Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
DogInATent · 24/08/2022 12:18

Toddlerteaplease · 24/08/2022 10:00

I'm a top band five nurse. I get £16 an hour. It makes my 18 years of work worthless.

No one should work full time and need to claim benefits
If businesses can't do that they are not viable

For small businesses, those that are going to suffer the most in the coming crisis, the problem isn't excessive profits depressing wages. It's the limits of what people will pay for goods and services. Your local corner shop isn't paying minimum wage because it's funneling vast profits to offshore tax havens.

Minimum wage needs to rise, and needs to rise faster than middle incomes, which in turn need to rise faster than top incomes.

We need to get past the politics of envy. If minimum wage increases by 20% then your middle income salary does not need to rise by more than that. If it does then it's only fuelling the problem.

This need to value self-worth by having someone else to look down on is why we can't have nice things for everyone, and why we keep on ending up with Conservative governments. It's why we get shit like Brexit.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 12:18

Davina69 · 24/08/2022 12:05

I run a small business and an increase in minimum wage will probably finish us off.

I currently take the same as my staff which is just over minimum wage and any increase would mean we would need to increase prices.

Nobody seems to admit that lockdown wasn't perhaps as good an idea as first thought. Most of the money I make this year will be used to repay the huge loan and overdraft I incurred just to be able to stay in business.

It's time to admit that the second lockdown was hugely damaging and that until the government cuts the amount of money it wastes, we are stuck

Whilst I sympathise with your struggles to keep your business and employees afloat I'm not quite sure how you think this would help.

If everyone stood up and said "yep, bad idea" what would change for you or your employees? If the government hadn't offered those loans you would presumably already be out of business. Your employees either reliant on benefits or employed elsewhere. Assuming they went to jobs earning the same they would be costing/inputting exactly the same amount of money.

The net loss/benefit to the government would stay the same. You are paying the loans because you wanted to keep the business afloat, presumably because you hope to increase your gains in the future or because you prefer working for yourself and are prepared to put in the slog to do that.

Lockdown is virtually nothing to do with where we are now.

MarshaBradyo · 24/08/2022 12:16

Ilovemycatalot · 24/08/2022 12:01

Everyone deserves a wage to live on and current NMW doesn’t reflect that. If businesses go bust because they have to pay a real living wage it probably wasn’t a very viable busses to start with.

This is worrying

So small businesses would collapse, employment would rise, young people have fewer opportunities to start working and we’d see very bad outcomes

If tax we pay goes towards redistribution as pp said and avoids collapse of SME then imo it is preferable

There are other areas that could be looked at over this to with skills first

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 24/08/2022 12:14

This is always going to be a contentious topic. Raising the NMW to £15 per hour is all very well but if everywhere has to raise their prices because of it then suddenly, £15ph has the same buying power as £9ph used to and we’re in the same situation anyway 🤷‍♀️ No idea what the solution is.

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 12:13

Thats irrelevant to people under 40 in reality who are unlikely to get much of a pension full stop due to the current economic reality.

(The ‘irrelevant’ thing, according to this poster, is the fact that the shareholders of FTSE quoted businesses are often pension funds. The type that invest the savings of ordinary people saving for retirement).

Is that so? They will end up with a lot less if you get your way, won’t they? When corporate profits are curtailed so that these mythical shareholders can sit on their diamond encrusted thrones setting fire to £50 notes. Which in reality means that ordinary people’s pension savings will grow more slowly.

In any event, who says that the under 40s can’t save into a pension? Plenty do, especially since joining a workplace pension scheme became the default.

I’m not saying that the minimum wage should be suppressed because shareholders are more important but as a PP notes the lack of understanding of how things like plc profits and dividends, and corporate ownership, work, is surprising.

We can not get away from the issue that the over 65 are net benefiaries from the tax system whilst those under 40 will be net contributors over the courses of their whole life. We really have a situation where the elderly have taken away from subsequent generations.

Great, blame the ‘boomers’ again. Those bastards. Or do you mean that everyone retired (I assume that’s what thebover 65 thing means) will be a burden on the young? What do you propose to do about that, since it will happen to all of us one day?

Walkden · 24/08/2022 12:12

Surely it has to be wrong that people working minimum wage still have to claim state benefits to survive?

Ultimately this means taxpayers are subsidising all business that rely on minimum wage labour and those subsidies are shovelled on to shareholders and CEO in the form of profits.

The argument that decent wages cause inflations or mean people will lose jobs or businesses fail date back to the mills and the origins of the trade union movements

ginnybag · 24/08/2022 12:11

Some of what's being missed is that 'benefits' are wealth redistributors. Tax credits, universal credit, child benefit etc - they're hated on here 'because no-one working should have to rely on benefits' but, actually, they form an important role of moving money from the wealthiest to the poorest. And they do it in a way that doesn't damage small businesses or cost jobs.

The problem with lifting the minimum wage is that it's becoming cost-ineffective to do it, and is contributing to an overall drop in the standard of living. Low wage sectors are seeing roles cut rather than paying increased costs, and these roles are increasingly replaced with technology and higher insurance premiums.

Security is a classic example. Not that long ago, every construction site had guards. Then the minimum wage lifted, and lifted, and sites realised that, for the cost of paying the guards for half a project, they could buy and install a CCTV system, pay an increased insurance premium for the whole thing, and crack on.

And that's what they've done. They gamble the cost saving against the disruption of losses and the insurance overheads and the costs don't stack up. The fact that you get a less-safe environment is a knock on cost. Those jobs are gone, now, for the most part, and they're probably gone for ever. Many remaining security roles needs skills beyond the basics. It's becoming another 'closed' field for the very set of people it once offered lifelong, decent employment to.

Supermarkets are similar. Tech is replacing jobs, and the customer suffers as well as the employee.

And, yes, absolutely people should be offered more training, but its also reality that not everyone in society has (or ever will have) the ability, personality or interest in a 'highly-skilled' role. We need jobs for those people, too, so keeping them cost-viable is necessary, whilst also allowing those people to pay their bills and have a standard of living.

You need available jobs across society, not just highly skilled ones. You also need a reason for people to take on the less-desirable ones, or the stressful ones, or the ones that require years of training and student debt. If you hike the minimum wage, you can get rid of 'benefits', but then cost of living will increase, because wages for the semi-skilled and skilled will also have to jump (see all the strikes from those sectors currently, because they haven't kept pace with the lift in the NMW). You need businesses to be here, to thrive and survive to create those roles, and not all of them are 'viable' but a lot are definitely needed - private care companies, nurseries, shops, garages etc - so we'll need tax-breaks and support for them. We'll need to fund better conditions and perks for roles like nurses, forgive student debt for teachers and doctors, or people won't go into or stay in those roles.

We also need to acknowledge that a percentage of people in society will never 'work', for any number of reasons, and will - financially - always be takers rather than contributors. We need to stop demonising these people.

A previous poster suggested a much more dynamic taxing system. That's a brilliant idea, but would need massive investment in HMRC and DWP, because they aren't fit for purpose now.

There's no way to do this without spending public money somewhere in the system.

Left to me, I would freeze the minimum wage, overhaul both personal and business tax - and business tax rates should be based on a combination of the profit margin of a company, the absolute amount made, and the pay gap between highest and lowest, including director dividends past a threshold - and then increase low wage support via the PAYE system.

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 12:09

Crikeyalmighty · 24/08/2022 11:56

When we were in Denmark minimum wage was really high(around this I think) but so were lots of wages- a lot of quite average office jobs paying around £38k.

The thing is they had high minimum wage, huge tax (around 46%) but no NI, no council tax , cheap public transport and childcare full time at around £240 a month- so most couples with kids worked. There was also lots of very good quality social housing (for Danes) so whilst a lot of couples were bringing home around £3800 equivalent, even with 2 kids their childcare and rent were around £1300. Leaving around £2500 , no council tax etc. The tax take was high and so services were good.

It benefitted young families a lot, it didn't benefit older workers with no kids or single people if any age (apart from cheap good quality housing) but the mentality was different - it was seen as for the common good.

People always say, yes but it's expensive. The only thing I thought was very expensive was eating and drinking out - (that's because people are well paid). So we just did Less if it and more 'brunches' - less evening meals out.

Yep. Social common good as a priority rather than a individualist society which fuelled populism.

Its a completely different value system.

But you can't break out of where we currently are, without having a massive shift in ideas. Thats not fixable with a minimum wage rise.

The fact that the unions see a minimum wage rise as the solution rather than a cultural shift is probably the most depressing thing.

Its also why I comment on the Union leaders earning £100,000 and living in council houses because its indicative of the problem. They don't believe in solving the issues anymore than the Tory government. If they did they would fully understand their social responsibility and why their personal accountability mattered so much.

Grumpypants78 · 24/08/2022 12:09

Miajk · 24/08/2022 12:04

If we can afford to pay ceo's and shareholders millions I don't see why we can't afford to pay other people £15

Most CEOs and shareholders don't get millions, you're just talking about conglomerate corporations not the majority of SMEs.

Grumpypants78 · 24/08/2022 12:07

UrsulaPandress · 24/08/2022 09:32

I’m no financial expert but if everyone’s wages go up then prices increase then we are back where we started.

The issue is everyone's wages are not pushed up though only those on minimum wage, others on higher salaries get minimal increases so you end up with workers wages overtaking those of their managers or people in more senior roles 🙄

MarshaBradyo · 24/08/2022 12:07

MidnightMeltdown · 24/08/2022 12:01

YABU

Inflation is coming from energy prices and these prices are set on the international market.

A rise in minimums wage wouldn't mean that these people are suddenly rushing out to stock up on luxuries, it will mean being able to afford the basics (I.e. food and energy).

It would mean a hike in prices for companies though, pushing up inflation

Davina69 · 24/08/2022 12:05

I run a small business and an increase in minimum wage will probably finish us off.

I currently take the same as my staff which is just over minimum wage and any increase would mean we would need to increase prices.

Nobody seems to admit that lockdown wasn't perhaps as good an idea as first thought. Most of the money I make this year will be used to repay the huge loan and overdraft I incurred just to be able to stay in business.

It's time to admit that the second lockdown was hugely damaging and that until the government cuts the amount of money it wastes, we are stuck

Miajk · 24/08/2022 12:04

If we can afford to pay ceo's and shareholders millions I don't see why we can't afford to pay other people £15

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 12:04

Tryingtokeepgoing · 24/08/2022 11:34

Those ‘obscene’ payouts to shareholders are what is funding our pensions though, or at least those of us without government backed pensions. So destroy profitability in private companies and you create another problem of supporting the retired.

The complex structure of benefits and tax credits, cooked up by Gordon Brown and that no one has dared reform, mean that there are lots of people ostensibly on £10/£11 an hour who are actually taking home more than £15 already because of benefits/tax credits. I wa amazed to read in a thread yesterday that someone eating £54k could in some instances be entitled to benefits

Thats irrelevant to people under 40 in reality who are unlikely to get much of a pension full stop due to the current economic reality.

We can not get away from the issue that the over 65 are net benefiaries from the tax system whilst those under 40 will be net contributors over the courses of their whole life. We really have a situation where the elderly have taken away from subsequent generations.

You might be fine if you have elderly relatives who will leave money to you, but if you aren't then you have been structurally screwed.

Much of our current political problems owe much to our politicians only serving the interests of a single generation, rather than future planning and considering the impact on future generations because that would have involved unpopular political decision making at the time. Instead issues were kicked down the line, and have got significantly worse until they have developed into massive crisis which may mean our current level of lifestyle and world influence is unsustainable. People warned about things like private investment in building hospitals because of the cost at the time, but it was ignored. Its now catching up with us and people are complaining about how public sector wages haven't kept pace - there's a good reason for that... And on top of that we have a decline in health because of a rise in poverty. So again, demographic timebomb.

This is down to political demographics and populism. This has massively disadvantaged younger generations who haven't had the voting power to assert themselves.

The number of people I know in their 50s taking early retirement in the last year is unreal. This is something that those under 40 are unlikely to ever be able to dream of - and their state retirement age is going up - even as life expectancy has dropped. This makes the pool of the working age population smaller as the retired age population swells in size. Again, another time bomb - we need more health care workers at a time when we have less workers overall. We need people to be skilled. People with degrees in the right fields are important. We need people with higher levels of education than we did even 20 years ago. Because this reflects the changing needs of the workplace. We need higher skill levels in most areas.

There will come a generational demographic tipping point at some point. At this point, I think there's going to be a cliff edge in terms of how the elderly are treated because of this demographic time bomb.

Equally though, I don't believe that the unions necessarily represent the interests of the general population either. On a number of scores. There is a self serving internal political system within the unions thats rife with sexism, racism and a dreadful toxic culture of bullying and silencing of debate in the name of progressiveness.

We have a problem. A living standards issue. One thats hard to see a way out of being solved when we have more people as a state to support.

Our benefits system is built on a pyramid scheme set up. One thats about to break.

Ilovemycatalot · 24/08/2022 12:01

Everyone deserves a wage to live on and current NMW doesn’t reflect that. If businesses go bust because they have to pay a real living wage it probably wasn’t a very viable busses to start with.

MidnightMeltdown · 24/08/2022 12:01

YABU

Inflation is coming from energy prices and these prices are set on the international market.

A rise in minimums wage wouldn't mean that these people are suddenly rushing out to stock up on luxuries, it will mean being able to afford the basics (I.e. food and energy).

Trinity65 · 24/08/2022 11:58

Cornettoninja · 24/08/2022 09:40

How do you address the issue that wages haven’t covered the cost of living in some demographics for a long time hence the take up of in-work benefits? We are all paying for private companies profits.

I don’t necessarily agree that minimum wage is the way to adjust that (although I suspect it’s one of the easier ways) but there does need to be some process that ensures work actually pays for a minimum standard of living without government help. Currently people are being priced out of simply existing even when they work all the hours physically possible.

This ^
Spot on @Cornettoninja

Ilovemycatalot · 24/08/2022 11:58

Don’t worry we have a Tory government so it will never happen.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 11:57

turbonerd · 24/08/2022 11:50

I dont understand how «hard» some posters think people should work just to have the opportunity to have a decent place to live and enough money to buy food, clothes, electricity and furniture?
without getting top ups from the state.

you, the taxpayer in the UK, are effectively subsidising all business and all landlords to a ridiculous degree. Why should people not have a decent standard of living whilst stacking shelves in asda?

Of course they should have a decent standard of living but raising the minimum wage won't do that. Other wages will also have to go up and there would be massive inflation. Then the people on minimum wage would be no better off than they were before it was raised.

Crikeyalmighty · 24/08/2022 11:56

When we were in Denmark minimum wage was really high(around this I think) but so were lots of wages- a lot of quite average office jobs paying around £38k.

The thing is they had high minimum wage, huge tax (around 46%) but no NI, no council tax , cheap public transport and childcare full time at around £240 a month- so most couples with kids worked. There was also lots of very good quality social housing (for Danes) so whilst a lot of couples were bringing home around £3800 equivalent, even with 2 kids their childcare and rent were around £1300. Leaving around £2500 , no council tax etc. The tax take was high and so services were good.

It benefitted young families a lot, it didn't benefit older workers with no kids or single people if any age (apart from cheap good quality housing) but the mentality was different - it was seen as for the common good.

People always say, yes but it's expensive. The only thing I thought was very expensive was eating and drinking out - (that's because people are well paid). So we just did Less if it and more 'brunches' - less evening meals out.

FacebookPhotos · 24/08/2022 11:56

I completely support an increase in minimum wage. It is ridiculous to think that anyone working full time should be unable to buy food, have safe housing and keep themselves warm over winter. Increase minimum wage and offer support to the necessary industries which cannot afford it (eg childcare, elderly care, food production). If that means some businesses only make half their previous profits, then tough. If the only way to make your unnecessary business profitable is to exploit poverty stricken workers or to rely on government topping up their wages then your business isn’t sustainable.

I’d like to see the government actually address the root causes of the high cost of living too though (housing being a perennial problem that almost nobody wants to fix, energy costs which everyone wants to fix but takes a long time).

Toddlerteaplease · 24/08/2022 11:56

@dianthus101 I certainly do my job because I love it, but it is incredibly hard work and long hours. Not everyone will stay out of love if they can get better hours and less stress in Tesco.

TPL · 24/08/2022 11:56

A job is not just necessarily about the pay but also conditions. Many people here are saying they would quit their jobs to work in a supermarket as they wouldn't be better off but many people seem to forgetting the 'perks' they may get in their currently higher paid jobs.

Many minimum wage jobs don't pay sick pay, give you the absolute minimum amount of days off, involve late starts and early finishes, shift work, not being able to access drinks or even the toilet easily, spoken to like rubbish by both customers and management, told you can be replaced anytime, enforced overtime - I know of people in retail who have worked 3 weeks solid. Question this and you'll be out the door. Have your hours changed at little notice and be told you shouldn't make plans on your days off in case you are needed. The list goes on.

Boreded · 24/08/2022 11:55

Your knowledge of economics is very very poor…you’ve made sweeping assumptions with no real knowledge of how things work.

you’ve also done like the Facebook GPs who know more about vax than doctors. Here you act like you know more about economics than those working in the treasury

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 11:55

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 11:50

But you've been told repeatedly that this is not how it works by many postersHmm

@JustALittleHelpPlease I quoted the wrong post, and reported to get it deleted.

But as someone who has worked with businesses who are trying to grow/survive for 10 years. My hands on experience is this is exactly how it works. Increase costs = increase prices to maintain profits OR automate more to reduce overheads (I.e cut jobs)

OP posts: