Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 11:31

This thread is a delightful illustration of the tactics working. Divide and conquer, look out for number 1, watch out for "them".

It's what the government did with immigration, benefits, disabled people, the EU - othering, turn people into "others" hint at them being "the problem" then sit back and watch the people fall over themselves to keep everyone down.

The race to the bottom is accelerating again.

Also op you keep bleating on about the wage spiral, please go and do some basic reading around the reasons this is not the issue (or believe the evidence in front of you of lower wages and higher inflation - it's right there out in the open)

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 11:29

DenbyChina · 24/08/2022 11:23

Sainsburys: chief executive Simon Roberts picked up £2.8 million in bonuses for the year to March 5, on top of his £875,000 a year salary and other benefits. His mammoth pay deal includes a £1.7 million annual bonus and £1.1 million in long-term incentive scheme shares.

Tesco: The chief executive officer of Tesco Plc received 4.7 million pounds ($ 5.7 million) last year

Marks and Spencer: CEO on 2.6 million

Median pay for a FTSE 100 CEO increased from £2.46m in 2020 to £3.41m in 2021. CEO pay has also surpassed the £3.25m median recorded in 2019. The research shows that the median FTSE 100 CEO is now paid 109 times the median UK full-time worker, up from 79 times in 2020 and 107 times in 2019.

God you're right: those poor, poor CEOs and their massive, massive salaries.

Who was sympathising with the CEOs? They don’t need sympathy. Are you deliberately misreading the post or did you genuinely not understand it?

I asked whether anyone had calculated how much extra the people working for minimum wage in those businesses would get if the CEO worked for nothing and his or her salary and bonus was divided up between them. Have you?

NotQuiteUsual · 24/08/2022 11:28

The people saying we obviously want empty and derelict shops if we think fair wages should be standard. Absolutely yes I do. I'd rather an empty, dead high street than one full of 'businesses' that think it's fair to pay poverty wages. Hopefully it'll bring the property prices down with it.

The council run services need actual funding, care services are having major issues with recruiting and keeping staff. Maybe if they paid a fair wage for the incredibly difficult work they'd retain more staff. Then the services would have more experienced people and be less likely to be struggling the way they are now so would become more efficient.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 11:28

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

They might have gone into the professions for the “love of the job” but that doesn't mean they're going to stay in them. Many professions are very stressful with a lot of responsibility. If the salary is no higher than working in a supermarket, many people will switch to work in a supermarket.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 24/08/2022 11:24

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever.

Are there enough higher paying jobs for everyone then? Just waiting for everyone in retail or whatever to retrain?

Somethingtoask · 24/08/2022 11:24

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps firstly because obtaining 2 degrees incurred a lot debt. It involved working 2 jobs around university. Nursing jobs (I'm not a nurse) involve making life threatening decisions, unsociable working (including nights). So whilst it may be lovely to work in a caring profession (for a pretty crap wage). Who is going to be motivated to incur thousands of pounds of debt and being responsible for people's lives when they could get the same pay stacking shelves. Yes, minimum wage workers have very tough and demanding roles but not all. Why have huge responsibility and student debt when you can stack shelves in Aldo for the same pay.

DenbyChina · 24/08/2022 11:23

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 11:12

I love that everyone has decided that most big businesses are run by Scrooge McDuck, diving into a swimming pool full of cash at the end of a hard day flogging the serfs.

Er, no. Even if you took the CEO’s pay and bonus from him or her, in a business that pays minimum wage for some roles, and distributed it amongst the lower paid staff, how much do you think they would get each? Go on, guess.

And ‘the shareholders’ are mostly pension funds and investment funds. Investing ordinary people’s savings. Curse those ordinary people, squeezing the poverty stricken!

Sainsburys: chief executive Simon Roberts picked up £2.8 million in bonuses for the year to March 5, on top of his £875,000 a year salary and other benefits. His mammoth pay deal includes a £1.7 million annual bonus and £1.1 million in long-term incentive scheme shares.

Tesco: The chief executive officer of Tesco Plc received 4.7 million pounds ($ 5.7 million) last year

Marks and Spencer: CEO on 2.6 million

Median pay for a FTSE 100 CEO increased from £2.46m in 2020 to £3.41m in 2021. CEO pay has also surpassed the £3.25m median recorded in 2019. The research shows that the median FTSE 100 CEO is now paid 109 times the median UK full-time worker, up from 79 times in 2020 and 107 times in 2019.

God you're right: those poor, poor CEOs and their massive, massive salaries.

ohholyday · 24/08/2022 11:22

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 11:02

@ohholyday I don't think it's abhorrent, I genuinely think it's the only way to make a real terms increase in minimum wage without prices just rising in line.
There should be a % of profit allowed before windfall taxes occur. But there would need to be so much reform required before that actually happens.

Sorry, I wasn't suggesting that was your take but others on the thread who think the ecomony is dependant on big companies raking in as much profit as possible for their share-holders.

They could take less profit, pay their employees more which would stimuate spending etc etc. Instead, people are getting spending less and getting into dept. What a shit show. But we'll put up with all sorts of shit in this country so I have no hope that any of it will change.

Honeyroar · 24/08/2022 11:22

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 11:16

Skills are skills and should be recognised as such. They still are, currently, but not to the degree they should.

There are so many people on here wanting to dismiss the hard work that education to beyond GCSE level entails - do you really think that unskilled work should be paid the same as skilled?

And no, we are not talking academic snobbery here - there is a reason plumbers, electricians and joiners earn such a high amount of money (I was recently told by a carpet shop that many of their carpet layers would not even get out of bed for less than £400/ day) - it's because we value the knowledge and expertise that they have. So why talk those with academic knowledge, acquired over many years, down and call them snobs?

Hard work and the desire to learn must be rewarded fairly.

So no, I fully disagree with the notion that people who have put years into a degree should be earning the same as those who have dropped out of school and education.

Too many people have degrees. So they shouldn’t be paid much higher. When my 80 year old dad went to uni 1% of the population went. Nowadays it’s a massive percentage. You don’t have to be clever or particularly intelligent to go (I’m proof of that myself).

ToffeeEl · 24/08/2022 11:22

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 11:16

Skills are skills and should be recognised as such. They still are, currently, but not to the degree they should.

There are so many people on here wanting to dismiss the hard work that education to beyond GCSE level entails - do you really think that unskilled work should be paid the same as skilled?

And no, we are not talking academic snobbery here - there is a reason plumbers, electricians and joiners earn such a high amount of money (I was recently told by a carpet shop that many of their carpet layers would not even get out of bed for less than £400/ day) - it's because we value the knowledge and expertise that they have. So why talk those with academic knowledge, acquired over many years, down and call them snobs?

Hard work and the desire to learn must be rewarded fairly.

So no, I fully disagree with the notion that people who have put years into a degree should be earning the same as those who have dropped out of school and education.

I think you'll find that most people saying low wages should be increased are saying that those already earning more should increase as a reflection too. Unless you're just ignoring that

ButteryNuts · 24/08/2022 11:21

Increasing the minimum wage doesn't increase prices to the extent it puts us 'back to where we started'. Theres a lot of studies done on this.

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 11:20

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:11

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And God forbid someone slogging their arse off in a factory doing backbreaking work, (and doing anti-social, tiring shifts,) or sitting at a supermarket checkout with very few breaks, (and stacking the shelves and doing the dotcom orders when the checkouts slow down,) gets paid the SAME as the nurses, police, and teachers. I mean they couldn't POSSIBLY work as hard COULD they? Hmm

We really need to get past this mindset that only the 'professionals' in 'public service roles work hard. It's untrue, and a fucking insult to hard working people doing manual labour, who didn't have the same opportunities as them to get a university degree! (Or were not quite 'academic' enough.)

As for the people saying 'I am a nurse/police officer/teacher, and if I could get paid the same for working in a supermarket, or working in a factory, I would leave today;' if you're so stressed in your job, then leave. What's stopping you? If it's that you need the salary you're on, then change a few priorities in your life. Downsize your home, have fewer luxuries, have the same lifestyle as the lower earners. You seem to think it's OK for others to earn less, so why not you? Why are you staying in your 'hugely stressful' jobs? Just leave and take one of the lower paid jobs that you consider to be much easier!

And as I said, I was clearly wrong about people being in these professions for the love of the job. How sad. Sad

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps Nobody is saying factory or shop workers don't work hard, they very clearly do and are realistically the backbone of the UK.

People are saying why get into £50k debt, study for 8 years and work in awful conditions causing terrible mental issues for £16 per hour when you can work in a manually hard but job straight out of school with no stress outside of work hours for £15.

Everyone would want an increase in salary pushing prices up. Otherwise you get a universal basic income which would just lead to skills shortages and even wider spread poverty.

OP posts:
Liebig · 24/08/2022 11:20

The purpose of a system is what it does. It is delivering profits and power to the higher echelons of society and impoverishing the working masses. It is working exactly as expected.

Now, if you wish to change this state of affairs, you’ll need of massively overhaul the entire global economy to stop such a thing subverting any changes from outside national borders. We all know the rise of globalisation and neoliberal policy in the ‘80s meant that you were effectively competing with the global labour market, not just your national peers. This is the consequence of that system running for forty years.

There isn’t really the resources to face everyone on the same, relatively decent salary anyway. The world is predicated on debt expansion to paper over the cracks of an economy that can no longer cash the cheques it writes with physical resources. Instead, it’s all financial games, with companies having massively inflated stock values leading to market caps in the tens of billions for, what? A company that has an app and runs third party taxis? A messenger app that allows funny face filters? Real estate that has yet to be fully built in China?

It’s all a house of cards. And welcome to the unravelling, because the fact that people are questioning the very core of how we live due to the cost of living, is a pretty good indicator that the winds of change are in motion now.

I wonder how the proles will react to their better elites telling them there’s no more money, just eat cake.

Honeyroar · 24/08/2022 11:19

Branleuse · 24/08/2022 09:36

Not if the big CEOs and shareholders didnt squeeze the entire rest of their businesses so that the people who create the wealth for them, remain in poverty.
Business models need restructuring. I mean, looks whats happening with the energy companies.

This. This. This.
And our governments are so in their pockets too.

Everything must change. But it won’t, because our MPs are mainly setting up their futures for when they are no longer MPs rather than caring for the country. And I don’t just mean the Tories either.

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 11:16

Skills are skills and should be recognised as such. They still are, currently, but not to the degree they should.

There are so many people on here wanting to dismiss the hard work that education to beyond GCSE level entails - do you really think that unskilled work should be paid the same as skilled?

And no, we are not talking academic snobbery here - there is a reason plumbers, electricians and joiners earn such a high amount of money (I was recently told by a carpet shop that many of their carpet layers would not even get out of bed for less than £400/ day) - it's because we value the knowledge and expertise that they have. So why talk those with academic knowledge, acquired over many years, down and call them snobs?

Hard work and the desire to learn must be rewarded fairly.

So no, I fully disagree with the notion that people who have put years into a degree should be earning the same as those who have dropped out of school and education.

fUNNYfACE36 · 24/08/2022 11:16

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 09:44

Pretty much. It's not about assuming that people who earn more work harder than those on min wage, but being realistic many higher paid jobs do carry additional responsibility and training. Who on earth would want to be a doctor, for example, when they could earn similar for working in retail where there's no need to get into debt and spend years training or have responsibility for people's lives day in day out? So either you raise wages of those professsions (hence back to where we started) or accept the already chronic shortage will be made worse.

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever. Yes the value to society of some of these roles is very high and definitely some should be paid more, but raising it across the board will create more issues. There are better ways.

The problem with your argument is if low paid workers unskilled themselves and get a better paid job, the person who moves into their old job faces the same problem.
I don't think many people go into medicine for the money. You can earn much more in other sectors, and still there is a surplus of bright youngsters willing to train to be doctors
I think minimum wage increases need to come from economies and cutting back on the salaries of high earners.

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 11:15

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:11

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And God forbid someone slogging their arse off in a factory doing backbreaking work, (and doing anti-social, tiring shifts,) or sitting at a supermarket checkout with very few breaks, (and stacking the shelves and doing the dotcom orders when the checkouts slow down,) gets paid the SAME as the nurses, police, and teachers. I mean they couldn't POSSIBLY work as hard COULD they? Hmm

We really need to get past this mindset that only the 'professionals' in 'public service roles work hard. It's untrue, and a fucking insult to hard working people doing manual labour, who didn't have the same opportunities as them to get a university degree! (Or were not quite 'academic' enough.)

As for the people saying 'I am a nurse/police officer/teacher, and if I could get paid the same for working in a supermarket, or working in a factory, I would leave today;' if you're so stressed in your job, then leave. What's stopping you? If it's that you need the salary you're on, then change a few priorities in your life. Downsize your home, have fewer luxuries, have the same lifestyle as the lower earners. You seem to think it's OK for others to earn less, so why not you? Why are you staying in your 'hugely stressful' jobs? Just leave and take one of the lower paid jobs that you consider to be much easier!

And as I said, I was clearly wrong about people being in these professions for the love of the job. How sad. Sad

People also work to support themselves. It’s outrageous to suggest that someone who has chosen to study a professional career, get £££££ in debt should be paid the same as someone who hasn’t. The pity party needs to stop. I grew up in poverty and took myself off to night school to get a degree as an adult to make sure I was sorted. I was homeless as a child and had to leave education to work.

The entitlement that people who go out of their way for personal progression should be paid the same as those who don’t is staggering. Communism doesn’t work.

MarshaBradyo · 24/08/2022 11:15

WeepingSomnambulist · 24/08/2022 11:13

But they dont need to go out of business. There is plenty of money to go around.
Instead if allowing royal mail to have £700million in profits, allow them £350million.
Plenty of money is there to pay fair wages which allow people to live.

Do that across the board. No obscene profits, no obscene payouts to shareholders and directors.

There are so many small independent businesses though who just afford today’s costs

eg restaurants, cafes, garden centre (ours just closed so sad)

Right now £15 wage would finish many of them off

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 11:15

It would be pointless to do this. £15 min wage is over 30k a year for a 40 hour a week job. If they paid that to people in unskilled jobs those currently paid 30k a year for more skilled jobs would also expect a salary rise or they would stop doing the skilled jobs and look for ones that didn't that didn't require skill or responsibility.. This would lead to a massive increase in inflation and we would be back to square one.

HideTheCroissants · 24/08/2022 11:15

Dotjones · 24/08/2022 09:32

YABU. "Person on £40K doesn't thing low earners should earn more."

The only reason £15/hour could be wrong is that it's too low. That's not even 30K a year for a 37.5 hour week.

I’m not on minimum wage, I’m on £12 per hour and part of that is holiday pay as I work in school so we don’t get annual leave as such. I get paid for 39 weeks per year and due to budget cuts my hours have been cut and I don’t actually earn enough to pay tax. BUT I don’t want a raise to £15 per hour - that would simply mean the school couldn’t afford the wage bill of all the support staff so there would be even more redundancies. Many employers simply can’t afford a higher wage.

Paying higher wages means higher costs, means higher prices, means pay is then less in real terms, means people want higher pay, - rinse and repeat.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/08/2022 11:14

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.
OK - so if you are against in increase to the pitiful minimum wage, what exactly do you propose when you say "something must change"?
How do you expect people to survive, & what is your alternative recommendation?

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses,
Who do you think should pay those costs, apart from the businesses that are profiting from the exploitation of low-paid workers?

therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.
Businesses can absorb those costs instead of handing them out to shareholders.
At the threat of a government-imposed windfall tax.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?
Not at all.
What do you think is actually bridging the gap between the minimum wage & actually getting enough income to survive on?
In the main - it is Working Tax Credits.
Paid by 'the government' ie you & me - to make up for the shortfall.
Working Tax Credits is one of the biggest legal dodges available to big business. Instead of paying a wage their staff can live on, they underpay, & sit back while the public purse steps in to keep low earners just above the breadline.

In 2015, WTC cost the government £11 billion. That's £11b that should have been paid by corporations, but was instead funded by the public.

theknave · 24/08/2022 11:14

gatehouseoffleet · 24/08/2022 10:02

I always take the view that if a business/organisation says it can't afford to pay its staff a sensible wage/salary, it doesn't have a viable business.

There is an issue with the differential between the low paid and the more skilled jobs, but then you could take the view that the lower skilled jobs are undervalued anyway and are not so low skilled or lacking in responsibility.

Other countries seem to manage to pay their workers decent salaries - they pay high taxes too - but they have a decent standard of living and far more equal society.

That doesn't apply at the moment though. Costs of all types are going through the roof. Take your average fast-food franchise - because they're a franchise they can't put prices up and down, they're fixed. They've seen food costs increase massively, they've seen electricity shoot through the roof, they're still paying business rates (albeit at 50% but it's still a big chunk), they're still paying rent, they've got the day to day costs of equipment repairs (which in a business like that where the equipment is always on the go is high) and all the other sundry costs that are increasing because all those businesses are having to put prices up. You start putting minimum wages up that increases NI and pension contributions too automatically, so it's not just minimum wage itself but the add-ons. And those who are already on a bit over minimum wage will also expect to see their wages go up. So where does it come from? Profit. Or more to the point right now it pushes that business into a loss-making position, and then the business folds. That costs all the employees their jobs. And the companies supplying it with goods and services also take a direct hit because their income goes down. And it spirals. Yes you have to pay people enough to live on but right now it's not the answer. Because the average business owner isn't raking it in, they're wondering if they're going to have a business left.

thebutcherswife · 24/08/2022 11:14

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:11

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And God forbid someone slogging their arse off in a factory doing backbreaking work, (and doing anti-social, tiring shifts,) or sitting at a supermarket checkout with very few breaks, (and stacking the shelves and doing the dotcom orders when the checkouts slow down,) gets paid the SAME as the nurses, police, and teachers. I mean they couldn't POSSIBLY work as hard COULD they? Hmm

We really need to get past this mindset that only the 'professionals' in 'public service roles work hard. It's untrue, and a fucking insult to hard working people doing manual labour, who didn't have the same opportunities as them to get a university degree! (Or were not quite 'academic' enough.)

As for the people saying 'I am a nurse/police officer/teacher, and if I could get paid the same for working in a supermarket, or working in a factory, I would leave today;' if you're so stressed in your job, then leave. What's stopping you? If it's that you need the salary you're on, then change a few priorities in your life. Downsize your home, have fewer luxuries, have the same lifestyle as the lower earners. You seem to think it's OK for others to earn less, so why not you? Why are you staying in your 'hugely stressful' jobs? Just leave and take one of the lower paid jobs that you consider to be much easier!

And as I said, I was clearly wrong about people being in these professions for the love of the job. How sad. Sad

Very well said 👍

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:13

thebutcherswife · 24/08/2022 11:07

YABU. The divide and conquer is strong in this thread. If minimum wage was to go up to people in the little jobs (you know, retail assistants/cleaners/waitresses etc) then the wages of other professions would also go up. The unbridled snobbery of some on here is sickening, looking down your perfect little noses at people who have, in all honesty, got to work hard day in day out for not very much at all. A lot of these jobs involved people working in shops and looking after the general public during the pandemic, who didn’t have the luxury of being furloughed or working from home. Not everyone has the support to go to college/university, some of us had to go straight to work. Not everyone is academically minded. And one more thing, if everyone did retrain, learn a new profession, who would clean the toilets, stack the shelves, man the tills??

Great post @thebutcherswife 😀

WeepingSomnambulist · 24/08/2022 11:13

justaladyLOL · 24/08/2022 11:07

It would make companies totally uncompetitive - companies would go out of business then the guy on £15 min wage has no job at all
it is and always has been the fact that some people earn much less than others

But they dont need to go out of business. There is plenty of money to go around.
Instead if allowing royal mail to have £700million in profits, allow them £350million.
Plenty of money is there to pay fair wages which allow people to live.

Do that across the board. No obscene profits, no obscene payouts to shareholders and directors.

Swipe left for the next trending thread