Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 18:32

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 18:10

@Anothernamechangeplease You are aware they pay for their own training now? While working in the NHS.

I am paying my student loans back while working in the NHS. I never had a single penny of my training paid by the NHS or the government and in fact I worked unpaid for 3 years during my training. I owe them nothing!

Yes, I'm well aware that doctors have to pay back their student loans, obviously. But as far as I am aware, the student loans don't reflect anything like the full cost of training a doctor, so I'm not quite sure how you never had anything paid towards your training. Did you have to pay the additional costs on top of your tuition fees?

I am well aware of how hard doctors have to work to get to where they are, and I absolutely think we need to do something about the terrible working conditions in the NHS in order to reduce the number of people burning out/wanting to leave. If you read what I said above, I would actually reduce what NHS doctors and dentists would have to pay back, by limiting their liability to the tuition fees that would be paid by students doing any standard 3 year degree. (Ideally, I would scrap the tuition fees for medics and nurses altogether if I could.) I just don't think the state should subsidise the very expensive studies of people who want to work in the private sector.

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 18:10

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 16:32

But why should they be allowed to do private work without paying back the cost of the training? And would they really leave the NHS en masse if there was a huge financial penalty for doing so? Surely they're more likely to leave right now, when there is no disincentive for doing so?

@Anothernamechangeplease You are aware they pay for their own training now? While working in the NHS.

I am paying my student loans back while working in the NHS. I never had a single penny of my training paid by the NHS or the government and in fact I worked unpaid for 3 years during my training. I owe them nothing!

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 18:07

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 17:05

Why is ok to accept people living on poverty wages who then have to rely on top ups and are demonised for doing so? All to save these small businesses - without actually testing how big a problem it really would be.

We have a massive problem with international organisations pushing down wages on the basis that they’re global and can threaten to offshore jobs. That is the problem with the current model of capitalism that we face.

Has anyone done an assessment of businesses that would actually fold if they paid £15/hour?

If you pay people more - then they can afford more….. That includes spending money on small businesses.

Plenty of big companies pay shit wages - Amazon being a classic example. The public sector is another example - outsourcing jobs on the cheap to companies when they could pay directly and pay higher wages. Think of care homes, cleaners etc. Those things alone would make a massive difference to the state of the economy and rebalance wealth a bit.

I don't know if anyone has done an assessment of what the impact would be, but I do know that profit margins are very tight on many businesses, such as the cafe where my dd works. You only have to look at how many small businesses fold because they struggle to make a profit even with wages as they are. Most small charities would fold, unless the government bailed them out in some way. And the school where I'm a governor struggles to make its budget balance already, so it would need more government money to keep it going as well.

The reality is that many small and medium businesses simply couldn't carry on operating with wage bills that high. So someone would need to create new business models that made it viable to employ unskilled labour on £15 an hour in order to replace all of the jobs that would be lost in the sectors that ceased to be viable.

Alternatively, I suppose some private businesses might survive if they could pass enough of the increased costs on to their customers. If everyone was willing to pay much more because they had more money in their pockets, I suppose this might be achievable. I am not sure that the lowest paid would necessarily be any better off in reality though, because they would just be buying the same stuff at higher prices, but I guess their salaries would look better on paper. Unfortunately, the public sector and the voluntary sector don't get to pass on increased costs in quite the same way, so their services would almost certainly have to be cut back or discontinued.

LifesTooShortForYourNonsense · 25/08/2022 18:02

If people earn more, they are taxed more, plus less has to paid out in tax credits etc.
Yes, service industry costs will go up, but not so much on goods.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 17:54

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 16:59

I meant they would quit their jobs as doctors altogether not just the NHS. Many are leaving already.

Doctors who do private work usually also work for the NHS, often full time hours for the NHS. They generally only do private work as consultants which will mean they have worked for the NHS for many years. Are you saying that people who work as doctors can't do any other job even if it's in addition to NHS work?

No, I'm not saying that they shouldn't be allowed to do extra private work at all, but I don't agree with the state paying for the training if they're going to use it to make loads of money in private practice. Perhaps saying that they have to be full time in the NHS is too much, but there should be a minimum number of hours that they have to work in the NHS in order to avoid repaying the fees. I don't think that's unreasonable.

Dadaya · 25/08/2022 17:52

Has anyone done an assessment of businesses that would actually fold if they paid £15/hour?
The public sector would collapse first. Early career nurses and teachers, college lecturers and support staff, absolutely tons of essential public sector employees earn less than £15 per hour.

IKnowAPlace · 25/08/2022 17:47

It's really complicated but I can't be opposed to paying low paid people more when things are as they are.

Yes, it'd be inflationary initially but people will stop paying for things once prices of non essentials reach certain thresholds. Unfortunately that means businesses with small margins will go under and their minimum wage employees will need to find work elsewhere. Will that work exist?

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 17:42

25 miles commute is 50 miles a day and many cars that’s a gallon of petrol - £8 a day to go to work

all that nurse wanted was a social rented house but not enough are built and she couldn’t rent locally due to being on her own and not satisfying estate agents “affordability” criteria

if she quits that area as it’s too expensive that’s going to leave these areas with shortages of nurses and key workers - recycling emptiest, superworkers, teachers, carers

why should they commute and spend £50 a week to get to work when they can transfer- so rural areas will lose more facilities if they don’t get wage rises to correspond with housing prices and renting

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 17:42

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 16:51

That doesn’t make it right.

Why would it not be right? 25 miles isn't that far. It's not a new thing for people to travel to work.

antelopevalley · 25/08/2022 17:35

My parents got nothing before 1971, the level of poverty then was shocking amongst people working on low wages. Family allowance was to life those families with very low earners out of dire poverty. Tax credits was just a rename.

Alexandra2001 · 25/08/2022 17:32

@beachcitygirl
Sadly the last Labour government introduced tax credits which was bloody lunacy. Thus creating a situation where exactly that happened

that 's a complete myth, the Tories introduced family income support in 1971, supposed to be a temporary solution..... BUT the need was there though and support for working families grew, by the time the WFTC was introduced by labour in 1999, there were 1.5m people claiming support and the need has grown and grown ever since, whatever name its called.

Mainly, not due to low wages but the cost of housing, as benefits like these have always been means tested.

If we returned to mass cheap rent council housing, we'd not need such a high MW & the benefits would be lower and councils/govt would have an appreciating asset.

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 17:05

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 12:27

So enlighten us... what new business models are going to replace the huge number of employers whose business would no longer be viable? What jobs are all those people going to do when they are made redundant?

Why is ok to accept people living on poverty wages who then have to rely on top ups and are demonised for doing so? All to save these small businesses - without actually testing how big a problem it really would be.

We have a massive problem with international organisations pushing down wages on the basis that they’re global and can threaten to offshore jobs. That is the problem with the current model of capitalism that we face.

Has anyone done an assessment of businesses that would actually fold if they paid £15/hour?

If you pay people more - then they can afford more….. That includes spending money on small businesses.

Plenty of big companies pay shit wages - Amazon being a classic example. The public sector is another example - outsourcing jobs on the cheap to companies when they could pay directly and pay higher wages. Think of care homes, cleaners etc. Those things alone would make a massive difference to the state of the economy and rebalance wealth a bit.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 16:59

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 16:32

But why should they be allowed to do private work without paying back the cost of the training? And would they really leave the NHS en masse if there was a huge financial penalty for doing so? Surely they're more likely to leave right now, when there is no disincentive for doing so?

I meant they would quit their jobs as doctors altogether not just the NHS. Many are leaving already.

Doctors who do private work usually also work for the NHS, often full time hours for the NHS. They generally only do private work as consultants which will mean they have worked for the NHS for many years. Are you saying that people who work as doctors can't do any other job even if it's in addition to NHS work?

Believeitornot · 25/08/2022 16:51

MsPincher · 25/08/2022 16:24

To be honest as well, when did 25 miles become an unreasonable commute? I know a lot of people who commute further than that.

That doesn’t make it right.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 16:32

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 16:19

Stupid idea. They generally do private work as well as an NHS work. Any that don't want to do NHS work will just leave en mass.

But why should they be allowed to do private work without paying back the cost of the training? And would they really leave the NHS en masse if there was a huge financial penalty for doing so? Surely they're more likely to leave right now, when there is no disincentive for doing so?

MsPincher · 25/08/2022 16:24

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 13:47

What is the solution? Nurses aren't paid minimum wage so raising the minimum wage isn't going to help. If anything it will increase the chance they will quit their jobs. If small businesses fold it's not going to decrease the amount taxpayers pay as those people will probably be unemployed.

To be honest as well, when did 25 miles become an unreasonable commute? I know a lot of people who commute further than that.

Anewdayanewdawn · 25/08/2022 16:22

‘I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on ‘

were the 5th richest nation in the world. It’s disgraceful that people working in the U.K. can’t survive on the money they’re paid.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 16:19

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 15:08

No person undertaking state medical/dentistry training allowed to go into the private sector for 10 years

I would amend that to say that people can go into private practice at any time, if they so wish, but as soon as they do, they should be required to start paying off the full costs of their training. The total cost of that training should be calculated over, say, 40 years, and pro rata deductions could be made for any years in which they have worked full time for the NHS. The rest should be paid off in full, with an appropriate rate of interest applied. So medical professionals who stay in the NHS throughout their careers would not have to pay for more than the standard cost of a 3-year degree programme, whereas those who move to private practice at any point in their career would pay back what they owe, with interest, for whatever proportion of their career was worked in the private sector. Same if medics/dentists choose to leave the country to practice abroad, though I'm not totally sure how practical it would be to administer this.

Stupid idea. They generally do private work as well as an NHS work. Any that don't want to do NHS work will just leave en mass.

Dadaya · 25/08/2022 16:15

I wonder how many more minimum wage jobs would disappear from Britain if the NMW were raised to that level
This is exactly what would happen. I manage a gift shop and we sell a lot of products that are manufactured in the UK. They’re more expensive because of being made in the UK. But customers value that… to a certain extent.

I can sell a tea towel for £12 and people will buy it because it’s a good quality British product. But I wouldn’t be able to sell the same tea towel for £40. The “Made in UK” stamp is worth more, but not THAT much more. If the NMW increase pushed product prices above what the market will pay, I’d be forced to switch to selling tea towels made more cheaply elsewhere. Then the British textile factory workers would be out of a job.

Badbadbunny · 25/08/2022 15:53

Allywill · 25/08/2022 15:17

i remember the 70s and 80s very well i promise you. my point is requiring businesses to pay women more did not effect the economy adversely in any significant way. generally speaking improving workers rights and benefits is a good thing in the long run.

Did you not notice all the industry closing down and the start of the offshoring craze to transfer call centre and back office jobs to India etc?

Allywill · 25/08/2022 15:17

i remember the 70s and 80s very well i promise you. my point is requiring businesses to pay women more did not effect the economy adversely in any significant way. generally speaking improving workers rights and benefits is a good thing in the long run.

justasking111 · 25/08/2022 15:09

Allywill · 25/08/2022 14:59

there was increasing unemployment in the 70s but that is generally attributed to opec and oil price pressures. the equal pay act came in in dec 1975 and the actual rise of unemployment was less the year after. for example the unemployment increase from 74-75 was +1.1% the increase from 75-76 was less at 0.9%.

But the welfare cushion was much less, I promise it was tough. Families living locally to each other were able to share the burden. The council I worked for treasurer department were flat out working on rent and rate rebates. The people we had to turn away. No family credits then. Unemployed queuing up for help from the job centre. If you owned a property as the mortgage rates rose you could be in a mess quickly. Pre selling off council stock we still couldn't house everyone who needed a roof over their head

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 15:08

No person undertaking state medical/dentistry training allowed to go into the private sector for 10 years

I would amend that to say that people can go into private practice at any time, if they so wish, but as soon as they do, they should be required to start paying off the full costs of their training. The total cost of that training should be calculated over, say, 40 years, and pro rata deductions could be made for any years in which they have worked full time for the NHS. The rest should be paid off in full, with an appropriate rate of interest applied. So medical professionals who stay in the NHS throughout their careers would not have to pay for more than the standard cost of a 3-year degree programme, whereas those who move to private practice at any point in their career would pay back what they owe, with interest, for whatever proportion of their career was worked in the private sector. Same if medics/dentists choose to leave the country to practice abroad, though I'm not totally sure how practical it would be to administer this.

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 15:06

No person undertaking state medical/dentistry training allowed to go into the private sector for 10 years

God this. So much this.
I would also go for free school meals for all and that if uniform must be preserved, it is generic and widely available. If school badges are needed - to be provided by the school at cost as sew-on patches

All fees for uni to be abolished - bursaries (useful ones) for professions that have to do a lot of practical experience (nurses spring to mind)
Apprenticeships along German lines to be introduced - not just calling something an "apprenticeship" so you can pay 2.50 an hour

Not sure about the charitable status of private schools. However, am very keen on free places (didn't direct grants used to be a thing? I went to private school* and I'm sure some of the girls had direct grants which were abolished when we were in the 2nd form or something.)

*army brat. i hated it and was homesick for the entirety

Allywill · 25/08/2022 15:01

to be clear those figures are increase in the previous year not actual unemployment rates.