Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want a £15 minimum wage?

663 replies

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:30

This morning I saw a post saying there are calls for a £15 per hour minimum wage.

I understand fully that the current minimum wage doesn't give people enough to survive on and something needs to change to ensure everyone gets a comfortable living wage, and I support this.

However by pushing up the minimum wage doesn't that just add additional costs for businesses, therefore increase costs to consumers removing any benefit of an increased minimum wage in addition to reducing the disposable income and pay gap of anyone above minimum wage.

Surely this only benefits the government with additional income tax?

Is this the best option in a time of potential 18% inflation, would this not increase it further?

Capitalism is the issue, rather than sharing the profit wealth, CEO's (of all levels of business, small and large) keep the profits for themselves and just raise prices when costs go up.

Am i being unreasonable to assume that in order for the £15ph wage to be successful, companies must accept lower profits rather than increasing prices in line with the wage increase otherwise its just pointless and daminging to all wage earners not just the minimum wage.

Won't the government have to threaten windfall taxes to those who increase prices to maintain profits to make it work and to actually benefit minimum wage earners?

I'll admit I'm a middle earner (£40k) civil servant (so no chance of a payrise anytime soon) so would be financially damaged by a raise in minimum wage if nothing is done to stop the subsequently price increases of products after a minimum pay rise. As a result my view may be biased, but am I wrong?

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 15:41

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 15:30

Tesco's wages costs are £7,466,000.

how much of this wages bill is taken up by the top 5 earners?

CEO earning 224 x higher than the medium worker in £21k which is £9 less than National average

of course the wages bill makes up a large amount of the profit as those at the top are so fucking greedy

Yes, the CEO earned 1.1 million pounds this year and that's after taking a pay cut.

Crikeyalmighty · 24/08/2022 15:39

@Brefugee amen. We need to be looking at it from the other angle- why can't people earning £400 a week get by?? Housing costs, utilities, childcare.

Unless society changes to a Scandinavian model as I mentioned and becomes much higher wages, higher tax but no NI, no council tax, cheap childcare - then just upping the NMW isn't going to be a solution and will result in a lot of business failures . The other thing to note in Denmark is due to high wages a lot of places involving 'personal service' are very poorly staffed. Supermarkets and hospitality in particular.

StreetwiseHercules · 24/08/2022 15:38

UrsulaPandress · 24/08/2022 09:32

I’m no financial expert but if everyone’s wages go up then prices increase then we are back where we started.

No. This isn’t the case. Wage growth mitigates inflation. If people have more money for goods and services, businesses have to compete for that spend.

there will always be some items and services where demand outstrips supply and these things remain at a premium regardless of whether wages increase or not.

if wages increase, inflation is mitigated and reduces. It’s just the way it works.

AntlerRose · 24/08/2022 15:37

Just as an aside our local supermarkets all pay more than minimum wage and offer discounts on food. The pension contributions are 4-7% but it looks hard to get a full time role.

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 15:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 15:33

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 15:30

Tesco's wages costs are £7,466,000.

how much of this wages bill is taken up by the top 5 earners?

CEO earning 224 x higher than the medium worker in £21k which is £9 less than National average

of course the wages bill makes up a large amount of the profit as those at the top are so fucking greedy

👏🏻👏🏻

ivykaty44 · 24/08/2022 15:30

Tesco's wages costs are £7,466,000.

how much of this wages bill is taken up by the top 5 earners?

CEO earning 224 x higher than the medium worker in £21k which is £9 less than National average

of course the wages bill makes up a large amount of the profit as those at the top are so fucking greedy

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 15:30

TPL · 24/08/2022 14:46

Actually he kind of did as it was a health shop selling products that could have adverse effects if not taken correctly or taken along side other medications.

I think that this is a slightly moot point though because most high earners are not saving lives day after day. If the argument is that nurses, paramedics etc should earn more than I don't disagree. If the minimum wage was £15 then they should have an equal rise.

The fact that the product is being sold in the health food shop in the first place rather than a pharmacy is because it's not expected to cause severe adverse effects or drug interactions. I appreciate that does occasionally happen but even then the people that work in the shops are not held responsible.

I'm not arguing that nurses, paramedics etc should be paid more. I am making the point that many would probably leave the job and get a minimum wage one with no responsibility if it paid as well, particularly after being in the profession for a few years.

Heartbreaktuna · 24/08/2022 15:29

@Badbadbunny I hear what you're saying, but the figure will include staff who are already on more than £15 p.h. and includes the wages of 13 directors. One of which was paid £4.75million alone.
And the supermarket industry works on insanely small margins.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 15:27

@Whyareyouasking lol. why on earth would I be jealous of teachers? I earn much more & travel extensively & stay in great hotels, zero responsibility & no work to take home, generous travel package & I have time to study at university into the bargain for pleasure.

I just fully support a £15 min wage & think some teachers come across v entitled & lacking in empathy.
I have worked in many min wage roles in the past & I know many 'professionals'
That wouldn't last 5 mins in those roles.

You take care of yourself pet.

Cyclemarine · 24/08/2022 15:24

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:50

@Cyclemarine

It's absolutely not off-topic.

Working in a mind-numbing, insecure, low status, toilet regulated, low paid, unsociable hours, physically demanding job is as stressful & tough than many much higher paid higher status roles. Including but not restricted to teaching.

Teachers aren't the only special people & they are not more deserving of a decent salary than others.

Min wage workers getting more money does not impact teachers in the slightest.

If any teacher wants to leave teaching to go for the min wage supermarket job.

Fine.

You were veering off topic by insinuating things that were patently false - suggesting I do not care for the plight of service workers or I think their job isn't tough.

Teaching and nursing are physically demanding too btw and you may not have to ask for permission as such but teachers can't just swan off to the toilet anytime too.

That is not my argument, nor is my arguments teachers are the only special people. The fact is - you cannot compare teaching with all the training it involves (see time and costs required for this) and all the emotional burdens they carry and all the planning/marking they have to do outside of work hours ...and going on residential or day trips etc...with working an entry level/check-out job at a supermarket where you clock in and out and leave your work there.

I assume under this proposal that some TAs would see their wage rise to 15 pounds an hour? While TAs are underpaid, I think teachers would really have to question why they have these significant additional responsibilities and tasks for little more pay than the assistants in their classroom on £15/hour, so you really would have to raise teachers wages too by a significant amount .

Many teachers already work in supermarket jobs actually but my main
point is- NMW workers getting as much as £15 will impact not only teachers but many others who earn a similar amount, unless their wages are increased by a similar amount. The reason for that is landlords will hike up housing costs which is one of the biggest causes of a high standard of living.

So at the end of the day everyone, including NMW workers will still have the same struggle we are facing now.

I think a much more sensible approach would tackle extortionate housing and energy costs.

Badbadbunny · 24/08/2022 15:20

@Heartbreaktuna

Also wages are a relatively small part of the cost structure for large companies.

Tesco's wages costs are £7,466,000. It's profit was £1,693,000. So a pretty small increase in wages across the board of just 23% would plunge it into loss making. Increasing wages by 50% would wipe it out. For many big companies, the wages certainly AREN'T a "relatively small part"!

Whyareyouasking · 24/08/2022 15:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

entropynow · 24/08/2022 15:09

Heartbreaktuna · 24/08/2022 15:00

You are assuming a company prices their products according to minimum wage. They dont. They price it as high as they think they can get away with.
Also wages are a relatively small part of the cost structure for large companies. Fixed costs (rent/utilities etc) repairs and maintenance, supplies, distribution are also in the mix.
Wages do not effect market value. They do of course have an effect on profit margin.
Also what is rarely mentioned is that when wages rise, people have more disposable income left over with which to buy more stuff. All that money gets spent in the community pretty quickly because most people on minimum wage spend what they earn. Overall there are winners and losers, but overall businesses will get more patronage. Increased revenues to cover increase costs. The qualifier the question is won't businesses raise prices to be to keep the exact same net income. But in the same way they never reduce costs when costs fall, the same way wages are only part of the overall cost equation, is the reason my response is - they just won't. They will continue to charge the highest they think we will stomach.
Also. By virtue of paye collected at source, wage increases directly raise tax revenues better than the collection of corporation tax ever does. transfer pricing, artificial group management fees, profit shifting and group loss reliefs see to that.....

Most people are employed by small and medium-sized businesses. They cannot afford a minimum of £15 an hour wages for jobs that simply don't pull in that kind of money. Plus they are far more likely to spend a large part of their incoming on staff costs.
They would go out of business, pure and simple.
Also, don't forget that consumers now have a lot more choice thanks to globalised trade. If prices go up, even larger firms suffer.

entropynow · 24/08/2022 15:03

Israisingwagesworthit · 24/08/2022 09:34

Did you actually read my post? I'm not disagreeing that minimum wage should be higher.. but surely it just increases the cost of things making the minimum wage still unaffordable?

Doesn't companies have to reduce profits and mainten current prices to let the minimum wage increase actually make a difference?

They elided over everything except your salary which automatically makes you wrong, you see?🙄

ColonelCarter · 24/08/2022 15:03

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 24/08/2022 11:11

I do have to laugh at the 'why will people aspire to become nurses and teachers and police, when they can work in a supermarket or factory for the same wage?' line people are trotting out. And here's me thinking people went into these 'caring' professions for the love of the job. Clearly not LMFAO!

And God forbid someone slogging their arse off in a factory doing backbreaking work, (and doing anti-social, tiring shifts,) or sitting at a supermarket checkout with very few breaks, (and stacking the shelves and doing the dotcom orders when the checkouts slow down,) gets paid the SAME as the nurses, police, and teachers. I mean they couldn't POSSIBLY work as hard COULD they? Hmm

We really need to get past this mindset that only the 'professionals' in 'public service roles work hard. It's untrue, and a fucking insult to hard working people doing manual labour, who didn't have the same opportunities as them to get a university degree! (Or were not quite 'academic' enough.)

As for the people saying 'I am a nurse/police officer/teacher, and if I could get paid the same for working in a supermarket, or working in a factory, I would leave today;' if you're so stressed in your job, then leave. What's stopping you? If it's that you need the salary you're on, then change a few priorities in your life. Downsize your home, have fewer luxuries, have the same lifestyle as the lower earners. You seem to think it's OK for others to earn less, so why not you? Why are you staying in your 'hugely stressful' jobs? Just leave and take one of the lower paid jobs that you consider to be much easier!

And as I said, I was clearly wrong about people being in these professions for the love of the job. How sad. Sad

It's not about how hard a job is, but the level of responsibility it holds.

I'm responsible for decisions which could be life or death for some people, I have the weight of that responsibility on me all day everyday. I have to make decisions quickly that I then have to defend if something goes wrong. It's not just my career at stake, it's people's lives, people being abused. I love my job, I love helping people but it's a hell of a lot of responsibility.

If nmw goes up, the people I manage wages will go up (because it's currently less than £15) but mine won't so I'll have all that extra responsibility for no more pay. No one would move in to management. And it's the NHS so my 'company' won't have to step up, we'll just have bigger staffing issues than we currently do.

Love of the job only takes you so far, eventually you crack.

Heartbreaktuna · 24/08/2022 15:00

You are assuming a company prices their products according to minimum wage. They dont. They price it as high as they think they can get away with.
Also wages are a relatively small part of the cost structure for large companies. Fixed costs (rent/utilities etc) repairs and maintenance, supplies, distribution are also in the mix.
Wages do not effect market value. They do of course have an effect on profit margin.
Also what is rarely mentioned is that when wages rise, people have more disposable income left over with which to buy more stuff. All that money gets spent in the community pretty quickly because most people on minimum wage spend what they earn. Overall there are winners and losers, but overall businesses will get more patronage. Increased revenues to cover increase costs. The qualifier the question is won't businesses raise prices to be to keep the exact same net income. But in the same way they never reduce costs when costs fall, the same way wages are only part of the overall cost equation, is the reason my response is - they just won't. They will continue to charge the highest they think we will stomach.
Also. By virtue of paye collected at source, wage increases directly raise tax revenues better than the collection of corporation tax ever does. transfer pricing, artificial group management fees, profit shifting and group loss reliefs see to that.....

Maverickess · 24/08/2022 14:53

Honestly I think the problem is the fact that we attach individual human worth to the size of someone's bank balance.
Not big enough bank balance = not good enough human, and they're treated as such.

People are scared that someone worth less than them may be getting something they're not, something that they feel they should get and as they don't, don't think anyone worth less than them should get it either.

Most people work hard, up until recently it's been an employer's market and not working hard in any job means you won't keep it for long because the employer wants their money's worth. The work can be manual and physical, it can be literally saving lives, it can be the responsibility of keeping everything afloat and sourcing the work to be done, it can be keeping the infrastructure going - they're all interlinked and when one area falters then they all start to. When one area is dismissed as lower value then things start to falter across the board.

The issue lies with the attitude of who deserves what, and that those at the lower end of the scale are worth less and therefore less deserving of fundamental things like a wage that provides the basics, being treated with common decency and their value being recognised past what their payslip says.

Some people are driven, are able to take up opportunities, create opportunity for themselves, some aren't driven, miss opportunity because it's not right at that time, aren't able to create an opportunity - but we in some way rely on them all in order to keep the whole thing afloat. There's nothing wrong with someone earning more because they've created or taken an opportunity - what's wrong is when they devalue the people who haven't.
And there's nothing wrong with someone who earns less because they haven't had or haven't been able to take up such opportunities - what's wrong is when they devalue those that have.

I wouldn't want my boss's job, and that responsibility, but then I don't devalue her for having the extra money attached to it, and she doesn't devalue me for not wanting that responsibility because my pay slip doesn't have the same number of zero's as hers.

We both recognise neither of us would have a job without the other.

beachcitygirl · 24/08/2022 14:50

@Cyclemarine

It's absolutely not off-topic.

Working in a mind-numbing, insecure, low status, toilet regulated, low paid, unsociable hours, physically demanding job is as stressful & tough than many much higher paid higher status roles. Including but not restricted to teaching.

Teachers aren't the only special people & they are not more deserving of a decent salary than others.

Min wage workers getting more money does not impact teachers in the slightest.

If any teacher wants to leave teaching to go for the min wage supermarket job.

Fine.

Cyclemarine · 24/08/2022 14:47

Bramshott · 24/08/2022 14:41

Of course at the moment there is a massive squeeze on household budgets because of increased energy and food costs, but in more "normal" times I'd say the thing that makes the cost of living unaffordable for those on lower incomes is high housing costs. Would bringing back rent controls be a better option?

Agreed! We really need to get a handle on how much housing costs are.

There was a thread on here yesterday about a woman who earns over 50K who is facing a 3k mortgage since her husband walked out. 50K looks great on it's own but with a 3K mortage it's not.

Same as many young professionals who get decent wages in London but then shelling out £800 for a room in a house and for those who don't want to or can't house share - don't even me started on how much a 1-bed in London costs.

TPL · 24/08/2022 14:46

dianthus101 · 24/08/2022 14:11

That sounds physically stressful but ultimately he didn't have to go home and worry about whether his mistake harmed or killed anyone did he?

Actually he kind of did as it was a health shop selling products that could have adverse effects if not taken correctly or taken along side other medications.

I think that this is a slightly moot point though because most high earners are not saving lives day after day. If the argument is that nurses, paramedics etc should earn more than I don't disagree. If the minimum wage was £15 then they should have an equal rise.

AntlerRose · 24/08/2022 14:46

Yes to rent controls and security etc. There must be better models for renting than ours.

KeepYaHeadUp · 24/08/2022 14:45

I think it's the opposite of the trickle down economics theory. Low earners are precisely the people who should get more money from an economic perspective. They spend it. They spend a bit more on a weekly shop, buy a winter coat, get a take away etc. The really well off who earn x times the average worker generally won't buy x more pairs of jeans, tins of beans, etc.

So yes, more goes to HMRC, but it also means more jobs for retail, decorators, etc etc etc who in turn spend more on beans, take away, clothes, etc.

JustALittleHelpPlease · 24/08/2022 14:44

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 24/08/2022 14:36

How about instead of holding people down so others don't feel put out we try and raise the standard for as many working people as possible

but if a lot of people’s salary increases then prices will go up and we’ll be back to square one, wouldn’t we? And the poor buggers whose salary won’t increase or the ones fully on benefitswill even be worse off!

It is not a matter of « keeping lower paid workers at the bottom », it is about making something that will work!

Or how about we address the cost of living so that whatever is being earned is sufficient to live?

It doesn't actually matter where the scale starts from, it could start at 50p per hour or £500ph that's just numbers. What matters is what your wage can buy you. If lowest wages don't cover living then the whole system has to be propped up. If we are propping up we are artificially inflating everything by creating the illusion that there is more money - which means rents can be higher, people can charge more for services and so on. Prices go up because people have more disposable income notnbecause more of their income comes from a wage packet.

As someone said earlier two issues are being conflated and presented as being the cause of/solution for each other. However that isn't accurate.

Alexandra2001 · 24/08/2022 14:41

Bluesky2507 · 24/08/2022 14:11

@Alexandra2001 teachers weren't needed in lockdown?! What about the teachers that went into school still to look after the vulnerable children and children of key workers? Schools didn't close. And what about all the other teachers planning and delivering lessons over zoom to children at home? People have a short memory.

Yes of course i remember but the reality is for everyone, inc teachers and health workers, Supermarket staff were what we all needed, as everyone lined up queuing outside to buy food.

No one can do anything without food.

Swipe left for the next trending thread