Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
justasking111 · 24/08/2022 14:19

If £15 is the bottom of the heap, waitress say, then head waitress, restaurant manager will expect £2ph more minimum because of their responsibility

Pot washer £15 then anyone above this menial back break-in job will expect more

Teaching assistant £15 per hour, then what are teachers worth

Hospital cleaner £15 ph what's a porter, nurse worth

The solution would be to put most people on £15 per hour. We'd level up then.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 14:19

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:07

Can we just address the minimum wage rise = more money to spend = higher inflation fallacy quickly?

As it stands, (simple numbers to make it easy to follow) for the sake of argument, it costs around £15 per hour to cover the costs of living, that is to pay bills, get to work, put food on the table. Currently around £10 of that is earned and £5 comes from benefits or getting into debt.

If you make it £15 from earned income then nothing will come from benefits.

The worker has the same money, no extra to spend anywhere.

The benefit system gains £5 per hour. This does not get spent on latte and cake, it gets spent on other areas of public spending.

INCREASED MINIMUM WAGE DOES NOT INCREASE MONEY BEING SPENT IN THE ECONOMY it does not contribute to a wage spiral in and of itself.

Yes there are many other issues but I thought it might help to lay it out.

Exactly.

Plus we have a massive productivity problem rn. Businesses would do well to be plugging that which will also avert any potential inflationary spiral.

And ofc the very best way to get inflation under control is to stop printing money.

Do both of those things and increase wages and to there's a good chance of getting out of this with less pain.

Or keep wages as they are (ie depressed), keep printing money, keep throwing state benefits at working people and watch as we spiral into a winter of actual physical hardship for the lowest four income deciles while executive pay and asset acquisition skyrockets.

takealettermsjones · 24/08/2022 14:19

You really think humans would prefer doing something meaningless 40-70 hours per week for 50 years because it pays the same as saving lives?

Some of those who have already done the latter would, yes. Because the pleasant notion of "saving lives" doesn't mitigate the stress, fear, burnout, compassion fatigue, exhaustion, etc.

PrivateHall · 24/08/2022 14:18

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:11

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And God forbid someone slogging their arse off in a factory doing backbreaking work, (and doing anti-social, tiring shifts,) or sitting at a supermarket checkout with very few breaks, (and stacking the shelves and doing the dotcom orders when the checkouts slow down,) gets paid the SAME as the nurses, police, and teachers. I mean they couldn't POSSIBLY work as hard COULD they? Hmm

We really need to get past this mindset that only the 'professionals' in 'public service roles work hard. It's untrue, and a fucking insult to hard working people doing manual labour, who didn't have the same opportunities as them to get a university degree! (Or were not quite 'academic' enough.)

As for the people saying 'I am a nurse/police officer/teacher, and if I could get paid the same for working in a supermarket, or working in a factory, I would leave today;' if you're so stressed in your job, then leave. What's stopping you? If it's that you need the salary you're on, then change a few priorities in your life. Downsize your home, have fewer luxuries, have the same lifestyle as the lower earners. You seem to think it's OK for others to earn less, so why not you? Why are you staying in your 'hugely stressful' jobs? Just leave and take one of the lower paid jobs that you consider to be much easier!

And as I said, I was clearly wrong about people being in these professions for the love of the job. How sad. Sad

OK lets take nurses as an example. If nurses get paid minimum wage of £15 per hour, they will be paying back student debt and therefore their take home pay will be less than someone working in a job that requires no skills, qualifications or experience. This will continue until they move up the scale enough which will take years (student loan repayments are really quite high). You really can't see why this would be unappealing? Of course people go into nursing for vocational reasons, but actually it is pay that tends to keep people there as the realities of the horrendous working conditions come to light. Many nurses find it hard to move on into another role with similar pay, so are stuck. Putting them on minimum wage certainly removes that problem, so good good luck retaining any nurses.

missbunnyrabbit · 24/08/2022 14:17

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 12:46

And of course you need to feel better than other people...
Working in a supermarket is a far far far tougher gig than teaching. Most looked down on careers are.

And the prize for the stupidest reply goes to....

I worked in a supermarket for 4 years. I have been a teacher for 3. I would LOVE to go back to the supermarket, if it was paid the same. It was easy and carefree.

gnilliwdog · 24/08/2022 14:15

Many professionals including healthcare professionals don't sit down all day and work unsocial hours too. On top of that they get a lot of responsibility and stress. You are deluded if you don't think any of them would swap for a “boring job” with no responsibility but the same pay.

I don't think I am deluded. Menial work means working just to pay the bills - there's little respect or status, and the repetition of the same task over and over. There's a physical and mental toll - not because you are saving lives but because you are flipping burgers. You really think humans would prefer doing something meaningless 40-70 hours per week for 50 years because it pays the same as saving lives? That's quite cynical.

Closetbeanmuncher · 24/08/2022 14:14

We simply cannot keep getting tax payers to subsidise the profits of large profitable companies

Amen to that!

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 14:12

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:07

Can we just address the minimum wage rise = more money to spend = higher inflation fallacy quickly?

As it stands, (simple numbers to make it easy to follow) for the sake of argument, it costs around £15 per hour to cover the costs of living, that is to pay bills, get to work, put food on the table. Currently around £10 of that is earned and £5 comes from benefits or getting into debt.

If you make it £15 from earned income then nothing will come from benefits.

The worker has the same money, no extra to spend anywhere.

The benefit system gains £5 per hour. This does not get spent on latte and cake, it gets spent on other areas of public spending.

INCREASED MINIMUM WAGE DOES NOT INCREASE MONEY BEING SPENT IN THE ECONOMY it does not contribute to a wage spiral in and of itself.

Yes there are many other issues but I thought it might help to lay it out.

You're missing the reduced corporation tax income to the Govt, from the reduced business profits because they're now paying 50% higher wages, so any saving in benefits will be outweighed by lost tax revenue!

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:12

I didn't suggest they opt out in fact I said it was foolish to opt out but min wage workers have the same worries & needs.

I've also said teachers deserve higher salaries.

but neither you nor anyone has said why they need a higher salary ONLY & BECAUSE workers on min wage having their salary raised.

The whole package of teaching is better than those of supermarket workers. And yes as I've said that includes, status, holidays, employers contributions, self respect, not having to go out to work weekends and Christmas Day etc

I find all these professional people on here professing that they will work in supermarkets if the wage is £15 an hour utterly laughable, if it wasn't so Sneery & horrible.

But as I said earlier on for those who just need to "feel better" than someone else.. there's nothing else to say.

MarshaBradyo · 24/08/2022 14:11

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:07

Can we just address the minimum wage rise = more money to spend = higher inflation fallacy quickly?

As it stands, (simple numbers to make it easy to follow) for the sake of argument, it costs around £15 per hour to cover the costs of living, that is to pay bills, get to work, put food on the table. Currently around £10 of that is earned and £5 comes from benefits or getting into debt.

If you make it £15 from earned income then nothing will come from benefits.

The worker has the same money, no extra to spend anywhere.

The benefit system gains £5 per hour. This does not get spent on latte and cake, it gets spent on other areas of public spending.

INCREASED MINIMUM WAGE DOES NOT INCREASE MONEY BEING SPENT IN THE ECONOMY it does not contribute to a wage spiral in and of itself.

Yes there are many other issues but I thought it might help to lay it out.

Isn’t this only half the equation?

The higher wage pushes up prices for the business which causes inflation

Bluesky2507 · 24/08/2022 14:11

@Alexandra2001 teachers weren't needed in lockdown?! What about the teachers that went into school still to look after the vulnerable children and children of key workers? Schools didn't close. And what about all the other teachers planning and delivering lessons over zoom to children at home? People have a short memory.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:11

TPL · 24/08/2022 14:06

It is definitely not fair to assume minimum wage = minimum stress. There are cases where that fits but also higher paid jobs that aren't stressful.

I worked for a retailer that had a sister shop in the same shopping centre. The company were very very slow at hiring new staff as it was done by head office rather than through the shop manager. This led to the manager of the sister shop working very long hours with very little time off. The only break he got most days was when one of us in our shop covered him for a short break usually 15/20 minutes. The rest of the time he had to be out on the shop flooring dealing with every single customer on his own for 9 and a half hours with no help. He ended up so stressed that he ended up extremely unwell and had to go on sickness benefits.

Technically he didn't earn minimum wage but as he had a low salaried wage it worked out as minimum wage due to all the hours the company expected salaried managers to work.

I also had a colleague who went on sickness leave due to the stress. The irony is the company is a well known health shop.

That sounds physically stressful but ultimately he didn't have to go home and worry about whether his mistake harmed or killed anyone did he?

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 14:11

AStar98 · 24/08/2022 13:29

Perhaps increasing the tax & NI threshold for those on NMW would give low earners a bit of extra in their take home pay.
Not completely taking FT out of paying tax & NI at all but would certainly help not add to the spiralling cost of living.

That's exactly what has been happening. No tax nor NIC on earnings up to £12,570, which is a whopping increase in the thresholds over the past decade or so.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:09

Ugh, proof read. I meant it doesn't contribute to inflation not wage spiral Blush

BunsyGirl · 24/08/2022 14:08

@gnilliwdog well I was much fitter both physically and mentally when I stacked shelves. If it paid the same as the salary I get paid now as a lawyer I would go back to stacking shelves in a heartbeat. It would be amazing to go on holiday without worrying about the 1000’s of emails that I receive whilst I am away and the “emergency” texts and calls that will most probably be made to my mobile phone. The constant worry that one tiny mistake on a document could cost a client (and therefore the firm) 1000’s (or more). Waking up in the morning (or in the middle of the night) thinking shit did I remember to do that? I never worried about whether cereal was stacked neatly or that the labels on baked beans were facing the correct way!!! I know so many unhappy professionals who only continue for the money. Take that benefit away and they will leave.

ShandaLear · 24/08/2022 14:08

Welcome to Economics 101.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:07

Can we just address the minimum wage rise = more money to spend = higher inflation fallacy quickly?

As it stands, (simple numbers to make it easy to follow) for the sake of argument, it costs around £15 per hour to cover the costs of living, that is to pay bills, get to work, put food on the table. Currently around £10 of that is earned and £5 comes from benefits or getting into debt.

If you make it £15 from earned income then nothing will come from benefits.

The worker has the same money, no extra to spend anywhere.

The benefit system gains £5 per hour. This does not get spent on latte and cake, it gets spent on other areas of public spending.

INCREASED MINIMUM WAGE DOES NOT INCREASE MONEY BEING SPENT IN THE ECONOMY it does not contribute to a wage spiral in and of itself.

Yes there are many other issues but I thought it might help to lay it out.

Bluesky2507 · 24/08/2022 14:07

@beachcitygirl suggesting teachers opt
out of a union and their pension is not a suitable solution. It would make much more sense to increase their salary.

And I don't know where you got that figure from for the student loan, but I earn around 31k and my student loan repayment is £90 a month not 40.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 14:07

RedToothBrush · 24/08/2022 13:51

Supermarket workers do get abuse.
Supermarket workers are not however proxy social workers.
Supermarket workers do not have the responsibility of 30 little people trying to kill themselves or each other in their immediate care.
Supermarket workers do not take their work home with them.

I'd love to have it explained to me HOW working in a supermarket is harder than teaching rather than dismissive comments about snobbery against supermarket workers.

Maybe at the checkout shelf stacking level but in store supervisor/management, they are under a great deal of pressure for v poor reward & will take home the job and work long shifts too, 7 days a week, inc almost all bank holidays.

Our company had a lot to do with Morrisons, no way would i want to work in a Supermarket in any position.

Our Tesco recently lost their chill' section, the abuse given out to staff on occasion was shocking.

Plus who did we need during lockdowns? clue: it wasn't teachers.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:06

gnilliwdog · 24/08/2022 13:56

This is true. One of the hardest things about most retail jobs is that you are not allowed to sit down. You will be standing from 8.30am to 6.00pm every day, or longer. You may get 30mins for lunch, but quite often it's too busy. You certainly can't get a drink of water or go to the toilet when you want. There is certainly little respect or dignity to make up for this. Factory work is similar, but often longer shifts, lifting heavy items, and 15 minutes for lunch. These sorts of jobs are also often very boring and repetitive. I really don't think barristers, doctors, nurses would prefer these jobs if the money paid is the same. Jobs take a huge part of our lives, it's not just about money. It's also about enjoying work, finding it interesting, being treated with respect etc.

Many professionals including healthcare professionals don't sit down all day and work unsocial hours too. On top of that they get a lot of responsibility and stress. You are deluded if you don't think any of them would swap for a “boring job” with no responsibility but the same pay.

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 14:06

Dadaya · 24/08/2022 13:36

Too many people have degrees. So they shouldn’t be paid much higher.
Graduate jobs need to pay enough to make the investment worthwhile. So let’s say 50k for the degree plus 30k lost wages for every year you study. That’s 140k. Over 40 years you’d need to earn an extra 3.5k per year to recoup the cost of studying. So graduates need to earn a few thousand per year more than non graduates. But not a huge amount more. Doctors maybe need to earn 10k more per year to make it worthwhile. Not 60-80k more.

So how would you bridge the shortage of GPs? We are already short of them despite an experienced GP earning typically £100k. Do you really think they'd do the job for half that? In reality, they'd beggar off abroad or do more lucrative work, such as hospital consultant or locum work.

TPL · 24/08/2022 14:06

It is definitely not fair to assume minimum wage = minimum stress. There are cases where that fits but also higher paid jobs that aren't stressful.

I worked for a retailer that had a sister shop in the same shopping centre. The company were very very slow at hiring new staff as it was done by head office rather than through the shop manager. This led to the manager of the sister shop working very long hours with very little time off. The only break he got most days was when one of us in our shop covered him for a short break usually 15/20 minutes. The rest of the time he had to be out on the shop flooring dealing with every single customer on his own for 9 and a half hours with no help. He ended up so stressed that he ended up extremely unwell and had to go on sickness benefits.

Technically he didn't earn minimum wage but as he had a low salaried wage it worked out as minimum wage due to all the hours the company expected salaried managers to work.

I also had a colleague who went on sickness leave due to the stress. The irony is the company is a well known health shop.

takealettermsjones · 24/08/2022 14:05

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:03

@takealettermsjones

But would you also be willing to have the degradation of asking to go to the loo & stress of monotony & physical discomfort of hard physical work & lack of control & unsociable working hours.

If so, then great. No problem. Doesn't mean min wage shouldn't rise.

I know exactly the job I would do so yes I would personally swap it.

I wasn't suggesting NMW shouldn't rise. I'm just...despairing at the whole situation, I suppose.

Cyclemarine · 24/08/2022 14:05

LimboLass · 24/08/2022 13:30

"Working in a supermarket is a far far far tougher gig than teaching"

Pull the other one. I used to work a supermarket both stacking shelves and on the checkouts as needed. The easiest job I have ever had by a country mile.

Sorry I've done both as well and no supermarket is not harder than teaching for many reasons. One of them being as a teacher you need to take your work home and I don't just mean marking - that too - but also the mental strain of the worry about that kid you seen coming to school hungry etc, or the bullying that's started going on in your class or thinking about the extra materials that you're going to pay out of your own pocket etc. This is no disrespect to supermarket work but it's not comparable.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:03

@takealettermsjones

But would you also be willing to have the degradation of asking to go to the loo & stress of monotony & physical discomfort of hard physical work & lack of control & unsociable working hours.

If so, then great. No problem. Doesn't mean min wage shouldn't rise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread