Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 25/08/2022 20:02

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

can I check you understand the following?

  1. CEOs don’t keep profit “for themselves”…? The profit, if any, does to the directors of the company / shareholders - they are rewarded, if they add value to the market (ie peoples lives), for taking financial risk
  2. reference companies accepting lower profits - often the shareholders are pension funds ie it’s pensioners that get less

I’m assuming not as your post seems written from the perspective of profits are bad and the top are greedy…

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:58

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 19:49

@Anothernamechangeplease

You need to do some research!

Medical students use student loans to fund their course fees in their entirety for the first 4 years. In the 5th year they can claim an NHS contribution towards fees. This contribution is less than £3000 and at this point in the training they are WORKING in the NHS unpaid!

I don't need to do any research, I'm well aware of everything you have said in this post, not least because my dd is applying for medicine and I've been looking at what it is going to cost her/us over the course of her degree.

However, my understanding is that the actual cost of training a doctor is well in excess of £200k. Even with the eye watering fees that medical students have to pay, I do not believe that anyone has students loans that amount to that much? I am not quite sure why you think the taxpayer didn't contribute to the cost of your training?

Yes, medical students and doctors have to work ridiculously hard. Yes, working conditions are shit and should be improved. That doesn't mean that there isn't still a huge investment bt the taxpayer in the training of medical students, and as such, I think it's perfectly reasonable to expect them to work in the NHS or repay that additional investment made by the taxpayer.

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 19:49

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 18:32

Yes, I'm well aware that doctors have to pay back their student loans, obviously. But as far as I am aware, the student loans don't reflect anything like the full cost of training a doctor, so I'm not quite sure how you never had anything paid towards your training. Did you have to pay the additional costs on top of your tuition fees?

I am well aware of how hard doctors have to work to get to where they are, and I absolutely think we need to do something about the terrible working conditions in the NHS in order to reduce the number of people burning out/wanting to leave. If you read what I said above, I would actually reduce what NHS doctors and dentists would have to pay back, by limiting their liability to the tuition fees that would be paid by students doing any standard 3 year degree. (Ideally, I would scrap the tuition fees for medics and nurses altogether if I could.) I just don't think the state should subsidise the very expensive studies of people who want to work in the private sector.

@Anothernamechangeplease

You need to do some research!

Medical students use student loans to fund their course fees in their entirety for the first 4 years. In the 5th year they can claim an NHS contribution towards fees. This contribution is less than £3000 and at this point in the training they are WORKING in the NHS unpaid!

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:49

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 19:38

@Anothernamechangeplease

If the great majority are already working a substantial number of hours for the NHS (we haven't discussed where the minimum requirement should be set), then my proposals would not impact on them negatively at all. Quite the contrary, I am saying that NHS doctors should pay less towards their training, not more.

So your great idea could actually cost the taxpayer more not less.

Some consultants might leave the profession if they had to work in the NHS or if they had to repay more of their tuition costs, I suppose, but I am not sure that losing people who are motivated solely by how much money they can make are really the kind of doctors that we want anyway.

The fact that someone doesn't want to work in the NHS doesn't mean they're motivated solely by money. Lots of people wouldn't want to work in the NHS. Do you work in the NHS? What do you mean they are not the kind of doctors “we want”. Unless you get private treatment they're not going to treat you so what's it got to do with you? If other people want to buy their services that's up to them.

Yes, it might well cost the taxpayer more, especially if money was invested in improving conditions for NHS staff. The point of it wasn't to save money but rather to provide incentives for people to stay in the NHS and to stop subsidising the training of those who choose to go into private practice.

And yes, of course, it isn't for me to say what type of doctors other people should or shouldn't be willing to pay for. That's entirely up to them. I was talking about the kind of doctors that we, as taxpayers, might want to fund the training for.

If people want to pay for private treatment, then I think it's reasonable for them to pay towards the cost of their doctors' medical training too, rather than expecting this to be subsidised by the state.

chicken12 · 25/08/2022 19:49

I have an idea you can do my very stressful job for the 10.25 an hour don't wory no one is going to give 15.00 an hour for minimum wage before you say get a better paid job remember someone has to do the crap paid jobs

JacquiG2 · 25/08/2022 19:48

YABU Why should people go hungry and cold because a business screws it's workers? If you can't pay a decent wage, don't bother employing people. Why should the tax payer subsidise companies like Tesco who pay their workers less than they can live on?

CEOs pay themselves too much. Shareholders get higher dividends with each payout. These overpaid executives in companies earning billions in profits and shares salt it away, often offshore. It should be returned to use via heavy taxation. Profits should be invested in maintenance, repair, and modernisation.

Thanks to neo liberalism, uncontrolled capitalism, and naked greed, Britain is broken. In the main, people are treated appallingly by greedy employers who have whittled away the ability of the average employee to have a decent life and save for the future.

And government seems to be doing little or nothing to prevent starvation and death from cold for some, this winter.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 19:38

@Anothernamechangeplease

If the great majority are already working a substantial number of hours for the NHS (we haven't discussed where the minimum requirement should be set), then my proposals would not impact on them negatively at all. Quite the contrary, I am saying that NHS doctors should pay less towards their training, not more.

So your great idea could actually cost the taxpayer more not less.

Some consultants might leave the profession if they had to work in the NHS or if they had to repay more of their tuition costs, I suppose, but I am not sure that losing people who are motivated solely by how much money they can make are really the kind of doctors that we want anyway.

The fact that someone doesn't want to work in the NHS doesn't mean they're motivated solely by money. Lots of people wouldn't want to work in the NHS. Do you work in the NHS? What do you mean they are not the kind of doctors “we want”. Unless you get private treatment they're not going to treat you so what's it got to do with you? If other people want to buy their services that's up to them.

Mamai90 · 25/08/2022 19:32

Dadaya · 24/08/2022 09:36

The problem is those who earn just above current min wage but less than £15 per hour. Do we bump them up onto £15 per hour? In which case a job that used to pay above min wage is now less attractive because it’s become a min wage job and people can earn the same on the till in Asda.

For example lots of teachers currently earn less than £15 per hour. So if min wage increases, presumably teachers would be bumped up onto £15 per hour. So why would they continue to bother with the hassle of teaching if they’re now a min wage employee and can earn the same in an easier job?

Who said a minimum wage job was an 'easier' job?

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:28

Breezycheesetrees · 25/08/2022 19:24

Also, replicate this across the whole sector and that's a lot of newly unemployed people needing support...

Yes, absolutely. A disaster waiting to happen.

A pp suggested that it would be ok for charities to fold as the state would have to pick up the pieces, but someone would still have to pay for that. The reality is, it just wouldn't happen, and vulnerable people would lose the support.

Local authorities already have no money as it is. There is no way they could pick up all of the extra support provided by the third sector, and certainly not on top of managing the impact of their own exploding wage bill.

Breezycheesetrees · 25/08/2022 19:24

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:15

I work for a charity, I earn more than minimum wage but less than 15 an hour. If all of our salaries have to go up to £15/h I expect we will go bankrupt, or a large number of us will lose our jobs.

You're quite right @Breezycheesetrees. Many charities would be unsustainable if this level of minimum wage was introduced.

I guess some charities could cut staff to increase wages for those who remained, but this would mean significantly reducing the number of clients they could help. The question would be whether their funders would continue to perceive that approach as offering value for money, or whether they would ultimately choose to withdraw their funding.

Also, replicate this across the whole sector and that's a lot of newly unemployed people needing support...

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:15

I work for a charity, I earn more than minimum wage but less than 15 an hour. If all of our salaries have to go up to £15/h I expect we will go bankrupt, or a large number of us will lose our jobs.

You're quite right @Breezycheesetrees. Many charities would be unsustainable if this level of minimum wage was introduced.

I guess some charities could cut staff to increase wages for those who remained, but this would mean significantly reducing the number of clients they could help. The question would be whether their funders would continue to perceive that approach as offering value for money, or whether they would ultimately choose to withdraw their funding.

gogohmm · 25/08/2022 19:13

My work can barely afford to pay me now (£11.50) non profit

MarshaBradyo · 25/08/2022 19:11

Some larger organisations are more likely to deal with the rise, although many wouod still pass on

Smaller wouldn’t be and I do think it’s shortsighted to say not viable fine to lose them. Many people wouldn’t be better off they’d be unemployed.

Right now businesses are up against it with energy costs causing going up massively. They don’t get a cap like we do.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:10

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 19:03

The great majority are already working a minimum number of hours for the NHS at the same time though. For the few consultants that are entirely private, I'm not sure what's to be gained in making them quit as doctors entirely. It certainly won't help NHS waiting lists.

If the great majority are already working a substantial number of hours for the NHS (we haven't discussed where the minimum requirement should be set), then my proposals would not impact on them negatively at all. Quite the contrary, I am saying that NHS doctors should pay less towards their training, not more.

Some consultants might leave the profession if they had to work in the NHS or if they had to repay more of their tuition costs, I suppose, but I am not sure that losing people who are motivated solely by how much money they can make are really the kind of doctors that we want anyway.

The taxpayer needs to fund the NHS properly so that NHS staff have decent working conditions and patients are able to access the care that they need. I don't think the taxpayer needs to fund the training of doctors and dentists who choose to exploit the current under resourcing of the NHS to make money privately.

Israisingwagesworthit · 25/08/2022 19:07

Bard6817 · 25/08/2022 18:51

If you think CEO’s keep all the profits then being honest, no wonder the civil service is in dire straits….

@Bard6817 I never said the ceo keeps the profit. I said if the minimum wage goes up to £15, then the ceo/directors/boards of companies should be made to not raise prices inline to protect profit but reduce the level of profits retained and distributed via dividends to shareholders etc to actually make the £15 per hour wage an actual increase in real terms.

My whole point of the comment I made was profits must be sacrificed to increase the wage, which won't happen, so £15 per hour minimum wage will just be the catalyst for costs to go up, removing any benefit of an increased wage.

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 19:03

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 17:54

No, I'm not saying that they shouldn't be allowed to do extra private work at all, but I don't agree with the state paying for the training if they're going to use it to make loads of money in private practice. Perhaps saying that they have to be full time in the NHS is too much, but there should be a minimum number of hours that they have to work in the NHS in order to avoid repaying the fees. I don't think that's unreasonable.

The great majority are already working a minimum number of hours for the NHS at the same time though. For the few consultants that are entirely private, I'm not sure what's to be gained in making them quit as doctors entirely. It certainly won't help NHS waiting lists.

Breezycheesetrees · 25/08/2022 18:58

I work for a charity, I earn more than minimum wage but less than 15 an hour. If all of our salaries have to go up to £15/h I expect we will go bankrupt, or a large number of us will lose our jobs

Surely the answer is to radically reform our housing system so that housing costs come back in line with household earnings? I'd be in favour of banning private landlords altogether (or making it possible only through some sort of housing association), nationalising rented housing (or making it all non-profit) and completely detaching housing costs from market forces. Housing is a basic need not a luxury consumer good. Ditto energy and water. Pushing wages up is just going to fuck small businesses and charities, and push all prices up anyway.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 18:56

blublub · 25/08/2022 18:50

It’s almost like tax credits, as a means of wealth distribution for the poorest, were a good idea.

Indeed!

TheJade · 25/08/2022 18:51

It’s ridiculous. If they change my min wage job to £15 per hr then my husband needs to be paid about a million a year.

one perfect way to stoke inflation 😭

tttigress · 25/08/2022 18:51

Anewdayanewdawn · 25/08/2022 16:22

‘I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on ‘

were the 5th richest nation in the world. It’s disgraceful that people working in the U.K. can’t survive on the money they’re paid.

I hate that quote, which is incorrectly repeated parrot fashion from an early 2000s politician:

  1. we are actually 6th on terms of GDP having recently been overtaken by India
  2. we are 25th in terms of GDP per person which is a more realistic measure of our wealth

Bottom line, we are no longer that wealthy

Bard6817 · 25/08/2022 18:51

If you think CEO’s keep all the profits then being honest, no wonder the civil service is in dire straits….

blublub · 25/08/2022 18:50

It’s almost like tax credits, as a means of wealth distribution for the poorest, were a good idea.

99redballoonsgobyy · 25/08/2022 18:45

It would be great if minimum wage was £15 per hour but the only trouble is prices of everything goes up to compensate for employers having to pay out this extra money so nobody is every any better off. for example I used to work in a small independent shop on min wage and each time minimum wage risen our employer would increase prices of everything in the shop to compensate I noticed this happened everywhere too.

Diamondsareforever123 · 25/08/2022 18:42

The answer is that capitalistic greed has gone awry. The minimum wage should be £15 an hour, of course nurses, midwives, teachers, should be earning more than that. But this stinking bunch of Tory filth would rather have their shareholders bank profits than invest in the country and its talent. We are in for a very bad time in the UK.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 18:36

LifesTooShortForYourNonsense · 25/08/2022 18:02

If people earn more, they are taxed more, plus less has to paid out in tax credits etc.
Yes, service industry costs will go up, but not so much on goods.

True, the cost of imported goods wouldn't go up as much, though they would still be affected by the wages of people transporting them, packing them on the shelves, selling them etc.

UK manufacturing would largely be wiped out, though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread