Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
Mfsf · 25/08/2022 21:42

It’s actually a massive issue . I’m a mid earner like you but my partner is just I’ve minimum wage . Every time he gets a benefit as lower tax I end up paying much more than he gets in increase meaning we are worse off .
the reality is mid earners like us are always worse off no matter what happens . The price increases with absolutely nil help affect us a lot more than what people realise . Thank Lis I do t think people realise how much tax we actually pay and how much our real wages are

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 21:41

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 21:26

163,000 cost to the taxpayer

Divide by the 5 years they are training for = £32,600 a year
£636 a week

Doctors work a MINIMUM of 80 hours a week unpaid

£636 divide by 80 hours of work = £7.95 an hour

Less than minimum wage!

So they are not costing the taxpayer at all. They are in fact working and being paid less than the legal amount while getting into thousands of pounds of debt.

But they don't work 80 hours a week, 52 hours per week in the NHS for all 5 years that they're training. Confused

Having been to tons of open day presentations recently, and having talked to loads of current students at various stages in their medical student journey, that seems very far fetched tbh. If anything, many of the students were complaining that they didn't get enough clinical exposure during the earlier years of their studies. I don't think any of them were doing 80 hours a week 52 weeks per year. Also, from what many of them said, they also weren't really working in the earlier years...more shadowing and observing in order to learn. Of course, they were able to do more as they built up more knowledge and experience.

I am not disputing how much work is involved in the later years of a medical degree, and unlike a pp, I don't think it's acceptable to ask people to do 80 hour weeks, whether paid or unpaid. However, I think your calculations are off, and I do not believe that you spent your 5 years of medical school doing 80 hours of unpaid work, 52 weeks in the year. I don't think any UK medical school trains its students in this way.

I get that you are obviously angry with the system and I understand that you don't feel that you owe anyone anything. That's fine, I'm sure that you've worked hard to get to where you are and that you have contributed lots through your career. None of that changes my view though that state subsidised medical training should be for people who work in the NHS and not for those who go into the private sector. I wouldn't move the goalposts for people who are already in the system, but I would change it for people who are now going into it.

Mxr · 25/08/2022 21:38

Cyclemarine · 25/08/2022 20:59

Housing costs are out of control. I saw on Twitter a thread about 2-bed flats in Manchester and Glasgow for 2,000 pcm. Those are cities previously thought of as affordable, and the wages haven’t gone up a whole lot yet rent has seemingly doubled in the past 5 years . I can’t imagine how much they’d hike them up by if the government did actually raise the NMW significantly.

the government needs to get a grip on this housing crisis and fast.

I Agree that Housing is a basic need and people shouldn’t have to rely on the private sector for it.

LET ME EXPLAIN HOW IT WORKS !!

IN EARLY 1980's Council & Housing Assoc rents were ( as now ) classed as " fair rented ".
As such, any housing benefit was designed via benefits & / or wages, to allow rent to be covered.

Along comes a f*kin arehole , for there can be no polite way of describing the evil vile monster she was....called " THATCHER.

This is how she did it.
These " fair rents " also applied to private landlords.
If you rented a private place, you asked the local Councils " Fair rent officer" ( yep, they really had them !!) To visit your place.
THEY decided what the ' Fair rent ' was worth. !!
The landlord was OBLIGED TO COMPLY.
BRILLIANT SYSTEM ...

BUT , Mad Thatcher didn't want ' fairness. So she abolished it !
Simultaneously selling all council homes at a 70%% discount.
70-80% are now sold off.
Many are now owned by the private landlords we despise.

Free market economy.
Supply & demand.
Don't build Social Housing to replace what was sold dirt cheap.
Pushes up rent prices AND sale prices. Less supply, the landlord leeches can ask more. With NO protection of limit on asking price.

AND Thatcher began putting the limits & caps on HOUSING & BENEFITS INSTEAD .
This placing all lower in the hands of greedy landlords.
Housing isn't an option one can do without !!

Since then, 80/90's , it's been a continual decline , with more & more power going to landlords & the already wealthy.
And all tenant Rights slowly eroded.

Plus....previously, at least private landlords usually had some idea of their responsibilities.....now, as add all over social media announce.....there is SO MUCH PROFIT in BUY TO LETS , that the greedy pigs do not give a famn, nor have a clue, that they actually carry a ' Duty of Care '....& Many think they can sit in sunny villas whilst taking in the vast profits & doing no work. When they want the tenant out, don't give a toss, kick them out, not their problem.

SO FEW PEOPLE NOW UNDERSTAND THIS CHAIN OF EVENTS !
WE HAVE REACHED CRISIS POINT.
THE LEECHES HAVE THEIR VSDT PROFITS & PROPERTY PORTFOLIOS.

AND YOU MUGS ( FOR LETTING IT HAPPEN !) NOW CANT GET A HOME...( well, if your parents are wealthy &/ or landlords you're ok )

My words above should be told in every classroom & every pub LEST YOU FORGET IT WAS NOT ALWAYS LIKE THIS !!

AbreathofFrenchair · 25/08/2022 21:30

I work in a childcare it's a minimum wage job for everyone except apprentices and room leaders. Put minimum wage up to £15ph and our nursery would close down as fees would go up and parents wouldn't be able to afford it.

Our current day rate has gone to to £55 a day from £52 and weve lost 4 families (total of 5 children) who have both parents working in decent jobs and have all left, accusing the Manager of being a money grabber. The Manager also owns the nursery, doesn't pay herself a wage but the profits work out at less than minimum wage for her.

The 3 year old and 2 year old funding is killing childcare because people believe that it's free and we are overpaid.

Norwegiancopice · 25/08/2022 21:28

Lower earners spend therefore creating more business, jobs and wealth. Very wealthy put their wealth in tax free off shore accounts doing nothing for the economy. £15 an hour will be spent on food, fuel, clothes all essentials.

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 21:26

163,000 cost to the taxpayer

Divide by the 5 years they are training for = £32,600 a year
£636 a week

Doctors work a MINIMUM of 80 hours a week unpaid

£636 divide by 80 hours of work = £7.95 an hour

Less than minimum wage!

So they are not costing the taxpayer at all. They are in fact working and being paid less than the legal amount while getting into thousands of pounds of debt.

Bard6817 · 25/08/2022 21:23

Sheesh…. Student Loan Company is funded by taxpayers…. Who else would loan students 22billion with an indeterminate period of repayment and capped interet rates and a repayment expiry dates.

So technically, one can argue that students pay for their own tuition, but that’s just politics, in reality i would love to know how many students actually repay the full amount…. Can’t imagine it’s very high.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 21:22

I would add, I don't resent contributing to the cost of that medical training in the slightest. Quite the contrary. As a society, we need doctors. What I would like to see is the taxpayer contributing to more of the cost of training up doctors, with the proviso that those doctors will remain in the NHS. Same for dentists.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 21:04

And I’ve already said several times. Tax payers DO NOT fund medical training. It’s funded via student loans the same as any other training.

According to Full Fact in 2017, the government's claim that it cost £230,000 to train a doctor was misleading, because this implied that the £64,300 borne by the student themselves was a cost to the taxpayer. As around 80% of this is likely to be repaid, that is obviously incorrect. Full Fact estimate that the actual cost to the taxpayer of training a doctor (in 2017) was 163,000.

Students pay a maximum of £9,250 per annum in tuition fees, plus any living costs that they incur. If the actual cost of training a doctor exceeds this - and all of the evidence suggests that it does - then someone else has to make up the difference. My understanding is that the taxpayer currently fills that gap.

threatmatrix · 25/08/2022 21:01

What people fail to understand is that if it keeps going up people won’t have a job as all the small businesses will shut.

Cyclemarine · 25/08/2022 20:59

Breezycheesetrees · 25/08/2022 18:58

I work for a charity, I earn more than minimum wage but less than 15 an hour. If all of our salaries have to go up to £15/h I expect we will go bankrupt, or a large number of us will lose our jobs

Surely the answer is to radically reform our housing system so that housing costs come back in line with household earnings? I'd be in favour of banning private landlords altogether (or making it possible only through some sort of housing association), nationalising rented housing (or making it all non-profit) and completely detaching housing costs from market forces. Housing is a basic need not a luxury consumer good. Ditto energy and water. Pushing wages up is just going to fuck small businesses and charities, and push all prices up anyway.

Housing costs are out of control. I saw on Twitter a thread about 2-bed flats in Manchester and Glasgow for 2,000 pcm. Those are cities previously thought of as affordable, and the wages haven’t gone up a whole lot yet rent has seemingly doubled in the past 5 years . I can’t imagine how much they’d hike them up by if the government did actually raise the NMW significantly.

the government needs to get a grip on this housing crisis and fast.

I Agree that Housing is a basic need and people shouldn’t have to rely on the private sector for it.

Mxr · 25/08/2022 20:53

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 20:33

I would LOVE to see you work 80 hour weeks for £30k a year! Because that’s what junior doctors get, not rolling in money like you seen to think.

And I’ve already said several times. Tax payers DO NOT fund medical training. It’s funded via student loans the same as any other training. The NHS contributes LESS THAN £3000 in total to the training and they work thousands of hours unpaid during that training.

Doctors “fuck off to America” because the working conditions are vile, the pay is crap, the debt they carry is crippling and idiot members of the public like you haven’t got the slightest clue what it’s really like.

If you think it’s so privileged then train as a doctor yourself!

As someone in an allied healthcare profession I would do ANY OTHER job in the entire world before I worked as a junior doctor.

But how lovely of you to think that those multiple suicides are because they are not good enough and not because of the toxic working environment. Want to engage in some more victim blaming while you’re here?

You're just angry.
Actually we are ALL angry...& Rightly.
Junior Drs, tho you won't see if that way, are still ' training '.
80 hrs a week is not that much ...there are many fields & businesses , where that & more is ' normal '
Look, if whoever it is doesn't want such a vocation, then it's just ' wrong for them '.
And yes, it's the amount of beaucracy & red tape that's the biggest problem. That's a Govt & managerial fck up .

Btw, Drs are not the only vocation which asks commitment & dedication. But, it carries a very high social status ( it's not just about money ).

It really isn't worth debating , because there's a LOT more to it, as you will be aware.
Being abusive is just childish

Medicine is NOT that difficult !
What's difficult, is working within a fckef up System & having to be a jack of all trades in addition.

Also, I think you'll find huge numbers of ppl dedicated to what they love, who work 10-12 hrs & more a day.
Wtf else is there to do in life ?
IF one REALLY loves what they do ?
I question that in your case !!

Bard6817 · 25/08/2022 20:53

You said….

“Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.”

Thats not where business profits go… If you think that’s Capitalism, do more reading please, What you describe, is much more akin to socialism.. Thats why Russian Oligarchs exist. In Capitalism, the profits go to the shareholders, not one or two members of a party or the govt.

Blantw · 25/08/2022 20:47

Everytime similar is suggested, businesses say they cannot afford to give pay rises and their business will not survive, but it never seems to happen.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 20:37

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 20:27

Firstly, if doctors didn't agree prior to training that they would pay the cost of their training if they left the NHS it can't be imposed respectively. There would be massive push back from all doctors, regardless of whether it affected them personally and I'm not sure if it would be legal anyway.

Secondly, people who pay for private treatment have paid towards the cost of doctor’s medical training if they are taxpayers.

Thirdly, I'm not sure where you get the idea that the UK tax payer is not getting its money’s worth with regard to training doctors. As I said few doctors are entirely private and those that are will have worked for the NHS for many years.
If anyone should be complaining it's the countries whose doctors we have taken after they have trained them (e.g. India), not the UK taxpayer. The NHS trains fewer doctors than it employs, not the other way around.

I'm not suggesting that it should be imposed retrospectively. I agree that you couldn't do that. But you could make it clear to prospective students that this was what they were signing up for.

E17Stowmum · 25/08/2022 20:34

I don't know about unreasonable, but your politics and economics are all over the place.
You blame capitalism then defend market forces.
You do not distinguish between price-driven and wage-driven inflation.
You are a civil servant paid out of the income tax you want kept down, yet dislike government intervention.
This £15 is the same £10 it was two years ago. It's worth the same: nothing more.

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 20:33

Mxr · 25/08/2022 20:24

Drs don't get paid enough ?
Or have to work " too hard "?
Upside down again !
There are too many other positions paid far too much...eg many local Gove AND NHS senior managers.

And NO NO NO......If your country funds your training , you pay it back when you can AND Drs are obliged to work in the State System which allowed them their privileged status.

Absolutely sickens me....seen it so many times....foreign students join family here, take State medical / dental training, set up privately & earn a fortune.
Disgusting & taking the p"SS totally.

If the work is too ' hard for them ' , then they are not up to doing it. Simple !
Can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen & get work at the level you were born for.

Honestly, whining pathetic users who want everything .
Want to be ' private '?
Well fck off to America or similar, pay for your training, & do it yourself !
No, tax payers do NOT need wimpy scrounging egotist like you !!

I would LOVE to see you work 80 hour weeks for £30k a year! Because that’s what junior doctors get, not rolling in money like you seen to think.

And I’ve already said several times. Tax payers DO NOT fund medical training. It’s funded via student loans the same as any other training. The NHS contributes LESS THAN £3000 in total to the training and they work thousands of hours unpaid during that training.

Doctors “fuck off to America” because the working conditions are vile, the pay is crap, the debt they carry is crippling and idiot members of the public like you haven’t got the slightest clue what it’s really like.

If you think it’s so privileged then train as a doctor yourself!

As someone in an allied healthcare profession I would do ANY OTHER job in the entire world before I worked as a junior doctor.

But how lovely of you to think that those multiple suicides are because they are not good enough and not because of the toxic working environment. Want to engage in some more victim blaming while you’re here?

Brefugee · 25/08/2022 20:31

most people in this thread are STILL trying to square the circle within our current set up.
The current setup is a race to the bottom.
What is needed is a rethink about the society we want - and yes, that includes making the NHS somewhere people want to work, and can work without burnout. Properly funded and resourced and still free at the point of use.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 20:27

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 20:19

Except that won’t happen!

Because actually making the NHS a decent place to work would cost far far far more than the penalties applied to those leaving it due to those conditions. So it won’t happen.

All your idea achieves is punishing those who after dedicating their lives to help others, saddling thousands in debt as a result simply can’t see any other way out then to leave. Taking away that one escape by imposing financial penalties will push even more to suicide. And female doctors are already 4 times more likely to take their own lives.

Come back and read your comments when it’s your daughter coming home in tears every single night. Only then will you see how ignorant they are.

Yes, it would cost more. I'm not for a minute suggesting that it would pay for itself. The taxpayer needs to invest in a decent health care system that meets the needs of our changing population. I don't think it's impossible, but I do think it requires the political will and the courage to do what's needed. And some kind of cross-party collaboration that looks at the longer term.

I don't want to take away escape routes for people who are struggling. I want us to address the reasons why they are struggling. Yes, I will find it very difficult if dd ends up struggling with her mental health etc, but I don't think having everyone opt out to do private health care is the solution.

I'm sorry that you're obviously struggling as much as you are. Genuinely, I am, and I am not in the least belittling how hard it is or judging individuals for making the decisions that they need to make to preserve their sanity. I am just saying that we need to fix the underlying problems rather than merely preserving the escape routes.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 20:27

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:49

Yes, it might well cost the taxpayer more, especially if money was invested in improving conditions for NHS staff. The point of it wasn't to save money but rather to provide incentives for people to stay in the NHS and to stop subsidising the training of those who choose to go into private practice.

And yes, of course, it isn't for me to say what type of doctors other people should or shouldn't be willing to pay for. That's entirely up to them. I was talking about the kind of doctors that we, as taxpayers, might want to fund the training for.

If people want to pay for private treatment, then I think it's reasonable for them to pay towards the cost of their doctors' medical training too, rather than expecting this to be subsidised by the state.

Firstly, if doctors didn't agree prior to training that they would pay the cost of their training if they left the NHS it can't be imposed respectively. There would be massive push back from all doctors, regardless of whether it affected them personally and I'm not sure if it would be legal anyway.

Secondly, people who pay for private treatment have paid towards the cost of doctor’s medical training if they are taxpayers.

Thirdly, I'm not sure where you get the idea that the UK tax payer is not getting its money’s worth with regard to training doctors. As I said few doctors are entirely private and those that are will have worked for the NHS for many years.
If anyone should be complaining it's the countries whose doctors we have taken after they have trained them (e.g. India), not the UK taxpayer. The NHS trains fewer doctors than it employs, not the other way around.

Mxr · 25/08/2022 20:24

Drs don't get paid enough ?
Or have to work " too hard "?
Upside down again !
There are too many other positions paid far too much...eg many local Gove AND NHS senior managers.

And NO NO NO......If your country funds your training , you pay it back when you can AND Drs are obliged to work in the State System which allowed them their privileged status.

Absolutely sickens me....seen it so many times....foreign students join family here, take State medical / dental training, set up privately & earn a fortune.
Disgusting & taking the p"SS totally.

If the work is too ' hard for them ' , then they are not up to doing it. Simple !
Can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen & get work at the level you were born for.

Honestly, whining pathetic users who want everything .
Want to be ' private '?
Well fck off to America or similar, pay for your training, & do it yourself !
No, tax payers do NOT need wimpy scrounging egotist like you !!

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 20:19

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 20:10

I'm not encouraging her to be exposed to it in the slightest. If anything, I would far prefer that she did something else, but she funnily enough, she has her own mind and she wants to do it anyway. She has spoken to loads of people and done tons of research. She has tried to put herself off. She still wants to do it anyway. It isn't my decision.

I get how hard it is. Really, I do. I just don't think the answer is for people to have to escape the NHS because the working conditions are so fucking awful. That can't be the answer. The issues that are causing doctors to leave need to be addressed, rather than allowing them to fester and get worse while doctors are leaving in their droves.

We should fund medical training properly for those who want to work in the NHS and we should create decent conditions that make it sustainable for them to stay in the NHS, but I don't think the taxpayer should be subsidising private health care. Sorry if that annoys you, but I just don't agree with that.

Except that won’t happen!

Because actually making the NHS a decent place to work would cost far far far more than the penalties applied to those leaving it due to those conditions. So it won’t happen.

All your idea achieves is punishing those who after dedicating their lives to help others, saddling thousands in debt as a result simply can’t see any other way out then to leave. Taking away that one escape by imposing financial penalties will push even more to suicide. And female doctors are already 4 times more likely to take their own lives.

Come back and read your comments when it’s your daughter coming home in tears every single night. Only then will you see how ignorant they are.

Mxr · 25/08/2022 20:11

You are absolutely spot on correct !
I wrote to Labours front bench before last election, trying to explain why they would get decimated if they didn't wise up . To this & more...!
They got decimated.
But, most ppl don't seem to get the bigger picture...still !!!

So well done for seeing it !
It's a trick they've used for a very long time & still they demand ' more money '. Fools !!
Wrong way around...
Demand lower prices & living costs...strike for that principle.
This is the only sensible way to do it .

Also, similarly, a 10k salary payrise of 10% = 11k. You gain 1k.
But your boss on 100k gains 10k.= 110 k

The difference pre the rise, was 90k
After the rise, boss has 99k more than you.
And so it goes on & on.

Sometimes I think many deserve to be great like crap, Coz this seems pretty obvious to me.
But....the RMT, junior Drs, barristers all want a " pay rise !

Cap the profits , focus on the ' capital- ists '.....they created this misleading System.

I often despair the lack of common sense.

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 20:10

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 20:03

I worked far far more unpaid hours during my degree than I received in support from the tax payer. My student debts are astronomical. I owe the taxpayer nothing.

If your DD goes into medicine you will see this for yourself soon enough. However if this was my DD I would urge them to do anything else! Look at the research behind metal health issues and suicide rates for junior doctors. Why anyone would encourage their child to be exposed to that is beyond me!

And then to try and argue they should be forced to stay in the NHS longer when they eventually break and can’t cope any longer. Or face massive penalties for leaving (on top of their enormous debts). Honestly you haven’t got the slightest clue!

I'm not encouraging her to be exposed to it in the slightest. If anything, I would far prefer that she did something else, but she funnily enough, she has her own mind and she wants to do it anyway. She has spoken to loads of people and done tons of research. She has tried to put herself off. She still wants to do it anyway. It isn't my decision.

I get how hard it is. Really, I do. I just don't think the answer is for people to have to escape the NHS because the working conditions are so fucking awful. That can't be the answer. The issues that are causing doctors to leave need to be addressed, rather than allowing them to fester and get worse while doctors are leaving in their droves.

We should fund medical training properly for those who want to work in the NHS and we should create decent conditions that make it sustainable for them to stay in the NHS, but I don't think the taxpayer should be subsidising private health care. Sorry if that annoys you, but I just don't agree with that.

Madwife123 · 25/08/2022 20:03

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 19:58

I don't need to do any research, I'm well aware of everything you have said in this post, not least because my dd is applying for medicine and I've been looking at what it is going to cost her/us over the course of her degree.

However, my understanding is that the actual cost of training a doctor is well in excess of £200k. Even with the eye watering fees that medical students have to pay, I do not believe that anyone has students loans that amount to that much? I am not quite sure why you think the taxpayer didn't contribute to the cost of your training?

Yes, medical students and doctors have to work ridiculously hard. Yes, working conditions are shit and should be improved. That doesn't mean that there isn't still a huge investment bt the taxpayer in the training of medical students, and as such, I think it's perfectly reasonable to expect them to work in the NHS or repay that additional investment made by the taxpayer.

I worked far far more unpaid hours during my degree than I received in support from the tax payer. My student debts are astronomical. I owe the taxpayer nothing.

If your DD goes into medicine you will see this for yourself soon enough. However if this was my DD I would urge them to do anything else! Look at the research behind metal health issues and suicide rates for junior doctors. Why anyone would encourage their child to be exposed to that is beyond me!

And then to try and argue they should be forced to stay in the NHS longer when they eventually break and can’t cope any longer. Or face massive penalties for leaving (on top of their enormous debts). Honestly you haven’t got the slightest clue!

Swipe left for the next trending thread