Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
badhappening · 26/08/2022 09:26

“Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.”

@Israisingwagesworthit
what you say above is spot on.

No offence, but your thread is a bit long-winded, perhaps confusing.

I accidentally voted Yabu until I saw the above paragraph and then got your point.

YADNBU !!

badhappening · 26/08/2022 09:19

@Branleuse has hit the nail on the head.

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 09:10

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 08:04

Yes, it would take time before the taxpayer would see any benefits, but I believe we need longer term thinking and more investment in order to address the issues in the NHS.

In the shorter term, I think it would help prospective medical students from less wealthy backgrounds who might be deterred from the field by the prospect of so much debt and concerns about funding for the fifth year etc. I know a couple of outstanding students who abandoned the idea of going into medicine when they realised that they would be in so much more debt afterwards than they would from another degree. Limiting the debt to that of a standard degree for those who choose to stay within the NHS would help to address those fears. And yes, medicine is already competitive enough as it is, but if we want the best doctors, I think we need to make it accessible for people from all backgrounds, which it isn't right now.

As for cost, I assume that you're referring to the university of Buckingham as that's the only private medical school that I'm aware of in the UK? Apologies if there are others that I don't know about. At Buckingham, the fees of £173k do not include living costs, which were included in the original calculation of £200k plus, and also in the £64k contributed by the student. Once you add the living costs in, the figure of £200k+ seems about right. The University of Buckingham is not for profit.

There are always different ways of calculating these figures, and the full fact estimate is just one attempt. My point was not so much about an exact figure but rather about the basic fact that the substantial tuition fees paid by students are not sufficient to cover the total cost of training a doctor. On that point, I think we can agree?

As for the "why medics" question, I don't think it should only be medics, and I would apply the same principle to others who do expensive professional training at the taxpayer's expense. So, for example, I would like to see teachers who choose to work in private schools paying back the costs of their teacher training. Why should the state subsidise the professional qualifications of people who want to work in the private sector?

There wouldn't be any long term benefits for the NHS as most doctors in private practice work for the NHS anyway. It would probably result in many fewer if any people wanting to do medicine as who would want to sign a contract which means they can never change their job for the rest of their life even if they hated it?

You must be joking if you think students from a less wealthy backgrounds would be more likely to sign up if it meant that they could end up paying hundreds of thousands back if they find they hate the job and want to do something else. Only someone from a very wealthy background would want to sign up to that.

Not too sure about your cost calculations. Yes, University of Buckingham charge £173k but they will be making a profit so actual cost must be less. Why would you add living costs? The students pay for that themselves so why would they owe it to the tax payer?

I doubt teacher training is particularly expensive and given that teachers work in schools during their training year, I suspect they think the government owes them, not the other way around. They don't usually earn more in the private sector by the public sector by the way.

So you think that anyone who does a degree or professional qualification has to work in the public sector for the rest of their lives or pay back the full cost of their degree or qualification (if it is more than tuition fees) regardless of their wage in the private sector?

Cheeriyo · 26/08/2022 08:42

Zzzmumzzz · 26/08/2022 08:34

I am on minium wage. Those in jobs moaning about it please be mindful that some of you in public sector jobs. nurses, teachers do have good pensions, holiday allowance. I have NONE of these. Yoi are not equal to all minium wage employees

The good news is that there's a huge shortage across the country in many public sector roles. As its so peachy I trust you'll be coming to join us in the land of honey?

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 08:39

Zzzmumzzz · 26/08/2022 08:34

I am on minium wage. Those in jobs moaning about it please be mindful that some of you in public sector jobs. nurses, teachers do have good pensions, holiday allowance. I have NONE of these. Yoi are not equal to all minium wage employees

If you don't get holidays they are breaking the law.

Zzzmumzzz · 26/08/2022 08:34

I am on minium wage. Those in jobs moaning about it please be mindful that some of you in public sector jobs. nurses, teachers do have good pensions, holiday allowance. I have NONE of these. Yoi are not equal to all minium wage employees

Zzzmumzzz · 26/08/2022 08:24

Poor teachers on minium wage? At least they have a pension and good holidsys. My minium wage doesn't have any benefits.

Alexandra2001 · 26/08/2022 08:08

Bard6817 · 25/08/2022 20:53

You said….

“Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.”

Thats not where business profits go… If you think that’s Capitalism, do more reading please, What you describe, is much more akin to socialism.. Thats why Russian Oligarchs exist. In Capitalism, the profits go to the shareholders, not one or two members of a party or the govt.

Most companies are not quoted, so the "share holders" are the directors.

Putins Russia is not socialist by any stretch of the imagination, Oligarchs didn't exist pre 1991.

Sure very wealthy Soviet party members existed but it was our greed in the capitalist west that enabled the extremely rich Russian criminals to invest & live all over the World, esp in London.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 08:04

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 23:33

That means the tax payer would only receive a refund in about 25 years’ time when that person becomes a consultant. How much do you think they should pay back given they would already have worked for the NHS for 15 to 20 years and probably have paid a lot of tax in that time, not to mention unpaid overtime and the £40,000 student tuition fees. I'm sceptical that it actually does cost “well in excess of £200k”, to train a medic by the way given that private medical schools charge about £170 in total and they’re making a profit.

Would they only be charged if they treated patients privately or would you charge if they just leave the NHS full stop in their lifetime? I’m sure that you will be very happy for your daughter to sign away her life and promise to pay hundreds of thousands if she dares to do anything that doesn't involve working for the NHS
in her lifetime.

And why should only medics pay back the entire cost of their ducation/training?

Yes, it would take time before the taxpayer would see any benefits, but I believe we need longer term thinking and more investment in order to address the issues in the NHS.

In the shorter term, I think it would help prospective medical students from less wealthy backgrounds who might be deterred from the field by the prospect of so much debt and concerns about funding for the fifth year etc. I know a couple of outstanding students who abandoned the idea of going into medicine when they realised that they would be in so much more debt afterwards than they would from another degree. Limiting the debt to that of a standard degree for those who choose to stay within the NHS would help to address those fears. And yes, medicine is already competitive enough as it is, but if we want the best doctors, I think we need to make it accessible for people from all backgrounds, which it isn't right now.

As for cost, I assume that you're referring to the university of Buckingham as that's the only private medical school that I'm aware of in the UK? Apologies if there are others that I don't know about. At Buckingham, the fees of £173k do not include living costs, which were included in the original calculation of £200k plus, and also in the £64k contributed by the student. Once you add the living costs in, the figure of £200k+ seems about right. The University of Buckingham is not for profit.

There are always different ways of calculating these figures, and the full fact estimate is just one attempt. My point was not so much about an exact figure but rather about the basic fact that the substantial tuition fees paid by students are not sufficient to cover the total cost of training a doctor. On that point, I think we can agree?

As for the "why medics" question, I don't think it should only be medics, and I would apply the same principle to others who do expensive professional training at the taxpayer's expense. So, for example, I would like to see teachers who choose to work in private schools paying back the costs of their teacher training. Why should the state subsidise the professional qualifications of people who want to work in the private sector?

Alexandra2001 · 26/08/2022 07:57

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 23:29

Why bother training for 3 years to be a nurse, teacher, paramedic, allied health professional etc and come out with £50k plus debt?!!

nursing, paramedics and ailed health professionals all used to study on the job and didn't attend university - but since student fees have been introduced that has shifted - isn't that a bit strange? why do you need to pay £50k to do a vocation when you previously learnt not he job?

Because the job is far more technical and difficult with much more responsibility.

My mum was an SRN, she trained primarily on the wards, her role was patient care, making beds, administering drugs,,, by her own admission, she was the equivalent of an HCA.

Ambulance drivers, picked you off the road and took you to A&E, my best friend died because they had little medical knowledge & didn't realising she had a massive internal bleed.

Modern paramedics are highly trained.

There is also the "chicken and egg" situation that there is simply not enough spare staff to train 1000s of students running around our hospitals.

Why do you think being a AHP is a vocation but training as an accountant or a lawyer etc isn't?

Its this sort of thinking that has got AHPs such low pay rises.

MarshaBradyo · 26/08/2022 07:35

This is more a supply issue so a supply shortage drives global energy prices up and that impacts all parts of the economy

Wage prices going up cause more inflation because businesses put up prices to deal with it

It’s not so much people having more money as they don’t

Although I have wondered why tax cuts are said to cause inflation as same applies - people don’t have more money overall due to energy price rise

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 07:21

If people spend more money, prices go up.

so with people spending less money atm - why then are prices going up? Can you explain ?

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 07:19

Midwifery has been proven to be safer with degree educated midwives.

yet there is a shortage of midwives, surely it’s better to have a midwife than not? And if we recruit from overseas di those midwives have the same qualifications? We are seeing mass recruitment from overseas as we don’t have enough of our own nurses. Somehow the new system isn’t working and we will be left without- that can’t be safer

Madwife123 · 26/08/2022 00:16

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 23:29

Why bother training for 3 years to be a nurse, teacher, paramedic, allied health professional etc and come out with £50k plus debt?!!

nursing, paramedics and ailed health professionals all used to study on the job and didn't attend university - but since student fees have been introduced that has shifted - isn't that a bit strange? why do you need to pay £50k to do a vocation when you previously learnt not he job?

Midwifery has been proven to be safer with degree educated midwives.

Learning on the job teaches the skills but not the underpinning knowledge behind it.

gnilliwdog · 25/08/2022 23:39

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 23:29

Why bother training for 3 years to be a nurse, teacher, paramedic, allied health professional etc and come out with £50k plus debt?!!

nursing, paramedics and ailed health professionals all used to study on the job and didn't attend university - but since student fees have been introduced that has shifted - isn't that a bit strange? why do you need to pay £50k to do a vocation when you previously learnt not he job?

I remember the old nursing schools, but I think the job might have been different 40 years ago. I don't think there were health care assistants so nurses were probably doing more hands on care work. I suppose the job now includes more tasks that require a degree, and HCAs do some of the work nurses used to do.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 23:36

ThistleTits · 25/08/2022 22:43

Not the case, people with more wages spend more money. This increases the economy and keep prices down.

If people spend more money, prices go up.

dianthus101 · 25/08/2022 23:33

Anothernamechangeplease · 25/08/2022 20:37

I'm not suggesting that it should be imposed retrospectively. I agree that you couldn't do that. But you could make it clear to prospective students that this was what they were signing up for.

That means the tax payer would only receive a refund in about 25 years’ time when that person becomes a consultant. How much do you think they should pay back given they would already have worked for the NHS for 15 to 20 years and probably have paid a lot of tax in that time, not to mention unpaid overtime and the £40,000 student tuition fees. I'm sceptical that it actually does cost “well in excess of £200k”, to train a medic by the way given that private medical schools charge about £170 in total and they’re making a profit.

Would they only be charged if they treated patients privately or would you charge if they just leave the NHS full stop in their lifetime? I’m sure that you will be very happy for your daughter to sign away her life and promise to pay hundreds of thousands if she dares to do anything that doesn't involve working for the NHS
in her lifetime.

And why should only medics pay back the entire cost of their ducation/training?

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 23:29

Why bother training for 3 years to be a nurse, teacher, paramedic, allied health professional etc and come out with £50k plus debt?!!

nursing, paramedics and ailed health professionals all used to study on the job and didn't attend university - but since student fees have been introduced that has shifted - isn't that a bit strange? why do you need to pay £50k to do a vocation when you previously learnt not he job?

ivykaty44 · 25/08/2022 23:22

The 3 year old and 2 year old funding is killing childcare because people believe that it's free and we are overpaid.

if the government were playing fair they would fund the 2 year olds free places correctly - but they don't so you can't get a pay rise and be paid properly

ts not NMW that would shut your nursery down but the government fiasco of underfunding the free hours at nursery

Dragonsmother · 25/08/2022 22:51

Once again middle income earners would be hit the hardest

Why bother training for 3 years to be a nurse, teacher, paramedic, allied health professional etc and come out with £50k plus debt?!!

All along one could have stayed in a minimum wage job and not had the burden of debt, stress of the study and being economically inactive.

If this happened all the other wages would need to be matched with the same offer. if it doesn’t we will loose a massive part of our critical infrastructure and the burden will break a workforce that is already struggling.

ThistleTits · 25/08/2022 22:43

UrsulaPandress · 24/08/2022 09:32

I’m no financial expert but if everyone’s wages go up then prices increase then we are back where we started.

Not the case, people with more wages spend more money. This increases the economy and keep prices down.

TheUnquestionedAnswer · 25/08/2022 22:38

Carers should definitely get it.

Danielle9891 · 25/08/2022 22:31

It would be really nice to earn more but as a waitress on minimum wage and a zero hour contact, it would mean I'd get less hours.

Metabigot · 25/08/2022 22:08

I worked in HR when they first started hiking NMW not that I disagreed with it personally but it just meant staffing levels were cut and more work piled on everyone else to maintain profit margins (which were low to begin with) so people were worked to the bone.

Has to come from somewhere

lljkk · 25/08/2022 21:51

Sheer fantasy to think inflation can be controlled, least of all by capping wage rises. There is no way the private sector won't be raising wages massively. The horse is bolted, public sector will have to cave & give large rises too. We'll be stuck with high inflation for at least 4-5 years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread