Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 11:54

turbonerd · 24/08/2022 11:50

I dont understand how «hard» some posters think people should work just to have the opportunity to have a decent place to live and enough money to buy food, clothes, electricity and furniture?
without getting top ups from the state.

you, the taxpayer in the UK, are effectively subsidising all business and all landlords to a ridiculous degree. Why should people not have a decent standard of living whilst stacking shelves in asda?

Nobody is saying that people shouldn't have all of the above.

Every single poster here who said this would affect other workers on higher wages, though, has pointed out the knock-on effect this would have to have on anyone currently earning above minimum wage.

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 11:53

There will always be an correlation between how much you earn and how specialised/in demand your trade is, qualification and experience. Which is right, not everyone can be a nurse, plumber, barrister, teacher, dr. People need to be incentivised into skilled/in demand areas.

You’d have to raise the wages of everyone to keep people in these positions. That’s just fact and many skilled areas/trades already have critical shortages.

Many firms would go to the wall. Look at the teacher pay rise which schools can’t afford as they haven’t been given the money. The small Italian down the road, the small chain of family cleaners, the small construction business so on and so forth. They can’t afford to fund massive pay rises. It will result in huge job losses and companies collapsing. For example, many schools are talking about redundancies and condensing classes. This has just happened at my dc’s school. That on a national scale in all industry.

Wages go up, everyone will have to earn more so inflation rises more and everyone is in the same position they started, just not well of on £15 an hour.

The big firms shareholders are often pension funds not an anonymous billionaire claiming dividends. The CEOs in the large companies earn a lot, they will also pay a lot of tax. Once you’ve taken that out the difference won’t go far for a pay rise in large multinationals.

Economic education should be compulsory in schools, it’s staggering how many don’t have even a basic grasp.

Nicnac112 · 24/08/2022 11:53

So I’m on 40k and those who work probably harder it bothers you if they get paid more? Wow
simple fact if a household are out working full time then there should be zero need for wage tops ups, housing benefit etc. They should be paid a decent and fair wage to pay their bills end of story.

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 11:52

nwatty · 24/08/2022 11:34

Minimum wage should absolutely be higher - however - I work within a local authority and have just worked out that my current salary works out at what £15 an hour would be. Without all pay grades receiving the same uplift where would be the motivation for anyone to do the higher responsibility jobs when they could get paid the same wage to be cleaning to loos or doing the admin tasks of a much lower grade?

Is it still 1974? Who still talks about ‘pay grades’? Maybe it is time to move out of the public sector and experience the real world.

To your point, can you really not see why somebody would do a more responsible and ‘stressful’ job for the same pay as a less-responsible manual job? Really?

Can you see that when somebody is building a career they might want to build their experience and skills? When I started my accountancy training in a Big 4 firm I wasn’t earning much more than I would have earned working in River Island but I was building a professional career. That was my motivation. Is that so difficult to imagine?

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 11:52

turbonerd · 24/08/2022 11:50

I dont understand how «hard» some posters think people should work just to have the opportunity to have a decent place to live and enough money to buy food, clothes, electricity and furniture?
without getting top ups from the state.

you, the taxpayer in the UK, are effectively subsidising all business and all landlords to a ridiculous degree. Why should people not have a decent standard of living whilst stacking shelves in asda?

But this solution won't solve that, is it that hard of a concept to grasp?

turbonerd · 24/08/2022 11:50

I dont understand how «hard» some posters think people should work just to have the opportunity to have a decent place to live and enough money to buy food, clothes, electricity and furniture?
without getting top ups from the state.

you, the taxpayer in the UK, are effectively subsidising all business and all landlords to a ridiculous degree. Why should people not have a decent standard of living whilst stacking shelves in asda?

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 11:50

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

But you've been told repeatedly that this is not how it works by many postersHmm

puffyisgood · 24/08/2022 11:47

it'd be by far the highest minimum wage in the world. given that we're not nearly the richest (per head) country in the world then, yes, it does raise some serious questions. would have very serious implications for more industries than you might think.

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 11:46

Wheresmymoneytree · 24/08/2022 11:37

Let’s keep the poor in their place. How dare they have enough money to be warm and fed.

But this won't solve that. I don't think anyone has said we shouldn't do anything at all, have they? Just highlighted this isn't the answer.

HesterShaw1 · 24/08/2022 11:45

UrsulaPandress · 24/08/2022 09:32

I’m no financial expert but if everyone’s wages go up then prices increase then we are back where we started.

This.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 11:45

Wheresmymoneytree · 24/08/2022 11:37

Let’s keep the poor in their place. How dare they have enough money to be warm and fed.

The minimum wage and the cost of living are two separate things.

The conflation between the two does not help. Its lazy and reflects poor economic understanding.

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 11:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

DiddlyDoris · 24/08/2022 11:43

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

I agree. I am above minimum wage but below £15 PH.

Simply increasing MW is not the answer, I feel it would do more harm than good. Capitalism would ensure prices go up along with any wage rises to null and increase.

Similar to how I feel the benefits system is, just to keep doleing out more ie the £650 grant isn't the answer.

Less vat and taxes to reduce cost of living is how I'd go.

I'm no economist of course though!

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 11:40

ToffeeEl · 24/08/2022 11:22

I think you'll find that most people saying low wages should be increased are saying that those already earning more should increase as a reflection too. Unless you're just ignoring that

So everyone would get paid more and then everything would cost more and those on the minimum wage would be in the same position.

Wheresmymoneytree · 24/08/2022 11:37

Let’s keep the poor in their place. How dare they have enough money to be warm and fed.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 24/08/2022 11:36

Just to say, I currently earn £15.50ph if I break it down. I worked really hard to get where I am, it just doesn't pay fantastically. So that means I've got years of wasted qualifications when I in fact could still be on the tills in Primark and earn ever so slightly less with way less responsibility.

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 11:36

Honeyroar · 24/08/2022 11:22

Too many people have degrees. So they shouldn’t be paid much higher. When my 80 year old dad went to uni 1% of the population went. Nowadays it’s a massive percentage. You don’t have to be clever or particularly intelligent to go (I’m proof of that myself).

My point was that there is no snobbery from people who have a degree looking down on those that don't, as was implied here by several posters. Just that the actual dedication to learn a skill or acquire advanced knowledge should be rewarded.

The percentage of university goers doesn't matter. I cannot think of a single job that requires a degree and only offers minimum wage, though no doubt someone will find a rogue employer who gets away with it somewhere.

The point was that if you raise minimum wage for an unskilled position to the same level as the earnings of someone who has a degree, that degree may as well not be bothered with - it comes with thousands of pounds of investment and many wasted years of study (one could even argue that it would make unskilled workers better off as they would have had the opportunity to earn at an earlier age and therefore build up more in pensions - how skewed would that be, to be effectively punished for taking on more education?)

And as for the poster who pointed out that people are now rolling out strikes even though they don't earn minimum wage - yes, that is for reasons I've already given, because the gap gets ever smaller between those on many years of experience and with much more responsibilities and those who bring with them the bare basics of being able to stack shelves.

goldfinchonthelawn · 24/08/2022 11:34

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:34

Did you actually read my post? I'm not disagreeing that minimum wage should be higher.. but surely it just increases the cost of things making the minimum wage still unaffordable?

Doesn't companies have to reduce profits and mainten current prices to let the minimum wage increase actually make a difference?

Yes. It's the focus on profit that is wrecking the economy. Companies are legally obliged to put profit to sharegholders before fair pay or customer value, so if costs rise they will be passed on to consumers so shareholders get their cut. We need to move away from a profit-first system to one which places equal emphasis on staff pay and customer value.

nwatty · 24/08/2022 11:34

Minimum wage should absolutely be higher - however - I work within a local authority and have just worked out that my current salary works out at what £15 an hour would be. Without all pay grades receiving the same uplift where would be the motivation for anyone to do the higher responsibility jobs when they could get paid the same wage to be cleaning to loos or doing the admin tasks of a much lower grade?

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 11:34

Redqueenheart · 24/08/2022 11:11

Your thinking is rather muddled.

It is possible to support a higher minimum wage AND to want to see corporate profits curbed too...

Currently the tax payer supports many people on low wages through benefits so companies get away with paying people peanuts and instead using profits to pay CEOs ever larger salary and shareholders dividends.

I also don't see why we should get lectured by someone who earns £40,000 in a cushy job as to how people on low incomes should just tough it up and shut up...

@Redqueenheart

Firstly, have I lectured anyone? No. Read the post correctly. (Well I have now, to you..)

Secondly, the whole point of my post was If higher wages are to be successful company profits WILL need to be curbed. Read the post correctly.

Thirdly, I've said CEOs profits (where high) should be mandated to be less to ensure people can live comfortably (my words were heat, eat, holiday, afford life outside of basic survival). Read the posts correctly.

Finally, I've never said lower paid workers should tough it out and shut up. I said at present a £15 per hour pay rise won't actually result in a result in real terms pay rise, as corporate greed will increase costs to maintain excessive profits or small companies will crumble. Other things need to be in play at the same time to make it work. Read the post correctly.

I'm happy to be wrong, and to be considered unreasonable but not by someone who can't grasp my point and argue back to me using my own points.

OP posts:
Tryingtokeepgoing · 24/08/2022 11:34

WeepingSomnambulist · 24/08/2022 11:13

But they dont need to go out of business. There is plenty of money to go around.
Instead if allowing royal mail to have £700million in profits, allow them £350million.
Plenty of money is there to pay fair wages which allow people to live.

Do that across the board. No obscene profits, no obscene payouts to shareholders and directors.

Those ‘obscene’ payouts to shareholders are what is funding our pensions though, or at least those of us without government backed pensions. So destroy profitability in private companies and you create another problem of supporting the retired.

The complex structure of benefits and tax credits, cooked up by Gordon Brown and that no one has dared reform, mean that there are lots of people ostensibly on £10/£11 an hour who are actually taking home more than £15 already because of benefits/tax credits. I wa amazed to read in a thread yesterday that someone eating £54k could in some instances be entitled to benefits

ToffeeEl · 24/08/2022 11:33

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 24/08/2022 11:24

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever.

Are there enough higher paying jobs for everyone then? Just waiting for everyone in retail or whatever to retrain?

You can see from the comments here though that a lot of people in these well trained jobs wouldn't work in them if there were alternatives. So if people wanted to train and take their places seems like a swap to me.

Also if employers had to make jobs more attractive to keep hold of people, better working conditions for nurses, police etc. are only positive.

sjxoxo · 24/08/2022 11:33

They won’t seriously consider putting a windfall tax or higher tax on wealth because, well, we have a Tory government.

If you don’t want underfunded public services & increasing wealth inequality, don’t vote Tory. If you want a fairer/more equal society, don’t vote Tory. It’s that simple

Cheeriyo · 24/08/2022 11:33

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 24/08/2022 11:24

The best solution is surely supporting people into accessing training/qualifications/experience which helps them progress rather than to stay in low paid jobs forever.

Are there enough higher paying jobs for everyone then? Just waiting for everyone in retail or whatever to retrain?

People wouldn't walk into higher paid roles though would they, but doing a job for x years before moving on is reasonable. Then the cycle continues. As is many don't want to.

And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And rightly so. Its a job. Yes people who do these jobs and put up with the barrage of shitty conditions have something inside them that loves the job (or did at one point anyway), but they should be paid fairly and treated fairly without relying on the fact they see it as a vocation or whatever. There's severe shortages across the board though in healthcare and teaching to name just 2- I'm sure all of these who feel people should do the job because of a sense of duty will be lining up.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 11:31

ToffeeEl · 24/08/2022 11:02

Except most companies wouldn't NEED to increase prices to meet the wages.

They would only need to do that if they were going to continue draining every penny of profit to keep at the very top.

£700million taken in profit for Royal Mail but then telling their staff they need to work more for less?? Sounds like there's plenty to go around there to me.

'Most companies'

Ok.

www.fsb.org.uk/uk-small-business-statistics.html

There were 5.5 million small businesses at the start of 2021.
Compared with the previous year, the private sector business population decreased 6.5%
At the start of 2021 there were 5.5 million small businesses (with 0 to 49 employees), 99.2% of the total business. SMEs account for 99.9% of the business population (5.5 million businesses).
SMEs account for three fifths of the employment and around half of turnover in the UK private sector.
Total employment in SMEs was 16.3 million (61% of the total), whilst turnover was estimated at £2.3 trillion (52%).
Employment in small businesses (with 0 to 49 employees) was 12.9 million (48% of the total), with a turnover of £1.6 trillion (36%).
In 2021, there were estimated to be 5.5 million UK private sector businesses
1.4 million of these had employees and 4.2 million had no employees.
The UK private sector business population is made up of 3.2 million sole proprietorships (56% of the total), 2 million actively trading companies (37%) and 384,000 ordinary partnerships (7%) in 2021.
2.7 million private sector businesses as registered for VAT or PAYE, 48% of the estimated total population.
Sixteen percent of all SMEs were operating in Construction, compared with less than 1% in the Mining, Quarrying and Utilities sector.

A couple of things here.

  1. There are a hell of a lot of small businesses.
  2. Small businesses appear to be currently struggling. They are likely to be the most affected by a minimum wage increase. It would make the problem worse.
  3. They employ a lot of people. People who might end up with no jobs.
  4. Hidden in these figures is also the one about how people set themselves up as sole traders. This is either as a legal tax dodge or because bigger corporations insist on it as a legal tax dodge or to reduce employee rights.

It might be worth looking at what you could do with regards to No4 ahead of a possible minimum wage rise as its probably more useful and will have less side effects.
It would be deeply unwise to neglect the impact on small businesses by a minimum wage rise and that would undermine entreprentuership and likely lead to more people being employeed by bigger companies and thus these companies having MORE not less power. How do you encourage new start ups when you make it harder to employ new employers and build from nothing? Without thought to this in tandem with a wage rise, its like shooting yourself in the foot just to score points.
Unions have power over employees in large organisations. They don't get much from people who are in small businesses. They don't represent the interests of small businesses and their employees well as a result. Unions actually, ironically, benefit from massive companies and public sector organisations so their interests are weirdly aligned. This does not necessarily align with workers rights.

This is without considering the impact on skilled jobs which require degree level entry in medium paid job sectors.

Whats the point in raising wages, if you end up with staff shortages in key sectors as a direct result?

Whats the point in raising wages, if you are trying to use it as a blunt instrument to tackle inflation. Unless you look at other structural changes, you are actually achieving the sum total of FUCK ALL.

Yes, people should be paid what they are worth and be able to afford the cost of living. The minimum wage as the only tool to achieve this, is a nonsense. Why no suggestions to limit excessive shareholder bonuses? Why no talk of wage ratios between the lowest and highest paid?

We KNOW that the UK has the biggest gap between the highest paid and the lowest paid in Europe. THATS the problem. That doesn't mean we should raise the minimum wage though. Its about whether the cost of living is too high - thats stuff like the rental sector. We KNOW that there are massive conflicts of interest between Tory MPs and the building sector and the landlord sector. We also know that there are various Union leaders who think everyone should get a few house and are happy to live in a council house despite being able to afford the private sector. BOTH positions on this are fucked in the head and don't reflect the reality of experience of the general population. 'The workers' aren't really being well represented in terms of their best interests by either as a result.

You tackle the cost of living - thats housing and the glaring energy issues FIRST. The minimum wage thing is a red herring in real terms and would only create more problems if you don't acknowledge the side effects it would create.

I have a real beef with MN over the small business thing: the number of threads that come up and say 'contact your union' or 'contact HR' which are completely oblivious to the millions of people who work for small companies or are self employeed contractors.

The problem is the COST OF LIVING NOT WAGES AS SUCH.

This has risen due to more red tape with europe, the cost of the pandemic and the cost of energy and Nimbysm. The effect has been greatest on small busineses, with most large multi-nationals being able to capitalise on market competition finding it harder to compete due to economies of scale.

Its NOT about wages.

The Union leaders are far too often are fucked in the head self serving pricks who are just as out of touch as corporate CEOs.