Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 10:27

SpinCityBlues · 24/08/2022 10:19

I'd like to see the idea of Basic Universal Income properly addressed.

The issue with this is that whatever universal income is would turn out to be the new zero over time.

We cannot do away with greed; it is part of human nature, unfortunately, to exploit things and to try to gain an advantage from them.

So, say if everyone got a basic income of £1500 per month, regardless, after tax. What is then stopping landlords thinking, well, so-and-so can now afford to pay £750 in rent rather than the £400 they were paying before, because - well, they have more money? What is stopping retail from putting up prices, because everyone suddenly has just that little more disposable income?

Basic universal income - even if it could be funded somehow for populations as big as Britain's (let's not forget that where it has been trialled, populations are far smaller; where would all the money come from?) would only work for as long as everything else stays stagnant. Which it simply won't.

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 10:26

All the people in difficult jobs paying £30k or less will just think 'fuck this hassle I will go and stack shelves in a supermarket for the same money'

Either you end up with people leaving teaching, policing, nursing etc in their droves

… or these jobs become easier (maybe even perhaps enjoyable considering you’ve highlighted jobs that are traditionally considered vocations) because they’re not dealing with the consequences of poverty.

DenbyChina · 24/08/2022 10:25

Not wanting a decent minimum wage ensures that millions stay in poverty and during a CoL crisis, forcing more into poverty. Companies like Sainsburys and British Gas keep posting record profits and yet barely pay their staff a wage to exist upon. If you are upset that your job doesn't pay enough compared to jobs that you consider to be inferior and should therefore be badly paid, you are part of the problem.

The problem is is that our attitudes are wrong: we've been told for years by politicians that getting a further education somehow makes people superior and that you should therefore be able to ensure that you are above those who didn't continue their education. That then means that people never want those who they perceive to be 'lower' to get a decent wage. It's a nasty cycle in which we refuse to acknowledge that no-one should live in poverty, and no-one should be forced to decide between heating and eating.

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 10:25

midgetastic · 24/08/2022 10:01

No one should work full time and need to claim benefits

If businesses can't do that they are not viable

The whole economic model is fucked up

Reasons for getting educated should be less about money and more about being the best you can be, learning and growing

But the education model is devised around supporting a fucked up economic model not the human beings who are fodder for the model - whereas the model should support all humans ( not just those at the top )

@midgetastic I agree noone should work fulltime and claim benefits, yet its required and increasing minimum wage (and prices going up to cover it) could increase the of people who would need it.

There needs to be a complete restructure of businesses/companies to allow for fair working salaried of all workers.

I disagree with the education point though. I did my degree on top of a 40 hour working week, no social life, barely any sleep. I wrote my dissertation with a 4 week old and missed out alot from the first 4 weeks of my babies life. I 100% did it for the career prospects and money. I'd never put myself through a degree like that if it was for enrichment nor would i get into that level of debt for it, I'd read for pleasure or learn a language instead.

OP posts:
Wheretheskyisblue · 24/08/2022 10:25

Rather than a minimum wage how about a maximum ratio of say 10 between the highest and lowest 10% of wages. That way company bosses are encouraged to increase the wages of the lowest paid at the expense of profits, things are more equitable and wages do not fuel inflation.

ProbAmU · 24/08/2022 10:24

I earn just under £15 an hour for a very stressful job at times. If the minimum wage was £15 an hour I'd be expecting an equivalent pay rise (as would everyone in a similar situation), or I'd be off to do a much lower stress job for my money.

I don't think it's sustainable.

Lapland123 · 24/08/2022 10:23

Totally in the clouds if you think people would bother to become doctors, solicitors, whatever if they continue to have their pay devalued like currently. All that time, all those years of training, cost of all the training.
You’d be a fool to pick it
and Tralene’s comment is nonsense

Spikeyball · 24/08/2022 10:21

Some people mistakenly think that minimum wage roles are not skilled roles.

Latenightreader · 24/08/2022 10:21

It's a tricky one. I have two jobs with the same third sector organisation, one salaried and one an hourly rate. When MW went up in April I went from earning £1 an hour over MW to 10p over, which was a bit of a knock to my self esteem. My organisation would not be able to afford £15 an hour and would have to make cuts, but my goodness it would make a difference to my life if the wage could go up and work not be affected.

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 10:21

cushioncovers · 24/08/2022 10:19

My view is that companies need to accept lower profits. Corporate greed in big companies has gotten way out of hand. Smaller companies need to accept that if they can't pay a decent wage and make a profit then they don't have a viable business. I have a friend who has a small food business, she complains that she can't get any staff to work for the money she's offering but if she offers a higher wage then she won't make enough to make the business profitable. In my view she obviously doesn't have a business worth keeping then. There are too many people opening up small businesses such as gift shops, hat shops, pet shops, etc etc etc just because they want to then lamenting when they don't get the footfall or can't recruit staff because they aren't offering a decent hourly rate.

So you'd rather have empty/derelict shops then?

Dancingwithhyenas · 24/08/2022 10:21

I don’t know what the answer is but I earn about £15-£20 an hour and have a post graduate qualification and 15 yrs experience relevant to my job (charity sector, so not uncommon). It’s somewhat insulting that a school leaver would get the same.
Price of goods is going up in large part due to Brexit, as is hourly wages (because they literally cannot get the staff anymore). It’s a ridiculous situation to have inflation this high.

LimboLass · 24/08/2022 10:20

Should not happen.

£15 for a 38 hour week is nearly £30k

All the people in difficult jobs paying £30k or less will just think 'fuck this hassle I will go and stack shelves in a supermarket for the same money'

Either you end up with people leaving teaching, policing, nursing etc in their droves OR you have to bump up these salaries to remian competitive which then pushes up prices of goods/services so those on the new minimum wage are still just as relatively poor as they were to begin with.

It would be an unmitigated disaster. I used to work in minimum wage and I worked bloody hard to get up the ladder to a near average wage. If people want more money then put the effort into progressing.

Enough with the I want I want I want.

StormzyinaTCup · 24/08/2022 10:20

Agree OP.

I was looking at the Enough is Enough campaign at the weekend off the back of another thread where it was linked. Whilst I could certainly get on board with one or two of their ideas their suggestion of a minimum wage of £15.00 (amongst other things) whilst on the face of it would be good for the
average Joe/Julie I think is more likely to put smaller companies out of business and people out of jobs.

Also, as a PP mentioned, there is no way I would work in my job which requires a certain qualification and lots of deadlines for what would be minimum wage. I’d be out of there ditching the deadlines and stress and getting a job in a supermarket where I clocked in at 9am clocked out at 5.30pm and didn’t think about work again until I clocked in the next day. What would be the incentive to stay put. If a lot people were to take similar action it would be hugely problematic for the economy, job market and the whole country’s working age population.

Personally, I would want to have much more detail than just the headline grabbing £15.00 minimum wage before I could get behind it.

NellesVilla · 24/08/2022 10:19

Previously I was all for a raise in minimum wage, but £15 per hr is quite a jump and too much too soon surely? I earn around £25k for various reasons atm (needed low stress job for m h issues etc). I don’t quite earn this £15 per hr currently but I accept that if I retrain I can do so- easily- again.

But It’s not as simple as just raising the minimum wage though, is it? You get the next lot of people who are on just over £30k saying “what about us; we need a raise!” etc etc. Also, I bet people on benefits would feel they deserve a raise in their ‘income’- where does it stop?

I do feel though that many small businesses have no business operating if they can’t pay their staff properly. I’m always looking for jobs- keeping an eye on better opportunities in the market etc- and am alarmed to see that anything beyond entry level in admin etc these days only pays v little over minimum wage which is impossible to live comfortably on.

cushioncovers · 24/08/2022 10:19

My view is that companies need to accept lower profits. Corporate greed in big companies has gotten way out of hand. Smaller companies need to accept that if they can't pay a decent wage and make a profit then they don't have a viable business. I have a friend who has a small food business, she complains that she can't get any staff to work for the money she's offering but if she offers a higher wage then she won't make enough to make the business profitable. In my view she obviously doesn't have a business worth keeping then. There are too many people opening up small businesses such as gift shops, hat shops, pet shops, etc etc etc just because they want to then lamenting when they don't get the footfall or can't recruit staff because they aren't offering a decent hourly rate.

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 10:19

NotQuiteUsual · 24/08/2022 10:10

Surely if you can't afford to pay employees enough to live on your business isn't making enough to hire employees full stop. Businesses can't puss the buck into someone else because they want labour at unfair prices.

If businesses close down, then that will increase unemployment, costing the taxpayer a lot more than "subsidising" low wages via the benefits system. It would also cause more empty shops and derelict industrial premises, again, causing the taxpayer more expense in terms of crime, renovating run down areas, etc.

SpinCityBlues · 24/08/2022 10:19

I'd like to see the idea of Basic Universal Income properly addressed.

DogsAndGin · 24/08/2022 10:18

Dotjones · 24/08/2022 09:32

YABU. "Person on £40K doesn't thing low earners should earn more."

The only reason £15/hour could be wrong is that it's too low. That's not even 30K a year for a 37.5 hour week.

Should a couple of 18 year olds on minimum wage, doing unskilled work, with no qualifications, be bringing in £60k a year household income though?

I’m not arguing either way - I’m just very confused because as a skilled worker, with two degrees, and ten years work experience I earn £27k. And my husband’s wage works out to around £15 an hour for a very highly skilled role, and ten years experience. We’re not considered underpaid - we earn the going rate for our line of work.

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 10:17

Tralene · 24/08/2022 10:08

In Finland the wage structure is much more flat. People still aspire to be doctors or solicitors because they are stretching themselves and doing work which will satisfy them. And of course teaching is seen as a highly desirable jon which is only open to the best and brightest.

I assume working conditions for doctors, solicitors and teachers are far less appalling than they are over here?

I know that teachers have it much easier - more freedom, more public recognition and respect (rather than being seen as the root of all evil by so many), far less pressure on them to get results to nurse some stupid league table.

QuebecBagnet · 24/08/2022 10:15

I do think there needs to be a fair living wage not just a minimum wage but we also need to think of the repercussions. What is a NQ teacher or nurse on? NQ nurse starting salary is 27k which is a bit under £15.

So if you were earning minimum wage as a nurse are you going to keep doing that or find an easier job? Then if nurses wage are put up other sectors will want more and then yes prices rise and the people on &15 an hour are back at square one? I don’t know the answer.

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 10:14

Brefugee · 24/08/2022 10:03

@Toddlerteaplease
That is awful. And i definitely think that needs to be addressed because otherwise you have people repeating this nonsense

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever. Yes the value to society of some of these roles is very high and definitely some should be paid more, but raising it across the board will create more issues. There are better ways.

ad infinitum.

If all those who have remembered "wage price spiral" from Economics 101, they should also try to remember how the Keyensian multiplier works.

But also. If you train everyone to have these qualifications and therefore the high paying jobs (chortle, see the nurse above) and thus have a high-skills society - who is picking the fruit?

In 10 years time there won't be a need for fruit pickers, or shelf stickers, or warehouse workers, it will all be automated with few people managing the machines.

The country needs to move to upskilling the workforce before droves of low paid workers are made redundant with no opportunity to redeploy into skilled roles.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 10:14

NotQuiteUsual · 24/08/2022 10:10

Surely if you can't afford to pay employees enough to live on your business isn't making enough to hire employees full stop. Businesses can't puss the buck into someone else because they want labour at unfair prices.

So how does that work with public sector or firms that are nominally private but exist only because of the public sector i.e Care Agencies.

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 10:13

There must be another answer somewhere

To some extent, the increases in the tax free personal allowance and NIC thresholds are "part" of a potential answer. People on minimum wage now pay a lot less tax and NIC which is a "pay rise" in terms of their take home pay.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 10:12

There needs to be a tax system that penalises companies that pay low wages yet making billions and conversely one that helps the struggle business or charity with higher wages, be that on corp tax or with VAT, more support for Charites (not private schools, they aren't charities)

the big problem though is with public services, they are not for profit, so how do we pay for the 10s of billions needed for higher pay?

Sure there would be savings in not paying working benefits but it wont be enough.

So i think there needs to be a wealth tax.

We simply cannot keep getting tax payers to subsidise the profits of large profitable companies.

missbunnyrabbit · 24/08/2022 10:12

If that happens, I'm quitting teaching and going back to work in retail, that was much much easier!!

What is the point in training and doing a stressful job if you don't get rewarded for it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread