Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
Allywill · 24/08/2022 23:15

It’s supporting it by topping up the wages of the people who work there to a level that they can survive on. The owners are therefore able to pay a (very) minimum wage and so create a level of profit that wouldn’t otherwise be there. It has been suggested that if they had to pay an increased minimum wage then they would go to the wall which further suggests that customers do not value their product enough to pay the market level price that it should charge to cover both profit and actual costs. It’s a little like someone running a hobby business from home, but people will only pay enough to cover the basic costs of raw materials. It’s a hobby not a viable business, sorry about the cutesy comment, it was flippant and I can see why it annoyed.

TheHateIsNotGood · 24/08/2022 23:14

Another factor to consider is that many in employment positions of 'responsibility' actually enjoy and prefer these positions irrespective of pay and would not only be bored shitless 'behind a supermarket till' (the current fiction considering this the 'benchmark' job) but would really miss being in charge/responsible for their, and others', work and the 'kudos' involved. And just be a little cog in a big wheel instead?

Ooo methinks that whilst declarations of "I've trained, studied, worked my way to a position of responsibility/power" has some merit - it's not just for the paypacket that these positions are sought, it's for the 'power' too.

So I suggest the power-seekers get £17.50 an hour whilst the menials get £15.

Jellykat · 24/08/2022 23:05

How is your tax supporting the 'cutsey' Hmm independent shop i work in Allywill?
(interesting description, its never been called that before, but presume away..)

Allywill · 24/08/2022 22:51

Florenz · 24/08/2022 22:44

If having to pay staff a decent wage would mean they have to shut down, then they don't have a viable business. The end of slavery in the US meant a lot of plantations weren't viable and had to shut down. Nobody now would say that was a bad thing.

In any case, millions of people would have a lot more disposable income if NMW went up to £15. Businesses would flourish.

Indeed. My tax dollar is supporting your cutesy independent shop. This is not the purpose of taxation. It should be used to redistribute wealth and provide public services that benefit all like decent housing and universal health care.

Florenz · 24/08/2022 22:44

Jellykat · 24/08/2022 22:31

The little independent shop i work in, would have to close if NMW went up to £15 hour, as would thousands of others.
I really wouldnt want to see that happen (or lose my work)!.. Towns around here would be left with a Spar, and Lloyds the chemist .. oh and the odd estate agent!
Independent shops are vital for so many towns.

If having to pay staff a decent wage would mean they have to shut down, then they don't have a viable business. The end of slavery in the US meant a lot of plantations weren't viable and had to shut down. Nobody now would say that was a bad thing.

In any case, millions of people would have a lot more disposable income if NMW went up to £15. Businesses would flourish.

Lunar270 · 24/08/2022 22:44

Allywill · 24/08/2022 22:16

What people fail to understand is that if wages are so low that they require to up benefits - everyone is taxed at a higher rate than would be be necessary in a fully functioning market economy. We are basically propping up business models that are economically non viable. The money that is going in top up benefits could be spent on the nhs and improving services for all. I don’t want crumbs from the govt table. I want to earn enough to pay bills and support my family on a full time wage. It’s not a ridiculous ask.

I agree.

It's a sad state that the government allows large corporations to pay pittance and rely on the taxpayer to subsidise wages, all whilst paying out huge dividends to shareholders.

What we need are more companies that operate a John Lewis model (or at least how they used to operate), where staff are partners, earn a ratio of the CEO and receive a share of the profits. Although even with their business model, you'd still have to raise the minimum wage.

stayathomer · 24/08/2022 22:40

It's not about working harder- people in low paid jobs work exceptionally hard.
Yes, and in many ways tougher jobs, a lot would be physically demanding, with loads of pressure and less job stability and zero perks!

Jellykat · 24/08/2022 22:31

The little independent shop i work in, would have to close if NMW went up to £15 hour, as would thousands of others.
I really wouldnt want to see that happen (or lose my work)!.. Towns around here would be left with a Spar, and Lloyds the chemist .. oh and the odd estate agent!
Independent shops are vital for so many towns.

Florenz · 24/08/2022 22:24

laurenlodge · 24/08/2022 22:09

How is unpaid overtime (common in lots of jobs) being factored into this? A professional might earn 40k but doing a 50 hour week. Why would I do that when I could earn 30k doing a standard 37.5 hour job where I can just clock out?! The maths doesn't math.

Employers would have to either have to stop expecting employees to work unpaid overtime, or pay them an increased rate for the extra hours they work.

goldfinchonthelawn · 24/08/2022 22:18

laurenlodge · 24/08/2022 22:09

How is unpaid overtime (common in lots of jobs) being factored into this? A professional might earn 40k but doing a 50 hour week. Why would I do that when I could earn 30k doing a standard 37.5 hour job where I can just clock out?! The maths doesn't math.

I've often thought this. If you average out the hours and the responsibility and stress in some mid-salary jobs, they become way less desirable. If you are on 90k but regularly work a 60 hour week and only manage to get 2 weeks off a year and a few days at Chrostmas, you're only on £30ph. If the same is true on £45k, then the stress isn't worth £15ph.

Allywill · 24/08/2022 22:16

What people fail to understand is that if wages are so low that they require to up benefits - everyone is taxed at a higher rate than would be be necessary in a fully functioning market economy. We are basically propping up business models that are economically non viable. The money that is going in top up benefits could be spent on the nhs and improving services for all. I don’t want crumbs from the govt table. I want to earn enough to pay bills and support my family on a full time wage. It’s not a ridiculous ask.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 22:15

Then you should earn £50k. It's all good.

laurenlodge · 24/08/2022 22:09

How is unpaid overtime (common in lots of jobs) being factored into this? A professional might earn 40k but doing a 50 hour week. Why would I do that when I could earn 30k doing a standard 37.5 hour job where I can just clock out?! The maths doesn't math.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 22:00

But if you're not paying your own employees a decent wage while you're "helping" then you're just creating more hungry people/draining state funds.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 21:59

@JaceLancs With the reduction in working benefits a higher MW would bring, the Govt would have to increase support for charities like yours, as they would in funding for adult social care and for pay rises across the NHS.

Pay differentials have to be maintained, as does incentives for business owners, what does need to change is the vast pay given to some, at the expense of the many.

With very high inflation, the £15 min wage might be nearer than we think.

JaceLancs · 24/08/2022 21:53

@DigitalGoat totally agree
I am head of a small local charity - our income is precarious at the best of times and when we get awarded grants the amount is fixed
If we had to pay higher wages all I could do would be make people redundant or reduce their hours which would just mean we could help less vulnerable people (which we do free of charge)
We are already struggling with increase in other costs eg utilities
For anyone above who intimated businesses etc would just have to become more efficient and make savings elsewhere I would love you to work in the voluntary sector for even a few weeks and show me how to do so
We provide essential services - free or at very low cost and are genuinely not for profit - every extra penny we bring in just allows us to help more people

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 21:48

toomuchlaundry · 24/08/2022 21:11

Some senior managers/partners have to put their own money into businesses/take out loans at their own risk, to help build up businesses, employ more people . Would all workers be happy to take that risk?

As a pp said, everyone who works in a business takes the risk that it may go under. Only a few take the reward when it doesn't.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 21:43

Hit return somehow!

Anyway, 2.5m millionaires in the UK, almost 200 billionaires with a newt wealth of 590 billion.

A wealth tax of 1% would give an awful lot to 3 million low paid or better still fund a different tax system, that benefits the poor not the wealthy, who every single year just keep getting richer.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 21:40

@Iamthewombat

How many ‘CEOs etc’ earning many hundreds of thousands do you think that there are ?
Let’s say that there are 10,000 people in the U.K. earning at least £500k per year. You take £300k per annum off each of them, presumably before tax so that’s a load of income tax revenue gone, and somehow redistribute it as a boost to minimum wage
Can you do the sums? In case not, I will. You’d get £3 million. Add up the zeros. Let’s say that there are 1 million people working for minimum wage. How much extra would they get per year? If it helps, divide 3 million by 1 million. The answer is an extra £3 per year. Each
This has been explained so many times on this thread. It’s depressing

Yet again, your're the one who needs to do the math and learn some basic figures on earnings.

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 21:28

toomuchlaundry · 24/08/2022 21:11

Some senior managers/partners have to put their own money into businesses/take out loans at their own risk, to help build up businesses, employ more people . Would all workers be happy to take that risk?

Any employees of those people are taking a risk albeit a smaller one, but also with a smaller reward i.e they actually receive their wages when the business risks don’t pay off and they go bust.

there’s no room for gratefulness, everyone enters into a fairly simple contract.

hamsterchump · 24/08/2022 21:24

toomuchlaundry · 24/08/2022 21:11

Some senior managers/partners have to put their own money into businesses/take out loans at their own risk, to help build up businesses, employ more people . Would all workers be happy to take that risk?

No, do these partners understand that the increased reward they expect also comes with increased risk? Why should their pipe dream be propped up by the tax payer and slave labour? What makes them so special besides being self obsessed narcissists?

toomuchlaundry · 24/08/2022 21:11

Some senior managers/partners have to put their own money into businesses/take out loans at their own risk, to help build up businesses, employ more people . Would all workers be happy to take that risk?

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 21:03

and to add to that - if wages hadn't been cut in real terms by 33% over 0 years then the average wage would be £30k =33% so would be £40k

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 21:01

The minimum wage should pay enough to live a decent life, buy a modest house, go on holiday once a year, run a car, raise a child etc. Those with higher education, special skills etc should earn more but not THAT much more.
How much more do you suggest?

average house cost is around £250k so to be able to afford that with a 10% deposit and 3x earnings on two wages I guess from the post, so £40k

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 20:59

are actually unlikely to get paid holiday

that would be illegal, holiday pay must be paid in the uk