Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 25/08/2022 11:15

So everyone's pay goes way up?

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 11:13

So it does look like the TUC WANT people in skilled jobs to be earning not that much more than people on minimum wage.

it never ceases to amaze me that people apparently have zero idea of what unions actually do or want. A large part of discussions about wages and T&C are about pay differentials. That is pretty much the lifeblood of a union. And it is one reason why they weren't entirely on board with equal pay.

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 11:10

But why does minimum wage have to be £15 or nothing?

it’s not the case, NMW is already set at £9.50 per hour for those over 23 years old

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 11:08

dianthus101

I’ve had nurses commuting 25 miles due to not being able to afford to live in the area they are working, rents far to high and unable to get council property

private renting means that the agents decide what’s “affordable” and often one wage is not affordable for renting

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 11:03

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 10:14

r. If pay is not enough to provide a socially acceptable level of income, it's the job of the benefits system to fill the gap.

it is not the job of the tax payer to artificially prop up a business by topping up the unliveable wages

It's enough for single people to live reasonably comfortably in most areas of the country though. The top up benefits are for those who are trying to support more than one person on a minimum wage.

Ilovemycatalot · 25/08/2022 10:19

But why does minimum wage have to be £15 or nothing? Yes it should increase but maybe not as much as £15 for the reasons others have stated.

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 10:14

r. If pay is not enough to provide a socially acceptable level of income, it's the job of the benefits system to fill the gap.

it is not the job of the tax payer to artificially prop up a business by topping up the unliveable wages

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 10:10

Rents are determined by what people can afford to pay. What people are paid is determined by the value of their labour. Saying pay must adjust to rents has things backwards, the flow of money is in the opposite direction.

you’ll find in some areas many vacancies for menial jobs. If people can not afford to live in an area due to high rents, then carers, nurses etc will not work in those areas or be very few about. Rural areas are constantly pricing younger people out of the area - so they move away.

Cornwall and Devon are examples of lack of staff due to lack of affordable rental homes. Every other pub and cafe has signs up for staff. It’s not just those staff but carers, nursing staff that are needed but they can’t live their due to rents

antelopevalley · 25/08/2022 09:14

And women and black people were not paid less because their labour was worth less. They were paid less because society used to socially support that and legally employers could get away with it.

antelopevalley · 25/08/2022 09:12

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:52

Also, there is no "should" about what someone can afford. Labour is worth what it's worth, it may or may not pay enough to avoid cold and hunger. If pay is not enough to provide a socially acceptable level of income, it's the job of the benefits system to fill the gap. Artificially inflating pay rates (as a solution) is just throwing sand into the gears of the economy.

What labour is worth is an artificial concept.
If we had no benefits system at all, very elderly people could end up working for a meal. That is not what their labour is worth, that is simply desperation.

RedToothBrush · 25/08/2022 08:53

It turns out that:

John Rentoul @ JohnRetoul
To be fair, the TUC demand is for a £15 min wage when the median reaches £20

^ www.tuc.org.uk/blogs/we-need-15-minimum-wage^

Whats interesting is this paragraph:
Raise the minimum wage target to 75% of median wages
Secondly, the TUC believes government should raise its target for the minimum wage. The current target is 66 per cent of median wages by 2024. The obvious next step is 75 per cent.

Since it was introduced, the minimum wage has increased as a proportion of the median wage. The wage floor was introduced at 47 per cent and is now on its way to 66 per cent by 2024. As unions predicted, the evidence continues to show a positive effect on wages and no job losses.

So it does look like the TUC WANT people in skilled jobs to be earning not that much more than people on minimum wage.

It talks about wages and no job loses but it DOESNT talk about labour shortages in key areas.

It should. Thats the really bit challenge with this idea.

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:52

Also, there is no "should" about what someone can afford. Labour is worth what it's worth, it may or may not pay enough to avoid cold and hunger. If pay is not enough to provide a socially acceptable level of income, it's the job of the benefits system to fill the gap. Artificially inflating pay rates (as a solution) is just throwing sand into the gears of the economy.

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:49

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 06:19

Incidentally my local MP has just been on telly echoing what ive just said about local businesses in our rural area not being able to afford £15 hour.

so how much is the rent or average house price in your rural area? Can some working on minimum wage at £9.50 x 40 afford to rent a property and put food on the table or will they go hungry & cold?

Rents are determined by what people can afford to pay. What people are paid is determined by the value of their labour. Saying pay must adjust to rents has things backwards, the flow of money is in the opposite direction.

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:40

Wheretheskyisblue · 24/08/2022 10:25

Rather than a minimum wage how about a maximum ratio of say 10 between the highest and lowest 10% of wages. That way company bosses are encouraged to increase the wages of the lowest paid at the expense of profits, things are more equitable and wages do not fuel inflation.

I'm retired, living on my DC pension. Those profits are my income. Why should my income go down so workers income can up?

(All magical left-wing solutions to economic hardship assume there is some pot of money belong to other people that can be raided with no adverse consequences. Apparently all problems can be solved by finding an ill-defined group of other people who don't matter, and grabbing their money. Although I think economic illiteracy is the prime reason for this type of thinking. The idea that because profits of a given organisation are a large number that means they must be excessive seems to be accepted by everyone, in threads like these. It's utter nonsense. Profits are a return on capital, and when you average them across time, companies and countries, are in the vicinity of 5% a year, but with huge variability, so they are in fact worth less to investors than a fixed 5% interest rate would be.)

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 08:37

So, say we accept that businesses are just not viable if they can't afford to pay their staff at least £15 per hour. Based on the median salary, this will mean wage increases for more than half of the employees in Britain. Those who are already earning £15+ per hour will presumably expect their wages to go up as well, as they may no longer be willing to carry additional responsibilities if they are only getting minimum wage.

Loads of businesses - especially SMEs which employ a large proportion of the workforce - will be unable to afford that, and so they will fold. Others will pass on the increase in costs to customers in order to survive. The cost of running public services will rise substantially. Most charities will go under.

As vast numbers of businesses close due to no longer being viable, or cut staff in order to reduce their costs, unemployment will rise significantly.

With income tax receipts down as a result of mass unemployment, and corporation tax down as a result of large numbers of so many businesses no longer being viable, how are we going to raise enough money to pay for all of the extra benefits that will be needed to support people who have lost their jobs, and how are we going to cover the vastly increased costs of running public services? I guess we could whack up income tax for the people who are still employed on £15+ per hour, but wouldn't this wipe out the benefit of increasing their pay in the first place?

Instead of forcing employers out of business by making them pay wages that simply aren't affordable, wouldn't it make more sense to increase the income tax threshold so that people earning less than £15 per hour didn't have to pay tax on what they earn? And increase the tax on higher earners in order to balance out the loss to the Treasury?

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 08:12

You need a two pronged policy to make this even vaguely work.

Agree which is why i keep banging on about you have to completely rethink. UBI is a good place to start - could be handled via the tax and benefits system which would pretty much cover everyone on PAYE. Self employed and other would have to apply.

But the points about businesses not being viable if they can't afford to pay the NMW are valid. And it doesn't matter if staff are having their wages topped up by the government, a munificent benefactor or by doing 3 other p-t jobs. The fact is that if the business requires 2 members of staff plus the owners - let's say 80 extra paid-for hours a week - it doesn't matter if it's 4 people doing 20 hours or any combination: they still can't cover the NMW.

There are very good arguments for government help for small and new companies, and this too should be possible (via the tax system probably since the infrastructure is already there)

As for managers/owners having invested sometimes everything - them's the risks. Because the rewards can also be very good. Are they evenly sharing out those with their workforce? Any employee takes a risk when they hitch their wagon to a company. Way back when i was last applying for jobs i paid more attention than ever to doing due diligence on prospective employers, and i wasn't shy about asking probing questions at the interview stage. I've turned down offers from companies i believe to be on less than solid ground and i do know of one that has unfortunately (pre-covid) gone under.

Unpaid (expected) overtime is a whole other can of worms.

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/08/2022 06:39

Our current inflation isn't demand led. Its imported & due to supply restriction.

The theory about rising wages creating more inflation only really applies where inflation is demand led.

Prices will rise anyway. All that raising minimum wage will do is enable people to not starve and stay warm this winter.

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 06:19

Incidentally my local MP has just been on telly echoing what ive just said about local businesses in our rural area not being able to afford £15 hour.

so how much is the rent or average house price in your rural area? Can some working on minimum wage at £9.50 x 40 afford to rent a property and put food on the table or will they go hungry & cold?

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 00:59

I earn less than £15 per hour in my degree educated NHS role. Plus I work several unpaid hours each week. If minimum wage rises to the same level I am paid I will quit in an instant and go and do a job where I don’t have peoples lives in my hands and all the stress and responsibility that comes with that.

XenoBitch · 24/08/2022 23:54

Whatever the minimum wage is, it should be enough for some to have a decent standard of living.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 23:49

Allywill · 24/08/2022 22:16

What people fail to understand is that if wages are so low that they require to up benefits - everyone is taxed at a higher rate than would be be necessary in a fully functioning market economy. We are basically propping up business models that are economically non viable. The money that is going in top up benefits could be spent on the nhs and improving services for all. I don’t want crumbs from the govt table. I want to earn enough to pay bills and support my family on a full time wage. It’s not a ridiculous ask.

I DO actually agree with that.

But you can't just switch to an alternative system from the position we are now in with identifying where they'd be a problem because you would need further adjustments too. Particularly around those not in work for whatever reason or working in the public sector / essential services.

You need a two pronged policy to make this even vaguely work.

antelopevalley · 24/08/2022 23:47

If minimum wage is £15 an hour, lots of other jobs that are currently £15 an hour will not be able to recruit staff. So either everyone's wages below about £50k need a decent wage increase, or we accept lots of semi-skilled jobs will become impossible to recruit to.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 23:39

Flutterbybudget · 24/08/2022 19:51

A wage of £15/hr would pay around £31,200 for a 40hr week, 52 weeks a year. Remember that many minimum wage earners do not have set hours contracted, and are actually unlikely to get paid holiday/ sick leave on those hours, so would be lower than that. Now consider a wage of £31,200 (before tax) that’s £25,000 take home, and service bills in excess of £6,000, not counting housing costs, water, council tax, childcare costs, etc, etc

Currently, many are earning low wages, topped up by the taxpayer, through Universal credit and housing benefits. The question is, who should pay the “real” wage of a worker? The taxpayer, or the employer? My argument is that if your business doesn’t bring in enough for you to pay a wage sufficient for your employees to survive on, then you don’t have a viable business. Why should YOU (not aimed at any individual, general question) be taking home huge sums of money, while the tax payer subsides your wages bill/ running costs?

Your argument completely ignores the public sector and privately run services which perform essential services on a very thin profit margin. Like nurseries and care homes. Things that are already closing because they aren't viable financially. Yet we still have demand for them. Just not the means to pay higher wages for them.

Thats the problem. You can't just put up wages without making massive adjustments elsewhere too in parallel with that change.

And that does need to be highlighted and talked about rather than just having lazy soundbite ideas for policy that are social media friendly but shit in practice.

Jellykat · 24/08/2022 23:36

Allywill · 24/08/2022 23:15

It’s supporting it by topping up the wages of the people who work there to a level that they can survive on. The owners are therefore able to pay a (very) minimum wage and so create a level of profit that wouldn’t otherwise be there. It has been suggested that if they had to pay an increased minimum wage then they would go to the wall which further suggests that customers do not value their product enough to pay the market level price that it should charge to cover both profit and actual costs. It’s a little like someone running a hobby business from home, but people will only pay enough to cover the basic costs of raw materials. It’s a hobby not a viable business, sorry about the cutesy comment, it was flippant and I can see why it annoyed.

Again, presumptuous, there are 3 of us working there part time (along with the 2 owners) none of us are have our wages 'topped up', us 3 employees work in many other jobs too.
The owners have been in business for over 30 years and live very frugally above the shop, they charge realistic prices for the market believe me. A section of the shop has a very rapid turnover, others slower as they're more specialist/ collectors items.
But what with rising outgoings its a fine balancing act these days.

Incidentally my local MP has just been on telly echoing what ive just said about local businesses in our rural area not being able to afford £15 hour.

Allywill · 24/08/2022 23:28

its possibly useful when the business is very new and trying to become established, maybe then you could argue that some level of government support could be helpful to fledgling new businesses but it is not a justifiable long term strategy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread