Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 24/08/2022 10:51

I don’t know at what point government top up wages but on one hand doing this wouldn’t give people more money and increase inflation if that level is met

But the flip side is companies would have to raise prices to afford it which would cause higher inflation. That would be very difficult now

Whyareblokesonhere · 24/08/2022 10:49

I still think the John Lewis Partnership used to have a very good system that meant the highest Paid person could not earn more than 25x the lowest earner (based on FTE) they then increased it I think to x75 or x100 but then 'had to abolish' it because they couldn't retain 'top talent' but if it was legislation (at whatever %) then it would at least help the impact of 'just increase everyone's pay'. Obviously it is more complex than my brain can fathom because of entrepreneurship, accounting tactics and dividends etc but I do think there is something in that principle.

RunningSME · 24/08/2022 10:48

This was always the plan to inflate away the Debt there is literally no all the way out of this hole we can’t pay it back none of us can

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 10:46

DenbyChina · 24/08/2022 10:28

I disagree with the education point though. I did my degree on top of a 40 hour working week, no social life, barely any sleep. I wrote my dissertation with a 4 week old and missed out alot from the first 4 weeks of my babies life. I 100% did it for the career prospects and money. I'd never put myself through a degree like that if it was for enrichment nor would i get into that level of debt for it, I'd read for pleasure or learn a language instead.

And that really solidly supports my point. What about those people who are not academically minded and able to do what you chose to do? Should they live in poverty because their skills are manual instead of intellectual? That's an elitist mindset and super unfair.

Absolutely not, those who are not academically minded (my husband for example) should have additional options - apprenticeship, t-levels, hands on training where learning can be done in methods outside of sitting in a classroom, I agree these are VERY much lacking in favour of academic learning.

Also those who do work in the low skilled roles should have fair wages and earn enough to have a comfortable living. They should be able to heat, eat, go on holiday and afford luxuries outside of bare survival.

My point was don't efforts need to be made (by stopping the top businesses upping costs to maintain profits) to stop a wage spiral, as it won't actually benefit the poorest if costs go up inline with wages, won't that just make more people reach that poverty line.

OP posts:
slashlover · 24/08/2022 10:46

Spikeyball · 24/08/2022 10:21

Some people mistakenly think that minimum wage roles are not skilled roles.

This. During lockdown we had people who were let go and were hired by us. Some of them really couldn't hack the 5:30am starts or the 11pm finishes or didn't want to work weekends. They couldn't cope with how we are treated by the general public or the workload we are expected to cope with, it's way more than "stacking shelves in Tesco."

WeepingSomnambulist · 24/08/2022 10:46

Whammyyammy · 24/08/2022 09:39

Totally agree, put minimum wage up by 50%, then expect to pay 50% more in sectors that pay minimum wage to its employees.

And yes, I earn a lot more than minimum wage, but years of training to initially do my job, as well as promotions etc through hard work.

Do you think people on low paid jobs dont work/haven't worked hard?

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 10:39

An experienced worker should not be paid the same as a new starter, whatever the trade

We should be raising salaries annually based on hard work leading to reward

that’s an interesting point. I was talking about this the other day. The idea that you can increase your salary with experience is(has?) dying a death. There are many job paths where the only way to increase your wage is to go the management route. Obviously that particular pyramid is never going to lead to financial security for every worker simply because we can’t have a workforce of managers (or highly skilled experts).

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 10:39

Tralene · 24/08/2022 10:28

Yes, that's the point, teaching is seen as highly desirable and teachers are respected partly because only the very best are allowed to do it. Conditions are very different to here. We could reset our society by saying only the top graduates are allowed to work in social care. Won't hold my breath.

They tried that with teachers. QTS used to have an element of literacy, numeracy and ICT you had to pass and at one point, only graduates with a 2.1 and or a First were considered. That soon passed because no one wanted to do the job. Now we're at a point where almost anyone with a pulse will do, conditions are THAT dire, and we are STILL missing the recruitment target.

Societal attitudes towards education need changing, but that will take generations and would require long-term investment (and, yes, more incentives for potential teachers - what Physicist honestly contends with teaching when they could earn three times that in industry and be a lot more respected?)

ProbAmU · 24/08/2022 10:37

mumda · 24/08/2022 10:31

If at £15 an hour it removes the entire need for top up benefits for the employed that'd be good. Just think how much money that'd save. Assuming people could actually work a full week.

But self-employment will be forced to up their rates too.

It wouldn't. I still get top up benefits and that won't change anytime soon

Itsallyellow22 · 24/08/2022 10:36

YABU. "Person on £40K doesn't thing low earners should earn more." This.

Wages should be higher. It's crazy that we have a system where the government massively tops up wages through tax credits etc, this is basically subsidising businesses from having to pay wages that are enough to live on. If minimum wages were enough to live on the benefits bill would be a lot lower surely?

TheMullerLightOwl · 24/08/2022 10:36

YANBU OP. In an ideal world, minimum wage would be higher and that rise would be taken out of profits and therefore dividends. However, rightly or wrongly, SLTs are more interested in keeping the shareholders happy than they are in keeping the "unskilled" minimum wage workers happy.
In reality, an increase in minimum wage would lead to higher prices.

It's also worth noting that it's only the bigger companies that are paying out millions to shareholders. My family runs a small leisure facility with small profit margins - there is no million pound profit to eat into to feed wage increases. Therefore, wage increases would have to lead to price increases, which would of course lead to inflation.

Threelittlelambs · 24/08/2022 10:34

Minimum wage has caused an awful lot of issues and should be scrapped.

Full time workers shouldn’t need benefits, they should be earning enough to support themselves - that’s on businesses to raise salaries online with inflation.

An experienced worker should not be paid the same as a new starter, whatever the trade.

We should be raising salaries annually based on hard work leading to reward.

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 10:33

10HailMarys · 24/08/2022 10:31

YABU to think lower earners shouldn't have a better wage when you're on a decent salary yourself.

I do get what you're saying, and your concerns about the wider economy, but in reality you would be largely unaffected by this and even if you were slightly worse off as a result, you'd still be better off than people on minimum wage.

Everyone would be affected, its not even about the economy as such, but shops and services raising their prices to account for the higher wages, the wages of those in professional roles either rising proportionately or we suffer even worse shortages than we have now. A junior doctor earns less than £15 an hour, why on earth would anyone bother?!

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 10:33

LimboLass · 24/08/2022 10:28

… or these jobs become easier (maybe even perhaps enjoyable considering you’ve highlighted jobs that are traditionally considered vocations) because they’re not dealing with the consequences of poverty

There will still be poverty if the minimum wage goes up. The wage needs to be paid for so the prices for goods and services go up.

The only difference will be people are on poverty with a £2k take home rather than a £1200 take home.

Yes there will still be poverty, but less. If the minimum wage actually covered the cost of things then it follows there are less issues caused by lack of finance.

Or, again, we can look at the problem from the other end and make sure that there are resources (such as housing - clearly my bugbear Grin) that is affordable on a minimum wage. There are much better, arguably cheaper, ways of utilising public funds to support the lowest earners than direct payment benefits.

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 10:32

Wheretheskyisblue · 24/08/2022 10:25

Rather than a minimum wage how about a maximum ratio of say 10 between the highest and lowest 10% of wages. That way company bosses are encouraged to increase the wages of the lowest paid at the expense of profits, things are more equitable and wages do not fuel inflation.

How do you enforce that with international employers? We already have major problems with overseas companies operating from tax havens!

JudgeJ · 24/08/2022 10:32

UrsulaPandress · 24/08/2022 09:32

I’m no financial expert but if everyone’s wages go up then prices increase then we are back where we started.

You're far too sensible for MN! Basic economics are a foreign language it seems.

Spikeyball · 24/08/2022 10:32

"Just remember, many of these are absolutely necessary for the good of society. If everyone goes for a more well paid career, there would be no one left to do some of the absolutely essential roles needed in society"

They think they are easy roles that any teenager can do. See the recent thread where people thought that caring roles could be filled by 15 year olds on work experience.

mumda · 24/08/2022 10:31

If at £15 an hour it removes the entire need for top up benefits for the employed that'd be good. Just think how much money that'd save. Assuming people could actually work a full week.

But self-employment will be forced to up their rates too.

10HailMarys · 24/08/2022 10:31

YABU to think lower earners shouldn't have a better wage when you're on a decent salary yourself.

I do get what you're saying, and your concerns about the wider economy, but in reality you would be largely unaffected by this and even if you were slightly worse off as a result, you'd still be better off than people on minimum wage.

MRex · 24/08/2022 10:30

In my opinion, minimum wage should be raised to the point at which government doesn't need to supplement working salaries with universal credit. If government then choose to subsidise certain industries due to high wage cost but other added value, then great and it is clear what businesses receive that support. Subsidising business profits while the businesses don't pay a living wage does not make sense. If there is a smaller gap between the lowest and highest paid, then that is an improvement for society generally. The £15/hr or even the £40k/yr might need tax adjustments due to cost of living as well, but that's entirely separate to wages.

DenbyChina · 24/08/2022 10:28

I disagree with the education point though. I did my degree on top of a 40 hour working week, no social life, barely any sleep. I wrote my dissertation with a 4 week old and missed out alot from the first 4 weeks of my babies life. I 100% did it for the career prospects and money. I'd never put myself through a degree like that if it was for enrichment nor would i get into that level of debt for it, I'd read for pleasure or learn a language instead.

And that really solidly supports my point. What about those people who are not academically minded and able to do what you chose to do? Should they live in poverty because their skills are manual instead of intellectual? That's an elitist mindset and super unfair.

Tralene · 24/08/2022 10:28

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 10:17

I assume working conditions for doctors, solicitors and teachers are far less appalling than they are over here?

I know that teachers have it much easier - more freedom, more public recognition and respect (rather than being seen as the root of all evil by so many), far less pressure on them to get results to nurse some stupid league table.

Yes, that's the point, teaching is seen as highly desirable and teachers are respected partly because only the very best are allowed to do it. Conditions are very different to here. We could reset our society by saying only the top graduates are allowed to work in social care. Won't hold my breath.

LimboLass · 24/08/2022 10:28

… or these jobs become easier (maybe even perhaps enjoyable considering you’ve highlighted jobs that are traditionally considered vocations) because they’re not dealing with the consequences of poverty

There will still be poverty if the minimum wage goes up. The wage needs to be paid for so the prices for goods and services go up.

The only difference will be people are on poverty with a £2k take home rather than a £1200 take home.

caringcarer · 24/08/2022 10:27

If minimum wage is higher it means tax payers don't have to pay to top up so many peoples wages. Less money spent on benefits so inflation balances out.

Stylishkidintheriot · 24/08/2022 10:27

While everyone is feeling smug with their “higher than minimum wage” jobs. Just remember, many of these are absolutely necessary for the good of society. If everyone goes for a more well paid career, there would be no one left to do some of the absolutely essential roles needed in society

Swipe left for the next trending thread