Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
BR1967 · 26/08/2022 19:54

You have already seen reaction to price increases. Imagine increases due to corporate greed. People stop buying and business fails. Unless business wants to go back to high school employment, they need to be employee competitive!

Namedifferentorquestion · 26/08/2022 18:25

Ah, the middle earner on £40K doesn't believe in raising the income of the poorest earning individuals in society..... nice

Zzzmumzzz · 26/08/2022 15:25

At least you get a good pension, flexible working conditions and paid holiday and plenty of overtime.

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 13:52

The above post was to @Anothernamechangeplease

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 13:49

The government/tax payer don't need to give extra money as they are paying the tuition fees for all courses in first place. The students doing cheaper courses are only subsidising those doing the more expensive courses if they actually pay all the loan back. In reality, those that do the more expensive degrees are more likely to pay back the loans as they are likely to get higher earning jobs so if anything it will be the other way around.

I don't see what difference it makes if you have to have medical qualifications to do a job or if it is just useful to have the medical qualifications. But if you are saying that it will be fine for doctors to work in a field such as the pharmaceutical industry, journalism, research (where they would be paid a lot more because of their medical qualifications than someone who doesn’t have them) then I'm sure everyone who doesn’t want to work for the NHS will just do that rather than pay thousands back for the cost of medical training. i.e. your policy would have absolutely no impact on whether doctors remain in NHS and will just put people off training in the first place, particularly the less privileged.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/08/2022 13:18

@dianthus101 Yes I get that-

I'm not pro it being charged 'at all' unless it's 100% cosmetic. Surely it should come under health? The sheer cost these days is stopping people going. There are plans yes, but basically they want your teeth in very good order indeed to be able to get that- whereas people who actually need a lot of work need to pay a fortune to get to them 'very good indeed' stage

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 13:14

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 13:06

I'm not twisting what you are saying. You are the one constantly twisting things to try and make your ridiculous suggestion sound more reasonable. You said if they use their qualification in the “private sector” not the “private healthcare system”. That would include working in any business where medical qualifications would be useful, and certainly not just higher education e.g Pharmaceutical industry, journalism, research, and a lot of other industries.

There will be many degree subjects and qualifications which cost more than the tuition fees. For example engineering and some other practical science subjects. Those people will go into private sector jobs and pay a lot of taxes which more than pay back the costs of the state paid for their initial qualifications.

There are indeed other degrees such as engineering that cost more than the standard tuition fees, but these are generally subsidised within the universities themselves from the fees for classroom based degrees which cost a lot less to run. (And yes, we could have a discussion about whether or not that's fair, but that's a whole other thread.) I'm not aware of the Government investing extra funds to subsidise these degrees on top of what universities get from tuition fees, but ready to stand corrected if they do.

As for people "using their qualifications" in other fields, well yes they do, but you don't have to be a qualified doctor to work in journalism or the pharmaceutical industry etc, regardless of how useful your experience might be. It's not comparable to private practice medicine where you would not legally be able to work as a doctor without having done that taxpayer funded training first.

As for me twisting things to make it sound more reasonable... what exactly have I twisted?

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 13:06

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 12:45

You are absolutely twisting what I am saying, and you know it. I have made it clear that what I'm saying applies to people who choose to work as doctors in the private health care system. I am unaware of what other jobs might specifically require people to be qualified doctors - other than perhaps working in universities to train new doctors, which seems perfectly in line with the public service angle - so I cannot offer an opinion on those.

Re other professionals - I'm not sure what other professional qualifications are funded from the public purse so I can't really comment. I'm not aware of other degree subjects where there is additional state funding beyond the standard student loans which already have to be paid back when people earn enough, but if there are comparable examples, then yes, I think the same principles should apply if there is an equivalent "state sector" for them to work in. If there is no equivalent "state sector", then I would want to understand the reasons for the state subsidising this training before passing further comment.

The vast majority of teachers and doctors work within the state sector. What I'm proposing would benefit them. It is only those who move to the private sector who would pay more, and their private sector employers could make it financially beneficial for them to do so by building this into their costs.

I'm not twisting what you are saying. You are the one constantly twisting things to try and make your ridiculous suggestion sound more reasonable. You said if they use their qualification in the “private sector” not the “private healthcare system”. That would include working in any business where medical qualifications would be useful, and certainly not just higher education e.g Pharmaceutical industry, journalism, research, and a lot of other industries.

There will be many degree subjects and qualifications which cost more than the tuition fees. For example engineering and some other practical science subjects. Those people will go into private sector jobs and pay a lot of taxes which more than pay back the costs of the state paid for their initial qualifications.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 12:45

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 11:08

I am not willfully misrepresenting what you were saying at all. You have effectively said that people should have to repay thousands should they change their minds and no longer be doctors because you said that they would have to pay it back if they “used their qualifications”. Medical qualifications are not just useful for treating patients so you are saying that they can't do a wide variety of jobs unless they pay back the costs of their education. You aren't saying any other professional has to do that if they don't work in the public sector apart from teachers.

You are absolutely twisting what I am saying, and you know it. I have made it clear that what I'm saying applies to people who choose to work as doctors in the private health care system. I am unaware of what other jobs might specifically require people to be qualified doctors - other than perhaps working in universities to train new doctors, which seems perfectly in line with the public service angle - so I cannot offer an opinion on those.

Re other professionals - I'm not sure what other professional qualifications are funded from the public purse so I can't really comment. I'm not aware of other degree subjects where there is additional state funding beyond the standard student loans which already have to be paid back when people earn enough, but if there are comparable examples, then yes, I think the same principles should apply if there is an equivalent "state sector" for them to work in. If there is no equivalent "state sector", then I would want to understand the reasons for the state subsidising this training before passing further comment.

The vast majority of teachers and doctors work within the state sector. What I'm proposing would benefit them. It is only those who move to the private sector who would pay more, and their private sector employers could make it financially beneficial for them to do so by building this into their costs.

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 12:14

Crikeyalmighty · 26/08/2022 11:36

@dianthus101 I don't have any issue with anyone who does both- my biggest concern is the number who do dentistry but never work in NHS practices

Maybe there's better ways of doing this- cover off all costs or rent/rates for those that do at least 60% NHS practice maybe?? There does have to be some action on this though as people are genuinely not going to dentist when they need too once over 18 and it's causing big issues

The practices on the high street are all private businesses. The business might have a contract to do NHS work but that doesn't mean they are part of NHS. They do the dental work and then either NHS or the patient pays them. A large proportion do both private work and NHS work (or they would do if they had signed a contract saying they would do some in NHS work) but the price isn't much different once in many areas especially once you take into account that they do the NHS work much more quickly.

Madwife123 · 26/08/2022 12:05

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 11:54

Madwife123 So reverting to the training a midwife received previously wouldn’t be an option? It’s better to have no midwife’s than a midwife trained in the same manner a 1960s midwife was trained?

The manner in which a 1960’s midwife was trained would not be safe today.

Maternity has changed enormously since then. Women are older, unhealthier, with pre-existing conditions that you require knowledge of to be able to safely care for them.

Women who previously couldn’t safely have children now can thanks to medical advances and again we need to be able to safely care for those women, with cardiac conditions etc.

There is much much more medical knowledge required than previously and without that underpinning knowledge they would be unsafe.

It’s not better to have no midwives but replacing an unsafe system with another unsafe system solves nothing. We need to tackle the root cause. Why are their no midwives? Why are staff leaving the NHS in droves?

Otherwise all that will happen is we train more just for them to leave again. Are you aware that for every 30 midwives trained the NHS gains 1? That’s how bad it currently is! It’s nothing to do with training them, there’s no shortage of people being trained, it’s keeping them!

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 11:54

Madwife123 So reverting to the training a midwife received previously wouldn’t be an option? It’s better to have no midwife’s than a midwife trained in the same manner a 1960s midwife was trained?

Madwife123 · 26/08/2022 11:38

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 07:19

Midwifery has been proven to be safer with degree educated midwives.

yet there is a shortage of midwives, surely it’s better to have a midwife than not? And if we recruit from overseas di those midwives have the same qualifications? We are seeing mass recruitment from overseas as we don’t have enough of our own nurses. Somehow the new system isn’t working and we will be left without- that can’t be safer

@ivykaty44

We have a shortage of midwives due to crap pay and crap working conditions. Hiring midwives without the medical knowledge to safely do their job isn’t going to help that. It makes the system even more unsafe.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/08/2022 11:36

@dianthus101 I don't have any issue with anyone who does both- my biggest concern is the number who do dentistry but never work in NHS practices

Maybe there's better ways of doing this- cover off all costs or rent/rates for those that do at least 60% NHS practice maybe?? There does have to be some action on this though as people are genuinely not going to dentist when they need too once over 18 and it's causing big issues

ivykaty44 · 26/08/2022 11:33

Why do you think being a AHP is a vocation but training as an accountant or a lawyer etc isn't?

where did I write that those were my thoughts? That’s an assumption you made

so your mum as a nurse thinks her job is now done by others without qualifications- so lower pay

this has deliberately been manoeuvred so that those on lower pay are doing the job of a nurse - it’s a con

what would have happened to your mate in the road if no ambulance turned up?

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 11:08

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 10:51

@dianthus101 , I'm not sure if you are wilfully misrepresenting what I'm saying or just misreading. I have not said anywhere that people should have to repay thousands should they change their minds and no longer be doctors. In fact, I have explicitly stated that this is not what I am saying.

I am saying that, should they choose to continue working as doctors but in the private sector rather than the NHS, it is reasonable to expect them to repay a proportionate amount of their training costs. In reality, I would anticipate the burden of this extra cost falling on the private health care providers rather than on individuals, as they would need to factor the additional costs into what they pay their staff in order to make it attractive for them to work in the private sector. I see no reason why the private sector shouldn't contribute towards the cost of training doctors that it is going to employ.

I am not willfully misrepresenting what you were saying at all. You have effectively said that people should have to repay thousands should they change their minds and no longer be doctors because you said that they would have to pay it back if they “used their qualifications”. Medical qualifications are not just useful for treating patients so you are saying that they can't do a wide variety of jobs unless they pay back the costs of their education. You aren't saying any other professional has to do that if they don't work in the public sector apart from teachers.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 10:51

@dianthus101 , I'm not sure if you are wilfully misrepresenting what I'm saying or just misreading. I have not said anywhere that people should have to repay thousands should they change their minds and no longer be doctors. In fact, I have explicitly stated that this is not what I am saying.

I am saying that, should they choose to continue working as doctors but in the private sector rather than the NHS, it is reasonable to expect them to repay a proportionate amount of their training costs. In reality, I would anticipate the burden of this extra cost falling on the private health care providers rather than on individuals, as they would need to factor the additional costs into what they pay their staff in order to make it attractive for them to work in the private sector. I see no reason why the private sector shouldn't contribute towards the cost of training doctors that it is going to employ.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 10:45

gatehouseoffleet · 26/08/2022 10:25

What I would like to see is the taxpayer contributing to more of the cost of training up doctors, with the proviso that those doctors will remain in the NHS

The majority do stay in the NHS. The fact that they do private work on the side is irrelevant, except insofar as they earn extra money on which they pay tax. Win win (they wouldn't be working in the NHS at the times they do the private work, it's extra).

Dentistry is different of course as they do leave the NHS altogether.

Yes, and I specifically mentioned dentists at the outset. For those doctors who remain in the NHS - the majority, based on what you have said - there would be no impact, other than the fact that they would repay a smaller proportion of their student debt. For those who choose to leave the NHS, there would be a penalty.

And yes, I understand where you are coming from with regards to university tuition fees, and if we could get rid of them altogether, with appropriate taxation (of both corporations and individuals) to pay for it, then I would welcome that. I don't think the government will ever row back on that one now though.

What I am specifically talking about is the professional training over and above the standard degree costs that enables people to work in certain professions. And yes, teachers pay the same amount of tax in the private sector, so on an individual level, they are contributing. However, private schools are benefitting from the heavy lifting that is done by the state sector in training these new teachers up. And yes, they work in schools while they are training, but it is my understanding from the school where I am a governor that working with trainees and ECTs requires a huge amount of time and input from their more experienced teachers which private schools are not having to contribute.

Israisingwagesworthit · 26/08/2022 10:41

badhappening · 26/08/2022 09:26

“Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.”

@Israisingwagesworthit
what you say above is spot on.

No offence, but your thread is a bit long-winded, perhaps confusing.

I accidentally voted Yabu until I saw the above paragraph and then got your point.

YADNBU !!

@badhappening you're right, I'm very bad at articulating myself 😂

OP posts:
Bearsan · 26/08/2022 10:41

Yabu
Working people should not be in poverty.
There needs to be a rethink about the whole working culture. Working for possibly 50 of your best years with a few weeks off and then have bad health or drop dead is not exactly tempting anymore. Add a minimum wage job and you are unlikely to have any significant assets to show for all that effort.
It should be made much easier to work part time with decent income, three/ four day week, flexible and more holidays, everyone should be able to eat well and heat their homes minimum. No one should have to be sacrificing time with family, well being, lifestyle etc for a job anymore.
The problem is too much greed at the top, I'm not a socialist by any stretch of the imagination but the ridiculous pay and bonuses are getting out of hand.

gatehouseoffleet · 26/08/2022 10:25

What I would like to see is the taxpayer contributing to more of the cost of training up doctors, with the proviso that those doctors will remain in the NHS

The majority do stay in the NHS. The fact that they do private work on the side is irrelevant, except insofar as they earn extra money on which they pay tax. Win win (they wouldn't be working in the NHS at the times they do the private work, it's extra).

Dentistry is different of course as they do leave the NHS altogether.

gatehouseoffleet · 26/08/2022 10:23

So, for example, I would like to see teachers who choose to work in private schools paying back the costs of their teacher training. Why should the state subsidise the professional qualifications of people who want to work in the private sector

But it doesn't. All those people pay taxes and pay back the costs of their education manifold during their careers, wherever they work. That's why I've never understood the whole tuition fee thing. We need teachers, doctors, lawyers, engineers, accountants, marketers, business people to keep life and the economy going. All those people earn well and pay tax as well as contributing practically.

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 10:19

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 09:31

Why do you think the university of Buckingham is making a profit? It clearly states on its website that it is not-for-profit. Are you suggesting that this is a lie? And I'd so, who do you think those hidden profits are going to?

Re living costs...I don't know why they were originally included in the government estimate and the full fact one. It doesn't make much difference either way, though, because the living costs are covered by the students. Consequently, if you take them out, it makes no difference to the contribution from the taxpayer, it merely reduces the proportion that is covered by the student.

Having worked with talented teenagers from less privileged backgrounds for many years, I am absolutely not joking when I say that many would avoid going into medicine because of fears about the huge amount of debt, and that these fears would be substially allayed if the amount of debt would be substantially reduced for doctors who stayed within the NHS. Not all medical students aspire to go into private practice in any case. If they find that they hate medicine and want to do something else, then I'm not suggesting that they should have to pay back the fees. Everyone should be able to change career if they so wish, and sometimes they might have no choice. However, if they wish to use their tax-payer funded qualifications to work in the private sector, then I think it's perfectly reasonable for them to pay it back. The private sector can presumably account for these costs in the salaries that they pay, and the cost can be passed on to private patients.

Re teachers...of course, it doesn't cost as much and so there would be less to repay overall. As we are so short of teachers at present, I would waive the cost of teacher training entirely for those who want to work in the state sector, and only make them pay back if they subsequently move to a private school. It doesn't make any difference to me how much they are paid tbh. It's about the principle of publicly funded professional qualifications being used to benefit the public sector, and letting the private sector cover the costs of training its own staff.

Not-for-profit means that they are not paying owners or shareholders the profits and the money they make will be invested back in the business. It doesn't mean that they are only charging exact costs.

Regarding teenagers from less privileged backgrounds, I am not suggesting that you were joking about the fact that “many would avoid going into medicine because of fears about the huge amount of debt” Quite the opposite as you are the one suggesting that they would want to risk debt by signing up to pay the costs back should they change their minds and not want to be doctors. That will put off everybody (apart from the very wealthy) let alone the underprivileged. That is why I asked if you were joking.

When you say “if they wish to use their tax-payer funded qualifications to work in the private sector”, you do realise that you're talking about any business that is not public sector? This would include higher education, pharmaceutical industry, journalism, research.

I don't think that there would be anything to repay for teachers. Given that their professional training involves them working in schools, they would probably argue that it was the other way around and they are owed money. Regardless, why should only teachers and doctors pay back for their education if they don’t work in the public sector for the rest of their lives? What about other professionals? Most don't work in the public sector. In fact public sector jobs don't even exist for many professionals so presumably you think they should have to pay the full cost of their qualifications in the first place.

InMySpareTime · 26/08/2022 10:05

If the minimum wage was only for totally unqualified unskilled jobs that might be fair enough, but the vast majority of MW work requires some skill, qualification or training. What if every employer requirement made the hourly wage higher?
Eg. no qualifications or skills = NLW,
DBS =NLW + 50p/hr
Good interpersonal skills +50p/hr
Database skills +50p/hr
GCSE English +50p/hr
GCSE maths +50p/hr
Food safety cert +50p/hr
Till/equipment training +50p/hr
H&S at work training +50p/hr
Software training +50p/hr
Each year of relevant experience required +50p/hr
Flexibility of shifts =10% pay for standby hours not worked.

It would quickly add up, and employers who currently have job requirements for minimum wage roles would have to decide what standard they're willing to drop to pay the least possible. You can't ask for more than minimum skill for minimum wage.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 09:31

dianthus101 · 26/08/2022 09:10

There wouldn't be any long term benefits for the NHS as most doctors in private practice work for the NHS anyway. It would probably result in many fewer if any people wanting to do medicine as who would want to sign a contract which means they can never change their job for the rest of their life even if they hated it?

You must be joking if you think students from a less wealthy backgrounds would be more likely to sign up if it meant that they could end up paying hundreds of thousands back if they find they hate the job and want to do something else. Only someone from a very wealthy background would want to sign up to that.

Not too sure about your cost calculations. Yes, University of Buckingham charge £173k but they will be making a profit so actual cost must be less. Why would you add living costs? The students pay for that themselves so why would they owe it to the tax payer?

I doubt teacher training is particularly expensive and given that teachers work in schools during their training year, I suspect they think the government owes them, not the other way around. They don't usually earn more in the private sector by the public sector by the way.

So you think that anyone who does a degree or professional qualification has to work in the public sector for the rest of their lives or pay back the full cost of their degree or qualification (if it is more than tuition fees) regardless of their wage in the private sector?

Why do you think the university of Buckingham is making a profit? It clearly states on its website that it is not-for-profit. Are you suggesting that this is a lie? And I'd so, who do you think those hidden profits are going to?

Re living costs...I don't know why they were originally included in the government estimate and the full fact one. It doesn't make much difference either way, though, because the living costs are covered by the students. Consequently, if you take them out, it makes no difference to the contribution from the taxpayer, it merely reduces the proportion that is covered by the student.

Having worked with talented teenagers from less privileged backgrounds for many years, I am absolutely not joking when I say that many would avoid going into medicine because of fears about the huge amount of debt, and that these fears would be substially allayed if the amount of debt would be substantially reduced for doctors who stayed within the NHS. Not all medical students aspire to go into private practice in any case. If they find that they hate medicine and want to do something else, then I'm not suggesting that they should have to pay back the fees. Everyone should be able to change career if they so wish, and sometimes they might have no choice. However, if they wish to use their tax-payer funded qualifications to work in the private sector, then I think it's perfectly reasonable for them to pay it back. The private sector can presumably account for these costs in the salaries that they pay, and the cost can be passed on to private patients.

Re teachers...of course, it doesn't cost as much and so there would be less to repay overall. As we are so short of teachers at present, I would waive the cost of teacher training entirely for those who want to work in the state sector, and only make them pay back if they subsequently move to a private school. It doesn't make any difference to me how much they are paid tbh. It's about the principle of publicly funded professional qualifications being used to benefit the public sector, and letting the private sector cover the costs of training its own staff.