Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
Cyclemarine · 24/08/2022 14:41

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:30

@Cyclemarine
Hmm yet another person who worked in a supermarket as a stop FAO commenting.

You knew you had a way out. Not comparable.

Secondly, are you seriously so lacking in empathy that you think supermarket workers don't see their regular customers coming to the fill & having to put food back as not able to afford it, or are people shoplifting baby formula, or see the homeless people outside waiting by the bins for food or worry that if they refuse to go to work at a minutes notice even if their own child is ill or needs them at a weekend or holiday that they will be unemployed in a heartbeat & visiting food banks.

Do you genuinely not recognise the soul crushing degradation of monotonous minimum wage work where you have to ask to go to the loo as well as the very human empathetic issues of worry you describe as being only teachers experiencing.

Or do you just not care.

@beachcitygirl

I didn't know I had a way out, I hoped I had a way out because I struggled to put the money and time to train myself to try and do something else.

No - you're the one lacking in empathy if you think teachers working with children, many with various issues and often under the age of 13 for, don't have a far greater emotional burden than a supermarket worker who sees adult who may put some items back. They know their names, their favourite colours, they celebrate festivals with them etc, it's just not the same as seeing people a couple of times a week at a check-out even if you have a brief chat with them.

Having also worked in call centres where toilet breaks were timed, I have every sympathy for improving conditions in the service industry, so please quit the high winded poor attempt at emotional blackmail. It's sanctimonious and unnecessary and quite frankly off-topic.

What I and many others are trying to get through to you is that this work is simply not comparable to teaching. I identified a few differences and am still going through the thread, but I've noticed others have mentioned training time/costs etc too. I can't be bothered re-hashing the arguments but other people have clearly stated the points.

To come back to the original topic, if these workers see a steep rise in wages everyone else's will need to rise significantly too so we can all deal with the inevitable hike in rents and prices which will bring us all back to square one. And that is the bottom line.

However if we deal with the root causes such as super high rents and housing prices and energy prices then it will be win for everyone.

Bramshott · 24/08/2022 14:41

Of course at the moment there is a massive squeeze on household budgets because of increased energy and food costs, but in more "normal" times I'd say the thing that makes the cost of living unaffordable for those on lower incomes is high housing costs. Would bringing back rent controls be a better option?

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 14:40

Entwifery · 24/08/2022 14:38

Heaven forbid corporate profit margins decrease ever so slightly!

Increasing wages by 50% wouldn't decrease profits "ever so slightly" - it would completely wipe out many firms, especially those like supermarkets who work on small margins and whose biggest cost is their wage bill!

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 14:39

gnilliwdog · 24/08/2022 14:27

Sad. I would have thought they would rather stay in their profession and progress. Well, private cleaners charge up to £18ph so I suppose most of them must be ex healthcare professionals, barristers, teachers who find the job so much more pleasant they are prepared to give up their profession. I do know a few cleaners, by the way, and they are not doing it because they gave up nursing, law or teaching for the good life.

Self employed have to charge more because they don't get the benefits of employment such as paid holidays, sick pay, pensions, training/materials/equipment, etc. paid for by an employer.

Getoff · 24/08/2022 14:38

Here is my formula for what the minimum wage should be:

Get the median UK full time wage (Google says £31,285)
take 60% of that to get the individual poverty threshold
divide poverty threshold by the number of weeks you expect someone to work (say 48)
divide by the number of hours per week (say 37.5 or 40)

The result will be minimum wage needs to be about 10 pounds in order to give a full-time worker an income that is 60% of the median full-time income.

(The poverty line is usually defined as a household income 60% of the median, the idea of defining an individual rather than household poverty threshold is something I've made up, for the purposes of this post.)

Entwifery · 24/08/2022 14:38

Heaven forbid corporate profit margins decrease ever so slightly!

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 24/08/2022 14:36

How about instead of holding people down so others don't feel put out we try and raise the standard for as many working people as possible

but if a lot of people’s salary increases then prices will go up and we’ll be back to square one, wouldn’t we? And the poor buggers whose salary won’t increase or the ones fully on benefitswill even be worse off!

It is not a matter of « keeping lower paid workers at the bottom », it is about making something that will work!

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 14:34

Lol @beachcitygirl yes!

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:33

@Anothernamechangeplease

I'm ok with that. I'm ok with your charity closing.

Taxpayers absolutely should be picking up the tab for services for the vulnerable.

gnilliwdog · 24/08/2022 14:33

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:22

Having done a job that saves lives, I agree. I wouldn't have felt like that at the start of my career, but after a few years the responsibility wears you down.

I get that, and it's partly the fault of government for underfunding and introducing student loans, especially for nurses. A job saving lives can't be done forever anyway, it's clearly too much pressure. I would have thought you could move to other areas in the same field that are less pressurised or related areas rather than only having retail work etc. as an option to reduce stress.

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 14:33

Apologies, got confused with all the quotes etc. My last comment was aimed at @Anothernamechangeplease who doesn't seem to realise that her own benefit claiming employees are, financially at least, vulnerable.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:32

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 14:12

You're missing the reduced corporation tax income to the Govt, from the reduced business profits because they're now paying 50% higher wages, so any saving in benefits will be outweighed by lost tax revenue!

As I said there are other issues, many other issues - thats why I said in and of itself People seem to be failing to understand the very very basics of it whilst trying to argue things that are extremely complex. Fundamentals first.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:32

@BarryBantam I don't have staff honey. Are you mixing me with another poster perhaps? X

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:30

@Cyclemarine
Hmm yet another person who worked in a supermarket as a stop FAO commenting.

You knew you had a way out. Not comparable.

Secondly, are you seriously so lacking in empathy that you think supermarket workers don't see their regular customers coming to the fill & having to put food back as not able to afford it, or are people shoplifting baby formula, or see the homeless people outside waiting by the bins for food or worry that if they refuse to go to work at a minutes notice even if their own child is ill or needs them at a weekend or holiday that they will be unemployed in a heartbeat & visiting food banks.

Do you genuinely not recognise the soul crushing degradation of monotonous minimum wage work where you have to ask to go to the loo as well as the very human empathetic issues of worry you describe as being only teachers experiencing.

Or do you just not care.

justasking111 · 24/08/2022 14:29

DS fresh out of university is thrilled to have got a job on 22k per annum. Because he's done the relevant job for the last four years in the holidays he was offered more. The flat hunting however is a nightmare. Rents still rising, properties gone in hours. £800 upwards pcm for one bedroom 🙈

BarryBantam · 24/08/2022 14:28

@beachcitygirl If your staff earn less than £15 an hour they are financially precarious themselves and may well become "vulnerable" (if they have children) this coming winter. They'll already be claiming state benefits themselves as it is.

So, are you really helping?

"In the event of an emergency, secure your own breathing apparatus first."

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:28

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:19

Of course it would cause a wage spiral. It would not only be the people who are currently on minimum wage who need a wage increase. Anyone currently on less than £15 would need a pay rise. Many on a bit more than £15 would expect a pay rise too or you would get managers receiving the same amount as their staff. Many of those people including those currently on minimum wage are not receiving benefits. Not everyone minimum wage is in in debt. Not everyone in debt is on minimum wage.

Yes sorry I did correct myself in the subsequent post. I meant inflation not wage spiral.

gnilliwdog · 24/08/2022 14:27

takealettermsjones · 24/08/2022 14:19

You really think humans would prefer doing something meaningless 40-70 hours per week for 50 years because it pays the same as saving lives?

Some of those who have already done the latter would, yes. Because the pleasant notion of "saving lives" doesn't mitigate the stress, fear, burnout, compassion fatigue, exhaustion, etc.

Sad. I would have thought they would rather stay in their profession and progress. Well, private cleaners charge up to £18ph so I suppose most of them must be ex healthcare professionals, barristers, teachers who find the job so much more pleasant they are prepared to give up their profession. I do know a few cleaners, by the way, and they are not doing it because they gave up nursing, law or teaching for the good life.

Brefugee · 24/08/2022 14:26

You're all still thinking inside the box.
If housing didn't take such a chunk of wages and cause so much stress... if utilities didn't take such a chunk of wages and cause so much stress... if the NHS were properly funded, resourced and used (by the end usefs)... if being a SAHP didn't potentially lead to poverty in case of relationship breakdown...

Tax loopholes should be closed (or tightened then closed), higher earners should pay more tax, corporations should pay (more) tax, windfall profits should be taxed accordingly, pay restraint among CEOs should be a thing,

just talking about an uplift to the NMW in the society we're now in leads to at least 14 pages of partially incoherent bumble

RamblingEclectic · 24/08/2022 14:25

In 10 years time there won't be a need for fruit pickers, or shelf stickers, or warehouse workers, it will all be automated with few people managing the machines.

People have been saying that for 30+ years. We might have moved closer to that, but especially with fruit picking, there are so many more tech hurdles to get through to make it remotely viable at scale.

For even longer, we've been told that this automation would mean we all work less hours and a myriad of other things that also haven't happened. If anything, we're pushed to work more to be productive and to diversify our income with side hustles and gigs.

Yeah, we need a cultural shift well beyond just raising the minimum wage, but as it stands, the minimum wage is currently basically variable with a portion paid by the government and another portion by employer(s). For some, it's already £15+ an hour if you add their in-work benefits on top of their wage. The question on wages is how much of it should employers vs government be responsible for (whether through the current Tax Credit and UC system, or UBI/UBS system), not just about raising it, as part of that cultural shifting.

Anothernamechangeplease · 24/08/2022 14:24

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 13:46

@Anothernamechangeplease

Or
You could reduce your dividends or freeze top level salaries.

Or

If you can't afford to live on your own salary/profit if you pay your staff £15 then maybe your business isn't viable.

We are not for profit, so we don't pay dividends and we don't pay huge salaries to senior management.

We are a charity that helps some of the most vulnerable in our society. Maybe we're not viable if we can't afford to pay all of our staff £15 an hour or more, but if we stop operating, a whole lot of vulnerable people will suffer. And the taxpayer will have to pick up the tab.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:23

@missbunnyrabbit wins the award for the stupidest most lacking of empathy & most ignorant poster on this thread.

YOUR minimum wage easy peasy fun supermarket job was a temporary role which you were able to leave behind as you were off to bigger & better things.

It was NOT your life.

Grow some
Empathy & decency.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:22

takealettermsjones · 24/08/2022 14:19

You really think humans would prefer doing something meaningless 40-70 hours per week for 50 years because it pays the same as saving lives?

Some of those who have already done the latter would, yes. Because the pleasant notion of "saving lives" doesn't mitigate the stress, fear, burnout, compassion fatigue, exhaustion, etc.

Having done a job that saves lives, I agree. I wouldn't have felt like that at the start of my career, but after a few years the responsibility wears you down.

Winceybincey · 24/08/2022 14:20

Minimum wage is no where near enough to live even a basic life in this current climate. And as you’ve pointed out, other salaries would also need to increase otherwise, people who’ve studied for years, worked hard and sacrificed so much to gain a qualification in a skilled sector will be demoralised earning the same amount as a supermarket assistant. My kids need their teachers, we need our doctors and businesses need managers.

But, I also don’t think it’s fair that CEOs get the slack that they do. They’re not all multi-millionaires. If they can’t take a good amount of profit then what’s the point in doing what they do? I don’t think many understand the work and sacrifice that goes into to starting up a business, ploughing savings into it that could be lost, getting the work in, getting the right candidates, keeping it afloat so everyone still has a job by the end of the year, making sure all legislation is followed and accounts up to date. My husband works 7 days a week, days, evenings and weekends. He’s missed out on so much of our young children, and we’ve missed out on him. He worries day and night incase contracts end unexpectedly and his staff won’t have work. He’s out there marketing his business to get more contracts on top of the nitty gritty of the job. He pays the staff above minimum wage, they do the job Monday to Friday and then go home to their families, leaving work at work. My husband doesn’t get to do that, so it’s not true that it’s just the staff that make all the money whilst the CEOs sit back and hoard it all.

If minimum wage went up to £15 an hour and it had to come out of the profits then they’d be no point in him working his fingers, brain and heart to the bone and he’ll close. His staff will then have no work, never mind a wage increase.

but, what he does do is offer his staff free courses. If they do the courses and gain experience he will put them forward for the more responsible and better paid roles rather than advertising externally to fill them. His staff aren’t interested though, they just want to do their job and go home which is fair enough - if they’re happy on their current wage, most are not though which is ironic.

I agree with a previous poster that workers should be encouraged to better themselves, gain skills and the confidence to aim higher. There are highly paid jobs out there but it’s hard work that people need to be willing to do. As a single mum many years ago I worked my minimum wage 40 hour a week job and studied at home during evenings and weekends. Yes me and my child missed out on much quality time together, but it takes sacrifice to create a better life on top of the actual work.

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:19

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:07

Can we just address the minimum wage rise = more money to spend = higher inflation fallacy quickly?

As it stands, (simple numbers to make it easy to follow) for the sake of argument, it costs around £15 per hour to cover the costs of living, that is to pay bills, get to work, put food on the table. Currently around £10 of that is earned and £5 comes from benefits or getting into debt.

If you make it £15 from earned income then nothing will come from benefits.

The worker has the same money, no extra to spend anywhere.

The benefit system gains £5 per hour. This does not get spent on latte and cake, it gets spent on other areas of public spending.

INCREASED MINIMUM WAGE DOES NOT INCREASE MONEY BEING SPENT IN THE ECONOMY it does not contribute to a wage spiral in and of itself.

Yes there are many other issues but I thought it might help to lay it out.

Of course it would cause a wage spiral. It would not only be the people who are currently on minimum wage who need a wage increase. Anyone currently on less than £15 would need a pay rise. Many on a bit more than £15 would expect a pay rise too or you would get managers receiving the same amount as their staff. Many of those people including those currently on minimum wage are not receiving benefits. Not everyone minimum wage is in in debt. Not everyone in debt is on minimum wage.