styles, you're two people after all. I'm much softer than my DH but we agree and back each other on the key things (having learned the hard way!).

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 17:29

@greywinds as you suggested a lot of it will be parenting style. I’m very much of the view that a 5 month old benefits from interaction when appears to be asking for attention repeatedly (or for that matter was asking for food on multiple occasions as we have learnt 😁)

DH more in the learn to wait camp (accompanied by if I was here alone, if there was another child - my point is, agreed, but that is not the scenario) But I do agree that a child should learn how to self entertain and wait, but the way how it’s done now doesn’t look like it’s working, in my view because of age.

So I step in (not every day) when shouting continues escalating, not at every shout or whimper. I do that because I’m here and I can, as in my view this also gives DH room to finish what ever he is doing.

Anyways, as said, was interested to hear what approaches people take with their up to 5 months old babies.

OP posts:
greywinds · 24/08/2022 16:42

it's also hard to judge exactly how much alone time your DH is having from your posts @Chickpea11 - if he's ignoring the baby for big chunks of the day that would be pretty concerning. If he's doing chores once a day for a short window, not so much.

ChateauMargaux · 24/08/2022 16:37

I wil go against the grain and hold my hand up to say I am further along the spectum towards attachment parenting than many respondants on this thread.

My babies are teenagers and I still respond to them when they express their needs even if I cannot understand what they mean. I do not claim to be the perfect parent and am far from it but I do believe that babies benefit from interaction more than they benefit from learning things alone.

I do not believe that babies need to learn to be alone at 5 months. They benefit from interaction.

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 16:02

Thanks for all the opinions.

I’m actually more in the don’t make your child clingy camp, as well as I think the early years are important in terms of development (I.e. stimulate them enough to keep the brain growing but also give them plenty of room to self explore).

Appreciate that from a relatively short post it is hard to judge how much constant interference and undermining is actually happening (and most likely me and DH would have different views). It’s not an every day thing, but enough to bother my husband, which I don’t want.

When ever I do ‘interfere’ it’s always thinking about what would be best for the baby’s development - not saying that I’m always right. Which is why I was interested to know what people do with their babies up to 5 months of age.

On a side note, interesting how some people feel quite strongly about watching TV and are worried about my performance at work.

OP posts:
MsSquiz · 24/08/2022 13:58

dworky · 24/08/2022 12:31

If it was the father working from home, the mother would be doing everything in her power to keep the baby quiet, but no, it mustn't be expected of a revered man, must it?🙄

@dworky no actually. And if they do they must be exhausted from doing that!

When DH worked from home during lockdown, if he had an important call, he would time it around a nap or when I could take her out for a walk.
If not, he would start the call with "just to let you know we have a 4 month old baby, so apologies if there's any background noise"

MsSquiz · 24/08/2022 13:52

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 11:22

One, hopefully last addition from me, to clarify, I do not rush to pick him up every time. I only pick him up if the noise is escalating and it sounds like baby is getting distressed (And I also start feeling somewhat distressed by it), and also I only pick him up if I need to get on with work whilst DH is finishing what ever is he doing. Other times, when the same scenario described above is happening I pop in and just push some toys closer or talk a bit, rather than pick up and go back to my desk.

Ok, I’m going to give this one away as well, sometime DH is actually holding the baby but DH is watching TV (not kids TV) and baby is shouting in his arms.

I spent yesterday sitting on the floor folding a huge basket of laundry while my 4 month old sat shouting away in her bouncer chair next to me. We were both watching an episode of Real Housewives...

I was multitasking, baby likes to shout, everyone was happy enough.

I couldn't do the laundry later as I then had to collect DD1 from nursery and she definitely requires a lot more attention.

That doesn't make your DH (or me) a bad parent.
He isn't ignoring the baby for hours on end while she screams blue murder. Some babies at this age especially love to hear their own voice! DD2 spent 20 mins "chatting" (shouting) at a cuddle George pig this morning.

I think you need to let your DH parent as you would expect him to allow you to, without interfering

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/08/2022 13:35

Chickpea11 · 24/08/2022 12:07

Serious question. How many parents leave their babies shout and let them escalate the shouting (emphasise yet again escalate) whilst they watch TV themselves (This one is not about my DH now).

Genuinely curious.
They don’t pass them a toy to play with, they don’t check why the shouting is escalating, they just continue watching the TV (probably not being able to hear properly anyways through the shouting).

Are there many?

Yes, of course you do.

They're in your arms or within easy reach of a few steps (unless you've dropped them off in the West Wing whilst you're in the Orangery), they're safe, they're not crying, they're just making noise because that's what babies like doing.

Why would you want to shut them up by distracting them from an important physiological learning process every single time it happens? They're fine, you get to learn when they are self settling or needing something other than the satisfaction and pleasure of making noise, they get to learn how to talk.

Calphurnia88 · 24/08/2022 13:24

So I have a 5mo...

I think this really depends on two things:

  1. How often and for how long DH leaves baby to their own devices (by this I mean baby is left to entertain themselves with the odd cursory glance). I do think babies need time to play and explore independently, but they also need stimulation and interaction, especially from their primary caregivers. It's about balance, and if I felt DP was ignoring our baby for long periods I would be miffed. I agree with what PP said about babies wants/needs being the same, and a call or cry for attention (if that's what it is) shouldn't be ignored IMO. At that age their brains are no way near developed enough to understand that Mummy and Daddy aren't responding because they're trying to teach them a lesson in independence, they simply learn to stop calling or crying because they learn that Mummy and Daddy don't respond (which to me is a bad thing).
  1. The noises that DC is making. My 5mo is almost constantly making noises, some of which sounded alarming at first but we quickly realised was just him practising his voice. You know your baby though, and if you think these noises are signalling an impending meltdown then I can see why you would intervene as IME meltdowns don't get any better by ignoring them.
SunnyD44 · 24/08/2022 13:16

Ok, I’m going to give this one away as well, sometime DH is actually holding the baby but DH is watching TV (not kids TV) and baby is shouting in his arms.

So the baby is a shouter anyway then.

In that case YABU to go in and intervene when the baby is shouting or crying knowing that they’re not distressed.

I ran to my baby the second she made a noise and if I could go back I would definitely be more like your DH as she turned into a very clingy child.

How long is DH leaving him?

10 minutes whilst he’s making dinner is a lot different to 2 hours watching TV.

Are you concerned for your child or is it distracting you from wfh that’s the problem?

NewMum0305 · 24/08/2022 12:59

Discovereads · 24/08/2022 12:41

No, don’t intervene. Your DC and DH need to establish their own communication patterns. Your DH needs to learn when louder noises tip over into distressed sounding calls, so he can respond to them. Your DH is never going to learn this if you constantly intervene.

Your DC also needs to learn that his calls can and will bring his dad to him at a certain point. This builds a trust bond between your DC and DH…which if you keep inserting yourself into won’t happen.

In addition, you are inadvertently teaching the DC if he wants YOU and not dad, he need only to shout that much louder. And at 5mos old they know the difference between mum and dad and will express a preference if offered a choice. They also are clued in enough to understand that doing x will bring me mum or bring me dad. They also are quite good mimics and will have undoubtedly noticed you calling loudly to each other in the house even though they do not have language/words yet.

You may be encouraging the loud calls because the DC now thinks that’s how I get the mum when dad is busy.

This advice is spot on (and I say that as a mum who found (and still finds) it really difficult to ‘let go’ and just leave my husband to take his own approach to parenting our little one).

GiltEdges · 24/08/2022 12:57

YABU. Leave your DH to parent in his own way and concentrate on what you’re supposed to be doing i.e. working.

Also, appreciate it isn’t relevant, but why all the “baby” and “it” references, when one of your posts indicates your DC is a “him”? Just say him! Grrrrr

Annaritanna · 24/08/2022 12:57

MyneighbourisTotoro · 24/08/2022 12:51

YABU your dh is doing just fine! Babies make noise. I cared for both of mine with 0 help, when I had my second I had to leave one of them to shout, moan or even cry sometimes as I had to finish what I was doing with the other.
If your baby is safe then there’s no harm in what your DH is doing.
I also find it odd that you are referring to your child as it?

Yes, same here, DS1 was 2 when i had DD, i had to leave her shouting for a while several times while we were doing potty training 😂
Also we would never eat a single meal if i pick my kids up everytime they are calling.

Of course it is different if the baby starts really to cry and is distressed.