Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
Allywill · 25/08/2022 14:59

justasking111 · 25/08/2022 14:36

It did in the 70s I know coz I was there. The benefits buffer was much less then so it's an interesting experiment this time round

there was increasing unemployment in the 70s but that is generally attributed to opec and oil price pressures. the equal pay act came in in dec 1975 and the actual rise of unemployment was less the year after. for example the unemployment increase from 74-75 was +1.1% the increase from 75-76 was less at 0.9%.

Crikeyalmighty · 25/08/2022 14:51

@Brefugee I see you've kicked off the crikey almighty/brefugee manifesto

If I can add to it

No person undertaking state medical/dentistry training allowed to go into the private sector for 10 years

Bring back DIYSO - shared ownership housing on the open market (not just new builds) via housing associations

Childcare subsidised at scandinavian levels for 9 months plus.

No company allowed to buy out another company by simply loading the new company with massive debt.

No CEOs of any public authority/service/charity allowed to be on over £250k a year

No private school to retain charitable status unless at least 10% of places are free.

justasking111 · 25/08/2022 14:36

Allywill · 25/08/2022 14:29

the argument that business will go bankrupt and price will just go up and negate any ruse was the same argument that people used when the minimum wage was brought it. in actual fact neither of those things happened or at least happened in any significant way. Similar arguments have been made all thorough history whenever anyone proposed a improvement in workers rights or benefits. equal pay for women? madness! business won’t be able to afford it, and women will just lose their jobs! did it happen? no.

It did in the 70s I know coz I was there. The benefits buffer was much less then so it's an interesting experiment this time round

Allywill · 25/08/2022 14:29

the argument that business will go bankrupt and price will just go up and negate any ruse was the same argument that people used when the minimum wage was brought it. in actual fact neither of those things happened or at least happened in any significant way. Similar arguments have been made all thorough history whenever anyone proposed a improvement in workers rights or benefits. equal pay for women? madness! business won’t be able to afford it, and women will just lose their jobs! did it happen? no.

ThrallsWife · 25/08/2022 14:06

I wonder how many more minimum wage jobs would disappear from Britain if the NMW were raised to that level.

Call centre roles are already heavily outsourced, mostly to India. With the massive increase in tech to allow WFH over the course of the pandemic, what is stopping any large corporation from taking all NMW jobs which can largely be done remotely and moving them abroad? Or replacing even more staff with machines, as is already happening to cut staffing costs?

Our school is part of a MAT. The first jobs to go will not be TAs - it will be HR, exam and admin staff, with one central person or small team overseeing the work that is normally done in individual schools. It's already happening, in part, as our HR person is only on site twice a week, as is the IT team, and any pressing issues need to be addressed with HQ in London (we are nowhere near London). So processes are less efficient, more mistakes are being made as no one knows anyone anymore, but in terms of staffing out MAT has saves a few £100k.

This would also be a heavy blow to manufacturing and almost guarantee that we, as a country, become even more reliant on imports.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 14:06

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 25/08/2022 13:58

You have a guarenteed pension and other jobs perks such as holidays, in addition to a £15 phour minimum.

Most on minimum wage are on 0 hours and rarely get any perks

You are being rather 'I'm alright jack' in your attitude

People on zero hours contracts should still receive holiday pay. it's normally added onto the hourly rate.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 25/08/2022 13:58

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:39

@Branleuse this is exactly what I meant, there needs to be a limit of profits made, which would destroy the capitalism structure. That's never going to happen as those fat cats run the country essentially via lobbying/being chummy with government.

You have a guarenteed pension and other jobs perks such as holidays, in addition to a £15 phour minimum.

Most on minimum wage are on 0 hours and rarely get any perks

You are being rather 'I'm alright jack' in your attitude

Badbadbunny · 25/08/2022 13:56

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 12:31

Also, I presume that you realise that, while people will have more money to spend in real terms, companies will push up their prices in order to recoup the increased costs, so people's actual buying power won't necessarily increase by very much at all?

Meanwhile, the people who lose their jobs while their employers go under will have less to spend than ever.

And as wages rise, benefits such as UC and tax credits will fall (as they're income based), so people won't have as much increase in wages as they expect. So lots of damage done in terms of businesses closing down and public sector/charities making redundancies, but not as much increased spending power so more unemployment and those lower earners in work losing some of their benefits!

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 13:47

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 11:08

dianthus101

I’ve had nurses commuting 25 miles due to not being able to afford to live in the area they are working, rents far to high and unable to get council property

private renting means that the agents decide what’s “affordable” and often one wage is not affordable for renting

What is the solution? Nurses aren't paid minimum wage so raising the minimum wage isn't going to help. If anything it will increase the chance they will quit their jobs. If small businesses fold it's not going to decrease the amount taxpayers pay as those people will probably be unemployed.

CheapBeersFilledwithCrocodileTears · 25/08/2022 12:45

@Believeitornot is absolutely right. What the OP is pointing toward but maybe not quite reaching is saying that the entire system is broken and no, raising minimum wage does not automatically fix it for the myriad reasons pointed out by other posters. It’s akin to the way many employers worry about employees stealing and have double-validation systems, constant CCTV of their own employees, etc, in factories and professional workplaces, when the truth is that the biggest type of theft is wage theft committed BY employers TOWARD their employees, to the tune of £35 billion in the UK in 2019 alone. And that figure doesn’t even include the companies registered abroad who may be the most egregious offenders, and in addition, pay no taxes. Then you’ve also got between 300,000 and 580,000 not even being paid the National minimum wage by these companies: tribunemag.co.uk/2021/11/wage-theft-karl-marx-capitalism-workers-bosses-labour

We wouldn’t be having this discussion if the system wasn’t broken because the real issue is that people can’t live on what they’re being paid, and a minimum wage increase is a shoddy sticking plaster for that. Instead, maybe if all the tax loopholes were closed, and all the wage theft stopped, and everyone was given everything they earned, and windfall taxes were charged to companies that tried to raise prices for basic commodities like electricity beyond what people could afford while also claiming huge profits and fat CEO bonuses, people either wouldn’t need £15ph to be the minimum wage, or every wage could be set on a fair scale and people would still be able to eat and heat their homes, not just trying to fix a single set of wages at the bottom and not pretend like everything’s not broken top to bottom.

And no, the benefits system is not supposed to be there so that our taxes can cover corporate wage theft, not enacting windfall taxes on corporations when we should, not closing corporation tax loopholes to the tune of trillions, or to make up for higher prices caused by all those things as well as CEOs that all agree to pay each other more, etc (and yes, CEOs sit on each others’ boards of directors and approve each others’ large payrises). But sadly, yes, that’s what benefits have to be used for now, and that’s not the fault of benefit claimants. But it is the fault of the government at large. And they think a minimum wage increase will just shut everyone up. It comes down to this:

They wouldn’t offer this minimum wage increase unless it was cheaper for the Tories and their corporate masters than all the things they SHOULD be offering instead: windfall taxes on corporations, capping the amount energy companies can charge since that’s what worries people most at the moment, other limits on corporate profits, new tax regulations on foreign corporations, etc.

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 12:38

But why should Amazon be allowed to exist in the form that it does?

In theory i have no issues with huge corporations. I do have massive issues with:
a) a government that allows tax avoidance and offshoring on an industrial scale
b) a govenrment that doesn't get maximum utility from the taxes it does manage to collect
c) a government that invests so much of it's resources chasing benefit claimants vs what it allocates to tax avoidance
d) a government that rejects out of hand, instead of giving it a proper evaluation, UBI
e) a government, and society, that only considers success in terms of how much money an individual makes. That undervalues the public good that the NHS, the education sector, the care sector, carers etc do over and above the actual cost of what they provide
f) a government that sits by and lets privatised utilities and industries that should be in private hands (there is a good case to be made for including telecoms/post services in that list) rather than renationalising them and paying attention to efficiency
g) related to f, a government that does not understand what a natural monopoly is and how it needs to be regulated
h) a government that perpetuates the class war and allows the gap between the haves and have-nots to contiunally widen
i) a government that does not recognise the benefits of good industrial relations, and yes, that includes things like unions, workers councils and representation of minorities (and women - because let's face it, we are not a minority we are just marginalised for historical reasons) at board level

much much more though

I literally don't care which government it is - but these are basics for me.
(yeah - vote for me - i PROMISE i will be a benevolent dictator)

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 12:31

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 12:27

So enlighten us... what new business models are going to replace the huge number of employers whose business would no longer be viable? What jobs are all those people going to do when they are made redundant?

Also, I presume that you realise that, while people will have more money to spend in real terms, companies will push up their prices in order to recoup the increased costs, so people's actual buying power won't necessarily increase by very much at all?

Meanwhile, the people who lose their jobs while their employers go under will have less to spend than ever.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 12:27

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 12:13

YABU

Any business model that requires people to earn poverty wages is not a viable model. I don’t care if that’s a small or large business. It is not viable.

Why should those on low wages effectively subsidise the success of capitalism?

A higher minimum wage is a good thing because it means people have more money in their pockets to spend on things other than essentials. Eg luxuries, better food, sports, holidays. Which benefits their mental and physical health and has so many great knock on effects.

I have no sympathy with those bleating that their business would fold without paying their staff a pittance. It means the business is not a good business model.

So enlighten us... what new business models are going to replace the huge number of employers whose business would no longer be viable? What jobs are all those people going to do when they are made redundant?

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 12:24

Thelnebriati · 25/08/2022 12:12

Can most of us agree that the taxpayer shouldn't be subsidising wages for large, established companies while upper management in those same companies receive large salaries and bonuses?

I would think most people could probably sign up to that. I think most people, too, would probably agree that we should close tax loopholes that enable large corporations to profit from UK business without paying a fair amount of tax etc.

Personally, I'm totally on board with making the rich pay higher taxes, with taxing corporate profits more, and with taking the lowest paid out of taxation altogether. I would also support a modest rise in the national minimum wage.

What I would not support is the massive hike that's being proposed here to a nmw of £15 per hour, because I believe that it would be counterproductive. It would just push more people into unemployment, public services would inevitably deteriorate due to lack of sufficient funding, and the third sector which currently provides much-needed support for the most vulnerable would all but collapse. I can't see how that benefits anyone.

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 12:17

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:52

Also, there is no "should" about what someone can afford. Labour is worth what it's worth, it may or may not pay enough to avoid cold and hunger. If pay is not enough to provide a socially acceptable level of income, it's the job of the benefits system to fill the gap. Artificially inflating pay rates (as a solution) is just throwing sand into the gears of the economy.

A very naive point of view. Labour costs are not natural laws like say, the law of gravity. Labour costs are set by businesses. As you go further up the chain, you’ll see that CEOs are paid high wages because other CEOs agree that they should get high wages (and then claim “it’s just the market”).

Utter bullshit.

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 12:15

Badbadbunny · 25/08/2022 11:49

@beachcitygirl

And it's the small businesses who employ roughly half of the UK workforce and roughly a third of the turnover (sales) of the private sector. They're the ones who ARE paying taxes etc.

If they fail and close down (i.e. your local corner shop, your local cafe, etc)., then their trade will be taken over by larger/international firms who arguable DON'T pay their full share of UK taxes.

So the Treasury could well see much lower tax revenues from a further shift away from small firms to large firms.

Do we really want more Starbucks/McDonalds rather than independent cafes??

Do we really want Amazon to get an even bigger market share when even more small shops/small manufacturers go bust?

Be VERY careful what you wish for.

But why should Amazon be allowed to exist in the form that it does?

If everyone was paid better wages - except those who have excessive wealth who need to be paid less - then we could afford the higher prices that small businesses would need to charge.

Having large, overly wealthy businesses, who push the wages down creates massive problems for those smaller businesses. The answer is not to let the smaller businesses follow the same approach of rip off wages.

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 12:13

YABU

Any business model that requires people to earn poverty wages is not a viable model. I don’t care if that’s a small or large business. It is not viable.

Why should those on low wages effectively subsidise the success of capitalism?

A higher minimum wage is a good thing because it means people have more money in their pockets to spend on things other than essentials. Eg luxuries, better food, sports, holidays. Which benefits their mental and physical health and has so many great knock on effects.

I have no sympathy with those bleating that their business would fold without paying their staff a pittance. It means the business is not a good business model.

Thelnebriati · 25/08/2022 12:12

Can most of us agree that the taxpayer shouldn't be subsidising wages for large, established companies while upper management in those same companies receive large salaries and bonuses?

beachcitygirl · 25/08/2022 12:03

Sorry didn't realise I had to provide a full blue print for economic policy here.

We should be demanding of our elected officials that the loop

Holes which allow multi-national Corps to not pay their taxes or corporation taxes are closed.
We should not tolerate elected officials who are involved in off shore behaviours.

Raise taxation to huge levels on the very very rich & raise the thresh hold at which tax has to be paid.

Raise unemployment benefit to median wage.

To be honest I'd introduce UBI but that's a different thread.

Yup tax the ultra rich. Oh and while I'm at it stop allowing off shore individuals to buy up property & huge swathes of land as investment.
I live in Scotland & people are forced far out of villages and family support as some want pretty holiday cottage investments.

Oh and shut that Airbnb shit right down.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 11:57

Badbadbunny · 25/08/2022 11:44

@beachcitygirl

If your idea of "non viable" businesses fail, then that just puts more people on the dole claiming all their income from benefits, not just a portion, so cost the taxpayer billions more. If businesses fail, they're not paying VAT, PAYE, NIC, income/corporation tax, so less money paid to the government to pay the additional dole costs!

What about organisations that aren't "businesses", such as charities, public sector, schools, NHS, etc - how do they afford to pay the increase in wages? Presumably you don't want them to fail, so they'll also need more money from the taxpayer.

So you'd have to increase taxes on those who've had a pay rise from the increase in minimal wages, making them probably little better off, in fact, probably not better off at all as with their higher wages, they'll be eligible for less UC/tax credits so maybe they won't have any more money at all.

But, in the meantime, you've caused huge numbers of businesses to fail and squeezed the non profit sector!

@beachcitygirl has already confirmed that she doesn't care if charities fail. She thinks that the state should pick up the tab for providing services to vulnerable people.

I'm not unsympathetic to this view at all. In an ideal society, there would be no place for charities providing essential services. However, if the state had to fill the gap that would arise from charities going under and cover the cost of a massively increased wage bill in the public sector and provide benefits at a decent level for all of the newly unemployed people whose employers couldn't afford the hike in minimum wage, then I am not totally clear as to where the money for all this would be coming from.

If people have ideas for new types of business that can viably employ large numbers of relatively unskilled workers on £15 an hour in order to replace all of the existing jobs that would be lost and to make up the loss of tax revenue to the state, then maybe this can work. I just don't have enough imagination to be able to see what those businesses might look like or where they might be coming from.

Badbadbunny · 25/08/2022 11:49

@beachcitygirl

And it's the small businesses who employ roughly half of the UK workforce and roughly a third of the turnover (sales) of the private sector. They're the ones who ARE paying taxes etc.

If they fail and close down (i.e. your local corner shop, your local cafe, etc)., then their trade will be taken over by larger/international firms who arguable DON'T pay their full share of UK taxes.

So the Treasury could well see much lower tax revenues from a further shift away from small firms to large firms.

Do we really want more Starbucks/McDonalds rather than independent cafes??

Do we really want Amazon to get an even bigger market share when even more small shops/small manufacturers go bust?

Be VERY careful what you wish for.

Badbadbunny · 25/08/2022 11:44

@beachcitygirl

If your idea of "non viable" businesses fail, then that just puts more people on the dole claiming all their income from benefits, not just a portion, so cost the taxpayer billions more. If businesses fail, they're not paying VAT, PAYE, NIC, income/corporation tax, so less money paid to the government to pay the additional dole costs!

What about organisations that aren't "businesses", such as charities, public sector, schools, NHS, etc - how do they afford to pay the increase in wages? Presumably you don't want them to fail, so they'll also need more money from the taxpayer.

So you'd have to increase taxes on those who've had a pay rise from the increase in minimal wages, making them probably little better off, in fact, probably not better off at all as with their higher wages, they'll be eligible for less UC/tax credits so maybe they won't have any more money at all.

But, in the meantime, you've caused huge numbers of businesses to fail and squeezed the non profit sector!

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 11:40

beachcitygirl · 25/08/2022 11:28

This couldn't be more wrong.

It is not the job of taxpayers to top up and artificially inflate the viability of private enterprise and profit.

Sadly the last Labour government introduced tax credits which was bloody lunacy. Thus creating a situation where exactly that happened.

Businesses (as mentioned in this thread a lot) have grown to actually believe they are viable even when they cannot afford a staffing bill that simply pays a living wage.

Bloody ludicrous.

Non-viable businesses must fail. The market will decide.

Benefits are a safety net for the the unemployed, the vulnerable & sick.

They ARE not meant to be and should
Not be a way for crap business to get away with paying low wages &'still trousering profit.

It actually makes me feel so sad that some on here have such a need to feel better than others that they would begrudge the lowest paid in society a wage rise up to one on which they could live without having to claim benefit.

Then instead of propping up profit of private enterprise -benefits could be at a level that doesn't mean those people still have to turn to food banks & school uniform banks and charity shops.

Really some of you need to give your head a wobble.

Big society means that whatever way it works it means we all rely on each other to prop each other up anyway.
I for example have no patents - part of my tax goes to care homes
I have no nursery age children - part of my tax goes to nurseries & nursery vouchers
I have no one on benefits - part of my tax goes on that.
I do however use the nhs regularly & my daughter received DLA

We all (in one way or another) give & we all take.

Either through charitable giving, food banks & taxes towards UC etc

Far better to pay decent levels of tax & NI and have businesses pay their own salaries from their own profits

And allow the lowest paid to climb off the benefit trap and allow those most vulnerable to have benefits that don't mean they also have to rummage food banks in 2022.

Dignified appropriate taxation, a real living wage that a person can actually live off & build a family.

It's not that long ago a manual labourer could afford to build a family with a housewife & 2 kids on his wage alone.

Huge corporations not paying taxation. The bloody vile wife of the exchequer having offshore accounts, the corruption so settled its almost accepted. The ideological decisions of a party determined to make the rich richer & the poor poorer as they hoover up even more ill-gotten wealth.

Reading the people on here trying to find excuses to avoid a £15 minimum wage is nauseating.

It isn't about begrudging people higher wages in the slightest. I would love to pay everyone at least £15 an hour, genuinely. And I have already taken a pay cut myself in order to enable us to give staff a pay rise.

I just don't see how it can work. While I agree with you in principle that tax credits/UC etc shouldn't be used to subsidise employers who don't pay their staff enough to live on, the reality is simply that many businesses operate on incredibly tight margins. Like the little cafe that employs my dd for example. It's all very well saying that businesses which aren't viable should be allowed to fail, but what will happen to all of those staff when the businesses fold? Where will all the new, higher paid jobs suddenly come from?

I want to believe that this could work, but I just don't see how it could. Of course, the huge corporates could afford to pay more by not paying huge fat cat salaries to their senior staff or by reducing profits, but the vast majority of the UK workforce don't work for huge corporates - they work for SMEs, in the public sector and in the third sector, all of which would struggle to resource these higher wages.

Iamthewombat · 25/08/2022 11:36

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 21:40

@Iamthewombat

How many ‘CEOs etc’ earning many hundreds of thousands do you think that there are ?
Let’s say that there are 10,000 people in the U.K. earning at least £500k per year. You take £300k per annum off each of them, presumably before tax so that’s a load of income tax revenue gone, and somehow redistribute it as a boost to minimum wage
Can you do the sums? In case not, I will. You’d get £3 million. Add up the zeros. Let’s say that there are 1 million people working for minimum wage. How much extra would they get per year? If it helps, divide 3 million by 1 million. The answer is an extra £3 per year. Each
This has been explained so many times on this thread. It’s depressing

Yet again, your're the one who needs to do the math and learn some basic figures on earnings.

I feel bad now about ruining your outpouring of spite. I deliberately mis-stated the result to see whether anyone would notice. Confirming how little understood big numbers are by anyone who thinks that cutting CEO pay will deliver utopia. I had a right old laugh. In the end somebody did - I think it was @PestorPeston though, not you. How funny. You couldn’t wait to stick the boot in though, could you? Poor spiteful little you.

beachcitygirl · 25/08/2022 11:28

Getoff · 25/08/2022 08:52

Also, there is no "should" about what someone can afford. Labour is worth what it's worth, it may or may not pay enough to avoid cold and hunger. If pay is not enough to provide a socially acceptable level of income, it's the job of the benefits system to fill the gap. Artificially inflating pay rates (as a solution) is just throwing sand into the gears of the economy.

This couldn't be more wrong.

It is not the job of taxpayers to top up and artificially inflate the viability of private enterprise and profit.

Sadly the last Labour government introduced tax credits which was bloody lunacy. Thus creating a situation where exactly that happened.

Businesses (as mentioned in this thread a lot) have grown to actually believe they are viable even when they cannot afford a staffing bill that simply pays a living wage.

Bloody ludicrous.

Non-viable businesses must fail. The market will decide.

Benefits are a safety net for the the unemployed, the vulnerable & sick.

They ARE not meant to be and should
Not be a way for crap business to get away with paying low wages &'still trousering profit.

It actually makes me feel so sad that some on here have such a need to feel better than others that they would begrudge the lowest paid in society a wage rise up to one on which they could live without having to claim benefit.

Then instead of propping up profit of private enterprise -benefits could be at a level that doesn't mean those people still have to turn to food banks & school uniform banks and charity shops.

Really some of you need to give your head a wobble.

Big society means that whatever way it works it means we all rely on each other to prop each other up anyway.
I for example have no patents - part of my tax goes to care homes
I have no nursery age children - part of my tax goes to nurseries & nursery vouchers
I have no one on benefits - part of my tax goes on that.
I do however use the nhs regularly & my daughter received DLA

We all (in one way or another) give & we all take.

Either through charitable giving, food banks & taxes towards UC etc

Far better to pay decent levels of tax & NI and have businesses pay their own salaries from their own profits

And allow the lowest paid to climb off the benefit trap and allow those most vulnerable to have benefits that don't mean they also have to rummage food banks in 2022.

Dignified appropriate taxation, a real living wage that a person can actually live off & build a family.

It's not that long ago a manual labourer could afford to build a family with a housewife & 2 kids on his wage alone.

Huge corporations not paying taxation. The bloody vile wife of the exchequer having offshore accounts, the corruption so settled its almost accepted. The ideological decisions of a party determined to make the rich richer & the poor poorer as they hoover up even more ill-gotten wealth.

Reading the people on here trying to find excuses to avoid a £15 minimum wage is nauseating.