Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 13:37

Profits vary year to year. Would you like salaries to vary year on year, too? How about after the pandemic, for example? Sorry guys, we’ve made a loss this year so it’s pay cuts all round?

John Lewis worked on a model of everyone getting some profits - its called everyone getting bonus, so no need for pay cuts when profits are lower

Crikeyalmighty · 24/08/2022 13:37

@Brefugee Want to form a political party with me matey??? Lol. I 100% agree with you (see my post about Denmark) - it isn't all about minimum wage-- it's about the costs people are paying and by massively upping minimum wage a great many smaller business can't make it pay and in the larger businesses prices rocket- meaning more people out of work and higher prices for everyone not out of work.

Where we need to get a grip is on the underlying support systems, childcare, energy costs, privatisation that doesn't work, housing costs -- so so many people are private renting and it's the Wild West out there. The number of people getting rent support via UC that bears zero resemblance to what they are actually paying is massive- meaning money that is intended for food and bills us propping up their rent - people say move somewhere cheaper- this isn't always possible, requires considerable up front cash payments and disrupting children schools or childcare arrangements or jobs etc.

People who are doing fine and have low mortgages in affordable areas or social housing and relatively secure jobs really can't understand the sheer insecurity of not being in that position, especially with a family.

.

Dadaya · 24/08/2022 13:36

Too many people have degrees. So they shouldn’t be paid much higher.
Graduate jobs need to pay enough to make the investment worthwhile. So let’s say 50k for the degree plus 30k lost wages for every year you study. That’s 140k. Over 40 years you’d need to earn an extra 3.5k per year to recoup the cost of studying. So graduates need to earn a few thousand per year more than non graduates. But not a huge amount more. Doctors maybe need to earn 10k more per year to make it worthwhile. Not 60-80k more.

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 13:35

No money is available to raise these salaries because of ideological decisison by the conservative government

I’m transported back to 1990 and the student union, being forced to listen to middle class members of the Socialist Worker Party.

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 13:35

@thebutcherswife
@JustALittleHelpPlease agree with both of you,

its always pushed as militant and workers are bad for wanting more, when all they want is to get by - not like they are greedy.

Now low earners on a bit more than minimum wage are frightened that they will be working for less than someone doing a menial job.

Everyone needs. praise to combat the cost of living - the cost isn't going down so all wages need to increase. But the disparity. between the top and the bottom needs to reduce greatly and those at the top need to stop being greedy

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 13:34

LimboLass · 24/08/2022 13:30

"Working in a supermarket is a far far far tougher gig than teaching"

Pull the other one. I used to work a supermarket both stacking shelves and on the checkouts as needed. The easiest job I have ever had by a country mile.

"Used to" being the operative words here.

ie a temporary gig that you had a way out of. Or why aren't you still there.

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 13:33

AntlerRose · 24/08/2022 13:30

Something needs to be done about linking ceo wages and shareholder profits to the lowest paid members of staff. I dont know how in a big global economy though. But there is something off with a system where large companies make large profits but their members of staff all get top up benefits.

I actually think housing is a big issue too and proper workers housing would help low earners a lot.

Profits vary year to year. Would you like salaries to vary year on year, too? How about after the pandemic, for example? Sorry guys, we’ve made a loss this year so it’s pay cuts all round?

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 13:33

@Bluesky2507

Of course I "have an idea" I'm a strong trade unionist"
No money is available to raise these salaries because of ideological decisison by the conservative government.

They make these decisions because they realise
That a selfish self interested elitist or so called aspirational electorate will vote them in again & again if they have these types of policy.

People such as you "laughing" or stating that that a low status job such as supermarket workers is a tough gig helps create the me
Me me society that we live in.

My sister is a teacher. I'm not immune to the stress of her role & she definitely deserves better remuneration.

Guess what, she would Never ever ever give up her status, career progression, working hours
holidays, pension and weekends off for a supermarket role EVEN if the wage was the same.

oviraptor21 · 24/08/2022 13:32

No, it doesn't just add additional costs - it means that profits are reduced for those at the top and distributed further down the pecking order

Doesn't work like that I'm afraid.
And how would you apply your model to all the non-profit organisations employing people?

BaileySharp · 24/08/2022 13:30

It won't happen anyway. In the nhs anything below mid band 5 would be less than minimum wage if it was £15 ab hour, so it would be very expensive to increase this

AntlerRose · 24/08/2022 13:30

Something needs to be done about linking ceo wages and shareholder profits to the lowest paid members of staff. I dont know how in a big global economy though. But there is something off with a system where large companies make large profits but their members of staff all get top up benefits.

I actually think housing is a big issue too and proper workers housing would help low earners a lot.

LimboLass · 24/08/2022 13:30

"Working in a supermarket is a far far far tougher gig than teaching"

Pull the other one. I used to work a supermarket both stacking shelves and on the checkouts as needed. The easiest job I have ever had by a country mile.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 13:29

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 12:59

Show us the research that somehow proves that pension funds and investment funds used by individuals (eg Vanguard index funds that ordinary people might put into ISAs) only own 3% of FTSE listed companies. If you can. I’ve worked for several FTSE businesses, in external reporting, and I know who owned the biggest tranches of shares.

The ‘burning £50 notes’ thing referred to shareholders, not CEOs. It poked fun at the people who think that ‘shareholders’ are versions of Scrooge McDuck. No. Some might be, but to claim that all shareholders are a uniform bloc of Marie Antoinette types is ludicrous. Because many of them are ordinary people paying into pension funds. You must see that?

As for your last paragraph, you have no idea what I think about minimum wage. I’ve challenged some lazy and poorly informed statements on this thread. Quite how you’ve got from that to making statements about ‘people like you’ is a mystery, but it says something about your ability to assimilate and analyse information.

Not difficult, they own approx 60b of ftse100 companies, the problem arises when insurance companies are added in.

You said Pension funds, not general investments, which would obv be far higher & as you ve not worked for all Ft100 companies and they change constantly, your anecdotal experience is worthless.

As for the the rest of your rant, not worth getting in to.

AStar98 · 24/08/2022 13:29

Perhaps increasing the tax & NI threshold for those on NMW would give low earners a bit of extra in their take home pay.
Not completely taking FT out of paying tax & NI at all but would certainly help not add to the spiralling cost of living.

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 13:28

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 13:27

Did you learn maths at school?

How many ‘CEOs etc’ earning many hundreds of thousands do you think that there are ?

Let’s say that there are 10,000 people in the U.K. earning at least £500k per year. You take £300k per annum off each of them, presumably before tax so that’s a load of income tax revenue gone, and somehow redistribute it as a boost to minimum wage.

Can you do the sums? In case not, I will. You’d get £3 million. Add up the zeros. Let’s say that there are 1 million people working for minimum wage. How much extra would they get per year? If it helps, divide 3 million by 1 million. The answer is an extra £3 per year. Each.

This has been explained so many times on this thread. It’s depressing.

This thread has proven that economics should be compulsory at GCSE.

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 13:28

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

Yes, so increase the minimum wage allows people to have money to live on

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

No, it doesn't just add additional costs - it means that profits are reduced for those at the top and distributed further down the pecking order

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

This decrease the amount of working benefits that are payable, thus reducing the benefits bill considerably

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners? no

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

Your thinking seems to be - Im alright on my wages and will get by but can't see why those at the bottom should earn more to make it easier to heat and eat. The more people that do not have money to spend the worse the economy becomes and people then lose jobs as its self perpetuating and a spiral downwards. As a society we should want people to earn a living without relying on working benefits. People earning their own money and not reliant on the state for top up is a healthier society and people wanting those at the bottom to be suffering and not have enough money to live on should be regarded with suspicion.

DepartmentOfMysteries · 24/08/2022 13:28

I agree with previous posters, while the minimum wage does desperately need to increase, this only works if other, relatively low, wages increase too.
I am a doctor and I don't earn £15/h. The amount of stress and responsibility is so much more than all of the minimum wage jobs I have also worked (cafe, pub, care assistant). I imagine the same goes for teachers, nurses, barristers etc. It doesn't encourage people to go into these under-resourced jobs if they can earn the same in a job with better hours, less responsibility and less stress. Of course people don't go into teaching/nursing/medicine for the money, but to my mind it is fair to pay more to those with higher levels of responsibility.
We do desperately need higher wages for lower earners, but I don't think it is as simple as increasing minimum wage (much as I would love to have my pay bumped to £15/h....!)

Iamthewombat · 24/08/2022 13:27

Snog · 24/08/2022 13:13

The idea is that we pay the CEO etc hundreds of thousands of pounds less than at present and use that to pay a higher minimum wage. So no need to raise prices. And less need to pay UC to people in work.

Did you learn maths at school?

How many ‘CEOs etc’ earning many hundreds of thousands do you think that there are ?

Let’s say that there are 10,000 people in the U.K. earning at least £500k per year. You take £300k per annum off each of them, presumably before tax so that’s a load of income tax revenue gone, and somehow redistribute it as a boost to minimum wage.

Can you do the sums? In case not, I will. You’d get £3 million. Add up the zeros. Let’s say that there are 1 million people working for minimum wage. How much extra would they get per year? If it helps, divide 3 million by 1 million. The answer is an extra £3 per year. Each.

This has been explained so many times on this thread. It’s depressing.

thebutcherswife · 24/08/2022 13:26

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 11:31

This thread is a delightful illustration of the tactics working. Divide and conquer, look out for number 1, watch out for "them".

It's what the government did with immigration, benefits, disabled people, the EU - othering, turn people into "others" hint at them being "the problem" then sit back and watch the people fall over themselves to keep everyone down.

The race to the bottom is accelerating again.

Also op you keep bleating on about the wage spiral, please go and do some basic reading around the reasons this is not the issue (or believe the evidence in front of you of lower wages and higher inflation - it's right there out in the open)

Completely agree @JustALittleHelpPlease

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 13:26

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 13:21

@Whyareyouasking

Once again wrong. You either haven't read or understood my posts.

The op is about a decent minimum wage. Good

I also said very early on in the thread that I'm a trade unionist. Unions should be negotiating on behalf of their workforce upwards & that teachers & nurses deserve higher pay.

As do binmen & care workers & home helps & supermarket workers.

These two things are not mutually exclusive.

If someone has a wage they are happy with then someone else's pay rise is NONE of their business.
If a teacher prefers to quit & work in a low status, unsociable hour, zero progression role for the £15 an hour. I've zero issue with that.. what's the best precisely none of them will. 🙄

I said that if a private enterprise doesn't earn enough profit to pay a decent wage then it's not viable.

I said that a low paid menial unskilled job is a tougher gig than one with career progression, decent pension, self respect & status & good holidays & office hours.

You're entitled to disagree but if you can't understand any of that - not my problem.

Genuinely you keep replying to me and quoting teachers. Why? It’s really bizarre. Why not nurse, barrister, engineer. You’ve clearly got a serious issue with teachers and your trade union position goes hand in hand with the complete lack of economic awareness in your posts. Maybe work on your own education rather than making a career out of being aggressive and stubborn. Also look to your bosses.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 13:21

@Whyareyouasking

Once again wrong. You either haven't read or understood my posts.

The op is about a decent minimum wage. Good

I also said very early on in the thread that I'm a trade unionist. Unions should be negotiating on behalf of their workforce upwards & that teachers & nurses deserve higher pay.

As do binmen & care workers & home helps & supermarket workers.

These two things are not mutually exclusive.

If someone has a wage they are happy with then someone else's pay rise is NONE of their business.
If a teacher prefers to quit & work in a low status, unsociable hour, zero progression role for the £15 an hour. I've zero issue with that.. what's the best precisely none of them will. 🙄

I said that if a private enterprise doesn't earn enough profit to pay a decent wage then it's not viable.

I said that a low paid menial unskilled job is a tougher gig than one with career progression, decent pension, self respect & status & good holidays & office hours.

You're entitled to disagree but if you can't understand any of that - not my problem.

balalake · 24/08/2022 13:21

I think a minimum wage should never be a measure in isolation. Tackle the causes of the race to the bottom that has made this necessary.

First thing should be keeping energy costs down. Reduce costs is better for many than increasing income.

Bluesky2507 · 24/08/2022 13:21

@beachcitygirl teachers and nurses have had to pass exams, go to university, train for years on the job and are saddled with student loans for starters! And the fact that nurses literally save people's lives surely they need rewarding. Do you not appreciate the work that teachers, nurses do??

I'm not saying low skilled workers don't do important work too, but anyone can work in a supermarket. Not many people can teach A level physics or be a cancer nurse. You have to pay these jobs a better salary to attract the best people into those careers.

And you obviously have no idea because unions have been asking for more pay for years and years. Any pay rises have to paid out of the existing budget from which there is no extra funding from the government.

Brefugee · 24/08/2022 13:19

I also agree with pp who said we should take a good look at Universal Basic Income. What that would do is lead to a flourishing of the arts, as much as anything else and I'd be all for it.

We also need to cut away from thinking that if only you'd work harder you'd earn more. Well, sure if you really do get an hourly rate and you double your hours and are paid for them. Sure working harder = more money. But as the saying goes, if those who worked the hardest got the most money, women in developing nations* would be millionaires. (can not remember where i read that)

I mean this is mumsnet: how about feminist economics? how about feminist international relations while we're at it?

There are rumblings among preppers and so on about the Great Reset. How great would it be if we could really really run with that? (but not in the way those preppers want)

*sorry, i never remember if Global South is considered less patronising.

ThrallsWife · 24/08/2022 13:17

This isn't about teachers vs shop staff, but I'll bite.

But I would absolutely argue that dealing with the public on a shop floor for long hours is tough physically and mentally.

As is dealing with a room full of teenagers with the same, if not worse attitudes.

It's largely an insecure role with zero respect, zero status. Unsociable hours [...] working for large corporations that don't give a fuck.
All of those are true for teaching.

No dream of upward progression
BS again. That's what managers have done, literally.

or sense of satisfaction
I talk to many a shop worker who this isn't true for.

or knowledge that you have helped people,
down to attitude, not experience - shop workers help society every day, too.

no autonomy
Same for teaching.

gut wrenchingly mind numbing boring and monotonous with zero self satisfaction
It's what you make of it. Anyone with customer contact can make their day more interesting. Same for teaching, I don't just dumbly deliver the same material every year; it's the interaction with students that make the difference.

and (as evidenced here) so so many people look down on you.
Just like you look down on teachers?

Your posts are unnecessarily hostile against people on higher wages than you. The anti-NMW hike people are not doing this out of envy or to try and keep the underclass down or whatever bull is going on in your head. They are merely pointing out that it doesn't work like that, for all the reasons given.

Swipe left for the next trending thread