Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
NotQuiteUsual · 24/08/2022 10:10

Surely if you can't afford to pay employees enough to live on your business isn't making enough to hire employees full stop. Businesses can't puss the buck into someone else because they want labour at unfair prices.

Tralene · 24/08/2022 10:08

In Finland the wage structure is much more flat. People still aspire to be doctors or solicitors because they are stretching themselves and doing work which will satisfy them. And of course teaching is seen as a highly desirable jon which is only open to the best and brightest.

iwannascream · 24/08/2022 10:08

I currently work for a small business and if min wage was increased to £15ph my boss would have to let staff go to cover the increase. As much as I would love a pay rise not had one for 4 yrs I would much rather not do the work of 2 or 3 to gain it. I think many other business's would be in the same situation

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 10:08

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 09:53

YABU. I was on £8 an hour in the mid 1990s when I worked for a big company as a secretary. Would be around £17 an hour now. Yet minimum pay is less than £10 an hour. The minimum wage absolutely SHOULD be much more. Too many people at the top of these companies are taking too much, whilst the 'little people' get fuckall, except the stale crumbs,

Time to level the playing field. Shit is getting serious now. People need more money. And if anyone says 'people should have worked harder, if they wanted a better paid job,' I swear I'll blow a gasket! Don't even fucking go there.

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps But that was the point of my post. The top bosses will just increase costs to maintain their massive profits, rather than letting profits dip to allow the real terms benefit of minimum wage happen.

If they just increase prices to cover the cost of an increased minimum wage then it disadvantages everyone, those who earn minimum wage, those below £15 per hour currently and those slightly over £15 per hour. For example, I earn £19.50 ish per hour for a very stressful job, If I could stack shelves for £15 I'd take the payout as my mental health would probably improve and I'd be moving all day rather than stuck at a desk alone. That leaves a gap in the 'skilled jobs'.

The introduction of the minimum wage made it easy for businesses to undervalue staff. My mom earnt piece work in the 1980s and earnt more than she does now on minimum wage. Should we remove minimum wage altogether? But that allows further exploitation of the poorest in reality.

Also I'd never say that minimum wages need to work harder to get more pay. My mom is on minimum wage, her bones are literally crumbling as a result of being a 60 year old doing hard manual labour in a factory 40 hours per week for minimum wage. Seeing her working so hard for so little i ensured i got a higher paid job to have easier work.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 24/08/2022 10:08

I'd either lose my job or have my hours reduced because they couldn't afford to pay that much.

PeekAtYou · 24/08/2022 10:08

A £15ph minimum wage should mean that the amount of top up benefits fall. It is perverse that taxpayers subsidise a boost to minimum wage because it's not enough to live on.

I can't get angry at people on low wages wanting to be paid more when people at the top are getting pay rises. If you run a company and want your lower paid people to accept a below inflation pay rise then you should accept a pay cut too. It's outrageous that share holders are making record profits when low paid workers basically have pay cuts.

TimeAtTheBar · 24/08/2022 10:05

I earn £10.81 an hour as a manager with a shitload of responsibility and stress; and that’s if I only work my contracted 48hrs.

Our wages bill is already too high; and our EBITDA is a few pounds a week at best; in a minus often.

I don’t see how this would work without prices skyrocketing. It’s not always about fat cat CEOS, we’re a business just about paying to stay open.

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 10:05

Dadaya · 24/08/2022 09:36

The problem is those who earn just above current min wage but less than £15 per hour. Do we bump them up onto £15 per hour? In which case a job that used to pay above min wage is now less attractive because it’s become a min wage job and people can earn the same on the till in Asda.

For example lots of teachers currently earn less than £15 per hour. So if min wage increases, presumably teachers would be bumped up onto £15 per hour. So why would they continue to bother with the hassle of teaching if they’re now a min wage employee and can earn the same in an easier job?

This, in spades.

In my 2 decades working, my real-terms pay has already been cut by 20% and the gap between what someone starting in my job and someone of 10+ years experience can earn has shrunken considerably as those at the bottom got way more of a % pay increase while those higher up the ladder had to contend with less.

If we keep increasing minimum wage but forget about everyone else then, at some point, everyone will be on minimum wage and the jobs with crappy conditions, which nonetheless at least used to pay reasonably well, will be left without people wanting to work in them.

This doesn't just apply to teaching - how many managerial jobs in retail, hospitality etc. earn above minimum wage, but by far not £15 per hour? ho would take on the extra work and responsibility while being paid the same as everyone else?

The answer is not to continually just look to the bottom.
And, as PP have pointed out, just deciding to increase people's pay will simply make everything more expensive.

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 10:04

Ok, so if people are concerned about their wage being devalued for whatever reason then we need to look at help adjusting the cost of living to match what the lowest paid can afford. Housing is the first thing that springs to my mind.

Brefugee · 24/08/2022 10:03

@Toddlerteaplease
That is awful. And i definitely think that needs to be addressed because otherwise you have people repeating this nonsense

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever. Yes the value to society of some of these roles is very high and definitely some should be paid more, but raising it across the board will create more issues. There are better ways.

ad infinitum.

If all those who have remembered "wage price spiral" from Economics 101, they should also try to remember how the Keyensian multiplier works.

But also. If you train everyone to have these qualifications and therefore the high paying jobs (chortle, see the nurse above) and thus have a high-skills society - who is picking the fruit?

gatehouseoffleet · 24/08/2022 10:02

I always take the view that if a business/organisation says it can't afford to pay its staff a sensible wage/salary, it doesn't have a viable business.

There is an issue with the differential between the low paid and the more skilled jobs, but then you could take the view that the lower skilled jobs are undervalued anyway and are not so low skilled or lacking in responsibility.

Other countries seem to manage to pay their workers decent salaries - they pay high taxes too - but they have a decent standard of living and far more equal society.

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 10:01

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 09:53

YABU. I was on £8 an hour in the mid 1990s when I worked for a big company as a secretary. Would be around £17 an hour now. Yet minimum pay is less than £10 an hour. The minimum wage absolutely SHOULD be much more. Too many people at the top of these companies are taking too much, whilst the 'little people' get fuckall, except the stale crumbs,

Time to level the playing field. Shit is getting serious now. People need more money. And if anyone says 'people should have worked harder, if they wanted a better paid job,' I swear I'll blow a gasket! Don't even fucking go there.

It's not about working harder- people in low paid jobs work exceptionally hard. But it's being able to access training etc that enhances your earning potential. I did a healthcare degree because I grew up in poverty and didn't want that life for myself. If I could move across into a job that paid similar that was less responsibility then of course I would.

DigitalGoat · 24/08/2022 10:01

I work for a charity with a mix of paid and voluntary staff. With fewer people volunteering (there's a whole other thread on that here today) an increase in our wage bill on this scale would about sink us.

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 10:01

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 09:53

YABU. I was on £8 an hour in the mid 1990s when I worked for a big company as a secretary. Would be around £17 an hour now. Yet minimum pay is less than £10 an hour. The minimum wage absolutely SHOULD be much more. Too many people at the top of these companies are taking too much, whilst the 'little people' get fuckall, except the stale crumbs,

Time to level the playing field. Shit is getting serious now. People need more money. And if anyone says 'people should have worked harder, if they wanted a better paid job,' I swear I'll blow a gasket! Don't even fucking go there.

It's not about working harder- people in low paid jobs work exceptionally hard. But it's being able to access training etc that enhances your earning potential. I did a healthcare degree because I grew up in poverty and didn't want that life for myself. If I could move across into a job that paid similar that was less responsibility then of course I would.

midgetastic · 24/08/2022 10:01

No one should work full time and need to claim benefits

If businesses can't do that they are not viable

The whole economic model is fucked up

Reasons for getting educated should be less about money and more about being the best you can be, learning and growing

But the education model is devised around supporting a fucked up economic model not the human beings who are fodder for the model - whereas the model should support all humans ( not just those at the top )

covilha · 24/08/2022 10:01

Hmmm - if a midwife is paid £16 ph it’s more than a nurse-so not sure this is accurate. A band 5 nurse currently gets £13.84ph. And many are paying back student loans. Glad others can see how poorly paid they are but sorry it’s taken an international financial crisis to prove it

Toddlerteaplease · 24/08/2022 10:00

I'm a top band five nurse. I get £16 an hour. It makes my 18 years of work worthless.

Brefugee · 24/08/2022 09:58

So perhaps look into what is driving inflation before arguing against things you don't fully understand. Don't fall for the fact that a few tory MPs have loosely mentioned inflation when talking about wage rises. They have a vested interest in avoiding increasing costs for companies and they are experts at the drop and run approach to population level thought control.

yep. they are dragging the phrase "wage price spiral" from Economics 101 and totally showing up their lack of understanding of the modern /current economy by spouting this nonsense.

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 09:56

The problem you have with that is that minimum wage job will then be on par to entry level barristers, nurses, teachers, drs, etc, etc. Where is the incentive to study, do well and get a professional job? There isn’t. It’s not a case of one being more valuable, it is the case that people who spend ££££ and years studying should be financially recognised for this. You can’t seriously expect a refuse collector to earn the same as a barrister. People want equal wages without working/studying for it, that’s the problem. Wages would need to rise across the board and then you are back to square one. YANBU.

ifonly4 · 24/08/2022 09:53

I have two jobs that pay just above the minimum wage. I've been a Clerical Assistant, Legal and Medical Secretary in my time, used to working in a pressurised environmental, but my two current jobs are currently the most pressurised I've had, they're both jobs other might look down on but I need a lot of background knowledge the ability to act in a calm manner even though I know have the times for problems, otherwise I stay late for nothing. I come home more exhausted than my previous jobs, so obviously I wouldn't say no to a pay rise. On the other hand, the government will have to pay me more, which means less for other services, and my other job will mean customers paying increased prices.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 09:53

YABU. I was on £8 an hour in the mid 1990s when I worked for a big company as a secretary. Would be around £17 an hour now. Yet minimum pay is less than £10 an hour. The minimum wage absolutely SHOULD be much more. Too many people at the top of these companies are taking too much, whilst the 'little people' get fuckall, except the stale crumbs,

Time to level the playing field. Shit is getting serious now. People need more money. And if anyone says 'people should have worked harder, if they wanted a better paid job,' I swear I'll blow a gasket! Don't even fucking go there.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 09:50

How do you square the fact that wages have gone down over the last decade yet inflation has gone up - to historical highs?

It is not wage increases driving inflation. That is evident.

So perhaps look into what is driving inflation before arguing against things you don't fully understand. Don't fall for the fact that a few tory MPs have loosely mentioned inflation when talking about wage rises. They have a vested interest in avoiding increasing costs for companies and they are experts at the drop and run approach to population level thought control.

SwanBuster · 24/08/2022 09:46

It's so complex,

The first and simplest thing I'd do is for the Office of national statistics to get with the times and use technology.

In Real time, they should be advising how much it would cost a family living in a variety of locations in the UK to have a basic standard of living. They could.pull this data from energy suppliers, supermarkets etc. It could easily be done in the modern world.

Obviously this has a huge number of variables because people live in a variety of different ways, but keeping things simple it should Encompass

Housing
Food
Energy
Transport costs

And these figures are updates in real time.

HMRC should take these figures and on a monthly basis tax a family unit only on income exceeding those basic costs. We shouldn't be taxing people and then handing it back to them in benefits - that only helps landlords and corporations because they are the ones subsidised.

If we did this we could very quickly gather a vast amount of statistics on what a true living wage is in every part of the UK. it's likely very different from place to place..

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 09:44

UrsulaPandress · 24/08/2022 09:32

I’m no financial expert but if everyone’s wages go up then prices increase then we are back where we started.

Pretty much. It's not about assuming that people who earn more work harder than those on min wage, but being realistic many higher paid jobs do carry additional responsibility and training. Who on earth would want to be a doctor, for example, when they could earn similar for working in retail where there's no need to get into debt and spend years training or have responsibility for people's lives day in day out? So either you raise wages of those professsions (hence back to where we started) or accept the already chronic shortage will be made worse.

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever. Yes the value to society of some of these roles is very high and definitely some should be paid more, but raising it across the board will create more issues. There are better ways.

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:43

Dadaya · 24/08/2022 09:36

The problem is those who earn just above current min wage but less than £15 per hour. Do we bump them up onto £15 per hour? In which case a job that used to pay above min wage is now less attractive because it’s become a min wage job and people can earn the same on the till in Asda.

For example lots of teachers currently earn less than £15 per hour. So if min wage increases, presumably teachers would be bumped up onto £15 per hour. So why would they continue to bother with the hassle of teaching if they’re now a min wage employee and can earn the same in an easier job?

@Dadaya I fully agree, by raising the minimum wage you push those who just earn over £15 per hour closer to minimum wage earning, which causes the same affect. What's the point of training to be a midwife for example if you only earn £1 per hour over minimum wage in tesco.

Also the government are just increasing the number of those eligible (and would need to rely) on top up benefits to survive (not thrive) as a result of the subsequent cost of living.

There must be another answer somewhere

OP posts: